题名

結合環保訴求之多屬性文化商品設計成效評估模型－以美濃客家為例

并列篇名

An Effectiveness Evaluation Model for Designing Products, in Integrating Multi-Attribute Cultural and Environmental Eco-friendly Factors: A Case Study of the Meinong Hakka

DOI

10.30105/JDS.201307_16(1).0005

作者

薛淞林(Sung-Lin Hsueh)

关键词

環保訴求 ； 客家文化 ； 德菲爾法 ； 層級分析法 ； 模糊邏輯理論 ； Environmental Eco-friendly ； Hakka Culture ； Delphi Method ； Analytical Hierarchy Process ； Fuzzy Logic Theory

期刊名称

設計學研究

卷期/出版年月

16卷1期（2013 / 07 / 01）

页次

81 - 105

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

文化活動具有記錄、延續及傳遞地方特色的功能，同時對地方旅遊產業亦有加值的效果。台灣美濃地區民眾為了維持目前的居住環境，還有保護黃蝶翠谷（Yellow Butterfly Valley）的自然生態景觀及黃蝶與八色鳥Fairy Pitta（Pitta nympha）的生存權，極力反對美濃水庫的興建。本研究為了提升美濃客家文化活動記錄環境保護的歷史價值，將美濃客家文化融合事件中的代表黃蝶與八色鳥的特色，應用Delphi method專家群體決策的設計技巧，Analytical Hierarchy Process（AHP）的多屬性決策及Fuzzy Logic Theory處理量化的功能，建立一套融合環保訴求的多屬性文化商品設計成效評估模型，用來探討美濃客家文化特色結合環保訴求的情感因素，作為轉化現代商品及意象圖騰設計的輔助決策，本研究的價值除了提供文化商品開發前的客觀量化評量方式外，同時可作為選擇最佳的新商品開發案，有助降低錯誤的決策風險，本模型具有實務應用的價值，有助強化美濃在地文化的應用與環境保護的永續發展。
英文摘要

The functions of Cultural activities are to record and promoted local characteristics that were being continued. These activities also add extra value to local tourism industries. To maintain their current living environment and preserve the natural landscapes of the Yellow Butterfly Valley and the right to life of the yellow butterfly and the Fairy Pitta (Pitta nympha), the residents of Taiwan's Meinong region, strongly against the construction of the Meinong Reservoir. To promote the historical value of the Meinong Hakka cultural activities and recording environmental protection process, the characteristics of the yellow butterfly and the Fairy Pitta, the representative symbols in the Meinong Hakka cultural fusion event, was applied in a model to evaluate the effectiveness in designing environmental eco-friendly and multi-attribute cultural products. The theoretical context to establish this model is based on Delphi method design techniques of experts' group decision-making, multi-attribute decision making of analytical hierarchy process (AHP), and functions of fuzzy logic theory in quantitative processing. This model can be an assisting tools to review and processes to transfer environmental Eco-friendly features and Meinong local cultural characteristic into a modernized commercial cultural products and designed imagery and totems. This study provides not only an objective and quantitative evaluation, but is also be applied for selecting a best commercial product developing by reducing the risks of mistakes in decision-making. This model has value in practical application, also promotes Meinong local culture and environmental preservation and sustainable development.
主题分类 人文學 > 藝術
参考文献
  1. Desmet, P.,Hekkert, P.(2007).Framework of product experience.International Journal of Design,1(1),57-66.
    連結：
  2. Desmet, P.,Hekkert, P.(2007).Framework of product experience.International Journal of Design,1(1),57-66.
    連結：
  3. 朱柏穎、陳立杰、俞維昇(2010)。產品認知價值之情感向度指標萃取與評價模式研究。設計學報，15(1)，25-49。
    連結：
  4. 李亞傑、何明泉(2011)。商品意象設計指標權重之研究。設計學報，16(1)，41-64。
    連結：
  5. 陳文亮、陳姿樺(2008)。模糊決策模式在職校技藝競賽選手評選之研究－以服裝製作組為例。設計學報，13(3)，23-38。
    連結：
  6. 陳文亮、陳姿樺(2007)。運動休閒服飾設計指標之建立與分析。設計學報，12(4)，79-95。
    連結：
  7. 衛萬里、張文智(2005)。應用模糊德爾菲與分析網路程序法選擇最佳產品設計方案之研究。設計學報，10(3)，59-77。
    連結：
  8. 美濃鄉公所，（2011），客庄十二大節慶，網址：http://www.ihakka.net/hv2010/12caci/1mon/1m2.html（上網日期：May 24, 2012）
  9. 經濟部水資源局（1999），美濃水庫工程計畫網址： http://hysearch.wra.gov.tw/wra_ext/WaterInfo/（上網日期：April 23, 2012）
  10. Adler, M.(Ed.),Ziglio, E.(Ed.)(1996).Gazing into the oracle: The Delphi method and its application to social policy and public health.London:Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
  11. Badke-Schaub, P.,Neumann, A.,Lauche, K.,Mohammed, S.(2007).Mental models in design teams: A valid approach to performance in design collaboration?.CoDesign,3(1),5-20.
  12. Bingul, Z.,Cook, G.,Strauss, A.(2000).Application of fuzzy logic to spatial thermal control in fusion welding.IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications,36,1523-1530.
  13. Brown, S.,Eisenhardt, K.(1995).Product development: Past research, present findings, and future directions.Academy of Management Review,20(2),343-378.
  14. Burchett, E.(2005).Colour harmony and the visual message.Color Research Application,30(3),243.
  15. Calantone, R.,Benedetto, A.,Schmidt, J.(1999).Using the analytic hierarchy process in new product screening.Journal of Product Innovation Management,16,65-76.
  16. Caves, R.(2003).Contracts between art and commerce.Journal of Economic Perspectives,17(2),73-83.
  17. Chang, W.,Wu, T.(2007).Exploring types and characteristics of product forms.International Journal of Design,1(1),3-14.
  18. Chen, C.,Chuang, M.(2008).Integrating the Kano model into a robust design approach to enhance customer satisfaction with product design.International Journal of Production Economics,114(2),667-681.
  19. Chhabra, D.,Healy, R.,Sills, E.(2003).Staged authenticity and heritage tourism.Annals of Tourism Research,30(3),702-719.
  20. Chitturi, R.,Raghunathan, R.,Mahajan, V.(2008).Delight by design: The role of hedonic versus utilitarian benefits.Journal of Marketing,72(3),48-63.
  21. Evans, P.(1998).Transferable lesson? Re-examing the institutional prerequisites of east Asian economic policies.The Journal of Development Studies,34(6),70-74.
  22. Fekri, R.,Aliahmadi, A.,Fathian, M.(2009).Predicting a model for agile NPD process with fuzzy cognitive map: The case of Iranian manufacturing enterprises.The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology,41(11-12),1240-1260.
  23. Feret, B.,Marcinek, M.(1999).The future of the academic library and the academic librarian - A Delphi study.Journal of Librarian Career Development,7(10),91-107.
  24. Feyzio, O.,Büyüközkan, G.(2006).Evaluation of new product development projects using artificial intelligence and fuzzy logic.Engineering and Technology,11(2),183-189.
  25. Hassenzahl, M.(2004).The interplay of beauty, goodness, and usability in interactive products.Human-Computer Interaction,19(4),319-349.
  26. Hsiao, S.,Chen, C.(1997).A semantic and shape grammar based approach for product design.Design Studies,18(3),275-296.
  27. Hsiao, S.,Chiu, F.,Hsu, H.(2008).A computer-assisted colour selection system based on aesthetic measure for colour harmony and fuzzy logic theory.Color Research Application,33(5),411-423.
  28. Hsueh, S.(2012).A Fuzzy Utility-Based Multi-Criteria Model for Evaluating Households' Energy Conservation Performance: A Taiwanese Case Study.Energies,5(8),2818-2834.
  29. Hsueh, S.,Hsu, C.(2011).A Multi-criteria Assessment Model of Community College Development for Energy Conservation Promotion in Network Environment.Communications in Computer and Information Science,216,457-467.
  30. Hsueh, S.,Hsu, K.,Liu, C.(2012).A Multi-Criteria Evaluation Model for Developmental Effectiveness in Cultural and Creative Industries.Procedia Engineering,29,1755-1761.
  31. Hsueh, S.,Lee, C.(2011).Construct Evaluation Model for Development Effect of Community Adult Education Using Fuzzy Logic Theory.American Journal of Engineering and Technology Research,11(12),384-388.
  32. Hsueh, S.,Perng, Y.,Yan, M.,Lee, J.(2007).On-line multi-criterion risk assessment model for construction joint ventures in China.Automation in Construction,16(5),607-619.
  33. Hsueh, S.,Yan, M.(2011).Enhancing sustainable community development a multi-criteria evaluation model for energy efficient project selection.Energy Procedia,5,135-144.
  34. Hui, C.,Lau, T.,Ng, S.,Chan, C.(2005).Learning-based fuzzy colour prediction system for more effective apparel design.International Journal of Clothing Science and Technology,17(5),335-348.
  35. Hummel, M.,Rossum, W.,Verkerke, G.,Rakhorst, G.(2002).Product design planning with the analytic hierarchy process in inter-organizational networks.R&D Management,32(5),451-458.
  36. Hummels, C.,Overbeeke, K.(2010).Special issue editorial: Aesthetics of interaction.International Journal of Design,4(2),1-2.
  37. Kim, B.,Kang, B.(2008).Cross-functional cooperation with design teams in new product development.International Journal of Design,2(3),43-54.
  38. Kleinsmann, M.,Valkenburg, R.(2008).Barriers and enablers for creating shared understanding in co-design projects.Design Studies,29,369-386.
  39. Knight, T.(1994).Shape grammars and color grammars in design.Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design,21,705-735.
  40. Ko, C.,Lee, P.,Bai, M.,Lin, R.(2009).A rule-based species predictive model for the vulnerable Fairy Pitta (Pitta nympha) in Taiwan.Taiwania,54,28-36.
  41. Landeta, J.,Barrutia, J.(2011).People consultation to construct the future: A Delphi application.International Journal of Forecasting,27(1),134-151.
  42. Lee, K.(2004).Design methods for a cross-cultural collaborative design project.Proceedings of Design Research Society International Conference - Futureground,Melbourne:
  43. Leong, D.,Clark, H.(2003).Culture-based knowledge towards new design thinking and practice - A dialogue.Design Issues,19(3),48-58.
  44. Lin, C.(2007).New product portfolio selection using fuzzy logic.IEEE International Conference onIndustrial Engineering and Engineering Management
  45. Lin, R.(2007).Transforming Taiwan aboriginal cultural features into modern product design: A case study of a cross- cultural product design model.International Journal of Design,1(2),47-55.
  46. Lin, R.,Lee, P.,Ding, T.,Lin, Y.(2007).Effectiveness of playbacks in censusing the Fairy Pitta (Pitta nympha) during the breeding season in Taiwan.Zoological Studies,46,242-248.
  47. Littrell, M.,Anderson, L.,Brown, P.(1993).What makes a craft souvenir authentic?.Annals of Tourism Research,20(1),197-215.
  48. Margolin, V.(2005).A world history of design and the history of the world.Journal of Design History,18(3),235-243.
  49. Moalosi, R.,Popovic, V.,Hickling-Hudson, A.(2007).Product analysis based on Botswana's postcolonial socio-cultural perspective.International Journal of Design,1(2),35-43.
  50. Murry, J.,Hammons, J.(1995).Delphi: A versatile methodology for conducting qualitative research.Review of Higher Education,18(4),423-436.
  51. Norman, D.(2004).Emotional design: Why we love (or hate) everyday things.New York:Perseus Books Group, Basic Books.
  52. Okada, E.(2005).Justification effects on consumer choice of hedonic and utilitarian goods.Journal of Marketing Research,42(1),43-53.
  53. Ou, L.,Luo, M.,Woodcock, A.,Wright, A.(2004).A study of colour emotion and colour preference. Part I : Colour emotions for singles colours.Color Research and Application,29(3),222-227.
  54. Perng, Y.,Hsueh, S.,Yan, M.(2005).Evaluation of housing constructionstrategies in China using fuzzy-logic system.International Journal of Strategic Property Management,9(4),215-232.
  55. Pulm, U.,Stetter, R.(2009).Influences of pressure on cooperative product development.International Journal of CoCreation in Design and the Arts,6(2),193-210.
  56. Pun, K.,Yiu, M.,Chin, K.(2010).Developing a self-assessment model for measuring new product development performance: An AHP approach.International Journal of Advanced Operations Management,2(1),57-79.
  57. Rowe, G.,Wright, G.(1999).The Delphi technique as a forcasting tool: Issues and analysis.International Journal of Forecasting,15,353-375.
  58. Saaty, T.(1994).How to make a decision: The analytic hierarchy process.Interfaces,24(6),19-43.
  59. Saaty, T.(1990).How to make a decision: The analytic hierarchy process.European Journal of Operational Research,48(1),9-26.
  60. Saaty, T.(1980).The analytical hierarchy process: Planning, priority setting, resource allocation.New York:McGraw-Hill Book Co..
  61. Saaty, T.,Takizawa, M.(1986).Dependence and independence: From linear hierarchies to nonlinear networks.European Journal of Operational Research,26(2),229-237.
  62. Schloss, K.,Palmer, S.(2011).Aesthetic response to color combinations: Preference, harmony, and similarity.Attention perception & psychophysics,73(2),551-571.
  63. Shen, X.,Tan, K.,Xie, M.(2000).An integrated approach to innovative product development using Kano's model and QFD.European Journal of Innovation Management,3(2),91-99.
  64. Shenhav-Keller, S.(1993).The Israeli souvenir: Its text and context.Annals of Tourism Research,20(1),182-196.
  65. Skulmoski, G.,Hartman, F.,Krahn, J.(2007).The Delphi method for graduate research.Journal of Information Technology Education,6,1-21.
  66. Steen, M.,Manschot, M.,De Koning, N.(2011).Benefits of co-design in service design projects.International Journal of Design,5(2),53-60.
  67. Sun, H.,Wing, W.(2005).Critical success factors for new product development in the Hong Kong toy industry.Technovation,25,293-303.
  68. Tapia, M.(1999).A visual implementation of a shape grammar system.Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design,26,59-73.
  69. Tsai, H.,Hsiao, S.(2004).Evaluation of alternatives for product customization using fuzzy logic.Information Sciences,158,233-262.
  70. Tzokas, N.,Hutlink, E.,Hart, S.(2004).Navigating the new product development process.Industrial Marketing Management,33,619-626.
  71. Vanschaik, P.,Ling, J.(2008).Modelling user experience with web sites: Usability, hedonic value, beauty and goodness.Interacting with Computers,20(3),419-432.
  72. Voss, K.,Spangenberg, E.,Grohman, B.(2003).Measuring the hedonic and utilitarian dimensions of consumer attitude.Journal of Marketing Research,40(3),310-320.
  73. Wearing, S.,McDonald, M.(2002).The development of community-based tourism: Re-thinking the relationship between operators and development agents as intermediaries in rural and isolated area communities.Journal of Sustainable Tourism,10(3),191-206.
  74. Wen, H.,Zhang, S.,Hapeshi, K.,Wang, X.(2008).An innovative methodology of product design from nature.Journal of Bionic Engineering,5(1),75-84.
  75. Westland, S.,Laycock, K.,Chung, V.,Henry, P.,Mahyar, F.(2007).Colourharmony.Colour Design Creativity,1(1),1-15.
  76. Wong, J.,Li, H.(2008).Application of the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) in multi-criteria analysis of the selection of intelligent building systems.Building and Environment,43(1),108-125.
  77. Yair, K.,Press, M.,Tomes, A.(2001).Crafting competitive advantage: Crafts knowledge as a strategical resource.Design Studies,22,377-394.
  78. Yan, W.,Chen, C.,Shieh, M.(2006).Product concept generation and selection using sorting technique and fuzzy c-means algorithm.Computers & Industrial Engineering,50,273-285.
  79. Yu, W.,Skibniewski, M.(1999).A neuro-fuzzy computational approach to constructability knowledge acquisition for construction technology evaluation.Automation in Construction,8,539-552.
  80. Zadeh, L.(1988).Fuzzy logic.IEEE Computer,21(4),83-89.
  81. Zadeh, L.(1996).Fuzzy logic = computing with words.IEEE Transaction on Fuzzy Systems,4,103-11.
  82. Zadeh, L.(1987).Fuzzy sets and applications: Selected Papers by L. A. Zadeh,New York:
  83. Zadeh, L.(1965).Fuzzy sets.Information and Control,8,338-353.
  84. Zadeh, L.(1976).A fuzzy-algorithmic approach to the definition of complex or imprecise concepts.International Journal of Man-Machine Studies,8,249-291.
  85. 行政院農業委員會特有生物研究保育中心(2012)。,未出版
  86. 張建成(2000)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立交通大學工業工程與管理研究所。
  87. 陳顯榮、廖學書(2008)。應用AHP 探究禪文化精神與產品設計因素之關連性。華梵藝術與設計學報，4，181-197。
  88. 黃意文(2007)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立臺灣科技大學設計研究所。
  89. 薛淞林、吳彥霖(2009)。以模糊邏輯建構色彩應用之評估模型。設計與產業學報，6，69-83。
  90. 鍾怡婷(2003)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中山大學公共事務管理研究所。
被引用次数
  1. (2016)。運用模糊德爾菲法與感性工學探討心肺復甦輔助裝置產品造形之研究。樹德科技大學學報，18(1)，54-70。
print cancel