Learning to Live with Water: A Systematic Review of Sustainable Techniques in Urban Water Resources Management

學習與水共存：永續都市水資源管理技術之系統性回顧

10.30105/JDS.201412_17(2).0001

周融駿(Rung-Jiun Chou)

永續排水系統SuDS ； 都市水環境 ； 都市水資源 ； 永續環境管理 ； Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) ； Urban Water Environment ； Urban Water Resources ； Sustainable Environmental Management

設計學研究

17卷2期（2014 / 12 / 01）

1 - 19

英文

水資源是構成多元化建成環境與多樣化生態系統的基礎元素。然而，都市化大規模改變都市水環境，使得水患風險升高，地下含水層下降，水質惡化，以及水域空間環境價值降低。有鑒於永續環境管理的思考，國際間持續在發展與推動對環境友善之水資源管理方式，例如歐洲地區之永續排水系統 Sustainable Drainage Systems （SuDS），其目的在於減緩上述水環境變遷的問題。因此，本文旨在系統性探討都市擴張對於水環境影響的程度，並分析SuDS的發展優點與限制因素，重要結論如下：（1）土地透水性相當大程度影響都市區域的水文特性，（2）多功能水域空間能有效促進城市多樣化的發展，（3）SuDS具備多功能環境效益，對生物棲地、水質、休閒價值與水患防治有所助益，（4）SuDS之可行性相當大程度取決於空間大小，例如台灣的都市空間條件。本文期能喚起更多對於都市水環境多功能發展的關注，並促進台灣都市水資源永續管理的發展。

Water resources are fundamental to the wide variety of the built environment and the rich diversity of ecosystems. Nevertheless, urbanization has extensively changed the water environment in urban areas, where flood risk is rising, groundwater aquifers are declining, water quality is reducing, and the amenity values of water places are degrading. In the light of the drive towards sustainable environmental management, environmentally-friendly approaches to manage water resources have been developed and promoted internationally, such as the techniques of Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) in Europe, which aim to mitigate the above problems. Hence, the purpose of this paper is to systematically examine the extent to which urban expansion has impacted on water environment, and to analyze the development strengths and limitations of SuDS. Several key points have emerged by the systematic review: (1) the water permeability of land surfaces greatly impacts the hydrological features of urban areas, (2) city development is effectively diversified by multi-functional water places, (3) SuDS, with the idea of multi-functionality, are beneficial to wildlife habitats, water quality, amenity values and flood prevention, and (4) the applicability of SuDS is largely dependent on the availability of space, such as the conditions of urban Taiwan. It is hoped that this paper will raise awareness that urban waters should serve multiple environmental and social purposes and thus help facilitate the sustainable management of urban water resources in Taiwan.

1. SuDS Wales (2014), 'The SuDS Treatment Train' , website: http://www.sudswales.com/education/background/the-suds-treatment-train/ (accessed: August 3, 2014).
2. Wang, J. J. (2012), 'Tomorrow's Cities and the Solution to Live with Water' , website: http://wetland.e-info.org.tw/index.php (accessed: August 4, 2014).
3. NetRegs (2013), 'Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems (SuDS)' , Northern Ireland Environment Agency and Scottish Environment Protection Agency, website: http://www.netregs.org.uk/library_of_topics/water/sustainable_urban_drain_system/green_roofs_in_suds.aspx (accessed: August 4, 2014)
4. Ministry of Environment & Forests Govt. of India (2011), 'Water', website: http://upenvis.nic.in/Database/Water_816.aspx (accessed: July 14, 2014).
5. Maslog-Levis, K. (2014), 'A Water Sensitive Urban Environment' , Citygreen, website: http://blog.citygreen.com/blog/bid/374039/A-Water-Sensitive-Urban-Environment (accessed August 3, 2014)
6. Hertfordshire County Council (2014), 'Managing Surface Water Drainage' , Hertfordshire County Council, website: http://www.hertslink.org/buildingfutures/water/solutions/16766063/ (accessed: August 4, 2014).
7. ASHLEY, R.(Ed.),Garvin, S.(Ed.),PASCHE, E.(Ed.),VASSILOPOULOS, A.(Ed.),Zevenbergen, C.(Ed.)(2007).Advances in Urban Flood Management.London:Taylor and Francis Group.
8. ASHLEY, R.(Ed.),GARVIN, S.(Ed.),PASCHE, E.(Ed.),VASSILOPOULOS, A.(Ed.),ZEYENBERGEN, C.(Ed.)(2007).Advances in Urban Flood Management.London:Taylor and Francis Group.
9. Bridgman, H.,Warner, R.,Dodson, J.(1995).Urban Biophysical Environments.Melbourne:Oxford University Press.
10. Chou, R. J.(2012).The problems of watercourse redevelopment: Disseminating new knowledge about flood risk perception in Taiwan's densely populated, typhoon-affected urban areas.International Development Planning Review,34(3),241-267.
11. Chou, R. J.(2011).From policy to implementation: The case of developing watercourses towards multi-functionality in flood-afflicted Taiwan.International Development Planning Review,33(2),213-239.
12. Construction Industry Research and Information Association=CIRIA(2001).Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems: Best Practice Manual for England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.London:CIRIA.
13. Construction Industry Research and Information Association=CIRIA(2000).Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems: Design Manual for England and Wales.London:CIRIA.
14. D'Arcy, B. J.,McLean, N.,Heal, K. V.,Kay, D.(2007).Riparian wetlands for enhancing the self-purification capacity of streams.Water Science and Technology,56(1),49-57.
15. David, L. M.,Sousa, P.(2008).SuDS Application in Catchment Retrofitting: Suitability for the Lisbon Rainfall Pattern.11th International Conference on Urban Drainage,Edinburgh, Scotland, UK.:
16. Department for Transport=DfT(2007).Manual for Streets.London:Thomas Telford Publishing.
17. Dixon, J.,Sharp, L.(2007).Collaborative research in sustainable water management: Issues of interdisciplinarity.Interdisciplinary Science Reviews,32(3),221-232.
18. Douglas, I.(1983).The Urban Environment.London:Edward Arnold.
19. Environment Agency=EA(2003).Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS): A Guide for Developers.Bristol:EA.
20. Environment Agency=EA(2003).Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS): An Introduction.Bristol:EA.
21. Feyen, J.(Ed.),Shannon, K.(Ed.),Neville, M.(Ed.)(2009).Water and Urban Development Paradigms: Towards an Integration of Engineering, Design and Management Approaches.Leiden:CRC Press.
22. GARDINER, J. L.(Ed.)(1991).River Projects and Conservation: A Manual for Holistic Appraisal.Chichester:John Wiley & Sons.
23. Gilbert, O. L.(1991).The Ecology of Urban Habitats.London:Chapman and Hall.
24. Goode, D.(2006).,London:Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution.
25. Gordon, D.(Ed.)(1990).Green Cities: Ecologically Sound Approaches to Urban Space.New York:Black Rose Books.
26. Graham, A.,Day, J.,Bray, B.,MacKenzie, S.(2013).Sustainable Drainage Systems: Maximising the Potential for People and Wildlife: A Guide for Local Authorities and Developers.UK:RSPB.
27. Hall, M. J.(1984).Urban Hydrology.London:Elsevier Applied Science Publishers.
28. Hemingway, P.,Brereton, N.(2009).What is a systematic review?.Medical Sciences Division, University of Oxford.
29. Howe, J.,White, I.(2004).Like a fish out of water: The relationship between planning and flood risk management in the UK.Planning, Practice & Research,19(4),415-425.
30. Institution of Civil Engineers=ICE(2001).Learning to Live with Rivers.London:ICE.
31. Institution of Civil Engineers,Landscape Institute(1999).Liquid Assets: Making the Most of our Urban Watercourses.London:ICE.
32. Jones, P.,MacDonald, N.(2007).Making space for unruly water: Sustainable drainage systems and the disciplining of surface runoff.Geoforum,38,534-544.
33. Karr, J. R.,Chu, E. W.(2000).Sustaining living rivers.Hydrobiologia,422-423,1-14.
34. Kells, J. A.,Warner, B. G.(2000).The emergence of ecological engineering and green technology.The Canadian Civil Engineer,17,11-13.
35. Mak, C.,James, P.,Scholz, M.(2013).Linking Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) and eEcosystem Services: New Connections in Urban Ecology.Water for the future - A practical knowledge exchange,Preston:
36. Matsushita, J.,Ozaki, M.,Nishimura, S.,Ohgaki, S.(2001).Rainwater drainage management for urban development based on public-private partnership.Water Science and Technology,44(2-3),295-303.
37. National SuDS Working Group(2004).Interim Code of Practice for Sustainable Drainage Systems.London:CIRIA.
38. Office of Deputy Prime Minister=ODPM(2003).Preparing for Floods.London:ODPM.
39. PACIONE, M.(Ed.)(1999).Applied Geography: Principles and Practice.London:Routledge.
40. Scholz, M.,Grabowiecki, P.(2007).Review of permeable pavement systems.Building and Environment,42(11),3830-3836.
41. Scholz, M.,Morgan, R.,Picher, A.(2005).Stormwater resources development and management in Glasgow: Two case studies.International Journal of Environment Studies,62(3),263-282.
42. Scottish Environment Protection Agency=SEPA(2000).Watercourses in the Community: A Guide to Sustainable Watercourse Management in the Urban Environment.Stirling:SEPA.
43. Sharma, D.(2008).Sustainable Drainage System (SuDS) for Stormwater Management: A Technological and Policy Intervention to Combat Diffuse Pollution.11th International Conference on Urban Drainage,Edinburgh, Scotland, UK.:
44. Spirn, A. W.(1984).The Granite Garden: Urban Nature and Human Design.New York:Basic Books.
45. Turner, T.(1996).City as Landscape: A Post-Postmodern View of Design and Planning.London:E & FN Spon.
46. United Nations Centre for Human Settlements=UN-HABITAT(2007).Enhancing Urban Safety and Security: Global Report on Human Settlements 2007.London:Earthscan Publications Ltd..
47. United Nations Educational、 Scientific, and Cultural Organization(2005).Global Change Impacts in Mountain Biosphere Reserves.Paris:UNESCO.
48. Wang, Y. C.(2010)。Taiwan，National University of Kaohsiung。
49. Water Environment Federation,American Society of Civil Engineers(1998).Urban Run-off Quality Management.Alexandria:WEF.
50. Water, Anglian(2009).Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) Guide.Huntingdon:Anglian Water.
51. Water, Anglian(2011).Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) Manual.Huntingdon:Anglian Water.
52. White, I.,Howe, J.(2004).The mismanagement of surface water.Applied Geography,24,261-280.
53. Woods-Ballard, B.,Kellagher, R.,Martin, P.,Jefferies, C.,Bray, R.,Shaffer, P.(2007).The SuDS manual.London:CIRIA.
54. World Wide Fund For Nature=WWF(2002).Turning the Tide on Flooding.Aberfeldy:WWF-UK-Scotland.