證券詐欺與資訊平等的拔河－評美國內線交易法制的發展

A Tug of War between Securities Fraud and Informational Parity Some Observations on the Development of the United States Insider Trading Law

10.6509/TLM.201312_64(12).0003

賴英照(In-Jaw Lai)

內線交易 ； 證券詐欺 ； 資訊平等 ； 健全市場理論 ； 信賴關係理論 ； Insider Trading ； Securities Fraud ； Parity in Information ； Market Integrity Theory ； Fiduciary Relations Theory

法令月刊

64卷12期（2013 / 12 / 01）

48 - 66

繁體中文

1. ProCon.org, How do Congressional representatives' stocks perform in relation to the general market? available at http://insidertrading.procon.org/iewanswers.php?questionID=001034.
2. Brody Mullins et al., Congress Staffers Grain from Trading in Stocks, Wall St. J. Oct. 11, 2010, at Al.
3. Apolinsky, Joanna B.(2011).Insider Trading as Misfeasance: The Yielding of the Fiduciary Requirement.Kansas Law Rev.,59,493-539.
4. Bailey, Robert, Jr.(2010).SEC v. Cuban: the Misapropriation Theory and Its Application to Confidentiality Agreements Under Section 10(B) and Rule 10B5-2 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.Del. J. of Corp. L.,35,539-561.
5. Bainbridge, Stephen M.(2011).Insider Trading Inside the Beltway.J. Corp. L.,36,281-307.
6. Bainbridge, Stephen M.(2009).Financial Services & E-Commerce: The Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge Act.Engage,10,59-65.
7. Bainbridge, Stephen M.(1999).Insider Trading Regulation: The Path Dependent Choice Between Property Rights and Securities Fraud.SMU. L. Rev.,52,1589-1651.
8. Bainbridge, Stephen M.(2009).Ruling on Hackers as Inside Traders: Right in Theory, Wrong on the Law.Legal Backgrounder (WLF),24(32)
9. Barbarbella, Matthew(2009).Insider Trading in Congress: The Need for Regulation.J. Bus. & Sec. L.,9,199-256.
10. Bebel, Christopher J.(1998).A Detailed Analysis of United States v. O'Hagan: Onward Through the Evolution of the Federal Securities Laws.Louisiana Law Review,59,1-61.
11. Bloomenthal, Harold S.,Wolff, Samuel(2002).Securities and Federal Corporate Law.West Group.
12. Brudney, Victor(1979).Insiders, Outsiders, and Informational Advantages under the Federal Securities Laws.Harv. L. Rev.,93,322-376.
13. Choper, Jesse H.,Coffee, John C., Jr.,Gilson, Ronald J.(2008).Cases & Materials on Corporations.Aspen Publishers.
14. Coffee, John C., Jr.,Seligman, Joel,Sale, Hillary A.(2007).Securities Regulation, Cases & Materials.Foundation Press.
15. Coles, Kathleen(2005).The Dilemma of the Remote Tippee.Gonz. L. Rev.,41,181-236.
16. Cox, James D.,Hillman, Robert W.,Langevoort, Donald C.(2009).Securities Regulation, Cases and Materials.Aspen Publishers.
17. Davis, Ryan M.(2010).Trimming the "Judicial Oak": Rule 10b5-2(b)(l), Confidentiality Agreements, and the Proper Scope of Insider Trading Liability.Vand.,63,1469-1506.
18. De Soto, Starkey(2012)."Well, Now I'm Screwed": The Ever-Expanding Liability for Outsider Trading.Whittier Law Rev.,33,275-310.
19. DiGiovanni, Mark F.(2012).Weeding out a New Theory of Insider Trading Liability and Cultivating an Heirloom Variety: A Proposed Response to SEC v. Dorozhko.Geo. Masson L. Rev.,19,593-627.
20. Doyle, Sean F.(2010).Simplifying the Analysis: The Second Circuit Lays Out a Straightforward Theory of Fraud in SEC v. Dorozhko.North Carolina L. Rev.,89,357-386.
21. George, Andrew(2008).Public (Self)-Service: Illegal Trading on Confidential Congressional Information.Harv. L. & Pol'y Rev.,2,161-172.
22. Hoffer, Douglas J.(2011).Quagmire: Is the SEC Stuck in a Misguided War Against PIPE Financing?.Tennessee J. of Bus. L.,12,9-36.
23. Karol, Brain A.(2011).Deception Absent Duty: Computer Hackers & Section 10 (B) Liability.Univ. of Miami Bus. L. Rev.,19,185-218.
24. Kim, Sung Hui(2013).The Last Temptation of Congress: Legislator Insider Trading and the Fuduciary Norm Against Corruption.Cor. L. Rev.,98,845-920.
25. Langevoort, Donald C.(2013)."Fine Distinctions" in the Contemporary Law of Insider Trading.Colum. Bus. L. Rev,2013,429-462.
26. Langevoort, Donald C.(2009).Insider Trading Regulation, Enforcement and Prevention.Thomson Reuters/West.
27. Langevoort, Donald C.(1999).Rereading Cady, Roberts: The Ideology and Practice of Insider Trading Regulation.Colum. L. Rev.,99,1319-1343.
28. Loss, Louis,Seligman, Joel(2004).Fundamentals of Securities Regulation.Aspen Publishers.
29. Macey, Jonathan R.,O'Hara, Maureen(2009).Essay, Regulation and Scholarship: Constant Companions or Occasional Bedfellows?.Yale J. on Reg.,26,89-116.
30. Nagy, Donna M.(2011).Insider Trading, Congressional Officials, and Duties of Entrustment.B. U, L. Rev.,91,1105-1163.
31. Nagy, Donna M.(1998).Reframing the Misapproprivation Theory of Insider Trading Liability: A Post-O'Hagan Suggestion.Ohio St. L. Rev.,59,1223-1310.
32. Nelson, Adam R.(2012).Extending Outsider Trading Liability to Thieves.Fordham Law Review,80,2157-2198.
33. Odian, Elizabeth A.(2011).SEC v. Dorozhko's Affirmative Misrepresentation Theory of Insider Trading: Improper Means to a Proper End.Marquette L. Rev.,94,1313-1349.
34. Pahl, Joseph(2012).A Heart as Far From Fraud as Heaven from Earth: SEC v. Cuban and Fiduciary Duties Under Rule 10B5-2.Northwestern University Law Review,106,1849-1882.
35. Painter, Richard W.(2009).Getting the Government America Deserves: How Ethics Reform Can Make A Difference.Oxford University Press.
36. Prentice, Robert A(1999).The Internet and Its Challenges for the Future of Insider Trading Regulation.Harv. J. L. & Tech.,12,263-364.
37. Wheatley, Michael D.(2010).Apologia for the Second Circuit's Opinion in SEC v. Dorozhko.J. of L. Eco. & Policy,7,25-60.
38. Ziobrowski, Alan J.(2004).Abnormal Returns from the Common Stock Investments of the U.S. Senate.J. Fin. & Quantitative Analysis,39,661-676.
39. 劉連煜(2012)。內線交易構成要件。台北:元照。
40. 賴英照(2011)。最新證券交易法解析。台北:自版。

1. 黃朝琮(2016)。內線消息傳遞責任之探討。法令月刊，67(6)，97-121。
2. 江朝聖(2016)。走出內線交易犯罪所得計算泥沼之嘗試─兼評最高法院104 年度台上字第2932 號刑事判決。東海大學法學研究，48，117-168。
3. 江朝聖(2018)。論明訂「預定交易計畫」作為內線交易抗辯事由之必要性。東吳法律學報，30(2)，43-78。
4. (2015)。防制內線交易的危機：隱匿財報造假，內線交易無罪？。中原財經法學，34，1-41。
5. (2016)。國會議員與內線交易─兼論證券交易法「基於職業關係獲悉消息之人」之範圍。興大法學，19，201-236。