音樂介入對早產兒生理指標的影響：系統性文獻回顧與統合分析

The Effects of Music Interventions on Physiological Indicators in Premature Infants: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

10.6540/NTJN.2017.2.005

戴仲宜(Chung-Yi Tai)；劉淑芬(Doresses Liu)

早產兒 ； 音樂介入 ； 統合分析 ； premature infant ； music intervention ； meta-analysis

新臺北護理期刊

19卷2期（2017 / 09 / 01）

47 - 59

繁體中文

背景：許多文獻證實音樂能對神經傳導產生直接的影響，進而適當調節心率、呼吸和降低血壓等作用。本文旨在透過全面性、系統性文獻搜尋與研究成果整合，探討音樂介入對於早產兒生理指標之影響。方法：採系統性回顧法，關鍵字為：「早產（Premature Birth [MeSH]）」、「早產兒（Infant, Premature [MeSH]）」、「音樂（Music [MeSH]）」與「音樂治療（Music Therapy [MeSH]）」，搜尋Cochrane Library、Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature（CINAHL）、Embase、PubMed、Web of Science與華藝線上圖書館等資料庫，文章出版日期至2016年12月的論文。運用“Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Intervention-tool for assess the risk of bias＂評價研究品質，以RevMan 5.3統計軟體進行統合分析。結果：共納入8篇的研究進行統合分析，結果顯示音樂介入對早產兒生理指標的影響，心跳速率是唯一呈現顯著差異的生理指標（MD=-2.94, CI: -5.62~-0.27）。另二項指標呼吸速率（MD=-1.8, CI: -4.39~0.80）與血氧飽和濃度（MD=0.97, CI: -0.26~2.20）皆未呈現顯著差異。結論：音樂介入對早產兒的心率降低有顯著的效果，而在呼吸速率減少與血氧飽和濃度增加的效果雖然不顯著，仍可看出結果偏向於音樂介入的趨勢。但目前關於早產兒運用音樂介入的研究，由於音樂形式與種類的選擇差異很大，且執行時間長短不一，因此很難有一具體穩健的成果能加以推論，建議學者專家盡早建立臨床操作指引。

Background: Previous studies have revealed that music interventions can regulate heart rate, respiration and blood pressure through affecting nerve conduction. This study aimed to explore the effects of music interventions on physiological indicators in premature infants by conducting a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis. Methods: We searched literature systematically by using keywords: ＂premature (Premature Birth [MeSH])＂, ＂premature infant (Infant, Premature [MeSH])＂, ＂music (Music [MeSH])＂ and ＂music therapy (Music Therapy [MeSH])＂ on electronic database, including Cochrane Library, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, Embase, PubMed, Web of Science, and Airiti Library from their first available date until December 2016. We assessed the quality of studies using the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Intervention-tool for assessing the risk of bias. We also performed a meta-analysis using the RevMan 5.3 software. Results: A total of 8 studies were included in quantitative analyses. The results revealed significant effects favoring music interventions on premature infants' heart rate (MD=-2.94, CI: -5.62~-0.27), but no significant effects on respiratory rate (MD=-1.8, CI: -4.39~0.80) and oxygen saturation (MD=0.97, CI: -0.26~2.20). Conclusion: Music interventions had a significant effect on heart rate reduction but not on respiratory rate reduction and oxygen saturation increase in premature infants. The effects of music interventions on physiologic indicators in premature infants remain inconclusive due to variations in the music type and duration employed in existing studies.

1. 王淯汶,張瑩如(2015)。發展性照護之理論發展與研究趨勢。護理雜誌，62(5)，89-95。
   連結：
2. 陳柏成,莊情惠(2016)。不同類固醇注射介入腕隧道症候群病人之成效－貝氏網絡統合分析。護理雜誌，63(3)，73-82。
   連結：
3. 趙明玲,何渼樺,邢鴻君(2010)。音樂治療介入對降低婦女生產焦慮之生理及心理反應成效研究。助產雜誌，52，21-30。
   連結：
4. Alipour, Z.,Eskandari, N.,Hossaini, S. K. E.,Sangi, S.(2013).Effects of music on physiological and behavioral responses of premature infants: a randomized controlled trial.Complementary therapies in clinical practice,19(3),128-132.
5. Amini, E.,Rafiei, P.,Zarei, K.,Gohari, M.,Hamidi, M.(2013).Effect of lullaby and classical music on physiologic stability of hospitalized preterm infants: a randomized trial.Journal of neonatal-perinatal medicine,6(4),295-301.
6. Antelmi, I.,De Paula, R. S.,Shinzato, A. R.,Peres, C. A.,Mansur, A. J.,Grupi, C. J.(2004).Influence of age, gender, body mass index, and functional capacity on heart rate variability in a cohort of subjects without heart disease.The American journal of cardiology,93(3),381-385.
7. Arnon, S.,Shapsa, A.,Forman, L.,Regev, R.,Bauer, S.,Litmanovitz, I.,Dolfin, T.(2006).Live music is beneficial to preterm infants in the neonatal intensive care unit environment.Birth,33(2),131-136.
8. Aydin, D.,Yildiz, S.(2012).Effect of classical music on stress among preterm infants in a neonatal intensive care unit.Health Med,6(9),3162-3168.
9. Aydın, D.,Yıldız, S.(2014).Effect of Turkish music that premature infants are made to listen during care on stress, oxygen saturation level and length of hospital stay.Journal of Human Sciences,11(1),1343-1359.
10. Bieleninik, Ł.,Ghetti, C.,Gold, C.(2016).Music therapy for preterm infants and their parents: a meta-analysis.Pediatrics,138(3),e20160971.
11. Bieleninik, Ł.,Gold, C.(2014).Early intervention for premature infants in neonatal intensive care unit.Acta Neuropsychologica,12(2),185-203.
12. Cassidy, J. W.(2009).The effect of decibel level of music stimuli and gender on head circumference and physiological responses of premature infants in the NICU.Journal of music therapy,46(3),180-190.
13. Dorn, F.,Wirth, L.,Gorbey, S.,Wege, M.,Zemlin, M.,Maier, R. F.,Lemmer, B.(2014).Influence of acoustic stimulation on the circadian and ultradian rhythm of premature infants.Chronobiology international,31(9),1062-1074.
14. Ellis, R. J.,Thayer, J. F.(2010).Music and autonomic nervous system dysfunction.Music Perception: An Interdisciplinary Journal,27(4),317-326.
15. Farhat, A.,Amiri, R.,Karbandi, S.,Esmaily, H.(2010).The effect of listening to lullaby music on physiologic response and weight gain of premature infants1.Journal of neonatal-perinatal medicine,3,1-5.
16. Garunkstiene, R.,Buinauskiene, J.,Uloziene, I.,Markuniene, E.(2014).Controlled trial of live versus recorded lullabies in preterm infants.Nordic Journal of Music Therapy,23(1),71-88.
17. Hartling, L.,Shaik, M. S.,Tjosvold, L.,Leicht, R.,Liang, Y.,Kumar, M.(2009).Music for medical indications in the neonatal period: a systematic review of randomised controlled trials.Archives of Disease in Childhood-Fetal and Neonatal Edition,94(5),F349-F354.
18. Haslbeck, F. B.(2012).Music therapy for premature infants and their parents: An integrative review.Nordic Journal of Music Therapy,21(3),203-226.
19. Higgins, J. P.,Green, S.(2011).Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions.John Wiley & Sons.
20. Hodges, A.,Wilson, L.(2010).Preterm infants’ responses to music: An integrative literature review.Southern Online Journal of Nursing Research,10(3),1-16.
21. Jabraeili, M.,Sabet, T.,MustafaGharebaghi, M.,Jafarabadi, M. A.,Arshadi, M.(2016).The Effect of Recorded Mum's Lullaby and Brahm's Lullaby on Oxygen Saturation in Preterm Infants: a Randomized Double-Blind Clinical Trial.Journal of caring sciences,5(1),85.
22. Keith, D. R.,Russell, K.,Weaver, B. S.(2009).The effects of music listening on inconsolable crying in premature infants.Journal of music therapy,46(3),191-203.
23. Khalfa, S.,Bella, S. D.,Ror, M.,Peretz, I.,Lupien, S. J.(2003).Effects of relaxing music on salivary cortisol level after psychological stress.Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences: The Neurosciences and Music,999(1),374-376.
24. Laptook, A.,Salhab, W.,Allen, J.,Saha, S.,Walsh, M.(2006).Pulse oximetry in very low birth weight infants: can oxygen saturation be maintained in the desired range?.Journal of Perinatology,26(6),337-341.
25. Lawn, J. E.,Davidge, R.,Paul, V. K.,von Xylander, S.,de Graft Johnson, J.,Costello, A.,Molyneux, L.(2013).Born too soon: care for the preterm baby.Reproductive Health,10(1),S5.
26. Loewy, J.,Stewart, K.,Dassler, A.-M.,Telsey, A.,Homel, P.(2013).The effects of music therapy on vital signs, feeding, and sleep in premature infants.Pediatrics,131(5),902-918.
27. Pineda, R. G.,Neil, J.,Dierker, D.,Smyser, C. D.,Wallendorf, M.,Kidokoro, H.,Mathur, A. M.(2014).Alterations in brain structure and neurodevelopmental outcome in preterm infants hospitalized in different neonatal intensive care unit environments.The Journal of pediatrics,164(1),52-60.
28. Standley, J.(2002).A meta-analysis of the efficacy of music therapy for premature infants.Journal of pediatric nursing,17(2),107-113.
29. Standley, J.(2012).Music therapy research in the NICU: an updated meta-analysis.Neonatal Network,31(5),311-316.
30. van der Heijden, M. J. E.,Araghi, S. O.,Jeekel, J.,Reiss, I. K.,Hunink, M. G. M.,van Dijk, M.(2016).Do hospitalized premature infants benefit from music interventions? A systematic review of randomized controlled trials.PloS one,11(9),e0161848.
31. Wirth, L.,Dorn, F.,Wege, M.,Zemlin, M.,Lemmer, B.,Gorbey, S.,Maier, R.(2016).Effects of standardized acoustic stimulation in premature infants: a randomized controlled trial.Journal of Perinatology,36(6),486-492.
32. 王淯汶,張瑩如(2009)。早產兒血氧飽和濃度降低之概念分析。長庚護理，20(3)，327-333。
33. 危娟,徐富霞(2014)。音樂療法在早產兒護理中的初步應用。護理研究：下旬版，28(1)，329-330。
34. 周莉莉,王如華(2001)。音樂治療於兒科護理之應用。護理雜誌，48(5)，51-56。
35. 施以諾(2003)。音樂治療與健康照護。長庚護理，14(1)，73-77。
36. 徐秀滿,陳萩憶(2012)。探討音樂治療對早產兒生理指標的影響。長庚護理，23(2)，135-144。
37. 袁朝蓉,華一鳴,李慈音(2009)。從氧化壓力重新思考早產兒氧氣的使用。護理雜誌，56(4)，77-82。
38. 陳燕雅,關炳生,李澤楷(2016)。早產兒音樂療法臨床應用效果的 Meta 分析。中國護理管理，7，895-901。
39. 黃月佳,劉映,方座華(2016)。中醫宮音治療對早產兒生長發育影響的臨床研究。深圳中西醫結合雜誌，15，50-51。
40. 齊彥春(2004)。音樂療法的相關問題及其臨床應用。護理研究，18(3)，473-474。