優質護理職場醫院策略方案分析

Strategies of Quality Nursing Work Environment

10.6540/NTJN.2017.2.002

林秋芬(Chiou-Fen Lin)；李秋桂(Chiu-Kuel Li)；張靜芬(Ching-Fen Chang)；謝佳容(Chia-Jung Hsieh)；黃仲毅(Chung-I Huang)；盧美秀(Meei-Shiow Lu)

優質 ； 護理職場 ； 醫院 ； 策略方案 ； high-quality ； nursing work environment ； hospital ； strategy

新臺北護理期刊

19卷2期（2017 / 09 / 01）

7 - 17

繁體中文

背景：台灣有許多醫院因護理人力不足關病房，但也有些醫院不缺護理人力，它們如何做到，是引發本研究的動機。目的：透過優質護理職場選拔得獎醫院書面資料，探討優質護理職場醫院的策略方案。方法：採多元研究法透過三階段進行，第一階段確認優質護理職場醫院評審項目；第二階段為辦理優質護理職場醫院選拔；第三階段就得獎醫院書面資料進行歸納性內容分析。結果：針對18 家獲獎醫院書面資料分析，找出五大構面策略方案，分別為（一）「領導與管理」構面：「護理主管採用參與式管理」、「傾聽基層人員意見」、「重視申訴管道」、「院方重視護理部」。（二）「人事政策及薪資福利」構面：實施「工作績效獎金」、「建立護理臨床教師制度」。（三）「結構性賦權」構面：「護理部主管參與院內重要會議」。（四）「專業照護」構面：「明訂各職級護理人員之工作職責」、「專人協助新進護理師適應工作與生活」。（五）「創新與改善」構面為「電子化護理行動車提供各項相關資訊連結」。結論／實務應用：本研究結果發現得獎醫院都有不同的策略方案，建議醫院和政府在發展優質護理職場環境時，應積極參考優質護理職場醫院的策略方案，將有助護理人力招募與留任，讓病人獲得更優質、安全的照護品質。

Background: This study is motivated by the fact that in Taiwan some hospitals closed down wards due to shortage of nursing manpower, but some other hospitals do not have this issue and how they can do it . Purpose: This study aims to review the documents from the hospital selection campaign of the quality nursing work environment to research the core strategic plan of the quality nursing work environment. Methods: The study adopts qualitative research through three phases. The first phase is to confirm assessment items of the quality nursing work environment that go through the conference of common consensus led by nursing managers. The second phase is to process the hospital selection of the quality nursing work environment. The third phase is to use inductive content analysis of competition documents from prizewinner hospitals. Finally, the study utilizes the content of structural data to induct and analyze the core contents of assessment items. Results: The strategic plan of each stage adopted mostly by 18 prizewinner hospitals is as follows. The first one is that nursing managers adopt participative management in the stage of leading and management. The second one is to use the prize of working performance and establish nursing clinical teacher system in the stage of personnel policy and salary benefit. The third one is that managers of nursing department join the majority of meetings in the stage of structural authorization. The fourth one is to identify the accountability in each level of nursing personnel clearly in the stage of professional caring. The fifth one is to connect and provide information by the electronic nursing cart in the stage of innovation and improvement. Conclusion and application: This study researches the core strategic plan of the quality nursing work environment by inductive content analysis. It is suggested that the government and hospitals while are exploring the quality nursing work environment should refer the core strategy of five domains actively. This will be useful on nursing personnel recruitment and retainment, and provide the best quality and safety caring for patients.

1. Lin, C. F.,Lu, M. S.,Huang, H. Y.(2016).The Psychometric Properties and the Development of the Indicators of Quality Nursing Work Environments in Taiwan.The Journal of Nursing Research,24(1),9-20.
   連結：
2. 張慧蘭, H. L.,盧美秀, M. S.,林秋芬, C. F.(2010)。應屆畢業新進護理人員離職相關因素之探討。醫護科技期刊，12(3)，161-172。
   連結：
3. 顧豔秋, Y. C.(2015)。推動護理職場正向工作環境。源遠護理，9(1)，12-18。
   連結：
4. Aiken, L. H.,Patrician, P. A.(2000).Measuring organizational traits of hospitals: The Revised Nursing Work Index.Nursing Research,49(3),146-153.
5. American Nurses Credentialing Center. (2014). Magnet Recognition Program model. Retrieved from http://www.nursecredential.org/magnet/programoverview/New-Magnet-Model.aspx
6. Broom, C.,Tilbury, M.(2007).Magnet status: A journey, not a destination.Journal of Nursing Care Quality,22(2),113-118.
7. Canadian federation of nurses unions. (2012). The nursing workforce Canadian federation of nurses unions backgrounder. Retrieved from http://www.nursesunions.ca/sites/default/files/2012.backgrounder.nursing_workforce.e_0.pdf
8. Centrella-Nigro, A. M.,Faber, K.,Wiklinski, B.,Bognar, L.,Flynn, D. L.,LaForgia, M.(2015).Effective collaboration among magnet hospitals: A win-win for nurses and institutions.The American journal of Nursing,115(7),50-54.
9. Cohen, J,Stuenkel, D,Nguyen, Q(2009).Providing a healthy work environment for nurses: the influence on retention.Journal of Nursing Care Quality,24(4),308-315.
10. Elo, S.,Kyngäs, H.(2008).The qualitative content analysis process.Journal of Advanced Nursing,62(1),107-115.
11. Friese, C. R.,Xia, R.,Ghaferi, A.,Birkmeyer, J. D.,Banerjee, M.(2015).Hospitals in 'magnet' program show better patient outcomes on mortality measures compared to non-'magnet' hospitals.Health affairs (Project Hope),34(6),986-992.
12. International Council of Nurses. (2007). Positive practice environments: Quality workplaces = quality patient care. Information and action tool kit developed by Andrea Baumann for ICN. Retrieved February 4, 2008, from the ICN Web site: http://www.icn.ch/indkit2007.pdf
13. Juraschek, S. P.,Zhang, X.,Ranganathan, V. K.,Lin, V. W.(2012).United States registered nurse workforce report card and shortage forecast.American Journal of Medical Quality,27(3),241-249.
14. MacKusick, C. I.,Minick, P.(2010).Why are nurses leaving? Finding from an initial qualitative study on nursing attrition.MEDSURG Nursing: Official Journal of the Academy of Medical-Surgical Nurses,19(6),335-340.
15. Ritter, D.(2011).The relationship between health work environments and retention of nurses in a hospital setting.Journal of Nursing Management,19(1),27-32.
16. 行政院衛生署（2013）‧醫療資訊網─醫事人員管理系統，臺閩地區護理人員統計‧臺北市：行政院衛生署。「Ministry of Health and Welfare. (2013). Health Information Network (HIN): Medical personnel management system, Taiwan and Fujian area paramedics Statistics. Department of Health: Taipei City Government.」
17. 李作英（2015）‧台灣護理資訊學會推動電子病歷之配套措施與建言‧取自http://www.mi.tcu.edu.tw/2015/route.html「Lee, C. E. (2015). The EMR strategy in nursing. Retrieved from http://www.mi.tcu.edu.tw/2015/route.html」
18. 林秋芬, C. F.,黃仲毅, C. I.,高靖秋, C. C.,盧美秀, M. S.(2013)。台灣護理人力短缺與留任措施。護理雜誌，60(3)，88-93。
19. 施麗香, L. H.,黃心樹, H. S.(2015)。人力資源彈性運用對護理人員留任意願之影響。澄清醫護管理雜誌，11(2)，15-23。
20. 柯雅婷, Y. T.,王秀紅, H. H.,周汎澔, F. H.(2014)。從後現代主義反思新手護理師之留任。高雄護理雜誌，31(1)，30-38。
21. 教育部統計處（2015.12.14）‧教育統計資料-大專校院各校科系別畢業生數‧取自http://140.111.1.140/pages/detail.aspx?Node=3752&Page=17284&Index=1&WID=31d75a44-efff-4c44-a075-15a9eb7aecdf 「Ministry of Education Republic of China (Taiwan) (2015.12.14)英譯」
22. 梁淑媛, S. Y.,莊宇慧, Y. H.,吳淑芳, S. F.(2012)。內容分析技巧在護理質性資料之初步應用。護理雜誌，59(5)，84-90。
23. 陳俊賢, J. S.,吳美容, M. J.,宋翠葉, T. Y.,林秋芬, C. F.(2011)。建構優質護理執業環境改善策略。新台北護理期刊，13(1)，43-51。
24. 黃仲毅, C. I.,盧美秀, M. S.(2013)。運用彈性護理人力資源管理，解決護理人力短缺問題。領導護理，14(2)，10-21。
25. 盧美秀(2014)。建構具吸引力之優質護理職場。醫療品質雜誌，8(1)，4-11。
26. 盧美秀, M. S.,林秋芬, C. F.,高日華, J. F.,黃仲毅, G. I.,賴甫誌, F. J.,黃璉華, L. F.,許麗珠, L. J.,陳玉枝, Y. J.(2013)。,臺北市=Taipei:行政院衛生署=Ministry of Health and Welfare。

1. 馬淑清,柯雅婷(2021)。營造新手護理師的友善職場－策略篇。源遠護理，15(3)，5-10。
2. 楊麗珠,陳麗琴(2021)。新世代科技護理鏈結優質職場。源遠護理，15(3)，17-24。