摘要結果獲知的時近訊息有利於自我控制學習

Enhancing Self-Controlled Learning through Recency Information in Summary Knowledge of Results

10.5297/ser.1801.002

吳詩薇(Elyse Shih-Wei Wu)；張至滿(Jim Chih-Man Chang)；卓俊伶(Hank Jun-Ling Jwo)；蔡銘仁(Min-Jen Tsai)

動作學習 ； 回饋 ； 時近效應 ； 自我控制回饋 ； motor learning ； feedback ； recency effect ； self-controlled feedback

大專體育學刊

18卷1期（2016 / 03 / 31）

14 - 26

繁體中文;英文

自我控制學習的動作學習者經由一系列動作練習之後，其選擇回饋訊息的內容是否依據動作記憶的時程，尚需釐清。本研究旨在探討透過自我控制學習的方式，其與記憶有關的時間遠近效應在動作表現與學習中的角色。60 名女性成人實驗參加者練習三段式N 字型序列時宜的按鍵動作，在獲得期進行90 次試作，並於24 小時後進行保留測驗。獲得期試作後，依選擇較多時近或時遠的次數，區分為較多時遠摘要結果獲知組與較多時近摘要結果獲知組。研究結果顯示：較多時近摘要結果獲知組，無論在獲得期和保留測驗的準確性，皆顯著優於較多時遠摘要結果獲知組；兩組改變分數未達顯著差異。本研究結論指出透過自我控制學習的方式，選擇較多時近的回饋有利於動作準確性的表現與學習。

It is necessary to clarify whether motor learners choose feedback information contents related to time course of motor memory after practicing in a series of movements through self-controlled learning. The purpose of this study was to examine the role of memory issues related to primacy and recency effects on motor performance and learning ability under the self-controlled learning. Sixty female adults served as participants, and were requested to practice a sequential timing task with three movement segments of ＂N＂ shape. All participants practiced 90 trials during the acquisition phase, and 24 hours delayed retention tests were administered. Participants were categorized into either more-recency SKR (summary knowledge of results) or more-primacy SKR groups, according to the selection of relatively high recency or primacy feedback trials after the acquisition phase. The results showed that more-recency SKR group had significantly higher accuracy than that of more-primacy SKR group in both acquisition phase and retention test. Furthermore, the change score was found no significant difference. Findings from this study suggest that choosing more recency information facilitated to enhance both motor performance and learning ability of movement accuracy through self-controlled learning.

1. 吳詩薇、張至滿、卓俊伶(2012)。摘要結果獲知的時間與順序安排：檢驗時近效應。大專體育學刊，14(2)，152-160。
   連結：
2. 吳詩薇、張至滿、卓俊伶(2014)。口語摘要結果獲知在動作表現與學習的時近效應。大專體育學刊，16(1)，26-36。
   連結：
3. 李淑華、林靜兒(2013)。自我控制回饋促進動作技能學習之因素。中華體育季刊，27(4)，335-341。
   連結：
4. 林尚武、卓俊伶、楊梓楣、陳重佑、葉俊良(2009)。自發錯誤估計促進自我控制回饋的動作學習效益。體育學報，42(2)，15-28。
   連結：
5. 陳孟文、林靜兒(2013)。自我控制的觀察學習與回饋促進動作學習。大專體育學刊，15(1)，21-28。
   連結：
6. 葉俊良、卓俊伶、林靜兒、陳重佑(2007)。自我控制回饋對動作表現、學習及錯誤估計的效應。大專體育學刊，9(1)，23-35。
   連結：
7. Adams, J. A.(1971).A closed-loop theory of motor learning.Journal of Motor Behavior,3(2),111-150.
8. Bilodeau, E. A.,Bilodeau, I. M.(1958).Variable frequency of knowledge of results and the learning of a simple skill.Journal of Experimental Psychology,55(4),379-383.
9. Carnahan, H.,Vandervoort, A. A.,Swanson, L. R.(1996).The influence of summary knowledge of results and aging on motor learning.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,67(3),280-287.
10. Chen, D. D.,Hendrick, J. L.,Lidor, R.(2002).Enhancing self-controlled learning environments: The use of self-regulated feedback information.Journal of Human Movement Studies,43(1),69-86.
11. Chiviacowsky, S.(2014).Self-controlled practice: Autonomy protects perceptions of competence and enhances motor learning.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,15(5),505-510.
12. Chiviacowsky, S.,Wulf, G.(2007).Feedback after good trials enhances learning.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,78(2),40-47.
13. Chiviacowsky, S.,Wulf, G.(2002).Self-controlled feedback: Does it enhance learning because performers get feedback when they need it?.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,73(4),408-415.
14. Chiviacowsky, S.,Wulf, G.,Medeiros, F. L.,Kaefer, A.,Wally, R.(2008).Self-controlled feedback in 10-year-old children: Higher feedback frequencies enhance learning.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,79(1),122-127.
15. Cowan, N.,Morey, C. C.(2007).How can dual-task working memory retention limits be investigated?.Psychological Science,18(8),686-688.
16. Fuster, J. M.(1995).Memory in the cerebral cortex: An empirical approach to neural networks in the human and nonhuman primate.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
17. Gillespie, M.(2003).Summary versus every-trial knowledge of results for individuals with intellectual disabilities.Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly,20(1),46-56.
18. Green, S.,Sherwood, D. E.(2000).The benefits of random variable practice for accuracy and temporal error detection in a rapid aiming task.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,71(4),398-402.
19. Guadagnoli, M. A.,Kohl, R. M.(2001).Knowledge of results for motor learning: Relationship between error estimation and knowledge of results frequency.Journal of Motor Behavior,33(2),217-224.
20. Guay, M.,Salmoni, A.,McIlwain, J.(1992).Summary knowledge of results for skill acquisition: Beyond Lavery and Schmidt.Human Movement Science,11(6),653-673.
21. Guérard, K.,Neath, I.,Surprenant, A. M.,Tremblay, S.(2010).Distinctiveness in serial memory for spatial information.Memory & Cognition,38(1),83-91.
22. Isarida, T.,Isarida, T. K.(2006).Influences of environmental context on the recency effect in free recall.Memory & Cognition,34(4),787-794.
23. Janelle, C. M.,Barba, D. A.,Frehlich, S. G.,Tennant, L. K.,Cauraugh, J. H.(1997).Maximizing performance feedback effectiveness through videotape replay and a self-controlled learning environment.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,68(4),269-279.
24. Janelle, C. M.,Kim, J.,Singer, R. N.(1995).Subject-controlled performance feedback and learning of a closed motor skill.Perceptual and Motor Skills,81(2),627-634.
25. Kantak, S. S.,Winstein, C. J.(2012).Learningperformance distinction and memory processes for motor skills: A focused review and perspective.Behavioural Brain Research,228(1),219-231.
26. Lavery, J. J.(1962).Retention of simple motor skills as a function of type of knowledge of results.Canadian Journal of Psychology,16(4),300-311.
27. Murdock, B. B., Jr.(1962).The serial position effect of free recall.Journal of Experimental Psychology,64(5),482-488.
28. Robertson, E. M.,Cohen, D. A.(2006).Understanding consolidation through the architecture of memories.Neuroscientist,12(3),261-271.
29. Salmoni, A. W.,Schmidt, R. A.,Walter, C. B.(1984).Knowledge of results and motor learning: A review and critical reappraisal.Psychological Bulletin,95(3),355-386.
30. Sanli, E. A.,Patterson, J. T.,Bray, S. R.,Lee, T. D.(2013).Understanding self-controlled motor learning protocols through the self-determination theory.Frontiers in Psychology,3,611.
31. Schmidt, R. A.(1975).A schema theory of discrete motor skill learning.Psychological Review,82(4),225-260.
32. Schmidt, R. A.,Bjork, R. A.(1992).New conceptualizations of practice: Common principles in three paradigms suggest new concepts for training.Psychological Science,3(4),207-217.
33. Schmidt, R. A.,Lange, C.,Young, D. E.(1990).Optimizing summary knowledge of results for skill learning.Human Movement Science,9(3),325-348.
34. Schmidt, R. A.,Lee, T. D.(2011).Motor control and learning: A behavioral emphasis.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
35. Schmidt, R. A.,Young, D. E.,Swinnen, S.,Shapiro, D. C.(1989).Summary knowledge of results for skill acquisition: Support for the guidance hypothesis.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition,15(2),352-359.
36. Van Overschelde, J. P.(2002).The influence of word frequency on recency effects in directed free recall.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition,28(4),611-615.
37. Vieira, M. M.,Ugrinowitsch, H.,Oliveira, F. S.,Gallo, L. G.,Benda, R. N.(2012).Effects of knowledge of results (KR) frequency in the learning of a timing skill: Absolute versus relative KR frequency.Perceptual and Motor Skills,115(2),360-369.
38. Weeks, D. L.,Sherwood, D. E.(1994).A comparison of knowledge of results scheduling methods for promoting motor skill acquisition and retention.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,65(2),136-142.
39. Wu, W.,Magill, R. A.(2011).Allowing learners to choose: Self-controlled practice schedules for learning multiple movement patterns.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,82(3),449-457.

1. 陳新福(2018)。不同相對頻率結果獲知回饋下網球正擊球技能學習之效應探討。嘉大體育健康休閒期刊，17(2)，1-12。
2. 梁嘉音,林幸樺,卓俊伶,吳詩薇(2022)。自我控制回饋頻率的限制效應：動作表現與學習。大專體育學刊，24(2)，271-286。
3. 張至滿,卓俊伶,吳詩薇(2019)。動作表現與學習：以動作記憶的觀點詮釋。中華體育季刊，33(1)，9-15。