Bibliometric Analysis of Physical Literacy in the Scopus Database: 2010-2020

身體素養在Scopus資料庫的文獻計量分析：2010至2020年

10.5297/ser.202209_24(3).0003

李宏盈(Hung-Ying Lee)；掌慶維(Ching-Wei Chang)

physical education ； sports sciences ； VOSviewer ； Bibliometrix R-package ； co-occurrence ； 體育 ； 運動科學 ； VOSviewer ； Bibliometrix R語言 ； 共現

大專體育學刊

24卷3期（2022 / 09 / 30）

330 - 346

英文

The multifaceted concept of physical literacy (PL) has been gaining momentum in physical education (PE) and sports sciences in recent years. The purpose of this study was to explore the bibliometric characteristics of international publication trends in PL research from 2010 to 2020. Using the keyword ＂physical literacy,＂ bibliographic records and references were retrieved from the Scopus database (retrieval date: May 27, 2021). The VOSviewer software and the Bibliometrix R-package were used for data analysis. The information was classified according to annual publication, country, journal, authors, and co-occurrences. The results indicate: There were 250 articles representing 39 countries and 97 journals. Articles published in 2018 were cited most often, and a publication peak was observed in 2020. Canada, the United States, and the United Kingdom were the three leading countries publishing PL research. Most of the articles were published in PE and public health-relevant journals. The highly cited articles identified the following core themes: PE, concept, motivation, age, and definition. In conclusion, this study noted PL's consistent presence in publications and rapid development in PE research, and identified recent PL-related topics. The logic of the PL definition could be a source of creative and innovative debates for advancing research frontiers. PL assessment is regularly updated to cover more diverse concepts and lifelong journeys. Future research should conduct in-depth studies on a single variable and an emerging issue and continue tracking and reviewing PL-related models.

近年來身體素養於體育與運動科學之探討日益增加，本研究目的在探討2010-2020年身體素養在國際出版之文獻計量特徵。透過Scopus資料庫，以身體素養為關鍵詞進行檢索（檢索日期：2021年5月27日），並利用VOSviewer軟體與Bibliometrix R語言進行書目資料分析，包含年度出版、各國出版量、期刊發布情形、作者發表狀況、共現分析。分析結果顯示：總共發表了250篇文章，包含39個國家與97本期刊，2018年被引用次數最高，2020年達出版最高峰。其中以加拿大、美國和英國為總發表篇數之前3名國家。文章大致發布於體育與公共衛生之期刊。從被高度引用的文章中確定了以下核心主題：體育、概念、動機、年齡與定義。本研究結論指出身體素養在體育研究中的持續且快速地發展，並掌握了近期於身體素養的相關主題。身體素養定義的辯論開創許多發展性的研究，而評量的內涵持續發展中，以涵蓋更多元的價值與終身旅程的概念。未來的研究可以針對單一變項或新興議題進行深度探討，並繼續追蹤與回顧身體素養的相關模型。

1. Abramo, G.,D’Angelo, C. A.(2011).Evaluating research: From informed peer review to bibliometrics.Scientometrics,87(3),499-514.
2. Anyi, W. U. K.,Zainab, A. N.,Anuar, N. B.(2009).Bibliometric studies on single journals: A review.Malaysian Journal of Library & Information Science,14(1),17-55.
3. Aria, M.,Cuccurullo, C.(2017).Bibliometrix: An R-tool for comprehensive science mapping analysis.Journal of Informetrics,11(4),959-975.
4. Bailey, R.(2022).Defining physical literacy: Making sense of a promiscuous concept.Sport in Society,25(1),163-180.
5. Briner, R. B.,Denyer, D.(2012).Systematic review and evidence synthesis as a practice and scholarship tool.Handbook of evidence-based management: Companies, classrooms and research
6. Chen, A.(2020).A clash of fundamental assumptions: Can/should we measure physical literacy?.Journal of Sport and Health Science,9(2),149-151.
7. Chen, A.(2015).Operationalizing physical literacy for learners: Embodying the motivation to move.Journal of Sport and Health Science,4(2),125-131.
8. Chen, C.(2006).CiteSpace II: Detecting and visualizing emerging trends and transient patterns in scientific literature.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,57(3),359-377.
9. Cobo, M. J.,López-Herrera, A. G.,Herrera-Viedma, E.,Herrera, F.(2011).An approach for detecting, quantifying, and visualizing the evolution of a research field: A practical application to the fuzzy sets theory field.Journal of Informetrics,5(1),146-166.
10. Corbin, C. B.(2021).Conceptual physical education: A course for the future.Journal of Sport and Health Science,10(3),308-322.
11. Corbin, C. B.(2016).Implications of physical literacy for research and practice: A commentary.Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,87(1),14-27.
12. Cornish, K.,Fox, G.,Fyfe, T.,Koopmans, E.,Pousette, A.,Pelletier, C. A.(2020).Understanding physical literacy in the context of health: A rapid scoping review.BMC Public Health,20(1),1569.
13. De Battisti, F.,Ferrara, A.,Salini, S.(2015).A decade of research in statistics: A topic model approach.Scientometrics,103(2),413-433.
14. Dudley, D.,Cairney, J.(2021).Physical literacy: Answering the call for quality education and sustainable development.Prospects,50(1-2),5-11.
15. Durden-Myers, E. J.,Green, N. R.,Whitehead, M. E.(2018).Implications for promoting physical literacy.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,37(3),262-271.
16. Durden-Myers, E. J.,Whitehead, M. E.,Pot, N.(2018).Physical literacy and human flourishing.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,37(3),308-311.
17. Edwards, L. C.,Bryant, A. S.,Keegan, R. J.,Morgan, K.,Jones, A. M.(2017).Definitions, foundations and associations of physical literacy: A systematic review.Sports Medicine,47(1),113-126.
18. Ennis, C. D.(Ed.)(2017).Routledge handbook of physical education pedagogies.Routledge.
19. Green, N. R.,Roberts, W. M.,Sheehan, D.,Keegan, R. J.(2018).Charting physical literacy journeys within physical education settings.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,37(3),272-279.
20. Hallinger, P.,Kovačević, J.(2019).A bibliometric review of research on educational administration: Science mapping the literature, 1960 to 2018.Review of Educational Research,89(3),335-369.
21. Hung, J.-L.(2012).Trends of e-learning research from 2000 to 2008: Use of text mining and bibliometrics.British Journal of Educational Technology,43(1),5-16.
22. Hussain, A.,Fatima, N.,Kumar, D.(2011).Bibliometric analysis of the "Electronic Library" journal (2000–2010).Webology,8(1),87.
23. Hyndman, B.,Pill, S.(2018).What’s in a concept? A Leximancer text mining analysis of physical literacy across the international literature.European Physical Education Review,24(3),292-313.
24. Jurbala, P.(2015).What is physical literacy, really?.Quest,67(4),367-383.
25. Keegan, R. J.,Barnett, L. M.,Dudley, D. A.,Telford, R. D.,Lubans, D. R.,Bryant, A. S.,Roberts, W. M.,Morgan, P. J.,Schranz, N. K.,Weissensteiner, J. R.,Vella, S. A.,Salmon, J.,Ziviani, J.,Okely, A. D.,Wainwright, N.,Evans, J. R.(2019).Defining physical literacy for application in Australia: A modified Delphi method.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,38(2),105-118.
26. Kirk, D.(2013).Educational value and models-based practice in physical education.Educational Philosophy and Theory,45(9),973-986.
27. Landi, D.,Walton-Fisette, J. L.,Sutherland, S.(2021).Physical education policy research in the United States: Setting a new orientation.Quest,73(1),45-62.
28. Leidl, R.(2013).A holistic approach to supporting physical literacy.Physical & Health Education Journal,79(2),19.
29. Lobelo, F.,Stoutenberg, M.,Hutber, A.(2014).The exercise is medicine global health initiative: A 2014 update.British Journal of Sports Medicine,48(22),1627-1633.
30. Longmuir, P. E.,Boyer, C.,Lloyd, M.,Borghese, M. M.,Knight, E.,Saunders, T. J.,Boiarskaia, E.,Zhu, W.,Tremblay, M. S.(2017).Canadian Agility and Movement Skill Assessment (CAMSA): Validity, objectivity, and reliability evidence for children 8-12 years of age.Journal of Sport and Health Science,6(2),231-240.
31. Lounsbery, M. A. F.,McKenzie, T. L.(2015).Physically literate and physically educated: A rose by any other name?.Journal of Sport and Health Science,4(2),139-144.
32. Pritchard, A.(1969).Statistical bibliography or bibliometrics?.Journal of Documentation,25(4),348-349.
33. Quennerstedt, M.,McCuaig, L.,Mårdh, A.(2021).The fantasmatic logics of physical literacy.Sport, Education and Society,26(8),846-861.
34. Robinson, D. B.,Randall, L.(2017).Marking physical literacy or missing the mark on physical literacy? A conceptual critique of Canada’s physical literacy assessment instruments.Measurement in Physical Education and Exercise Science,21(1),40-55.
35. Roetert, E. P.,MacDonald, L. C.(2015).Unpacking the physical literacy concept for K-12 physical education: What should we expect the learner to master?.Journal of Sport and Health Science,4(2),108-112.
36. Ryan, T. P.,Woodall, W. H.(2005).The most-cited statistical papers.Journal of Applied Statistics,32(5),461-474.
37. Shearer, C.,Goss, H. R.,Edwards, L. C.,Keegan, R. J.,Knowles, Z. R.,Boddy, L. M.,Durden-Myers, E. J.,Foweather, L.(2018).How is physical literacy defined? A contemporary update.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,37(3),237-245.
38. Spengler, J. O.,Cohen, J.(2015).Physical literacy: A global environmental scan.The Aspen Institute.
39. Sum, K. W. R.,Wallhead, T.,Ha, S. C. A.,Sit, H. P. C.(2018).Effects of physical education continuing professional development on teachers’ physical literacy and self-efficacy and students’ learning outcomes.International Journal of Educational Research,88,1-8.
40. Taplin, L.(2011).Physical literacy: An introduction to the concept.Physical Education Matters,6(1),28-30.
41. Thanuskodi, S.(2010).Journal of Social Sciences: A bibliometric study.Journal of Social Sciences,24(2),77-80.
42. Tsay, M.-Y.(2011).A bibliometric analysis and comparison on three information science journals: JASIST, IPM, JOD, 1998–2008.Scientometrics,89(2),591-606.
43. van Eck, N. J.,Waltman, L.(2017).Citation-based clustering of publications using CitNetExplorer and VOSviewer.Scientometrics,111(2),1053-1070.
44. van Eck, N. J.,Waltman, L.(2010).Software survey: VOSviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping.Scientometrics,84(2),523-538.
45. Voogt, J.,Fisser, P.,Pareja Roblin, N.,Tondeur, J.,van Braak, J.(2013).Technological pedagogical content knowledge-A review of the literature.Journal of Computer Assisted Learning,29(2),109-121.
46. Whitehead, M.(2010).The concept of physical literacy.Physical literacy: Throughout the lifecourse
47. Whitehead, M.(2010).Physical literacy: Throughout the lifecourse
48. Whitehead, M.(2010).Physical literacy, physical competence and interaction with the environment.Physical literacy: Throughout the lifecourse
49. Whitehead, M.,Durden-Myers, E. J.,Pot, N.(2018).The value of fostering physical literacy.Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,37(3),252-261.
50. Young, L.,O’Connor, J.,Alfrey, L.(2021).Mapping the physical literacy controversy: An analysis of key actors within scholarly literature.Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy,1-17.
51. Young, L.,O’Connor, J.,Alfrey, L.(2020).Physical literacy: A concept analysis.Sport, Education and Society,25(8),946-959.
52. Zupic, I.,Čater, T.(2015).Bibliometric methods in management and organization.Organizational Research Methods,18(3),429-472.