早期療育兒童發展聯合評估中心評鑑指標權重之研究

Weights of Quality Indices for Early Intervention Child Development Joint Evaluation Center

10.6457/BSER.201006.0025

王于欣(Yu-Hsin Wang)；傅秀媚(Shiou-Mei Fu)；蔡淑鳳(Shu-Feng Tsai)；吳裕益(Yuh-Yih Wu)；林巾凱(Chin-Kai Lin)

早期療育 ； 評鑑指標 ； 兒童發展聯合評估中心 ； early intervention ； evaluation of indices ； child development joint assessment center

特殊教育與復健學報

22期（2010 / 06 / 01）

25 - 42

繁體中文

本研究主要目的在探討聯合評估中心成效運作指標之權重。本研究共發出800份問卷，回收609份(76%)問卷，有效問卷518(65%)份，主要使用AHP(analysis hierarchical process)的研究方法設計調查問卷，問卷設計成二個階層，包含第一階層的主要指標與第二階層的次要指標。研究結果顯示主要指標中以評估內容的權重最高，評估內容的次要指標中以跨專業團隊評量的權重最高，服務模式的次要指標中以後續療育建議的權重最高，專業成長的次要指標中以在職訓練及繼續教育的權重為最高，其他服務的次要指標中以家長服務的權重為最高。研究結果可作為聯合評估中心提供服務與評鑑之參考。

The primary purpose of this study is to explore weights of quality indices for Early Intervention Child Development Joint Evaluation Center (EICDJAC). A total of eight hundred (800) copies of questionnaires were mailed, of which 609 copies were responded to (76%) of these, 518 (65%) copies were valid responses. The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) method was used in the question design and data analysis. The questionnaires include two hierarchical indices, the primary indices of the first hierarchy and the subindices of the second hierarchy. Results of the study show that the highest weight falls on the Assessment content in the primary indices, the assessment of transdisciplinary team in the Assessment content sub-indices; the subsequent intervention recommendations, in the Service Mode sub-indices; on the sub-indices job training and continuing education, in the Professional Growth sub-indices; and parental service, in the Other Services subindices. The results of this study could provide a reference of service and evaluation for EICDJAC.

1. 林立千、張卓寰(2005)。加工出口區發展全球運籌管理之研究。運籌管理評論，1(1)，33-48。
   連結：
2. 許碧芳、林宗瑋(2007)。醫院高級健檢中心醫療合作外包廠商評選模式—層級分析法之應用。醫務管理期刊，8(3)，232-248。
   連結：
3. 鍾瑞國、楊寶華(2006)。發展企業數位學習成效評鑑指標之研究。人力資源管理學報，6(1)，123-140。
   連結：
4. 行政院衛生署（2008）。委託辦理「97年兒童發展聯合評估中心」需求說明書。2008年7月18日，取自http://www.ptshb.gov.tw/style/front001/bexfront.php?sid=bmddyna&id=367&item=detail&class=13&depart=0&sort=1&keyword=%BD%D0%BF%E9%A4J%C3%F6%C1%E4%A6r&page=1
5. Bailey, D. B.,Hebbeler, K.,Scarborough, A.,Spiker, D.,Mallik, S.(2004).First experiences with early intervention: A national perspective.Pediatrics,113(4),887-896.
6. Cost, Quality,Child Out comes Study Team(1995).Cost, quality, and child outcomes in child care centers.Denver. CO:Department of Economics University of Colorado at Denver.
7. Dunst, C. J.,Burder, M. B.(2006).Early intervention service coordination models and service coordinator practices.Journal of Intervention,28(3),155-165.
8. Erikson, J.(1996).The Infant-Toddler Developmental Assessment (IDA): A family-centered trans-disciplinary assessment process.New visions for the developmental assessment of infants and young children,Washington, DC:
9. Fenichel, E.(ed.)(1992).Learning through supervision and mentorship to support the development of infants, toddlers and their families.Arlington, VA:Zero and Three.
10. Fewell, R. R.(2000).Assessment of young children with special needs: Foundations for tomorrow.Topics in early childhood special education,20(1),38-42.
11. Fleischer, K. H.,Belgredan, J. H.,Bangnato, S. J.,Ogonosky, A. B.(1990).An overview of judged-based assessment.Topics in early childhood special education,10,13-23.
12. Freeman, R.,Vakil, S.(2004).The role of family childcare providers in early intervention.Early childhood education journal,32(2),121-125.
13. Gallagher, P. A.,Rhodes, C. A.,Darling, S. M.(2004).Parents as professionals in early intervention: A parent educator model.Topics in early childhood special education,24(1),5-13.
14. Guralnick, M. J.(2005).The developmental system approach to early intervention.Baltinore:Brooks.
15. Halfon, N.,Inkelas, M.,Mistry, R.,Olson, L. M.(2004).Satisfaction with health care for young children.Pediatrics,113(6),1965-1972.
16. Kagan, S. L.(ed.)(1993).The essential functions of the early care and education system: Rational and definition.New Haven, CT:Quality 2000, Yale University.
17. Long, M.(1999).First steps to discovery.Denver, CO:The Legal Center and Colorado Development of Education.
18. Majnemer, A.,Shevell, M. J.,Rosenbaum, P.,Abrahamowicz, M.(2001).Early rehabilitation service utilization patterns in young children with developmental delays.Child: Care, Health & Development,28(1),29-37.
19. McConnell, S. R.(2000).Assessment in early intervention and early childhood special education: Building on the past to project into our future.Topics in early childhood special education,20(1),43-48.
20. Meisels, S. J.(1996).Charting the continuum of assessment and intervention.New visions for the developmental assessment of infants and young children,Washington, DC:
21. Neisworth, J. T.,Bagnato, S. L.(1992).The case against intelligence testing in early intervention.Topics in early childhood special education,12,1-20.
22. Olson, J.,Murphy, C. L.,Olson, P. D.(1998).Building effective successful teams: An interactive teaming model for in-service education.Journal of early intervention,21(4),339-349.
23. Paul, J.(ed.),Stedman, D.(ed.),Neufield, G.(ed.)(1977).Deinstitutionalization.Syracuse, NY:Syracuse University Press.
24. Throp, E. K.,McCollum, J. A.(1994).Defining the infancy specialization in early childhood special education.Meeting early intervention challenges: Issues from birth to three,Baltimore, MD:
25. Winton, P.(ed.),McCollum, J.(ed.),Catlett, C.(ed.)(1997).Reforming personnel preparation in early intervention: Issues, models, and practical strategies.Baltimore, MD:Paul H. Brookes.
26. 王天苗(1996)。台灣地區心智發展障礙幼兒早期療育服務供需及相關問題之研究。特殊教育研究學刊，14，21-44。
27. 行政院衛生署(2009)。,台中市:國立台中教育大學早期療育研究所。
28. 吳裕益(2005)。層級分析法（analysis hierarchical process; AHP）程式。高雄師範大學。
29. 周文麗、鄭麗珍、林惠芳(2000)。台灣早期療育的發展與未來展望。文教新潮，5(4)，7-12。
30. 林巾凱(2003)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立彰化師範大學特殊教育學系。
31. 林玉萍(2002)。專家醫師、一般醫師與治療師對發展遲緩的認知。兒童福利期刊，3，73-110。
32. 林進財、江長慈(2004)。以AHP法求算衛生署委外研究計畫績效評估指標權重。健康管理學刊，2(2)，229-240。
33. 傅秀媚(2002)。發展遲緩兒童評估發展趨勢。國教輔導，41(3)，34-40。
34. 黃振恭、沈進成(2004)。休閒農業區發展潛力評估模式之建立。生物與休閒事業研究，2(1)，1-16。
35. 黃惠如、何立博(2002)。中美英三國融合教育實施之比較—從早期療育之觀點談起。兒童福利期刊，2，35-59。
36. 萬育維、王文娟(2002)。早期療育中心角色與定位。兒童福利期刊，3，201-236。
37. 萬育維、莊凰如(1995)。從醫療與福利整合的角度探討我國發展遲緩兒童之早期療育制度之規劃。社區發展季刊，72，48-61。
38. 雷游秀華(2004)。行政院衛生署委託專案報告行政院衛生署委託專案報告,台北市:財團法人中華民國發展遲緩兒童基金會。
39. 蔡介元、王嘉慶(2006)。產品協同設計績效衡量指標之研究。產業論壇，8(3)，39-58。
40. 鄭彩鳳、陳啟榮(2005)。建構地方教育行政機關評鑑指標之研究—全面品質管理之觀點。當代教育研究，13(3)，181-222。
41. 鄭紹材、鄭森鴻(2006)。公共工程施工期間業主對施工廠商管理考核機制之研究。中華建築學刊，2(2)，27-39。
42. 鄧振源、曾國雄(1989)。層級分析法（AHP）的內涵特性與運用。中國統計學報，27(6)，5-22。
43. 鍾莉娟主編(2004)。早期療育手冊。台北市:心理出版社。