台中市國中普通班身心障礙學生遭受同儕霸凌現況之調查研究

A Survey Study of the Current Status for Students with Disabilities Bullied by Peers in Inclusive Classes

羅丰苓(Feng-Ling Lo)；盧台華(Tai-Hua Lu)

霸凌 ； 身心障礙國中生 ； 受凌學生 ； 融合教育 ； school bullying ； inclusive education ； junior high school students with disabilities ； bullied students

特殊教育與復健學報

29期（2013 / 12 / 01）

73 - 102

繁體中文

當前國內校園霸凌問題嚴重，然考量到目前台灣大多數的身心障礙國中學生主要是安置在普通班級與一般同儕一起就學，關於身心障礙學生遭受霸凌的情形實值得關注。故本研究採取調查研究法，以台中市公立國中有身心障礙學生的班級的一般同儕、身心障礙學生及導師為對象進行調查，以能探究身心障礙學生遭受霸凌的比例、受凌行為與原因為何？並進一步瞭解身心障礙受凌學生所認知遭受霸凌的行為與原因，和同儕與導師觀點的一致性情形。此外，身心障礙受凌學生也同一般受凌學生在遭受霸凌比例、行為及原因等各方面進行比較，以對身心障礙學生遭受霸凌情形有更深層的瞭解。研究結果，主要有以下發現。1.安置在普通班級的身心障礙學生遭受霸凌比率高達33%；一般學生則有5%，身心障礙學生遭受霸凌比例明顯高於一般學生。2.身心障礙受凌學生遭受霸凌行為方面，主要是以言語霸凌及關係霸凌為主。遭受霸凌原因方面，則以缺乏社交技巧為主要原因。此外，身心障礙受凌學生在所認知遭受霸凌行為與原因各方面，和同儕觀點、導師觀點均有不一致的情形。本研究依結果針對身心障礙受凌學生教學、輔導及未來研究之建議。

The bullying problem in Taiwan's schools has been increasingly serious. It is important to examine the bullying facing the students with disabilities who study in general classes. The purpose of this study was to explore the reality of the students with disabilities who are placed in general, classes and bullied by their peers. The main findings of this study are shown as follows.1. Thirty-three percent of the students with disabilities placed in general classes have suffered peer bullying whereas only 5% of their regular peers have been bullied. The bullying ratio for students with disabilities is significantly higher than that for regular students. In addition, the bullying ratio for female students with disabilities is even higher.2. The bullying behaviors encountered by students with disabilities are mainly exhibited via verbal and relational patterns. The major cause for bullying is lack of social skills. Moreover, the bullying behaviors and their causes perceived by students with disabilities are inconsistent with those perceived by their peers and teachers. This study provides recommendations for teaching, counseling, and future studies on students with disabilities.

1. 薛荷玉（2010）。不動手就沒事？ 網攻、排擠都是霸凌。取自聯合報，網址：http://mag.udn.com/mag/vote2007-08/storypage.jsp?f_ART_ ID=288129
2. 高級中等學校就讀普通班身心障礙學生安置原則及輔導辦法（2004）。
3. 陳茉莉（2009）。霸凌影響因素：個人生理缺陷。取自兒盟瞭望，2，網址：http://www.children.org.tw/about_service_1.php?id=277
4. 教育部（2011）。教育部防制校園霸凌專區【線上論壇】。取自http://140.111.1.88/faq/#id_13
5. 張益勤（2012）。北市校園霸凌，言語和關係霸凌最多。取自國立教育廣播電台，網址：http://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E5%8C97%E5%B8%82%E6%A0%A1%E5%9C%92%E9%9C%B 8%E5%87%8C-%E8%A8%80%E8%AA%9E%E5%92%8C%E9%97%9C%E4%BF%82%E9%9C%B8%E5%87%8C%E6%9C%80%E5%A4%9A-110220311.html
6. 盧台華（2000）。課程與教學。載於臺北市政府教育局（主編），臺北市八十八學年度特殊教育評鑑報告（頁439-443）。臺北市：臺北市政府教育局。。
7. 兒童福利聯盟基金會（2004）。國小兒童校園霸凌現象觀察發表。取自智邦公益館公益新聞，網址：http://www.17885.com.tw/welfare/show.asp?serial=731
8. 教育部（2007）。教育部防制校園暴力、霸凌之作法。取自 http://csrc.edu.tw/bully/issue.asp?page=1#7
9. 楊惠芳、吳啟綜（2010）。霸凌人數逾萬通報僅幾十件。取自國語日報社，網址：http://www.mdnkids.com/info/news/adv_listdetail.asp?serial=70389。
10. 楊惠芳（2006）。校園霸凌問題，全球苦思解決。取自國語日報社，網址：http://www.mdnkids.com/info/news/content.asp?Serial_NO=47633。
11. Atlas, R. S.,Pepler, D. J.(1998).Observations of bullying in the class room.The Journal of Educational Research,92,86-99.
12. Baldry, A.(2004).What about bullying?' An experimental field study to understand students' attitudes towards bullying and victimization in Italian middle schools.British Journal of Educational Psychology,74,583-598.
13. Batsche, G. M.,Knoff, H. M.(1994).Bullies and their victims: Understanding a pervasive problem in the schools.School Psychology Review,23,165-174.
14. Beaty, L.A.,Alexeyev, E.(2008).The problem of school bullies: What the research tells us.Adolescence,43(169),1-11.
15. Bejerot, S.,Edgar, J.,Humble, M. B.(2011).Poor performance in physical education - A risk factor for bully victimization. A case-control study.Acta Paediatrica,100(3),413-419.
16. Berry-Krazmien, C. A.(2006).Buffalo, NY,State University of New York.
17. Boulton, M.,Hawker, D.(1998).Emotional and psychological bullying.Young Minds,26,8-9.
18. Branwhite, T.(1994).Bullying and student distress: Beneath the tip of the iceberg.Journal of Experimental Educational Psychology,14,59-71.
19. Carlyle, K.,Steinman, K. J.(2007).Demographic differences in the prevalence, co-occurrence, and correlates of adolescent bullying at School.Journal of School Health,77(9),623-629.
20. Cranham, J.,Carroll, A.(2003).Dynamics within the bully/victim paradigm: A qualitative analysis.Educational Psychology in Practice,19,113-132.
21. Dillon, J. C.,Lash, R. M.(2005).Redefining and dealing with bullying.Momentum,36(2),34-37.
22. Estell, D.,Farmer, T.,Irvin, M.,Crowther, A.,Akos, P.,Boudah, D.(2009).Students with exceptionalities and the peer group context of bullying and victimization in late elementary school.Journal of Child & Family Studies,18(2),136-150.
23. Fuerst, D. R.,Fisk, J. L.,Rourke, B. P.(1989).Psychosocial functioning of learning-disabled children: Replicability of statistically derived subtypes.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,57,275-280.
24. Garbarino, J.,Delara, E.(2003).Words can hurt forever.Educational Leadership,60,18-21.
25. Good, C. P.,McIntosh, K.,Gietz, C.(2011).Integrating bullying prevention into schoolwide positive behavior support.Teaching Exceptional Children,44(1),48-56.
26. Gresham, F. M.,MacMillan, D. L.(1997).Social competence and affective characteristics of students with mild disabilities.Review of Educational Research,67,377.
27. Hanish, L. D.,Guerra, N. G.(2004).Aggressive victims, passive victims, and bullies: Developmental continuity or developmental change?.Merrill-Palmer Quarterly,50,17-38.
28. Heinrichs, R. R.(2003).A whole-school approach to bullying: Special considerations for children with exceptionalities.Intervention in school and clinic,38,195-204.
29. Hodges, E. V. E.,Malone, M.J.,Perry, D. G.(1997).Individual risk and social risk as interacting determinants of victimization in the peer group.Developmental Psychology,33(6),1032-1039.
30. Holmberg, K.,Hjern, A.(2008).Bullying and attention-deficit-hyperactivity disorder in 10-year-olds in a Swedish community.Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology,50(2),134-138.
31. Humphrey, N.(2008).Including pupils with autistic spectrum disorders in mainstream schools.Support for Learning,23(1),41-47.
32. Kavale, K. A.,Forness, S. R.(1996).Social skills deficits and learning disabilities: A meta-analysis.Journal of Learning Disabilities,29,226-237.
33. Kent, B. A.(2003).Identity issues for hard-of-hearing adolescents aged 11, 13, and 15 in mainstream setting.Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education,8,315-324.
34. Kochenderfer, B. J.,Ladd, G. W.(1996).Peer victim victimization in kindergarten: Manifestations and relations to school adjustment.Journal of School Psychology,34,267-283.
35. Limber, S.,Small, M.(2003).State law and policies to address bullying in schools.School Psychology Review,32,445-455.
36. Little, L.(2002).Middle-class mothers' perceptions of peer and sibling victimization among children with Asperger's syndrome and nonverbal learning disorders.Issues in Compre hensive Pediatric Nursing,25(1),43-57.
37. Mcfall, R. M.(1982).A review and reformulation of the concept of social skills.Behavioral Assossment,4,1-33.
38. Monchy, M. D.,Pijl, S. J.,Zandberg, T.(2004).Discrepancies in judging social inclusion and bullying of pupils with behavior problems.European. Journal of Special Needs Education,19,317-330.
39. Nabuzoka, D.(2003).Teacher ratings and peer nominations of bullying and other behaviour of children with and without learning difficulties.Educational Psychology,23,307-321.
40. Nansel, T.,Overpeck, M.,Pilla, R.,Ruan, W.,Simons-Morton, B.,Scheidt, P.(2001).Bullying behaviors among U.S. youth: Prevalence and association with psychosocial adjustment.Journal of the American Medical Association,285,2094-2100.
41. O''Connell, P.,Pepler, D.,Craig, W.(1999).Peer involvement in bullying: Insights and challenges for intervention.Journal of adolescence,22,437-452.
42. Olweus, D.(2001).Bullying at school: Tackling the problem.The OECD Observer,225,24-26.
43. Olweus, D.(1993).Bullying at school: What we know and what we can do.Malden, MA:Blackwell.
44. Pivik, J.,McComas, J.,LaFlamme, M.(2002).Barriers and facilitators to inclusive education.Exceptional Children,69,97-107.
45. Roberts, C. M.,Smith, P. R.(1999).Attitudes and behaviour of children toward peers with disabilities.International Journal of Disability, Development and Education,46(1),35-50.
46. Sabornie, E. J.(1994).Social-affective characteristics in early adolescents identified aslearning disabled and nondisabled.Learning Disability Quarterly,17,269-279.
47. Salmivalli, C.,Lagerspetz, K.,Bjorkqvist, k.,Osterman, K.,Kaukiainen, A.(1996).Bullying as a group process: Participant roles and their relations to social status within the group.Aggressive Behavior,22,1-15.
48. Sarah, S.(2007).Is your child a victim?.Special Edition-Child,17(2),51.
49. Savage, R.(2005).Friendship and bullying patterns in children attending a language base in a mainstream school.Educational Psychology in Practice,21(1),23-36.
50. Schwartz, D.(2000).Subtypes of victims and aggressors in children's peer groups.Journal of Abnormal and Child Psychology,28,181-192.
51. Schwartz, D.,Dodge, K. A.,Coie, J. D.(1993).The emergence of chronic peer victimization in boys play groups.Child Development,64,1755-1772.
52. Schwartz, D.,Farver, J.,Chang, L.,Lee-Shin,Y.(2002).Victimization in South Korean children's peer groups.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,30,113-125.
53. Shapiro, D. R.,Moffett, A.,Lieberman, L.,Dummer, G. M.(2008).Domainspecific ratings of importance and global self-worth of children with visual impairments.Journal of Visual Impairment & Blindness,102,232-244.
54. Siann, G.,Callaghan, M.,Lockhart, R.,Rawson, L.(1993).Bullying: Teachers' views and school effects.Educational Studies,19,307-321.
55. Slee, P. T.(1994).Situational and interpersonal correlates of anxiety associated with peer victimization.Child Psychology and Human Development,25,97-107.
56. Sonia, S.(Ed.),Peter, K. S.(Ed.),Peter, S.(Ed.)(1994).School bullying: Insight and perspectives.New York, NY:Routledge Press.
57. Taylor, L. A.,Saylor, C.,Twyman, K.,Macias, M.(2010).Adding insult to injury: Bullying experiences of youth with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.Children's Health Care,39(1),59-72.
58. Underwood, M. K.,Galen, B. R.,Paquette, J. A.(2001).Top ten challenges for understanding gender and aggression in children: Why can't we all just get along?.Social Development,10(2),248-266.
59. Unnever, J. D.(2005).Bullies, aggressive victims, and victims: Are they distinct groups?.Aggressive Behavior,31(2),153-171.
60. Weiner, M. T.,Miller, M.(2006).Deaf children and bullying: Directions for future research.American Annals of The Deaf,151(1),61-70.
61. 吳清山、林天佑(2005)。校園霸凌。教育研究，130，143。
62. 吳淑美(1996)。探討「竹師實小特教實驗班第二年實施中重度殘障學生完全包含課程模式成效」實驗研究。新竹市:新竹師範學院特教系。
63. 邱珍琬(2002)。國小國中校園霸凌行為比較研究。彰化師大教育學報，3，99-128。
64. 胡永崇(2000)。國小身心障礙類資源班實施現況及改進之研究：以高雄縣為例。屏東師院學報，13，75-110。
65. 張信務(2007)。營造友善校園─「從去霸凌開始」。北縣教育，61，31-35。
66. 曾尚民(2002)。學習障礙學生的社會情緒問題與輔導。特殊教育季刊，82，34-40。
67. 黃瑞珍(1993)。資源教室的經營與管理。臺北市:心理。
68. 黃瓊慧(2013)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。屏東市，國立屏東教育大學特殊教育學系。
69. 葉靖雲(1998)。資源教室的概念知多少？。特教園丁，13(3)，19-22。
70. 魏希聖、黃仲楷(2005)。校園霸凌研究之回顧，實徵發現與研究方法。臺東大學教育學報，16(1)，69-112。

1. 郝佳華(2021)。國民中學融合環境中身障生之「霸凌議題」探討，融合乎？標記乎？霸凌乎？。特殊教育發展期刊，72，35-50。
2. 黃開成(2019)。高職學生受凌學校因素之研究－身心障礙生與普通生做比較。犯罪學期刊，21(1)，100-138。
3. 劉惠美,丁政本(2023)。國中特殊需求學生的資源班學習投入與幸福感之研究。教育心理學報，54(3)，727-751。
4. (2018)。大學職員職場霸凌知覺與心理健康關係之研究－兼論情緒耗竭之中介效果與因應策略之調節效果。教育學報，46(2)，109-129。
5. (2022)。多媒體電腦輔助教學對國小學習障礙學生校園霸凌覺知成效之研究。東臺灣特殊教育學報，25，51-70。
6. (2024)。高中職身障生校園受凌之研究──與普通生做比較。教育心理學報，56(1)，127-158。