题名

科學特藏文獻之引用與學術貢獻：以田中長三郎對Penzig文庫的引用為例

并列篇名

Understanding Taxonomical Botanist's Usage of Special Collection in the Academic Library: A Bibliometrics Study of NTU Tanaka Collection

DOI

10.6182/jlis.202206_20(1).101

作者

林維真(Weijane Lin)；張翔柔(Hsiang-Jou Chang)

关键词

特藏資源 ； 植物分類學 ； 書目計量法 ； 引用文獻分析 ； 歷史書目 ； Special Collection ； Taxonomic Botany ； Bibliometrics ； Citation Analysis ； Historical Bibliography

期刊名称

圖書資訊學刊

卷期/出版年月

20卷1期（2022 / 06 / 01）

页次

101 - 129

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究應用書目計量方法對臺大圖書館特藏資源《田中文庫》的價值與貢獻，提供歷史書目的描述與引用文獻分析的支持。除了回顧臺大圖書館建置《田中文庫》的歷史文件外，本研究分析可獲得之204筆田中長三郎著作與792筆引用文獻，由田中長三郎的引用動機與目的，瞭解特藏資源對柑橘分類學研究的具體助益與重要性。本研究為極少數以書目計量方法對圖書館特藏資源進行引文與內容分析之實證研究，同時相較過去植物分類學領域以單一領域或單一學術期刊為主之書目計量研究，本研究為具有多元形式之圖書館特藏資源的引用行為提出具體的描述與說明，並根據研究結果對圖書館特藏資源之管理、內容與服務提出具體建議及參考。
英文摘要

Based on the representative attributes built around specific subjects or uniqueness in publishing forms, special collections are often viewed as important asset of research libraries. However, previous studies have pointed out the common issues of hidden collections and backlogs in many special collections due to the unfamiliarity of the collections. This bibliometric study adopts the research methods of document analysis and citation analysis to investigate NTU Tanaka Collection, a special collection about botanical literature housed by National Taiwan University Library. 204 of the plant taxonomist Tanaka Tyozaburo's publications and the 792 citations he used are selected for citation analysis with reference to the history of taxonomic botany. The results of the study suggest NTU Tanaka Collection possesses significant and important references to taxonomic botanists in general, and to Tanaka's research on the identification and phylogeny of citrus fruits in specific. According to the findings, this study provides a historical bibliography and a reference network of NTU Tanaka Collection. This study is one of the very few empirical studies that adopted bibliometric analyses in library special collection, and it also provides rather thorough and objective evidence of scholarly usage of special collections. The findings of the study contribute to the research and practices of special collection curation and outreach.
主题分类 人文學 > 圖書資訊學
参考文献
  1. 廖振旺, J.-W.(2004)。臺灣大學圖書館「田中文庫」所藏四冊搖籃期刊本初探。大學圖書館，7(2)，60-99。
    連結：
  2. 賴雅柔, Y.-J.,柯皓仁, H.-R.(2013)。臺灣地區大學圖書館特色館藏發展之研究。大學圖書館，17(2)，95-118。
    連結：
  3. Afacan, Y.(2017).Sustainable ibrary buildings: Green design needs and interior architecture students’ ideas for special collection rooms.The Journal of Academic Librarianship,43(5),375-383.
  4. Association of Research Libraries. (2003). Special collections statement of principles: Research libraries and the commitment to special collections. https://www.arl.org/wp-content/uploads/2003/02/specialcollections-statement-of-principles-2003.pdf
  5. Attar, K.(2013).Modern special collections cataloguing: A University of London case study.Journal of Librarianship & Information Science,45(2),168-176.
  6. Befu, M.,Kitajima, A.,Yang, X. L.,Hasegawa, K.(2000).Classification of ‘Tosa-Buntan’ pummelo (Citrus grandis [L.] Osb.), ‘Washington’ navel orange (C. sinensis [L.] Osb.) and trifoliate orange (Poncirus trifoliata [L.] Raf.) chromosomes using young leaves.Journal of the Japanese Society for Horticultural Science,69(1),22-28.
  7. Berenbak, A.,Putirskis, C.,O’Gara, G.,Ruswick, C.,Cullinan, D.,Dodson, J. A.,Walters, E.,Brown, K.(2010).SPEC kit 317: Special collections engagement.Association of Research Libraries.
  8. Berger, S. E.(2014).Rare books and special collections.ALA Neal-Schuman.
  9. Bettina, W.(Ed.)(2010).Early printed books as material objects.De Gruyter Saur.
  10. Biswas, B. C.,Roy, A.,Sen, B. K.(2007).Economic Botany: A Bibliometric Study.Malaysian Journal of Library & Information Science,12(1),23-33.
  11. Bitters, W. P.(1977).Tyôzaburô Tanaka: Last of the giants.Studia Citrologica,14(1),116-118.
  12. Borgman, C. L.,Furner, J.(2002).Scholarly communication and bibliometrics.Annual Review of Information Science & Technology,36(1),2-72.
  13. Chang, Y.-W.,Huang, M.-H.(2012).A study of the evolution of interdisciplinarity in library and information science: Using three bibliometric methods.Journal of the American Society for Information Science & Technology,63(1),22-33.
  14. Chiochios, M., Hedstrom, J., Meyer, K. P., & Rader, M. (2021). Library impact practice brief: Relationship between library collections and the recruitment and retention of faculty at UT Austin. Association of Research Libraries. https://doi.org/10.29242/brief.utaustin2021
  15. Delendick, T. J.(1990).Citation analysis of the literature of Systemic Botany: A preliminary survey.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,41(7 535),535-543.
  16. Donald, J. D.(2007).Understanding journal usage: A statistical analysis of citation and use.Journal of the American Society for Information Science & Technology,58(1),39-50.
  17. Garfield, E.(1980).Journal citation studies Botany journals, part 1: What they cite and what cites them.Essays of an information scientist
  18. Garfield, E.(1980).Journal citation studies Botany journals, part 2: Growth of botanical literature and highly-cited items.Essays of an information scientist
  19. Griffin, M.(2020).The past, present, and future of special collections library literature.RBM: A Journal of Rare Books, Manuscripts Cultural Heritage,21(2),63-77.
  20. Herrera Morillas, J. L.,Pulgarín Guerrero, A.(2010).Análisis cuantitativo y estudio del fondo mexicano (siglos XVI al XVIII) del Catálogo Colectivo del Patrimonio Bibliográfico Español.Investigación bibliotecológica,24(52),173-215.
  21. Hewitt, J. A.,Panitch, J. M.(2003).The ARL special collections initiative.Library Trends,52(1),157-171.
  22. Hitchcock, A. S. (1916). The scope and relations of taxonomic botany. Science, 43(1106), 331-342.
  23. Huang, M.-H.,Chang, H.-W.,Chen, D.-Z.(2006).Research evaluation of researchoriented universities in Taiwan from 1993 to 2003.Scientometrics,67(3),419-435.
  24. Hidden collections, scholarly barriers: Creating access to unprocessed special collections materials in North America’s research libraries
  25. Kennedy, M. L.(2019).The tangible and potential impact of research libraries.Information Services & Use,39(3),167-175.
  26. Krueger, R. R.,Navarro, L.(2007).Citrus germplasm resources.Citrus genetics, breeding and biotechnology
  27. Laszlo, P.(2007).Citrus: A history.University of Chicago Press.
  28. Line, M. B.(1993).Changes in the use of literature with time—Obsolescence revisited.Library Trends,41(4),665-683.
  29. Linnaeus, C. (1753). Species plantarum. Laurentius Salvius.
  30. Lundy, M. W.,Hollis, D. R.(2004).Creating access to invisible special collections: Using participatory management to reduce a backlog.The Journal of Academic Librarianship,30(6),466-475.
  31. Maron, N. L., & Pickle, S. (2013). Appraising our digital investment: Sustainability of digitized special collections in ARL Libraries. Association of Research Libraries. https://www.arl.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/digitizing-special-collections-report-21feb13.pdf
  32. Marx, W.(2011).Special features of historical papers from the viewpoint of bibliometrics.Journal of the American Society for Information Science & Technology,62(3),433-439.
  33. Missouri Botanical Garden. (2018). Ferrari, Giovanni Battista (1584 – 1655). https://www.botanicus.org/creator/409
  34. Moriarty, K.(2004).University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
  35. Nicolosi, E.(2007).Origin and taxonomy.Citrus genetics, breeding and biotechnology
  36. Panitch, J. M.(2001).Special collections in ARL libraries: Results of the 1998 survey sponsored by the ARL Research Collections Committee.Association of Research Libraries.
  37. Patty, W. J.(2008).Metadata, technology, and processing a backlog in a university special collections.Journal of Archival Organization,6(1/2),102-120.
  38. RBMS Bibliographic Standards Committee(2011).Descriptive cataloging of rare materials (books).Library of Congress.
  39. Ress, S.(2015).Special collections: Improving access and usability.The Reference Librarian,56(1),52-58.
  40. Smith, L. C.(1981).Citation analysis.Library Trends,30(1),83-106.
  41. Stace, C. A.(1991).Plant taxonomy and biosystematics.Cambridge University Press.
  42. Starr, S.,Williams, J.(2008).The long tail: A usage analysis of pre-1993 print biomedical journal literature.Journal of the Medical Library Association,96(1),20-27.
  43. Tanaka, T.(1976).Tanaka’s cyclopedia of edible plants of the world.Keigaku Publishing.
  44. Tanaka, T. (1918). A brief history of the discovery of citrus canker in Japan and experiments in its control. The Quarterly Bulletin of the State Plant Board of Florida, 3(1), 1-15.
  45. Tanaka, T.(1954).Species problem in Citrus: A critical study of wild and cultivated units of citrus, based upon field studies in their native homes.Japanese Society for the Promotion of Science.
  46. Tang, R.(2008).Citation characteristics and intellectual acceptance of scholarly monographs.College & ResearchLibraries,69(4),356-369.
  47. Turland, N. J.(Ed.),Wiersema, J. H.(Ed.),Barrie, F. R.(Ed.),Greuter, W.(Ed.),Hawksworth, D. L.(Ed.),Herendeen, P. S.(Ed.),Knapp, S.(Ed.),Kusber, W.-H.(Ed.),Li, D.-Z.(Ed.),Marhold, K.(Ed.),May, T. W.(Ed.),McNeill, J.(Ed.),Monro, A. M.(Ed.),Prado, J.(Ed.),Price, M. J.(Ed.),Smith, G. F.(Ed.)(2018).International code of nomenclature for algae, fungi, and plants (Shenzhen Code).Koeltz Botanical Books.
  48. Walton, C.,Morris, A.(2013).A bibliometric study of taxonomic botany.Journal of Documentation,69(3),435-451.
  49. Wiley Online Library. (2021). Wiley backfiles spotlight. https://secure.wiley.com/wiley_backfiles
  50. Witteveen, J.(2015).Naming and contingency: The type method of biological taxonomy.Biology & Philosophy,30,569-586.
  51. Wu, G. A.,Terol, J.,Ibanez, V.,López-García, A.,Pérez-Román, E.,Borredá, C.,Domingo, C.,Tadeo, F. R.,Carbonell Caballero, J.,Alonso, R.,Curk, F.,Du, D.,Ollitrault, P.,Roose, M. L.,Dopazo, J.,Gmitter, F. G.,Rokhsar, D. S.,Talon, M.(2018).Genomics of the origin and evolution of Citrus.Nature,554,311-316.
  52. 田中長三郎（1932a）。柑橘種類学講義（第九章柑橘書誌学）。柑橘研究， 5(2)，225-245。【Ta n a k a, T. (1932a). Lectures on taxonomic citrology ([Dai kyuu syou kankitsu syosi gaku]). Studia Citrologica, 5(2), 225-245. (in Japanese)】
  53. 田中長三郎（1919）。柑橘分類に関する基礎的研究。農学会報，207，945-966。【Tanaka, T. (1919). [Kankitsu bunrui ni kan suru kisoteki kenkyuu]. Journal of the Scientific Agricultural Society, 207, 945-966. (in Japanese)】
  54. 田中長三郎（1931b）。台湾に於けるタチバナの発見と其の学術的並産業的意義。柑橘研究，5(1)，1-20。【Tanaka, T. (1931b). Discovery of Citrus tachibana in Formosa, and its scientific and industrial significance. Studia Citrologica, 5(1), 1-20. (in Japanese)】
  55. 田中長三郎（1932b）。栽培植物の起原特に柑橘類の原生中枢に就て。日本学術協会報告，7(3)，391-398。【Tanaka, T. (1932b). [Saibai shokubutsu no kigen tokuni kankitsurui no gensei tyuusuu ni tsuite]. [Nihon Gakujutsu Kyoukai Houkoku], 7(3), 391-398. (in Japanese)】
  56. 田中長三郎（1935a）。台湾山地開発根本理論。熱帯園芸，5(4)，266-282。【Tanaka, T. (1935a). The theoritical basis of the highland utilization movement in Formosa. [Nettai Engei], 5(4), 266-282. (in Japanese)】
  57. 田中長三郎（1935d）。柑橘相の起原に関 する研究。日本学術協会報告，10(2)，570-576。【Tanaka, T. (1935d). Studies in the origin of Citrus Flora of various localitie. [Nihon Gakujutsu Kyoukai Houkoku], 10(2), 570-576. (in Japanese)】
  58. 田中長三郎（1935b）。柑橘の原産地。植物及動物，3(1)，141-142。【Tanaka, T. (1935b). [Kankitsu no gensanti]. [Syokubutsu Oyobi Doubutsu], 3(1), 141-142. (in Japanese)】
  59. 田中長三郎（1926）。日本領土の野生柑橘に就て。九州帝国大学農学部学芸雑誌，2(1)，51-58。【Tanaka, T. (1926). Wild citri of the Japanese teritories. Bulteno Scienca de la Fakultato Terkultura, Kjusu Imperia Universitato, 2(1), 51-58. (in Japanese)】
  60. 田中長三郎（1931a）。園芸研究の必要。熱帯園芸，1(3)，211-213。【Tanaka, T. (1931a). [Engei kenkyuu no hituyou]. [Nettai Engei], 1(3), 211-213. (i n Japanese)】
  61. 田中長三郎（1935c）。柑橘分類論争史。柑橘研究，7(1)，1-39。【Tanaka, T. (1935c). History of dispute in the Citrus classification. Studia Citrologica, 7(1), 1-39. (in Japanese)】
  62. 伊藤謙、北島宣主席(2016)。田中長三郎の交流資料と足跡。国際シンポジウム「世界的柑橘分類学者田中長三郎の足跡と系譜
  63. 吳明德（編）, M.-D.(Ed.),蔡平里（編）, P.-L.(Ed.)(1998).國立臺灣大學圖書館田中文庫藏書目錄.國立臺灣大學圖書館=National Taiwan University Library.
  64. 吳明德, M.-D.(1998)。序。田中長三郎教授著作目錄
  65. 岳修平、林維真、鍾國芳、北島宣主席(2016)。田中長三郎と国立台湾大学の関わり。国際シンポジウム「世界的柑橘分類学者田中長三郎の足跡と系譜」
  66. 林書妍, S.-Y.,莊文忠, W.-Z.,陳右人, I.-Z.,阮素芬, S.-F.(2011)。柑橘生產上常用的砧木種類及其分類地位。科學農業，59(4/6)，64-72。
  67. 林維真, W.(2018)。科技部補助科學技術人員國外短期研究計畫成果報告科技部補助科學技術人員國外短期研究計畫成果報告,科技部=Ke ji bu。
  68. 松居竜五(2020)。南方熊楠とスウィングル、田中長三郎の交流に関する新資料紹介（20世紀初頭のアメリカにおける東アジア博物学受容の研究：南方熊楠とスウィングル、および関連学者の交流を中心として。龍谷大学国際社会文化研究所紀要，22，55-80。
  69. 夏麗月, L.-Y.(1998)。田中文庫整編計畫簡介。田中長三郎教授著作目錄
  70. 國立臺灣大學圖書館（無日期）。田中文庫。https://dl.lib.ntu.edu.tw/s/ta/page/home【National Taiwan University Library. (n.d.). Tanaka collection. https://dl.lib.ntu.edu.tw/s/ta/page/home (in Chinese)】
  71. 國立臺灣大學圖書館（2018）。特藏資源。https://web.lib.ntu.edu.tw/Publication/pdf/DM_sp_eng.pdf【National Taiwan University Library. (2018). Special collections. https://web.lib.ntu.edu.tw/Publication/pdf/DM_sp_eng.pdf (in Chinese)】
  72. 許再文, T.-W.,陳祈男, C.-N.,何東輯, T.-C.(2015)。台灣產柑橘屬（芸香科）植物。台灣生物多樣性研究，17(1)，67-73。
  73. 森本純平(1977)。田中長三郎教授追悼記。柑橘研究，14，6-13。
  74. 楊緒任, X.-R.(1931)。柑橘之分類。科學農業，9(5/6)，69-178。
  75. 蔡平里, P.-L.(1998)。田中長三郎先生。田中長三郎教授著作目錄
  76. 諶克終, K.-Z.(1969).柑橘栽培學.正中書局=Cheng Chung Bookstore.
print cancel