探討教育領導理論流行情形：應用引用分析和趨勢分析

Analysis of the Fashion of Leadership Theories: Using Citation Analysis and Trends Analysis

10.6423/HHHC.201811_(118).0004

張芳敏(FANG-MIN CHANG)

引用分析 ； 谷歌趨勢 ； 領導時尚 ； 領導理論 ； citation analysis ； Google Trends ； leadership fashion ； leadership fad ； leadership theory

學校行政

118期（2018 / 11 / 16）

40 - 70

繁體中文

管理時尚探討造成流行時尚的管理理論，了解其流行成因、進行辨識、及分析對領導實務的影響，教育領導理論也有類似造成流行的現象，卻未見深度探討，因此聚焦探討教育領導理論流行的相關課題和實證分析其流行情形。經文獻評閱，本研究提出教育領導理論流行的意涵和特性，指出五類研究方法、三種評估方法、四階段發展模式和八類發展類型以做為實證研究基礎。經文件分析，提出19個重要教育領導理論清單為實證分析樣本，針對五個文獻資料庫，以引用分析和趨勢分析找出transformational leadership為居流行時尚地位的教育領導理論，發現八種教育領導理論流行發展類型。本研究說明文件分析、引用分析和趨勢分析是利於探討教育領導理論流行。

The management fashion focused on discussing the fashion management theories, understanding its reasons about fashion, identifying the fashion theory, and analyzing its influences on leadership practices. Educational leadership theory has also caused similar phenomenon as management fashion. Lack of deeper study on the fashion of educational leadership theory is a problem. Therefore the study focused upon exploring the related topics of the fashion of educational leadership theory as well as empirically verifying its fashion situations. Based on literature reviewing, the meaning, contents and characteristics about the fashion of educational leadership theory were proposed. Five research methods, three assessing methods, and four periodical developmental models were provided as the base for empirical testing. After conducting document analysis, 19 important educational leadership theories was taken as samples for empirical testing. Using citation analysis and trends analysis with five literature databases, transformational leadership was confirmed as a fashion educational leadership theory. Eight developmental types for interpreting the fashion of educational leadership theory were also discussed. Moreover the study illustrated that documental analysis, citation analysis, and trends analysis are useful to explore the fashion of educational leadership theories.

1. 葉連祺(2018)。應用Google Trends研究教育管理時尚。學校行政，115，156-174。
   連結：
2. 葉連祺(2013)。教育領導研究可探討什麼？。學校行政，84，1-35。
   連結：
3. 葉連祺(2018)。教育領導變項與教育管理變項體系研究。學校行政，117，1-72。
   連結：
4. 譚克平(2008)。極端值判斷方法簡介。臺東大學教育學報，19(1)，131-150。
   連結：
5. Abrahamson, E.(1996).Management fashion.Academy of Management Review,21(1),254-285.
6. Abrahamson, E.(1991).Managerial fads and fashions: The diffusion and rejection of innovations.Academy of Management Review,16(3),586-612.
7. Abrahamson, E.,Fairchild, G.(1999).Management fashion: Lifecycles, triggers, and collective learning processes.Administrative Science Quarterly,44(4),708-740.
8. Barnard, M.(Ed.)(2007).Fashion theory: A reader.New York, NY:Routledge.
9. Benders, J.,Nijholt, J.,Heusinkveld, S.(2007).Using print media indicators in management fashion research.Quality & Quantity,41(6),815-829.
10. Benders, J.,Van Veen, K.(2001).What's in a fashion? Interpretative viability and management fashions.Organization,8(1),33-53.
11. Blumer, H.(1969).Fashion: From class differentiation to collective selection.The Sociological Quarterly,10(3),275-291.
12. Brickley, J. A.,Smith, C. W., Jr,Zimmerman, J. L.(1997).Management fads and organizational architecture.Journal of Applied Corporate Finance,10(2),24-39.
13. Brooks, J. S.,Normore, A. H.(2018).Foundations of educational leadership: Developing excellent and equitable schools.New York, NY:Routledge.
14. Bush, T.(2011).Theories of educational leadership and management.Thousand Oaks, CA:SAGE.
15. Carson, P. P.,Lanier, P. A.,Carson, K. D.,Guidry, B. N.(2000).Clearing a path through the management fashion jungle: Some preliminary trailblazing.Academy of Management Journal,43(6),1143-1158.
16. Cunningham, W. G.,Cordeiro, P. A.(2003).Educational leadership: A problem-based approach.Needham Heights, MA:Allyn & Bacon.
17. Davies, B.(Ed.)(2009).The essentials of school leadership.London:Sage Publications Ltd..
18. Davies, L.,Gather, U.(1993).The identification of multiple outliers.Journal of the American Statistical Association,88(423),782-792.
19. Egghe, L.(2006).An improvement of the h-index: The g-index.ISSI newsletter,2(1),8-9.
20. English, F. W.(Ed.)(2011).The Sage handbook of educational leadership: Advances in theory, research, and practice.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage Publications.
21. Ettorre, B.(1997).What's the next business buzzword?.Management Review,86(8),33-35.
22. Fink, D.(2003).A life cycle approach to management fashion: An investigation of management concepts in the context of competitive strategy.Schmalenbach Business Review,55,46-59.
23. Grant, K.(2011).Knowledge management: An enduring but confusing fashion.Electronic Journal of Knowledge Management,9(2),117-131.
24. Hirsch, J. E.(2010).An index to quantify an individual's scientific research output that takes into account the effect of multiple coauthorship.Scientometrics,85(3),741-754.
25. Kotterman, J.(2006).Leadership versus management: What's the difference?.The Journal for Quality and Participation,29(2),13-17.
26. Li, J.,Fred, Y. Y.(2016).Distinguishing sleeping beauties in science.Scientometrics,108(2),821-828.
27. Madsen, D. Ø. (2016). Using Google Trends in management fashion research: A short note. Retrieved from https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01343880/document
28. Madsen, D. Ø. (2015). Using Google Trends in management fashion research: A short note. Retrieved from https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01343880/
29. Madsen, D. Ø.,Johanson, D.(2016).Examining customer relationship management from a management fashion perspective.Cogent Business & Management,3(1),1161285.
30. Madsen, D. Ø.,Stenheim, T.(2013).Doing research on ‘management fashions’: Methodological challenges and opportunities.Problems and Perspectives in Management,11(4),68-76.
31. Madsen, D.,Stenheim, T.(2014).Is corporate social responsibility a management fashion in Norway? Some Preliminary Evidence.European Journal of Business Research,14(1),87-98.
32. Mellon, J.(2013).Where and when can we use Google Trends to measure issue salience?.PS: Political Science & Politics,46(2),280-290.
33. Murphy, J.(Ed.),Louis, K. S.(Ed.)(1999).Handbook of research on educational administration.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass Publishers.
34. Oldroyd, D.,Elsner, D.,Poster, C. D.(1996).Educational management today: A concise dictionary and guide.London:Sage Publications Ltd..
35. Pierce, J. L.(Ed.),Newstrom, J. W.(Ed.)(2003).Leaders & the leadership process: Readings, self-assessments & applications.New York, NY:McGraw-Hill Higher Education.
36. Simmel, G.(1957).Fashion.American Journal of Sociology,62(6),541-558.
37. 王艾苓(2009)。臺北市，國立政治大學。
38. 王圓圓,袁澤沛(2005)。管理時尚研究。貴州財經學院學報，119，109-112。
39. 王圓圓,袁澤沛,張巧麗(2005)。管理時尚傳播過程研究。中國工業經濟，9，122-128。
40. 包玉澤,譚力文,劉林青(2010)。管理時尚在中國傳播的多案例文獻計量研究。情報雜誌，29(6)，22-26。
41. 秦夢群(2013).教育領導理論與應用.台北:五南.
42. 秦夢群(2005)。教育領導新理論與研究取向之分析。教育研究月刊，136，106-118。
43. 葉連祺(2004)。瞰教育領導理念之叢林─教育領導理念之初步綜觀。教育研究月刊，124，96-108。
44. 盧淵源,蘇登呼,黃英忠(2009)。當管理風潮進入組織：探索經理人的資訊守門過程。創業管理研究，4(2)，1-27。
45. 譚力文,王圓圓(2006)。基於戰略視角的管理時尚生命週期研究。石家莊經濟學院學報，29(3)，281-285。

1. 劉乙儀(2022)。臺灣幼兒園園長領導研究成果與發展徑路之探討－以學位論文為例。臺北海洋科技大學學報，13(2)，69-101。
2. 沈秋宏,沈芷嫣(2022)。國民小學實施課程標準時期教育領導研究趨勢之探究－應用文字探勘技術分析。教育理論與實踐學刊，45，1-33。
3. 釋淨如,蔡金田,沈秋宏(2022)。國民小學實施九年一貫課程期間教育領導趨勢之探究－應用文字探勘技術分析。學校行政，138，74-104。