新課綱變革下學校中層領導之探究：挑戰與因應策略

School Middle Leaders in New Curriculum Guidelines Reform: Challenges and Coping Strategies

10.6423/HHHC.202205_(139).0005

賴彥全(Yen-Chywan Lai)

十二年國民基本教育課程綱要 ； 中層領導 ； 學校行政 ； 學校領導 ； 12-year National Basic Curriculum Guidelines ； middle leadership ； school administration ； school leadership

學校行政

139期（2022 / 05 / 16）

94 - 113

繁體中文

學校中層領導者是學校組織變革的關鍵推手。《十二年國民基本教育課程綱要》實施後對高中端課程教學與學生學習帶來重大變革，也對中層領導者帶來挑戰。本研究採質性研究取徑，訪談五位學校現場之中層領導者，藉以瞭解新課綱推動下其所面臨之挑戰與因應策略。經資料整理及分析，本研究結論如下：一、在新課綱推動脈絡下，學校中層領導者面臨之挑戰包括制度結構、組織文化、溝通協作及專業成長等面向。二、中層領導者所採取的回應策略，包括釐清工作優先順序、發揮初任教師優勢、採取回應式領導與深化課程領導專業等。文末並提出後續研究與實務建議。

School middle leaders are crucial to school organizational changes. The implementation of ＂12-year National Basic Curriculum Guidelines＂ has drastically changed teaching methods and learning styles in high schools, which is challenging to middle leaders. Therefore, this research adopted qualitative interviews in order to explore the experiences of five high school middle leaders, and to realize the challenges and coping strategies during the curriculum reform. An analysis of the data yielded two results: 1. The challenges to middle leaders included dimensions of ＂institutional structure＂, ＂organizational culture＂, ＂communication and collaboration＂ and ＂professional development＂. 2. The coping strategies comprised ＂prioritizing task order＂, ＂using the advantages of junior teachers＂, ＂performing responsive leadership＂ and ＂developing curriculum leadership competency＂. Moreover, follow-up research and practical suggestions are put forward.

1. Ball, S. J.,Maguire, M.,Braun, A.(2011).How schools do policy: Policy enactments in secondary schools.Routledge.
2. Bassett, M.(2016).The role of middle leaders in New Zealand secondary schools: Expectations and challenges.Waikato Journal of Education,21(1),97-108.
3. Bennett, N.(1995).Managing professional teachers: Middle management in primary and secondary schools.Paul Chapman.
4. Bennett, N.,Wise, C.,Woods, P. A.,Harvey, J. A.(2003).,National College of School Leadership.
5. Bennett, N.,Woods, P.,Wise, C.,Newton, W.(2007).Understandings of middle leadership in secondary schools: A review of the empirical research.School Leadership and Management,27(5),453-470.
6. Buller, R.(2018).Leading from the middle: An overview of current research and trends on the topic.Journal of Access Services,15(1),44-56.
7. Day, C.,Grice, C.(2019).Investigating the influence and impact of leading from the middle: A school-based strategy.The University of Sydney.
8. De Nobile, J.(2018).Towards a theoretical model of middle leadership in schools.School Leadership & Management,38(4),395-416.
9. Dimmock, C.(2012).Leadership, capacity building and school improvement: Concepts, themes and impact.Routledge.
10. Dinham, S.(2016).Leading learning and teaching.ACER Press.
11. Edwards-Groves, C.,Grootenboer, P.,Ronnerman, K.(2016).Facilitating a culture of relational trust in school-based action research: Recognising the role of middle leaders.Educational Action Research,24(3),369-386.
12. Fairman, J. C.,Mackenzie, S. V.(2012).Spheres of teacher leadership action for learning.Professional Development in Education,38(2),229-246.
13. Fleming, P.(2019).Successful middle leadership in the secondary school: A practical guide to subject and team effectiveness.Routledge.
14. Grootenboer, P.(2018).The practices of school middle leadership: Learning profes- sional learning.Springer.
15. Grootenboer, P.,Edwards-Groves, C.,Rönnerman, K.(2020).Middle leadership in schools: A practical guide for leading learning.Routledge.
16. Hargreaves, A.,Shirley, D.(2020).Leading from the middle: Its nature, origins and importance.Journal of Professional Capital and Community,5(1),92-114.
17. Harrington, C.,Slann, M.(2011).Modeling shared governance at the school and department level.Academic Leadership Journal,9(4),Article 10.
18. Harris, A.,Jamieson, I. M.,Russ, J.(1995).A study of effective departments in secondary schools.School Organisation,15(3),283-300.
19. Harris, A.,Jones, M.,Crick, T.(2020).Curriculum leadership: a critical contributor to school and system improvement.School Leadership & Management,40(1),1-4.
20. Harris, A.,Jones, M.,Ismail, N.,Nguyen, D.(2019).Middle leaders and middle leadership in schools: exploring the knowledge base (2003–2017).School Leadership & Management,39(3?4),255-277.
21. Howlett, M.(2009).Governance modes, policy regimes, and operational plans: A multilevel nested model of policy instrument choice an policy design.Policy Sciences,42,73-89.
22. Irvine, P.,Brundrett, M.(2016).Middle leadership and its challenges: A case study in the secondary independent sector.Management in Education,30(2),86-92.
23. Leithwood, K.(2016).Department-head leadership for school improvement.Leadership & Policy in Schools,15(2),117-140.
24. Leithwood, K.,Riehl, C.(2003).What we know about successful school leadership.Temple University.
25. Lincoln, Y.,Guba, E.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.Sage.
26. Lowe, B.(2019).Middle leadership for 21st century schools: From compliance to commitment.Crown House Publishing.
27. Schon, D. A.(1987).Educating the reflective practitioner: Toward a new design for teaching and learning in the profession.Jossey-Bass Publishers.
28. 吳迅榮, S. W.,王逸飛, Y. F.(2009)。香港小學中層管理人員培訓需求研究。基礎教育學報，18(2)，21-39。
29. 林明地, M. D.(2020)。現象與危機：國民中小學「行政職逃亡」分析。教育研究月刊，314，66-83。
30. 潘慧玲, H. L.(2004).教育研究的取徑：概念與應用.高等教育=Higher education.
31. 賴志峰, C. F.(2020)。中小學中層領導的理論與實踐。教育研究月刊，318，32-46。
32. 譚彩鳳, C. F.(2007)。學科領導在課程改革中的角色：香港個案研究。課程研究，3(1)，109-138。

1. (2022)。面對108課綱，高中校長變革領導之研究。教育政策論壇，25(4)，69-100。
2. (2024)。學校中層領導者之領導與被領導期待──以臺北市國小主任為例。學校行政，152，59-92。