建構數位廣告設計創意評價之構面與準則

An Assessment System for the Creativity of Digital Advertising Design: Evaluation Dimensions and Criteria

方菁容(Ching-Jung Fang)；鄧成連(Cheng-Lein Teng)；衛萬里(Wan-Li Wei)

數位廣告 ； 廣告設計 ； 創意評估 ； Digital Advertising ； Advertising Design ； Creativity Evaluation

設計學報

21卷1期（2016 / 03 / 01）

1 - 18

繁體中文

網路科技發展雖然能適時地加速廣告產業的變革，惟創意才是帶動產業業績持續成長的萬靈丹。本研究目的在於探討過往評價廣告創意的準則，是否仍適用於今日數位廣告時代之嶄新或獨特創意，進而建構一衡量此類數位廣告創意的各評價構面與準則。研究分為兩個階段：第一階段藉由專家訪談彙整有關且較為廣泛的數位廣告創意評估項目，第二階段則以問卷調查和探索性因素分析萃取重要的評量因子。而研究結果得出：數位廣告創意評價層級可歸納為4個構面和15項準則，第一個構面為「擴散性」，包括「原創的」、「與眾不同的」、「令人吃驚的」、「有魅力的」和「富有想像的」5項準則；第二個構面為「改變」，包括「具有改變行為的」、「有邏輯的」、「有說服力的」和「有影響力的」4項準則；第三個構面為「實效性」，包括「與品牌具有相關性的」、「與產品有連結的橋樑」和「具有品牌正面體驗的」3項準則；最後，第四個構面為「互動」，包括「具有參與的」、「具有娛樂性的」和「互動性的」3項準則。其中「擴散性」和「實效性」是創意廣告評價的兩個核心構面，而新注入的「改變」和「互動」則可適切滿足數位廣告創意評價之完整和所需。最後，此研究成果將可提供設計產學界於進行數位廣告設計時，於概念發展階段以為設計創意適切性之衡量標準。

The rapid growth of network provides a change in the advertising industry from time to time, but the essential factor that triggers the growth is actually creativity. This paper focuses on the key dimensions and criteria used to evaluate creativity as well as its usability in the current digital advertising design. The study proceeds with two main steps: evaluate the criteria through experts interview and extract the key elements through exploratory factor analysis and questionnaire survey. The research outcome includes the hierarchy structure of assessment on the creativity of digital advertising design which can be structured into 4 dimensions and 15 criteria. The first dimension is associated with ＂divergence＂ composed of ＂original＂, ＂unique＂, ＂startling＂, ＂attractive＂, and ＂imaginative＂ evaluation criteria. The second dimension is related to ＂change＂ including ＂change behavior＂, ＂logic＂, ＂persuasive＂, and ＂affect＂ criteria. The third dimension is referred to ＂utility＂ consisting of ＂relevance＂, ＂connection＂, and ＂experience＂ as its criteria. The fourth dimension is connected to ＂interaction＂ containing ＂engagement＂, ＂entertainment＂, and ＂interaction＂ evaluation criteria. Moreover, ＂divergence＂ and ＂utility＂ are considered as the core factors on assessing creativity, and with the addition of ＂change＂ and ＂interaction＂ dimensions, the creativity on digital advertising design can be properly evaluated in order to reach its requirements. The results of this study can provide actual evaluation dimensions and criteria to the design industry on the process of digital advertising design.

1. 方菁容、衛萬里(2013)。世界自然基金會（WWF）環保公益廣告創意效果與觀者認知差異。設計學報，18(2)，71-91。
   連結：
2. 方菁容、衛萬里、鄧成連(2015)。渴望延遲閉合需求對創意廣告效果之影響。設計學報，20(1)，69-85。
   連結：
3. 維基百科（無日期）。數位。取自：http://www.wiki.com Wiki (n.d.). Digital. Retrieved from http://www.wiki.com [in Chinese, semantic translation]
4. 林友琴（2015，4 月9 日）。創意與代理商該做哪些改變？創意如何被解放？。動腦新聞。取自：http://www.brain.com.tw Lin, J. (2015, April 9). Creativity liberated: Creativity and ideas in the digital age. Brain News.Retrieved from http://www.brain.com.tw [in Chinese, semantic translation]
5. 高野文隆（2014，8 月）。OLD DAYS→NEW DAYS。演講發表於Digital Love TIDAF 台北國際數位廣告節，世貿台北國際會議中心，台北市，台灣。Fumitaka, T. (2014, August). OLD DAYS→NEW DAYS. Speech presented at Digital Love TIDAF (Taipei International Digital Advertising Festival), Taipei International Convention Center, Taipei, Taiwan. [in Chinese, semantic translation]。
6. 長尾啟樹（2014，8 月）。只有行動，才有愛！。演講發表於Digital Love TIDAF 台北國際數位廣告節，世貿台北國際會議中心，台北市，台灣。Hiroki, N. (2014, August). Only action, only love! Speech presented at Digital Love TIDAF (Taipei International Digital Advertising Festival), Taipei International Convention Center, Taipei, Taiwan. [in Chinese, semantic translation]。
7. Ang, S. H.,Lee, Y. H.,Leong, S. M.(2007).The ad creativity cube: Conceptualization and initial validation.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,35(2),220-32.
8. Arrindell, W. A.,van der Ende, J.(1985).An empirical-test of the utility of the observations to-variables ratio in factor and components analysis.Applied Psychological Measurement,9(2),165-178.
9. Baack, D. W.,Wilson, R. T.,Till, B. D(2008).Creativity and memory effects: Recall, recognition, and an exploration of nontraditional media.Journal of Advertising,37(4),85-94.
10. Baldwin, M. W.,Keelan, J. P. R.,Fehr, B.,Enns, V.,Koh-Rangarajoo, E.(1996).Social cognitive conceptualization of attachment styles: Availability and accessibility effects.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,71(1),94-109.
11. Campbell, E.(2011).Evidence proves the future is now: Why great creative needs great research.Journal of Advertising Research,March,222-223.
12. Dahlén, M.(2006).The medium as a contextual cue: Effects of creative media choice.Journal of Advertising,34(3),89-98.
13. del Río, J.(2007).Research in advertising creativity in the Journal of Advertising (1972-2006).1s European Foundation for Commercial. Communications Education (EFCCE),Brussels, Belgium:
14. El-Murad, J.,West, D. C.(2004).The definition and measurement of creativity: What do we know?.Journal of Advertising Research,44(2),188-201.
15. Fiandaca, D.ed.、Byrgoyne, P.ed.、賴治怡譯(2012)。數位廣告：過去、現在、未來。新北市=New Taipei City:小魚廣告網工作室=Kleinerfisch。
16. Flandin, M. P.,Martin, E.,Simkin, L. P.(1992).Advertising effectiveness research.International Journal of Advertising,11(3),203-214.
17. Frazer, C.(1983).Creative strategy: A management perspective.Journal of Advertising,12(1),36-41.
18. Hawkins, D. T.(1994).Electronic advertising on online information systems.Online,18(2),26-39.
19. Hoffman, D. L.,Novak, T. P.(1996).Marketing in hypermedia computer-mediated environments: Conceptual foundations.Journal of Marketing,60,50-68.
20. Kilgour, M.,Sasser, S.,Koslow, S.(2013).Creativity awards: Great expectations?.Creativity Research Journal,25(2),163-171.
21. Klebba, J. M.,Tierney, P.(1995).Advertising creativity: A review and empirical investigation of external evaluation, cognitive style and self-perceptions of creativity.Journal of Current Issues & Research in Advertising,17(2),33.
22. MacCallum, R. C.,Widaman, K. F.,Zahang, S.,Hong, S.(1999).Sample size in factor analysis.Psychological Methods,4(1),84-99.
23. McStay, A.(2013).Creativity and advertising: Affect, events and process.New York, NY:Routledge.
24. Mishra, P.,Henriksen, D.,the Deep-play Research Group(2013).A new approach to defining and measuring creativity: Rethinking technology & creativity in the 21st century.TechTrends: Linking Research & Practice to Improve Learning,57(5),10-13.
25. Nunnally, J. C.(1978).Psychometric theory.New York, NY:McGraw-Hill.
26. Nunnally, J. C.,Bernstein, I. H.(1994).Psychological theory.New York, NY:McGraw-Hill.
27. Ogilvy, R.(1983).Ogilvy on advertising.London:Pan Books Ltd. and Orbis Publishing Ltd..
28. Reid, L. N.,Moriarty, S. E.(1983).Ideation: A review of research.Current Issues and Research in Advertising,1,119-134.
29. Sheinin, D.,Varki, S.,Ashley, C.(2011).The differential effect of ad novelty and message usefulness on brand judgments.Journal of Advertising,40(1),5-17.
30. Smith, R. E.,MacKenzie, S. B.,Yang, X.,Brchholz, L. M.,Darley, W. K.(2007).Modeling the determinants and effects of creativity in advertising.Marketing Science,26(6),819-833.
31. Smith, R. E.,Yang, X.(2004).Toward a general theory of creativity in advertising: Examining the role of divergence.Marketing Theory,4(1/2),29-55.
32. Stuhlfaut, M. W.,Yoo, C. Y.(2013).A tool for evaluating advertising concepts: Desirable characteristics as viewed by creative practitioners.Journal of Marketing Communications,19(2),81-97.
33. Tabachnica, B. G.,Fidell, L. S.(2007).Using multivariate statistics.Needham Heights, MA:Allyn and Sacon.
34. Till, B. D.,Baack, D. W.(2005).Recall and persuasion: Does creative advertising matter?.Journal of Advertising,34(3),47-57.
35. Tippins, M. J.,Kunkel, R. A.(2006).Winning a Clio advertising award and its relationship to firm profitability.Journal of Marketing Communications,12(1),1-14.
36. Torrance, E. P.(1987).Using the torrance test of creative thinking to guide the teaching of creative behavior.Bensenville, IL:Scholastic Testing Service.
37. West, D. C.(1999).360 of creative risk.Journal of Advertising Research,39(1),39-50.
38. White, A.,Smith, B. L.(2001).Assessing advertising creativity using the creative product semantic scale.Journal of Advertising Research,41(6),27.
39. 邱皓政(2010)。量化研究與統計分析：SPSS（PASW）資料分析範例解析。台北=Taipei:五南圖書=Wu-Nan Book。
40. 洪慧芳譯、Strauss, J.、Frost, R.(2010)。網路行銷概論五版。台北市=Taipei:華泰=HwaA Tai。
41. 榮泰生(2014)。圖解網路行銷。台北=Taipei:五南圖書=Wu-Nan Book。

1. 鄧成連,方菁容(2019)。「數位廣告創意評價」構面與指標驗證之分析。設計學報，24(1)，41-60。
2. 鄧成連,方菁容(2020)。線上影音廣告創意策略與認知需求之溝通效果。設計學報，25(3)，25-44。
3. 方菁容(2021)。品牌運用社會行銷之創意策略溝通效果：以廣告知曉和學習廣告主張為中介。設計學報，26(4)，49-69。