题名

模糊理論介入可適應性設計方法研究－以傳統居民新增衛浴產品為例

并列篇名

A Study on integration of Fuzzy Theory into Adaptive Design Method -- A case study of New Bathroom Products in Traditional Housing

作者

梁桂嘉(Kuei-Chia Liang)；傅游磊(You-Lei Fu)

关键词

衛浴產品 ； 可適應性設計 ； 模糊集理論 ； 焦點小組 ； Bathroom Products ； Adaptable Design ； Fuzzy Set Theory ； Focus Group

期刊名称

設計學報

卷期/出版年月

27卷1期（2022 / 03 / 01）

页次

23 - 46

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

隨著傳統民居建築保護策略與適應性再利用方法的發展，不僅要求延續當地居民的文化與生活方式，還須對建築影響最少，使產品功能應具備簡化、整合、易組合和價格低廉等特性，以適應傳統民居建築文化保護與居住生活延續的雙重需求。本研究提出一種結合機率模糊集理論的可適應度量方法，並應用於傳統民居衛浴產品集合的設計開發中。依據衛浴產品可適應度值的高低程度，以簡化整合為目的，進行設計開發。首先匯總閩南蔡氏民居中現有的衛浴產品種類，並定義為目標可適應集（Tp），再逐一進行功能結構分解，建立功能配置矩陣，以此為基礎進行匹配度（P）計算；然後以焦點小組討論方式使用成對比較判斷矩陣技術與模糊理論結合的方法，得到衛浴產品（PF）的使用機率值（PR）；最後使用可適應度公式得到衛浴產品的可適應因數（AF）。研究結果得出22件PF的可適應度值（A）高低程度，某PF的A值越高，顯示其越適合優先進行以簡化或整合為目的設計開發。因此，可依據由高到低的可視化圖表順序，在原有設計的基礎上再設計，形成諸多設計方案。
英文摘要

With the development of conservation strategies and adaptive reuse methods for traditional dwellings, there is a need not only to continue the culture and lifestyle of the inhabitants but also to minimize the impact on the architecture. The design of new sanitary products should be simplified, integrated, easy to assemble, and inexpensive, to meet the dual needs of the preservation of traditional residential architecture and the continuation of residential life. This study proposed an adaptability measurement method that incorporates probabilistic fuzzy set theory for the design and development of a collection of traditional residential sanitary products. The design and development are simplified and integrated according to the degree of adaptability of the sanitary products. Firstly, the types of sanitary products available in Cai-Clan residence are compiled and defined as the target adaptable set (Tp), then the functional structure is decomposed one by one and a functional configuration matrix is established, based on which the matching degree (P) is calculated. Then, a pairwise comparative judgment matrix technique combined with fuzzy theory is used in a focus group discussion to obtain usage probability range (PR) values for bathroom products function (PF). Ultimately, the adaptability formula is used to obtain the adaptable factor (AF) of the sanitary products. Based on the results of the study, 22 pieces of PFs are derived for high and low adaptability values (A). The higher the A value of a certain PF is, the more suitable it will be for design development for simplification or integration as a priority. Therefore, many design solutions can be formulated based on the visualization chart order from high to low, which can be redesigned on top of the original design.
主题分类 人文學 > 藝術
社會科學 > 傳播學
参考文献
  1. Buckley, J. J.(1985).Fuzzy hierarchical analysis.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,17(3),233-247.
  2. Chen, Y.,Peng, Q.,Gu, P.(2018).Methods and tools for the optimal adaptable design of open-architecture products.The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology,94(1-4),991-1008.
  3. Delgado, M.,Herrera, F.,Herrera-Viedma, E.,Martinez, L.(1998).Combining numerical and linguistic information in-group decision-making.Journal of Information Science,107,177-194.
  4. Douglas, J.(2002).Building adaptation.Oxford, England:Butterworth Heinemann.
  5. Ferretti, V.,Bottero, M.,Mondini, G.(2014).Decision making and cultural heritage: An application of the multi-attribute value theory for the reuse of historical buildings.Journal of Cultural Heritage,15(6),644-655.
  6. Goddard, S. T.(1983).Ranking in tournaments and group decisionmaking.Management Science,29(12),1384-1392.
  7. Gu, P.,Hashemian, M.,Nee, A. Y. C.(2004).Adaptable design.CIRP Annals Manufacturing Technology,53(2),539-557.
  8. Gu, P.,Xue, D.,Chen, Y.(2011).Global product development.Berlin:Springer.
  9. Gu, P.,Xue, D.,Nee, A. Y. C.(2009).Adaptable design: Concepts, methods and applications.Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part B Journal of Engineering,223(11),1367-1387.
  10. Halliwell, J.,Shen, Q.(2009).Linguistic probabilities: Theory and application.Soft Computing,13,169-183.
  11. Harun, S. N.(2011).Heritage building conservation in Malaysia: Experience and challenges.Procedia Engineering,20,41-53.
  12. Jerome, P.(2008).An introduction to authenticity in preservation.APT Bulletin,39(2-3),3-7.
  13. Johnson, H. D.(1995).Green plans: Greenprint for sustainability.Lincoln, NE:University of Nebraska Press.
  14. Kacprzyk, J.(1986).Fuzzy sets in system analysis (in Polish) PWN.Warszawa, Poland:Panstwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe.
  15. Kaufmann, A.,Gupta, M. M.(1991).Introduction to fuzzy arithmetic: Theory and applications.New York, NY:Van Nostrand Reinhold.
  16. Kidd, P. S.,Parshall, M. B.(2000).Getting the focus and the group: Enhancing analytical rigor in focus group research.Qualitative Health Research,10(3),293-308.
  17. Klir, G. J.,Yuan, B.(1995).Fuzzy sets and fuzzy logic theory and applications.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice-Hall International Inc.
  18. Kohler, N.,Hassler, U.(2002).The building stock as a research object.Building Research and Information,30(4),226-236.
  19. Krueger, R. A.,Casey, M. A.(2000).Focus groups: A practical guide for applied research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage Publications.
  20. Kutut, V.,Zavadskas, E. K.,Lazauskas, M.(2014).Assessment of priority alternatives for preservation of historic buildings using model based on ARAS and AHP methods.Archives of Civil and Mechanical Engineering,14,287-294.
  21. Leupen, B.(2006).Polyvalence, a concept for the sustainable dwelling.Nordic Journal of Architectural Research,19(3),23-31.
  22. Lower, M.,Magott, J.,Skorupski, J.(2016).Analysis of air traffic incidents using event trees with fuzzy probabilities.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,293,50-79.
  23. Martinez, M.,Xue, D.(2016).Development of adaptable products based on modular design and optimization methods.Procedia CIRP,50(1),70-75.
  24. Morse, G. (2015, October 28). What is a machine for living in? Retrieved from https://placeexploration.com/2015/10/28/a-house-is-a-machine-for-living-in/
  25. Nurmi, H.(2004).A comparison of some distance-based choice rules in ranking environments.Theory and Decision,57(1),5-24.
  26. Otto, K.,Wood, K.(2001).Product design: Techniques in reverse engineering and new product development.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice-Hall International Inc.
  27. Penića, M.,Svetlana, G.,MurguL, V.(2015).Revitalization of historic buildings as an approach to preserve cultural and historical heritage.Procedia Engineering,117,883-890.
  28. Plevoets, B.,Van Cleempoel, K.(2013).Reinventing architecture and interiors: A socio-political view on building adaptation.London:Libri Publishers.
  29. Rabiee, F.(2004).Focus-group interview and data analysis.Proceedings of the Nutrition Society,63(4),655-660.
  30. Rapoport, A.(1969).House form and culture.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
  31. Rapoport, A.(1982).The meaning of the built environment: A nonverbal communication approach.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  32. Roy, B.(1971).Problems and methods with multiple objective functions.Mathematical Programming,1(1),239-266.
  33. Rutkowska, D.,Pilinski, M.,Rutkowski, L.(1997).Neural networks, genetic algorithms and fuzzy systems, PWN.Warszawa, Poland:Polish Scientific Publishers.
  34. Saaty, T. L.(2008).Decision making with the analytic hierarchy process.International Journal of Molecular Sciences,1(1),83-98.
  35. Sand, J. C.,Gu, P.(2006).Advances in design.London:Springer.
  36. Seo, K. K.,Park, J. H.,Jang, D. S.,Wallace, D.(2002).Approximate estimation of the product life cycle cost using artificial neural networks in conceptual design.International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology,19(6),461-471.
  37. Shao, X.,Wang, Z.,Zhang, G.,Li, P.,Gu, P.(2006).Adaptability measure for product family-based adaptable design.Proceeding of the 16th CIRP international design seminar,Kananaskis:
  38. Shih, H. S.,Shyur, H. J.,Lee, E. S.(2007).An extension of TOPSIS for group decision making.Mathematical and Computer Modelling,45(7-8),801-813.
  39. Starn, R.(2002).Authenticity and historic preservation: Towards an authentic history.History of the Human Sciences,15(1),1-16.
  40. Teo, P.,Huang, S.(1995).Tourism and heritage conservation in Singapore.Annals of Tourism Research,22(3),589-615.
  41. Tipnis, V. A.(1994).Challenges in product strategy, product planning and technology development for product life cycle design.CIRP Annals Manufacturing Technology,43(1),157-162.
  42. Van Laarhoven, P. J. M.,Pedrycz, W.(1983).A fuzzy extension of Saaty’s priority theory.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,11(3),229-241.
  43. Xu, Y.,Chen, Y.,Zhang, G.,Gu, P.(2008).Adaptable design of machine tools structures.Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering,21(3),7-15.
  44. Zadeh, L. A.(1975).Fuzzy logic and approximate reasoning.Synthese,30(3-4),407-428.
  45. Zhang, J.,Xue, D.,Gu, P.(2015).Adaptable design of open architecture products with robust performance.Journal of Engineering Design,26,1-23.
  46. Zimmerman, H. J.(1991).Fuzzy set theory and its application.Boston, MA:Kluwer Academic.
  47. 中山繁信, S.,光藤俊夫, T.(2008).住居的水與火.新北市=New Taipei:楓書坊文化出版社=Maple House Cultural Publishing.
  48. 中國國家文物局（2015 年 4 月 17 日）。關於國保省保集中成片傳統村落漳州寮村蔡氏古民居建築群保護工程立項的批復。取自 http://www.sach.gov.cn/art/2015/4/17/art_1324_119261.html National Cultural Heritage Administration. (2015, April 17). The approval of the project for the protection of Cai-Clan traditional residential buildings in Zhangzhou Liao Village, a cluster of traditional villages in National conservation Province. Retrieved from http://www.sach.gov.cn/art/2015/4/17/art_1324_119261.html [in Chinese, semantic translation]
  49. 王嵐, L.,羅奇, Q.(2003)。蔡氏古民居建築群。北京交通大學學報，27(1)，87-93。
  50. 曲藝, Y.(2009)。汕頭市=Shantou, China，汕頭大學=Shantou University。
  51. 辛志傑, Z.,陳永亮, Y.,張大衛, D.,滿佳,劉澤福, Z.(2008)。面向數控弧齒銑齒機產品族的可適應動態設計方法。天津大學學報，41(10)，1202-1208。
  52. 阮儀三, Y.,林林, L.(2003)。文化遺產保護的真實性原則。同濟大學學報(社會科學版)，14(2)，1-5。
  53. 阮儀三, Y.,孫萌, M.(2001)。我國歷史街區保護與規劃的若干問題研究。城市規劃，25(10)，25-32。
  54. 徐娟燕, J. Y.(2008)。衛浴產品設計發展趨勢研究。包裝工程，29(7)，141-144。
  55. 高陽, Y.,陳常青, C.(2006)。一種基於 ELECTRE 排序的簡化方法。統計與決策，10，37-39。
  56. 常青, Q.(2009)。歷史建築修復的“真實性”批判。時代建築，3，118-121。
  57. 畢恒達, H. D.(1990)。東西的意義與環境轉變。國立台灣大學建築與城鄉研究學報，5(1)，41-56。
  58. 許楹, Y.(2003)。功能化的衛浴產品—衛浴功能化。家飾，4，150-153。
  59. 陳永亮, Y.,滿佳, J.,曲藝, Y.,顧佩華, P.(2010)。機械產品可適應性度量方法與應用。工程設計學報，17(1)，1-11。
  60. 陳永亮, Y.,褚巍麗, W,徐燕申, Y.(2007)。面向可適應性的參數化產品平臺設計。電腦集成製造系統，13(5)，877-884。
  61. 費迎慶, Y.,秦樂, L.,郭銳, R.(2011)。蔡氏古民居的居住方式及其再利用研究。南方建築，1(1)，44-49。
  62. 董衛, W.(2000)。城市更新中的歷史遺產保護—對城市歷史地段/街區保護的思考。建築師，6(3)，31-37。
  63. 戴志堅, Z.(2003).閩臺民居建築的淵源與形態.福州=Fuzhou:福建人民出版社=Fujian People’s Publishing House.
print cancel