綠色信用評等機制與融資決策模式

Green Credit Scoring Mechanisms and Financing Decisions

10.6985/TBFQ.201112.0042

李堅明(Chien-Ming Lee)；江振興(Cheng-Hsin Chiang)

綠色金融 ； 碳風險 ； 信用評等 ； Green Finance ； Carbon Risk ； Credit Scoring

台灣金融財務季刊

12卷4期（2011 / 12 / 01）

42 - 69

繁體中文

許多文獻均顯示，企業環境績效與財務績效密不可分，並逐漸受到金融機構的重視。然而，現存的信用風險評等方法，未納入企業環境績效因子，恐將扭曲金融機構的資金配置效率，降低金融體系貸放資金的環境生產力價值，不利整體國家綠色經濟發展。基於此，本研究嘗試建立一套綠色信用風險評等機制，並探討對金融機構融資決策行為之影響。進而，本研究再以台灣三個企業個案（一個污染產業及兩個綠能產業），實證在綠色信用風險評等機制之適用性。研究發現，在綠色信用風險評等機制下，的確會改變金融機構的融資決策與條件。本研究據此提出相關配套措施，提供金融主管機關推動綠色金融政策參考。

There is a lot of literature indicating that industrial environmental performance has a positive relationship with its financial performance. Therefore, it should be incorporated into the bank's credit scoring system. However, the current credit scoring system lacks environmental performing factors. As a result, it has led to resource misallocation and lower monetary productivity, financed by the banking system, which in turn made a long-term limitation for a green economy. The main purpose of this research is to construct a new green credit scoring mechanism, which is to substitute the existing one. To achieve this objective, firstly the study establishes a theoretical green credit scoring model, and discusses its optimal financing decision process in the banking system. Secondly, based on these analytical results, this study selects three cases for empirical analysis. According to the empirical results, the research has discovered that green credit scoring can indeed change the financing decision process, which implies that green credit scoring can induce a transfer of funding from brown industries to green industries.

1. 李君屏、陳宏輝(2007)。存款保險之評價：信用風險模型之應用。風險管理學報，9(1)，5-25。
   連結：
2. 張大成(2003)。違約機率與信用評估模型。台灣金融財務季刊，4(1)，19-34。
   連結：
3. 黃仁德、郭淑郁(2004)。信用風險衡量—信用風險加成模型。台灣金融財務季刊，5(3)，77-111。
   連結：
4. 鍾經樊、黃嘉龍、黃博怡、謝有隆(2006)。台灣地區企業信用評分系統的建置、驗證和比較。經濟論文，34(4)，541-590。
   連結：
5. (2001).Knowledge, Power and Participation in Environmental Policy Analysis.Transaction Publishers.
6. Elliott, G. and R. P. Lieli (2005), “The Prediction of Binary Outcomes,”Manuscript, Department of Economics, University of California, San Diego..
7. Ziegler, A., T. Busch and V. H. Hoffmann (2009),“Corporate Responses to Climate Change and Financial Performance: The Impact of Climate Policy,”Working Paper 09/105, Center of Economic Research at ETH Zurich.
8. Annandale, D.,Bailey, J.,Ouano, E.,Evans, W.,King, P.(2001).The potential role of strategic environmental assessment in the activities of multilateral development banks.Environmental Impact Assessment Review,21,407-429.
9. Bettina, F.,Swoboda, M.,Hoffmann, V. H.(2009).,WWF (World Wildlife Fund)-Germany.
10. Carbon Trust(2006).Carbon footprints in the supply chain: The next step for business.London:Carbon Trust.
11. Carbon Trust(2007).Carbon footprints: An introduction for organization.London:Carbon Trust.
12. Carbon Trust(2006).Climate change and shareholder value.London:Carbon Trust.
13. Carolyn, F.(2005).Technical Innovation and Design Choices for Emissions Trading and Other Climate Policies.Climate Protection and Emissions Trading:Cambridge University Press.
14. Coulson, A.(2007).How Should Banks Govern the Environment? Challenging the Construction of Action Versus Veto.Business Strategy and the Environment,19,149-161.
15. Dasgupta, S.,Laplante, B.,Wang, H.,Wheeler, D.(2002).Confronting the environmental Kuznets curve.Journal of Economic Perspectives,16(1),147-168.
16. Dowell, G.,Hart, S.,Yeung, B.(2000).Do corporate global environmental standards create or destory market value?.Management Science,46(8),1059-1074.
17. EIA(2007).Voluntary reporting of greenhouse gases program, fuel and energy source codes and emission coefficients.Washington, D. C.:EIA.
18. EnCana(2007).Environmental performance.Calgary, Canada:Encana.
19. Fama, E. F.,French, K. R.(2004).The Capital Asset Pricing Model: Theory and Evidence.Journal of Economic Perspectives,18,25-46.
20. Friedman, M.(1970).The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits.The New York Times Magazine,13
21. Heal, G.(2005).Corporate Social Responsibility: An Economic and Financial Framework.Geneva Papers,30,387-409.
22. Henderson,Trucost(2005).The carbon 100-quantifying the carbon emissions, intensities, and exposures of the FTSE 100.London:Henderson Global Investors.
23. Hoffmann, V.,Busch, T.(2008).Corporate Carbon Performance Indicators-Carbon Intensity, Dependency, Exposure and Risk.Journal of Industrial Ecology,505-520.
24. House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee(2011).Second Report of Session 2010-11.
25. Klassen, R. D.,McLaughlin, C. P.(1996).The Impact of Environmental Management on Firm Performance.Management Science,42(8),1199-1214.
26. Lieli, R.,White, A.(2010).The Construction of Empirical Credit Scoring Rules Based on Maximization Principles.Journal of Econometrics,110-119.
27. Macerinskiene, I.,Ivaskeviciute, L.(2008).The Evaluation Model of A Commerical Bank Loan Portfolio.Journal of Business Economics and Management,9(4),269-277.
28. Maxime, D.,Marcotte, M.,Arcand, Y.(2006).Development of eco-efficiency indicators for the Canadian food and beverage Industry.Journal of Cleaner Production,14(14),636-648.
29. Nakao, Y.,Amano, A.,Matsumara, K.,Genba, K.,Nakano, M.(2007).Relationship between environmental performance and financial performance: an empirical analysis of Japanese corporations.Business Strategy and Environment,16(2),106-118.
30. OECD(2010).Transition to a Low-carbon Economy-Public Goals and Corporate Practices.OECD Publishing.
31. Thompson, P.,Cowton, C.(2004).Bringing the Environment into Bank Lending: Implications for Environmental Reporting.The British Accounting Review,36,197-218.
32. Trucost(2006).Carbon Counts- the Trucost Carbon Footprint Ranking of UK lnvestment Funds.London:Trucost Plc..
33. UNFCCC(2011).,未出版
34. United Nations Development Programme(2011).Catalysing Climate Finance.A&K Office Supplies.
35. United Nations Environment Programme(2011).Towards a Green Economy: Pathways to Sustainable Development and Poverty Eradication.UNEP/GRID-Arendal.
36. Urdal, B. T.,Kopp, M.,Volker, T.(2006).,Zurich, Switzerland:SAM, WWF.
37. Voisin, S.,Lamotte, C.(2006).Carbon impact on utilities.Paris:Cheuvreux-Sustainable & Responsible Investment.
38. Weber, O.,Scholz, R.,Michalik, G.(2010).Incorporating Sustainability Criteria into Credit Risk Management.Business Strategy and the Environment,19,39-50.
39. 李堅明、江佳蓁(2010)。歐盟排放交易制度、氣候政策和產業競爭力分析。碳經濟，18，16-29。
40. 沈大白、張大成(2003)。信用風險模型評估—以台灣市場為例。財團法人金融聯合徵信中心。
41. 張大成、劉美纓、萬智傑(2008)。中小企業之財務危機預警模型與新巴塞爾協定信用評等。中小企業發展季刊，9，199-220。

1. 陳俊元(2021)。綠色債券監理之研究：以國際準則之最新發展為中心。證券市場發展季刊，33(2)，105-152。
2. 林書吟,李堅明(2019)。綠色融資策略比較－以直接與間接利差補貼為例。農業經濟叢刊，25(1)，27-68。