居住調整決策中的社群關係與經濟理性

Preference of Housing Adjustment Intention under the Impact of Economic Rationality and Social Networks

10.6375/JHS.201006.0001

靳燕玲(Yen-Ling Chin)

居住調整行為 ； 遷移意向 ； housing adjustment behavior ； intention to move

住宅學報

19卷1期（2010 / 06 / 01）

1 - 27

繁體中文

居住調整決策中的社會群己關係偏好存在嗎？若有，如何連結上經濟理性效益脈絡的思考？本研究旨在探討影響預期遷移住戶選擇意向或偏好的因素，並將過去研究所忽略的群體社會心理層面因素納入考量。在方法上，利用內政部建集研究所台灣地區購屋動向調查92年第3季之原始資料，以預期遷移住戶為受訪對象，採邏輯特(logit)模型檢視住戶全圖不同調整策略之行為意向，除了經濟效益因素之外，是否也受到社會因素影響。之後應用訪談調查為輔助，釐清社會關係因素的具體影響內容及項目，並解釋其機制如何作用。研究結果發現，社會群己關係的影響不亞於個體經濟理性層面；並且，地點認同、家庭傳統、及鄰里社會支持因素，形塑了無形的居住價值偏好，以致誰動或牽制了住戶原先預期遷移的意向選擇。

In housing adjustment behavior, does the preference of a social group-self relationship exist? If it does, how can the deliberation of such a reasonable context be connected? This article attempts to integrate the preference formation model in terms of its economic and social aspects, and to review the behavioral features of the individual pending relocation. As indicated in the study, the impact of the social group-self relationship is no less than would be reasonable in an individual economy. In addition, factors such as location recognition, social support and family culture help shape the intangible housing value, and are likely to facilitate or check the intention of the household regarding the anticipated move.

1. 陳淑美、張金鶚(2004)。三代同堂家庭遷移決策之研究。人文及社會科學集刊，16(2)，325-349。
   連結：
2. 陳淑美、張金鶚(2004)。家戶就業結構與通勤選擇之變遷分析—論1990年和2000年間的變化。都市與計劃，31(4)，295-312。
   連結：
3. 陳淑美、張金鶚、陳建良(2004)。家戶遷移與居住品質關係變化之研究—台北縣市的實證分析。住宅學報，13(1)，51-74。
   連結：
4. 曾喜鵬、薛立敏(2005)。不同類型遷移者之住宅區位與權屬選擇的實證估計—以台北都會區遷入者為例。台灣土地研究，8(2)，24-48。
   連結：
5. 曾喜鵬、薛立敏(2004)。家戶在都會區內部之遷移與住宅選擇模式—以住宅消費失衡與調整為觀點的解釋。建築與規劃學報，5(1)，1-28。
   連結：
6. 曾喜鵬、薛立敏(2008)。家戶住宅消費調整選擇行為之研究—台灣地區擁屋家戶的實證分析。台灣土地研究，11(2)，105-125。
   連結：
7. 薛立敏、李中文、曾喜鵬(2003)。台灣區域人口遷移及其與就業市場、住宅市場關係之實證研究。都市與計劃，30(1)，37-61。
   連結：
8. 薛立敏、曾喜鵬(2000)。台灣各都市內部遷移率與住宅市場關係之實證研究。住宅學報，9(2)，79-97。
   連結：
9. 薛立敏、曾喜鵬、謝鈺偉(2007)。台灣地區近年來遷移行為變化之影響因素分析—家戶遷移決策與遷移地點選擇之聯合估計。人口學刊，34，69-107。
   連結：
10. McFadden, D. 1977 Modeling the Choice of Residential Location. Cowles Foundation Discussion Paper, No.477.
11. 內政部建築研究所 2003 《台灣地區92 年第3 季購屋動向調查》Architecture and Building Research Institute, Ministry of the Interior 2003 Housing Demand Survey of the Third Season 2003
12. Alperovch, G.(1983).Economic Analysis of Intraurban Migration in Tel-Aviv.Journal of Urban Economics,14,280-292.
13. Berger, M. C.,Blomquist, G. C.(1992).Mobility and Destination in Migration Decision: The Roles of Earnings, Quality of Life, and Housing Prices.Journal of Housing Economics,2,37-59.
14. Blumen, I.,Kogan, M.,McCarthy, P. J.(1955).The Industrial Mobility of Labor as a Probability Process.Ithaca:Cornell University Press.
15. Boehm, T. P.(1981).Tenure Choice and Expected Mobility: A Synthesis.Journal of Urban Economics,10,375-389.
16. Boehm, Thomas P.,Ihlanfeldt, Keith R.(1986).The Improvement Expenditures of Urban Homeowners: An Empirical Analysis.AREUEA Journal,14(1),48-60.
17. Bogdon, A.S.(1996).Homeowner Renovation and Repair: The Decision to Hire Someone Else to Do the Project.Journal of Housing Economics,5,323-350.
18. Bogue, D. J.(1953).Needed Urban and Metropolitan Research.Oxford, Ohio:Scripps Foundation.
19. Bourdieu P.,Wacquant, L.(1992).An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology.Chicago:Univ. Chicago Press.
20. Brown, D. L.,Moore, E. G.(1970).The Intra urban Migration Process: A Perspective.Geografiska Annaler,52,1-13.
21. Brummell, A. C.(1979).A Model of Intraurban Mobility.Economic Geography,55,338-352.
22. Clark W. A. V.,Huff, J. O.(1978).Cumulative Stress and Cumulative Inertia: A Behavioral Model of the Decision to Move.Environment and Planning A.,10,1101-1119.
23. Clark, W. A. V.,Dieleman, F. M.(1996).Household and Housing: Choice and Outcomes in the Housing Market.New Jersey:Center for Urban Policy Research.
24. Clark, W. A. V.,Onaka, J. L.(1983).Life Cycle and Housing Adjustment as Explanations of Residential Mobility.Urban Studies,20,47-57.
25. Edin, P. A.,Englund, P.(1991).Moving Costs and Housing Demand: Are Recent Movers Really in Equilibrium?.Journal of Public Economics,44,299-320.
26. Galster, G.(1987).Homeowners and Neighborhood Reinvestment.London:Duke University Press.
27. Goldsheider, C.(1971).Population, Modernization, and Social Structure.Boston:Little, Brown and Company.
28. Goodman, J. L. Jr.(1976).Housing Consumption, Disequilibrium and Local Residential Mobility.Environment and Planning A.,8,855-874.
29. Hanushek E. A.,Quigly, J. M.(1978).An Explicit Model of Intra-Metropolitan Mobility.Land Economics,54(4),411-429.
30. Hsueh, L. M.(2000).The Relationship between Housing Price, Tenure Choice and Saving Behavior in Taiwan.International Real Estate Review,3(1),11-33.
31. Ioannides Y. M.,Kan, K.(1996).Structural Estimation of Residential Mobility and Housing Tenure Choice.Journal of Regional Science,36(3),335-363.
32. Ioannides, Y. M.(1987).Residential Mobility and Housing Tenure Choice.Regional Science and Urban Economics,17,265-287.
33. Kan, K.(2007).Residential mobility and social capital.Journal of Urban Economics,61,436-457.
34. Keil, K. A.(1994).The Impact of House Price Appreciation on Household Mobility.Journal of Housing Economics,3,92-108.
35. Kendig H. L.(1984).Housing Careers, Life Cycle and Residential Mobility: Implications for the Housing Market.Urban Studies,21,271-283.
36. Land, K. C.(1969).Duration of Residence and Prospective Migration: Further Evidence.Demography,6,133-140.
37. Leenders, T. A. J.(ed.),Gabbay, S. M.(ed.)(1999).Corporate Social Capital and Liability.Boston:Kluwer Academic Press.
38. Littlewood, A.,Munro, M.(1997).Moving and Improving: Strategies for Attaining Housing Equilibrium.Urban Studies,34(11),1771-1787.
39. Mangen, D. J.,Bengtson, V. L.,Landry, P. H.(1988).Measurement of Intergenerational Relations.CA:Sage Publications.
40. McGinnis, R.(1968).A Stochastic Model of Social Mobility.American Sociological Review,33,712-722.
41. Mendelsohn, R.(1977).Empirical Evidence on Home Improvements.Journal of Urban Economics,4,459-468.
42. Montgomery, C.(1992).Explaining Home Improvement in the Context of Household Investment in Residential Housing.Journal of Urban Economics,32,326-350.
43. Morris, E. W.,Winter, M.(1978).Housing, Family and Society.New York:Wiley.
44. Morris, E. W.,Winter, M.(1975).A Theory of Family Housing Adjustment.Journal of Marriage and the Family,37,79-88.
45. Morrison P.(1967).Duration of Residence and Prospective Migration: the Evaluateon of a Stochastic model.Demography,4,553-561.
46. Pollakowski, H. O.(1988).Final Report Prepared for the Office of Policy Development and ResearchFinal Report Prepared for the Office of Policy Development and Research,Washington DC:U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
47. Portes A.,Landolt, P.(1996).The Downside of Social Capital.The American Prospect,94,18-21.
48. Potepan, Michael J.(1989).Interest Rates, Income, and Home Improvement Decisions.Journal of Urban Economics,25(3),282-294.
49. Roberts, R. E. L.,Bengtson, V. L.(1990).Is Intergenerational Solidarity a Undimensional Construct? A Second Test of a Formal Model.The Journal of Gerontology,45,12-20.
50. Rossi, P. H.(1980).Why Familys Move.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage Publications.
51. Seek, N. H.(1983).Adjusting Housing Consumption: Improve or Move.Urban Studies,20,455-469.
52. Shelton, J. B.(1968).The Cost of Renting Versus Owning a Home.Land Economics,44(1),59-72.
53. Simon, H. A.(1957).Models of Man.New York:John Wiley.
54. Speare, A. Jr.(1974).Residential Satisfaction as an Intervening Variable in Residential Mobility.Demography,11,173-188.
55. Speare, A. Jr.,Goldstein, S.,Frey, W.(1975).Residential Mobility, Migration and Metropolitan Change.Cambridge:Ballinger.
56. Spilerman, S.(1972).Extensions of the Mover-Stayer Model.The American Journal of Sociology,78(3),599-626.
57. Van Dijk F.(1996).Social Ties and Economic Performance.The Netherland:Kluwer Academic Press.
58. Weinberg, D. H.(1979).The Determinants of Intra-Urban Household Mobility.Regional Science and Urban Economics,9,219-246.
59. Weinberg, D. H.,Friedman, J.,Mayo, S. K.(1981).Intraurban Residential Mobility: The Role of Transactions Costs, Market Imperfections, and Household Disequilibrium.Journal of Urban Economics,9,332-348.
60. Wolpert, J.(1965).Behavioral Aspects of the Decision to Migrate.Papers and Proceedings of the Regional Science Association,15,159-169.
61. Wolpert, J.(1966).Migration as an Adjustment to Environmental Stress.Journal of Social Issues,22,91-102.
62. Zimmer, B. G.(1955).Participation of Migrants in Urban Structures.American Sociological Review,20,218-224.
63. 周新富(2006)。Coleman社會資本理論在台灣地區的驗證—家庭、社會資本與學業成就之關係。《當代教育研究》季刊，14(4)，1-28。
64. 林枝旺(2005)。簡介Coleman之社會資本理論。網路社會學通訊期刊，51
65. 陳淑美(1999)。國立政治大學地政學系=Department of Land Economics, National Chengchi University。
66. 陳淑美、張金鶚(2000)。家戶住宅區位與通勤選擇之研究—1990年台北市單薪與雙薪家戶之比較。台灣社會學刊，24，89-125。
67. 章英華、傅仰止(2002)。,台北市=Taipei:中央研究院社會學研究所=Institute of Sociology, Academia Sinica。
68. 曾喜鵬(2004)。國立台北大學都市計劃研究所=Graduate Institute of Urban Planning, National Taipei University。
69. 廖培珊(2004)。情感依附與居住滿意對臺灣民眾遷移意向之影響。人口學刊，28，49-79。

1. 盧新海,王進祥(2014)。以層級分析法建立影響消費者購屋因素之研究。育達科大學報，39，19-38。