違章建築現象分類與其對外部環境衝擊之研究－以台南市為例

A Study on the Classification and Environmental Impact of Building Violations-Using Tainan City as an Example

10.6375/JHS.201012.0059

曾鵬光(Pong-Kuang Tseng)；江哲銘(Che-Ming Chiang)；陳肇堯(Chau-Yau Chen)

違章建築 ； 環境外部性 ； 特徵價格 ； 台南市 ； building violations ； environmental externality ； hedonic price ； Tainan city

住宅學報

19卷2期（2010 / 12 / 01）

59 - 80

繁體中文

違章建築是目前台灣各縣市政府主管建築機關所面臨執行建築管理的重要課題之一，本研究以台南市已查報之違章建築案件為實證研究對象，依時間向度及空間向度將違建資料加以歸類分析比較其違建之特性與影響，並藉由外部性理論予以探討法令規範角度下的「合法建築使用」及使用者觀點下的「實際建築使用」之間的落差。同時透過問卷調查瞭解居民空間使用的需求，以分析建築空間管理之規範與法令的合理性，提出適當的建築管理策略之建議。最後透過特徵價格法建立違章建築之特徵價格模型，以分析政府部門在採取不同建築管理策略下，所獲得的實質效果進行比較分析，並嘗試提出未來的處理建議策略。

Building violations are one of the most important issues for the building authorities of all local governments. These authorities must cope with such building management violations. Based on reported building violations in Tainan City, we classified the cases using time and space dimensions for the analysis and comparison of the features and the impact for each kind of building violation. Externality theory was employed to investigate the gap between legal building usage as defined by related laws and practical building usage as per the users' view. A questionnaire survey was conducted to understand residents' needs for space usage. Based on the survey results, we analyzed the reasonability of the current laws and regulations governing building and space management. We then proposed building management strategies based on this analysis. Finally, a hedonic price model for illegal buildings was established using this method that examined the substantial effects of different building management strategies to find future directions for handling building violations.

1. 姜渝生、王小娥、張欣聰(2004)。都市運輸計畫經濟效益分析之初探。運輸計劃季刊，33(2)，249-276。
   連結：
2. 曾菁敏(2008)。空間外部性、交易成本與市地重劃對住宅土地價格影響之研究─ 台南市的實證分析。住宅學報，17(1)，23-50。
   連結：
3. Chan, K. J. K.(2000).Maintenance of Old Buildings.The Hong Kong Surveyors,11(2),4-7.
4. Ho, D. C. W.,Chau, K. W.,Yau, Y.,Wong, S. K.(2007).An Empirical Study of Unauthorized Appendages in Multi-storey Residential Buildings in Hong Kong.6th China Urban Housing Conference
5. Lai, L. W. C.,Ho, D. C. W.(2001).Unauthorized Structures in Structures in High-rise High-density Environment.Property Management,19(2),112-123.
6. Leung, A. Y. T.(ed.),Yiu, C. Y.(ed.)(2004).Building Dilapidation and Rejuvenation in Hong Kong.Hong Kong:City University of Hong Kong.
7. Litman, T.(1997).Software Review-full Cost Accounting of Urban Transportation: Implications and Tools.Cities,14,169-174.
8. Nijkamp, P.,Blaas, E.(1994).Impact Assessment and Evaluation in Transportation Planning.Massachusetts:Kluwer Academic Publishers.
9. Poon, T. N. T.(ed.),Chan, E. H. W.(ed.)(1998).Real Estate Development in Hong Kong.Hong Kong:Pace Publishing Limited.
10. Rosen, S.(1974).Hedonic Prices and Implicit Markets: Product Differentiation in Pure Competition.Journal of Political Economy,82(1),34-55.
11. Sullivan, A. M.(1983).The General Equilibrium Effects of Congestion Externalities.Journal of Urban Economics,14,80-104.
12. Yiu, C. Y.(2005).Institutional Arrangement and Unauthorized Building Works in Hong Kong.Structural Survey,23(1),22-29.
13. Yiu, C. Y.,Kitipornchai, S.,Sing, C. P.(2004).Review of the Status of Unauthorized Building Works in Hong Kong.Journal of Building Surveying,4(1),28-34.
14. Yiu, C. Y.,Yau, Y.(2005).Exemption and Illegality-the Dividing Line for Building Works in Hong Kong.CIOB(HK) Quarterly Journal,10,16-19.
15. 林庭毅(2006)。國立台灣科技大學=National Taiwan University of Science and Technology。
16. 邱宏哲(2001)。中華大學=Chung Hua University。
17. 洪小文(2005)。公共財的擁擠外部性與最適租稅政策=Congestion and First-best Tax Policy。華岡經濟論叢，5(1)，87-101。
18. 洪村山(2002)。中華大學=Chung Hua University。
19. 黃錦堂(2003)。台北市違章建築處理法制之研究。台北=Taipei:台北市政府法規委員會=Law and Regulation Commission, Taipei City Government。
20. 賴宗裕(2000)。開發影響費課徵額度比例關係之研究。台北=Taipei:內政部營建署=Construction and Planning Agency, Ministry of the Interior。
21. 賴啟銘(2000)。國立成功大學=National Cheng Kung University。
22. 謝崑滄(2006)。國立中山大學=National Sun Yat-sen University。

1. 曾鵬光,陳佳欣(2012)。建蔽率與容積率管制誘發開發商建築違建現象之探討─台南市新建透天住宅之實證分析。住宅學報，21(1)，19-36。
2. 林子欽,吳文傑,朱永恩(2021)。臺北市違章建築查報及後續處理決策因素。住宅學報，30(2)，47-66。
3. 邱啟新(2015)。「朗讀違章」與「建構蘭花屋」：當代台灣違建論述之公共空間觀點與公共性詮釋。建築與規劃學報，16(1)，21-40。
4. 邱啟新(2017)。永續思維之違建規範體制與其環境意涵：台中市與高雄市政策之比較。建築與規劃學報，18(2)，113-128。
5. 邱啟新(2018)。陽光下之非正式性：綠能導向違建治理之發展願景與城市管理意義。地理學報，90，27-54。
6. (2015)。墾丁國家公園住民違章建築問題及處理策略研究。國家公園學報，25(2)，29-39。