成本法估價偏誤之探討－分量迴歸應用

Appraisal Bias of the Cost Approach-A Quantile Regression Analysis

10.6375/JHS.201012.0081

游適銘(Shih-Ming You)；張金鶚(Chin-Oh Chang)

成本法 ； 估價偏誤 ； 折舊 ； cost approach ； appraisal bias ； depreciation

住宅學報

19卷2期（2010 / 12 / 01）

81 - 104

繁體中文

本文以2007年及2008年北部地區974筆交易案例，由估價人員逐筆以成本法估計之成本價格，與成交價格比較其差異。發現成本價格經統計檢定分析，皆顯著高於實際成交價格。推論成本價格有相對較高之系統性偏誤現象，與以往文獻認為成本價格可作為估計值上限之論述相同。此外，屋齡老舊的確會使估價偏誤提高；惟不同分量點之效果不同。本文實證影響成本法偏誤之變數，發現單位地價愈低、總樓層數愈高、移轉樓層愈低、建物面積愈小、建築工期愈長及利潤率愈小者；偏誤愈小。結構、房屋類型、分區、區域之不同對偏誤亦有影響。經由分量迴歸分析，高低偏誤之影響因素亦存在差異。營造施工費求取方式方面，應用工程造價比較法較單位面積比較法偏誤小。

This paper compares the sale price and cost value, as appraised by valuers applying the cost approach for a sample of 974 transactions for properties sold in 2007 and 2008 in Northern Taiwan. We discovered that the sale price is on average lower than the cost value. The reliability of the cost approach was comparatively questionable due to the systematic bias of the overestimation. The previous literature claimed that cost value could serve as the upper limit for value conclusion and that the cost approach was unreliable. Moreover, the bias associated with cost value increased as buildings aged and this bias differed for different quantiles. This paper demonstrated the bias influencing variables based on the cost approach. We found that the bias will be smaller when the land unit value is smaller, the building is higher, the story is lower, the area is smaller, the period of construction of the property is longer and the profit rate is smaller. The bias was affected by structure, building type, zoning, and region. There were differences between the high and low bias on some factors in regard to the quantile regression. The bias was greater based on the construction items comparison method compared to the unit square method when estimating the construction fees for properties.

1. 林秋瑾, C. C.,楊宗憲, C. S. ,張金鶚, C. O.(1996).住宅價格指數之研究—以台北市為例.住宅學報,4,1-30.
   連結：
2. 張怡文、江穎慧、張金鶚(2009)。分量迴歸在大量估價模型之應用—非典型住宅估價之改進。都市與計劃，16(2)，23-42。
   連結：
3. 張金鶚、陳明吉、鄧筱蓉、楊智元(2009)。台北市房價泡沫知多少？—房價vs.租金、房價vs.所得。住宅學報，18(2)，1-22。
   連結：
4. 張麗姬(1994)。從遠期契約和現貨的角度論預售屋和成屋的價格關係—以台北市為例。住宅學報，2，67-85。
   連結：
5. Geltner, D. 1998 “Appraisal Smoothing: The Other Side of the Story-A Comment,”SSRN Working Paper 131459, Social Science Research Network.
6. Appraisal Institute(2008).The Appraisal of Real Estate.Chicago:Appraisal Institute.
7. Cannaday, R. E.,Sunderman, M. A.(1986).Estimation of Depreciation for Single-family Appraisals.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,14(2),255-273.
8. Christensen, B.(1986).Subsidized Housing and the Three Approaches.The Real Estate Appraiser and Analyst,52(1),52-54.
9. Clayton, J.,Geltner, D.,Hamilton, S. W.(2001).Smoothing in Commercial Property Valuation: Evidence from Individual Appraisals.Real Estate Economics,29(3),337-360.
10. Creteau, P. G.(1974).Real Estate Appraising (Step-by-step).Portland:Castle Publishing Company.
11. Cutsinger, S.(1978).The Cost Approach May Produce the Lowest Valuation Estimate.The Real Estate Appraiser and Analyst,44(1),35-37.
12. Derbes, M. J.(1982).Is the Cost Approach Obsolete?.Appraisal Journal,50(4),581-590.
13. Dotzour, M. G.(1990).An Empirical Analysis of the Reliability and Precision of the Cost Approach in Residential Appraisal.Journal of Real Estate Research,5(1),67-74.
14. Dotzour, M.,E. Moorhead,Winkler, D.(1998).The Impact of Auctions on Residential Sales Prices in New Zealand.Journal of Real Estate Research,16(1),57-71.
15. Entreken, H. C.,Kapplin, S. D.(1977).The Proper Place and Purpose of the Cost Approach.The Real Estate Appraiser,43(1),5-9.
16. Frew, J.,Jud, G. D.(2003).Estimating the Value of Apartment Building.The Journal of Real Estate Research,25(1),77-86.
17. Harrison, H. S.(1989).Income properties.New Haven:H2 Company.
18. International Valuation Standards Committee(2007).International Valuation Standard.London:IVSC.
19. Jensen, D. L.(1988).The Use of Multiple Linear Regression in Residential Land Valuation.Property Tax Journal,7(3),215-241.
20. Kahn, S. A.,Case, F. E.(1977).Real Estate Appraisal and Investment.New York:John Wiley & Sons Inc.
21. Koenker, R.,Bassett, G. W.(1978).Regression Quantiles.Econometrica,46(1),211-244.
22. Koenker, R.,Hallock, K. F.(2001).Quantile Regression.Journal of Economic Perspectives,15(4),143-156.
23. Kuan, C. M.(2003).An Introduction to Quantile Regression.Taipei:Institute of Economics Academia Sinica.
24. Kummerow, M.(2003).Theory for Real Estate Valuation: An Alternative Way to Teach Real Estate Price Estimation Methods.PRRES Conference
25. Lancaster, K.(1965).The Theory of Qualitative Linear Systems.Econometrica,33(2),395-409.
26. Lin T. C.,Chen, W. C.(2006).Estimation of Depreciation for Residential Properties-scientific Discovery or Rule of Thumb.23rd Pan Pacific Congress
27. Lusht, K. M.(1996).A Comparison of Prices Brought by English Auction and Private Negotiations.Real Estate Economics,24(5),517-530.
28. Lusht, K. M.(2001).Real Estate Valuation-principles and Applications.Philadelphia:KML Publishing.
29. Malpezzi, S.,Ozanne, L.,Thibodeau, T. G.(1987).Microeconomic Estimates of Housing Depreciation.Land Economics,63(4),372-385.
30. Miller, G. H.,Gilbeau, K. W.(1988).Residential Real Estate Appraisal.New Jersey:Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs.
31. Quan, D. C.(2002).Market Mechanism Choice and Real Estate Disposition: Search vs. Auction.Real Estate Economics,30(3),365-384.
32. Quan, D. C.,Quigley, J. M.(1991).Price Formation and the Appraisal Function in Real Estate Markets.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,4(2),127-146.
33. Rand, S. J.(1986).Cost Approach to Value.Appraisal Journal,54(3),367-375.
34. Ratcliff, R. U.(1972).Valuation for Real Estate Decisions.Santa Cruz:Democrat Free Press.
35. Rosen, S.(1974).Hedonic Prices and Implicit Markets: Product Differentiation in Pure Competition.Journal of Political Economy,82(1),34-55.
36. Shenkel, W. M.(1992).Real Estate Appraisal.Cincinnat:South-western Publishing Company.
37. Shimizu, C.,Nishimura, K.G.(2006).Biases in Appraisal Land Price Information: The Case of Japan.Journal of Property Investment and Finance,24(2),150-175.
38. Sirmans, G. S.,Macpherson, D. A. ,Zietz, E. N.(2005).The Composition of Hedonic Pricing Models.Journal of Real Estate Literature,13(1),3-44.
39. Smith, B. C..Economic Depreciation of Residential Real Estate: Micro Level Space and Time Analysis.Real Estate Economics,32(1),161-180.
40. Tversky, A.,Kahneman, D.(1974).Judgement under Uncertainty.Science,185,1122-1131.
41. Ventolo, W. L.,William, M. R.(2001).Fundamentals of Real Estate Appraisal.La Crosse:DearBorn Real Estate Education.
42. Wolverton, M. L.(1996).Georgia State University.
43. Wolverton, M. L.(1998).Empirical Analysis of the Breakdown Method of Estimating Physical Depreciation.The Appraisal Journal,66(2),163-171.
44. Yiu, C. Y.,Tang, B. S.,Chiang, Y. H.,Choy, L. H. T.(2006).Alternative Theories of Appraisal Bias.Journal of Real Estate Literature,14(3),341-344.
45. 李月華, Y. H.(1999).淡江大學=Tamkang University.
46. 林英彥, Y. Y.(2006).《不動產估價》.台北=Taipei:文笙書局=Wensheng Book Store.
47. 林祖嘉, C. C.(1992).大台北地區房租與房價關係之研究.台灣銀行季刊,43(1),279-312.
48. 張金鶚, C. O.,劉秀玲, H. L.(1993).房地產品質、價格與消費者物價指數之探討.政大學報,67,369-400.
49. 陳彥仲、林國民(1998)。臺灣都市住宅屬性隱含需求分析—以高雄市為例。成功大學學報，33，303-320。