資本寬容對房屋抵押貸款保險之影響

The Impact of Capital Forbearance on Mortgage Insurance

10.6375/JHS.201106.0059

楊智元(Chih-Yuan Yang)；張嘉倩(Chia-Chien Chang)；王昭文(Chou-Wen Wang)；徐守德(So-De Shyu)

資本寬容 ； 房屋抵押貸款保險契約 ； 違約風險 ； capital forbearance ； mortgage insurance contract ； counterparty risk

住宅學報

20卷1期（2011 / 06 / 01）

59 - 83

繁體中文

房屋抵押貸款保險制度在國外已經行之有年，並成為房貸市場重要機制。但是，在次貸風暴期間，大型房貸保險公司無不承擔龐大損失，各國政府卻不敢貿然讓房貸保險公司倒閉，以免造成系統性的金融危機。有鑑於此，本研究除了考慮房貸保險公司違約風險，並同時考量資本寬容機制，推導出房屋抵押貸款保險契約之公平保費公式解。藉由數值分析可知，資本寬容程度越高，房貸保險契約之保費越高。此外，隨著資產負債價值比例增加，資本寬容門檻值對於房貸保險保費之影響更顯重要。最後，藉由延長房貸保險公司經營時間來解決房貸保險公司資本不足問題，亦將使得房貸保險契約之保費上升，且當資產負債價值比例增加，延長經營時間效果對保費上升之效果亦趨明顯。

The system of mortgage insurance has developed over a long period of time and plays an important role in the housing financial market. Since many mortgage insurers suffered huge losses during the subprime mortgage crisis which resulted in capital scarcity, the government came under great pressure to bail them out in order to avoid a systemic economic crisis. Hence, this paper derives a closed-form formula for a mortgage insurance contract that takes into consideration counterparty default risk and capital forbearance. From the numerical analysis, we demonstrate that the mortgage insurance premium is an increasing function of the forbearance threshold. Furthermore, a higher asset-liability ratio leads to a more significant impact of the forbearance threshold on the fair premium for mortgage insurance. In addition, the longer the capital forbearance period and the higher the asset-liability ratio, the higher the fair premium of mortgage insurance.

1. 王昭文(2010)。考量房價跳躍風險下房屋抵押貸款保險之評價。風險管理學報，12(1)，53-68。
   連結：
2. 林左裕、柯俊禎、王琮生(2006)。房貸保險之費率結構研究。臺灣土地研究，9(2)，27-52。
   連結：
3. Bardhan, A.,Karapandža, R.,Urošević, B.(2006).Valuing Mortgage Insurance Contracts in Emerging Market Economies.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,32,9-20.
4. Canner, G. B.,Passmore, W.(1994).Private Mortgage Insurance.Federal Reserve Bulletin,9,883-899.
5. Chen, M. C.,Chang, C. C.,Lin, S. K.,Shyu, S. D.(2010).Estimation of Housing Price Jump Risks and their Impact on the Valuation of Mortgage Insurance Contracts.Journal of Risk and Insurance,77(2),399-422.
6. Dennis, B.,Kuo, C.,Yang, T.(1997).Rationales of Mortgage Insurance Premium Structures.Journal of Real Estate Research,14(3),359-378.
7. Hendershott, P.,Van Order, R.(1987).Pricing Mortgages: Interpretation of the Models and Results.Journal of Financial Services Research,1(1),19-55.
8. Kane, E. J.(1986).Appearance and Reality in Deposit Insurance-The Case for Reform.Journal of Banking and Finance,10,175-188.
9. Kau, J.,Keenan, D.(1996).An Option-theoretic Model of Catastrophes Applied to Mortgage Insurance.Journal of Risk and Insurance,63(4),639-656.
10. Kau, J.,Keenan, D.(1995).An Overview of the Option-theoretic Pricing of Mortgages.Journal of Housing Research,6(2),217-244.
11. Kau, J.,Keenan, D.(1999).Catastrophic Default and Credit Risk for Lending Institutions.Journal of Financial Services Research,15(2),87-102.
12. Kau, J.,Keenan, D.,Muller, W.(1993).An Option-based Pricing Model of Private Mortgage Insurance.Journal of Risk and Insurance,60(2),288-299.
13. Kau, J.,Keenan, D.,Muller, W.,Epperson, J.(1992).A Generalized Valuation Model for Fixed-rate Residential Mortgages.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,24,280-299.
14. Kau, J.,Keenan, D.,Muller, W.,Epperson, J.(1995).The Valuation at Origination of Fixed-rate Mortgages with Default and Prepayment.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,11,3-36.
15. Lee, S.,Lee, C. J.,Yu, M.(2005).Bank Capital Forbearance and Valuation of Deposit Insurance.Canadian Journal of Administrative Science,22,220-229.
16. Merton, R. C.(1977).An Analytic Derivation of the Cost of Deposit Insurance and Loan Guarantee.Journal of Banking and Finance,1,3-11.
17. Nagarajan, S.,Sealey, C. W.(1995).Forbearance, Prompt Closure, and Incentive Compatible Bank Regulation.Journal of Banking and Finance,19,1109-1130.
18. Ronn, E.,Verma, A.(1986).Pricing Risk-adjusted Deposit Insurance: An Option-based Model.Journal of Finance,41,871-895.
19. Schwartz, E. S.,Torous, W. N.(1993).Mortgage Prepayment and Default Decisions: A Poisson Regression Approach.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,21,431-449.