固定利率與指數型不動產逆向抵押貸款之比較分析

A Comparison between Fixed-Rate and Adjustable-Rate Reverse Mortgages

10.6375/JHS.201112.0028

李秉芳(Ping-Fang Li)；楊屯山(Jerry T.Yang)；林哲群(Che-Chun Lin)

不動產逆向抵押貸款 ； 固定利率不動產逆向抵押貸款 ； 指數型不動產逆向抵押貸款 ； 總貸款成本率 ； reverse mortgage ； fixed-rate reverse mortgage ； adjustable-rate reverse mortgage ； total annual loan costs

住宅學報

20卷2期（2011 / 12 / 01）

27 - 46

繁體中文

不動產逆向抵押貸款（RM）允許年長者擁有之房屋權益轉換成現金，以支付日常生活所需，為近來以房養老諸多方案之一。本文使用2008台灣生命表之國民的平均餘命數據資料，根據性別、年齡、及模擬的房價與利率，估計最大可能的貸款成數，進而推估固定利率及指數型RM的年金水準。再者，設定不同的房貸保費結構，結合其情境模擬，從借款者角度比較兩者之月收入與總貸款成本，以判斷兩種RM對於台灣不同群組的年長者的適當性。研究結果顯示，借款者年紀越長，每月可得到的付款額也越多；且年齡低於90歲的女性，得到之每月付款額較男性為少。再者，除了95歲女性借款者外，同性別年齡之借款人，其指數型RM的每月付款額及總貸款成本，均較固定利率RM為高；而兩種RM的總貸款成本，隨著貸款之經過月數增加而下降。

We examine the fitness of fixed-or adjustable-rate reverse mortgages(RM) programs for various gender-age groups of retirees in Taiwan. RM programs allowsenioror retirees to exchange their house equity fora stream of level cash flows to cover their living expenses. We use the Taiwan 2008 Life Expectancy Database and simulate house prices and interest rates to estimate the annuitiesand the maximum loan to value for different gender-age groups if either RM program is adopted. While accounting for the mortgage insurance premium structure, we evaluate each RM program based upon the monthly payments the senior receive and the total annual loan costs (TALC) they pay. The results show that the elders receive more monthly payments, and female over 90 years old receive more monthly payment than the male counterparts while the reverse is true if the female are below 90. The TALC (or monthly payments) of the adjustable-rate RM is lower (are higher) than the fixedrate RM given the same gender-age group except for the female-95 group.

1. Ma, S. R. & Y. H. Deng 2006 "Insurance Premium Structure of Reverse Mortgage Loans in Korea," Working Paper, Daegu University.
2. Boehm, T. P.,Ehrhardt, M. C.(1994).Reverse Mortgages and Interest Rate Risk.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,22(2),387-408.
3. Chen, H., Cox, S. H.,Wang, S. S.(2010).Is the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage in the United States Sustainable? Evidence from Pricing Mortgage Insurance Premiums and Non-recourse Provisions Using the Conditional Esscher Transform.Insurance: Mathematics and Economics,46(2),371-384.
4. Chinloy, P.,Megbolugbe, I. F.(1994).Reverse Mortgages: Contracting and Crossover Risk.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,22(2),367-386.
5. Cox, J. C.,Ingersoll, J. E.,Ross, S. A.(1985).A Theory of the Term Structure of In-Terest Rates.Econometrica,53(2),385-407.
6. Foote, B. E.(2007).CRS ReportCRS Report,Congressional Research Service.
7. Miceli, T. J.,Sirmans, C. F.(1994).Reverse Mortgages and Borrower Maintenance Risk.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,22(2),433-450.
8. Rodda, D. T.,Herbert, C.,Lam, H. K.(2000).Evaluation Report of FHA's Home Equity Conversion Mortgage Insurance Demonstration.Cambridge, Mass:Apt Associates Inc..
9. Szymanoski, E. J.(1994).Risk and the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,22(2),347-366.
10. 林左裕、楊博翔(2011)。逆向房屋抵押貸款在臺灣推行之需求分析。住宅學報，20(1)，109-125。
11. 張金鶚(2009)。台灣以防養老三方案模式提議。以防養老逆向抵押貸款方案研討會

1. 蔡錦堂、楊屯山、林哲群(2014)。逆房貸抵押品的處置時間對保險費率的影響。住宅學報，23(1)，35-50。
2. 劉清吉,黃保憲,張瑞珍,吳庭斌(2020)。台灣以房養老契約設計之改良與評價。證券市場發展季刊，32(4)，155-202。
3. 劉議謙,黃綱毅,李永琮(2021)。我國反向房屋抵押貸款商品之模型與評價。證券市場發展季刊，33(2)，153-194。
4. 羅玉皓、李永琮(2016)。反向房屋抵押貸款商品結構分析。臺大管理論叢，26(2)，139-172。
5. 吳明哲(2023)。辨識我國逆向抵押貸款市場發展策略之優先順序－Fuzzy AHP之應用。住宅學報，32(1)，1-32。