不動產估價師理性行為之探討

Are Appraisers Rational?

10.6375/JHS.201112.0048

陳奉瑤(Fong-Yao Chen)

部分調整 ； 估價師行為 ； 不動產證券化 ； 估價平滑 ； partial adjustment ； appraisal behavior ； REITs ； smoothing

住宅學報

20卷2期（2011 / 12 / 01）

47 - 60

繁體中文

金融海嘯席捲世界造成重大傷害，突顯出經濟景氣循環中繁榮階段的過度樂觀與泡沫化，其似乎隱現投資人具動物本性，有追高助跌的行為，也引發對估價平滑評判的再省思。過去探討估價平滑之相關文獻多以總體資料切入，並將該現象歸因於估價師不能確實掌握市場變動，而直接尋求去平滑的方法。本文有別於過去多數相關研究，改由個別估價資料進行觀察，以T-REITs重新估價案例為對象，依循Quan & Quigley(1991)部分調整模型之理念，以迴歸分析衡量估值與當期市場價格和前期估值之關係，判斷部分調整的程度；並藉由信心函數的建立，進一步觀察部分調整行為是否理性。實證結果顯示，市場噪音越大，估價師賦予市場資訊的權重越小，驗證估價師確有部分調整行為且應屬理性行為。

Previous studies defined appraisal smoothing as reduced volatility or the lag structure of the appraisal-based index as compared to the transaction-based index. Most of these studies examined data at an aggregate level and used extensive data sets in order to de-smooth the appraisal-based index. This paper aims to observe smoothing behavior among appraisers in Taiwan. It uses the re-appraisal data of T-REITs and modifies the partial adjustment model, developed by Quan & Quigley(1991), to observe smoothing issues. The results show that partial adjustments have existed and that T-REITs appraisers attach less weights to market information because of market noise.

1. 江穎慧(2009)。不動產自動估價與估價師個別估價之比較─以比較法之案例選取、權重調整與估值三階段差異分析。住宅學報，18(1)，39-62。
   連結：
2. 洪鴻智、張能政(2006)。不動產估價人員之價值探索過程：估價程序與參考點的選擇。建築與規劃學報，7(1)，71-90。
   連結：
3. 陳奉瑤、楊依蓁(2007)。個別估價與大量估價之準確性分析。住宅學報，16(2)，67-84。
   連結：
4. Geltner, D. 1998 "Appraisal Smoothing: The Other Side of the Story-A Comment," Working Paper , Department of Finance, University of Cincinnati.
5. Brown, G. R.,Matysiak, G. A.(1998).Valuation Smoothing without Temporal Aggregation.Journal of Property Research,15(2),89-103.
6. Chen, F. Y.,Yu, S. M.(2009).Client Influence on Valuation: Does Language Matter? A Comparative Analysis between Taiwan and Singapore.Journal of Property Investment and Finance,27(1),25-41.
7. Clayton, J.,Geltner, D.,Hamilton, S. W.(2001).Smoothing in Commercial Property Valuation: Evidence from Individual Appraisals.Real Estate Economics,29(3),337-360.
8. Cole, R.,Guilkey, D.,Miles, M.(1986).Toward an Assessment of the Reliability of Commercial Appraisals.The Appraisal Journal,54(3),422-432.
9. Diaz, J.(1997).An Investigation into the Impact of Previous Expert Value Estimate on Appraisal Judgment.Journal of Real Estate Research,13(1),57-66.
10. Diaz, J.,Hansz, J. A.(1997).How Valuers Use the Value Opinions of Others.Journal of Property Valuation and Investment,15(3),256-260.
11. Diaz, J.,Wolverton, M.(1998).A Longitudinal Examination of the Appraisal Smoothing Hypothesis.Real Estate Economics,26(2),349-358.
12. Fisher, J.,Miles, M.,Webb, R.(1999).How Reliable are Commercial Property Appraisals? Another Look.Real Estate Finance,16(3),9-15.
13. Gallimore, P.,Wolverton, M.(1999).Client Feedback and the Role of the Appraiser.Journal of Real Estate Research,18(3),415-431.
14. Geltner, D.(1991).Smoothing in Appraisal-Based Returns.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,4,327-345.
15. Geltner, D.(1989).Bias in Appraisal-Based Returns.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,17(3),338-352.
16. Geltner, D.(1989).Estimating Real Estate's Systematic Risk from Aggregate Level Appraisal-Based Returns.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,17(4),463-481.
17. Hansz, J. A.(2004).Prior Transaction Price Induced Smoothing: Testing and Calibrating the Quan-Quigley Model at the Disaggregate Level.Journal of Property Research,21(4),321-336.
18. Hansz, J. A.,Diaz, J.(2001).Valuation Bias in Commercial Appraisal: A Transaction Price Feedback Experiment.Real Estate Economics,29(4),553-565.
19. Hendershott, P. H.(1996).Rental Adjustment and Valuation in Overbuilt Markets: Evidence from the Sydney Office Market.Journal of Urban Economics,39,51-67.
20. Hendershott, P. H.(2000).Property Asset Bubbles: Evidence from the Sydney Office Market.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,20(1),67-81.
21. Ibbotson, R.,Siegel, L. B.(1984).Real Estate Return: A Comparison with Other Investment.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,12,219-242.
22. Kahneman, D.,Tversky, A.(1973).On the Psychology of Prediction.Psychological Review,80(4),237-251.
23. Kinnard, W. N.,Lenk, M.,Worzala, E. M.(1997).Client Pressure in the Commercial Appraisal Industry: How Prevalent Is It?.Journal of Property Valuation and Investment,15(3),233-244.
24. Lai, T.Y.,Wang, K.(1998).Appraisal Smoothing: The Other Side of Story.Real Estate Economics,26(3),511-535.
25. Levy, D.,Schuck, E.(1999).The Influence of Clients on Valuations.Journal of Property Investment and Finance,17(4),380-400.
26. Mcallister, P.,Baum, A.,Crosby, N.,Gallimore, P.,Gray, A.(2003).Appraiser Behaviour and Appraisal Smoothing: Some Qualitative and Quantitative Evidence.Journal of Property Research,20(3),261-280.
27. Quan, D. C.,Quigley, J. M.(1991).Price Formation and the Appraisal Function in Real Estate Markets.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,4,127-146.
28. Sivitanidou, R.(2002).Office Rent Processes: The Case of U.S. Metropolitan Markets.Real Estate Economics,30(2),317-344.
29. 政治大學商學院信義不動產研究發展中心(2009)。台灣地區房地產年鑑。台北=Taipei:行義文化出版有限公司=Singyi Publishing Company。
30. 陳奉瑤(2011)。不動產估價行為研究。台北=Taipei:中國地政研究所=China Research Institute of Land Economics。

1. 黃麗燕、陳淑美、陳彥仲(2013)。不動產抵押貸款擔保品估價行為之研究。住宅學報，22(2)，59-86。
2. 林左裕(2017)。各國金融機構抵押貸款外部估價制度與金融穩定性之研究。土地問題研究季刊，16(4)，34-58。
3. 游適銘(2014)。部分調整行為之估價平滑─以地價基準地重估價為例。臺灣土地研究，17(1)，1-21。