股票與不動產投資信託的蔓延效果及安全投資轉移：以希臘主權債務危機為例

Contagion or Flight to Quality between the Stock and REITs Markets: Greek Debt Crisis

高子荃(Tzu-Chuan Kao)；高偉舜(Wei-Shun Kao)；林楚雄(Chu-Hsiung Lin)；蔡繡容(Hsiu-Jung Tsai)；鍾沛璇(Pei-Hsuan Chung)

蔓延效果 ； 安全投資轉移 ； 不動產投資信託(REITs) ； VC-MGARCH模型 ； contagion ； flight to quality ； REITs ； VC-MGARCH model

住宅學報

26卷2期（2017 / 12 / 01）

75 - 90

繁體中文

本研究建構一個整合的估計模型，稱為t分配下與時俱變相關係數多變量GJR模型(VCMGJR-t model)，以檢定蔓延效果與安全投資轉移的現象。本模型拓展Tse & Tsui(2002)與時俱變相關係數多變量GARCH模型(VC-MGARCH model)，可同時捕捉變異數異質性、波動不對稱性、與時俱變的相關係數、外溢效果以及高峰胖尾分配型態的金融資產報酬特性。結果顯示在希臘主權債務危機的衝擊下，除義大利的REITs市場外，其餘國家的REITs蔓延效果皆呈現不顯著。此外，希臘的RETIs市場在危機發生後一至三個月，皆呈現安全投資轉移的現象。本文建議REITs能作為危機發生時之避險工具，投資人可透過REITs商品以避免投資損失。

This study sets up an integrated multivariate GJR model with time-varying correlation based on the t distribution (VC-MGJR- t) to test the contagion effect and flight to quality during a financial crisis. We extend the MGARCH model by Tse & Tsui (2002) to address conditional heteroskedasticity, asymmetric volatility, time-varying correlation, spillovers, and fat-tailed distributions simultaneously. The empirical results reveal the presence of a contagion effect only in Italy during the Greek debt crisis period. The flight-to-quality effects from stocks to REITs were found to exist in Greece 1-3 months after a financial crisis. We therefore suggest that investors could use REITs for hedging and decreasing their losses.

1. Arestis, P.,Caporale, G.,Cipollini, A.(2005).Testing for Financial Contagion between Developed and Emerging Markets During the 1997 East Asian Crisis.International Journal of Finance and Economics,10(4),359-367.
2. Baur, D. G.,Lucey, B. M.(2009).Flights and Contagion an Empirical Analysis of Stock-Bond Correlations.Journal of Finance,5(4),339-352.
3. Bley, J.,Olson, D.(2003).An Analysis of Relative Return Behavior: REITs vs. Stocks.EFMA 2003 Helsinki Meetings,Helsinki:
4. Broda, S. A.(2012).The Expected Shortfall of Quadratic Portfolios with Heavy-Tailed Risk Factors.Mathematical Finance,22(4),710-728.
5. Cappiello, L.,Engle, R. F.,Sheppard, K.(2006).Asymmetric Dynamics in the Correlations of Global Equity and Bond Returns.Journal of Financial Econometrics,4(4),537-572.
6. Celik, S.(2012).The More Contagion Effect on Emerging Market: the Evidence of DCC-GARCH Model.Economic Modeling,29(5),1946-1959.
7. Chandrashekaran, V.(1999).Time-Series Properties and Diversification Benefits of REIT Returns.Journal of Real Estate Research,17(1),91-112.
8. Chen, J.,Richard, P.(1999).The Risk and Return Characteristics of REITs - 1993-1997.Real Estate Finance,16(1),61-68.
9. Cho, J. H.,Parhizgari, A. M.(2008).East Asian Financial Contagion Under DCC-GARCH.International Journal of Banking and Finance,6(1),16-30.
10. Clayton, J.,MacKinnon, G.(2001).The Time-Varying Nature of the Link between REIT, Real Estate and Financial Asset Returns.Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management,7(1),43-54.
11. Connolly, R. A.,Stivers, C.,Sun, L.(2005).Stock Market Uncertainty and the Stock-Bond Return Relation.Journal of Financialand Quantitative Analysis,40(1),161-194.
12. Conover, C. M.,Friday, H. S.,Sirmans, G. S.(2002).Diversification Benefits from Foreign Real Estate Investments.Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management,8(1),17-25.
13. Corsetti, G.,Pericoli, M.,Sbracia, M.(2005).Some Contagion, Some Interdependence: More Pitfalls in Tests of Financial Contagion.Journal of International Money and Finance,24(8),1177-1199.
14. Dajcman, S.(2013).Forbes and Rigobon's Method of Contagion Analysis with Endogenously Defined Crisis Periods- an Application to Some of Eurozone's Stock Markets.Inzinerine Ekonomika-Engineering Economics,24(4),291-299.
15. Darbar, S. M.,Deb, P.(2002).Cross-Market Correlations and Transmission of Information.Journal of Futures Markets,22(11),1059-1082.
16. Embrechts, P.,McNeil, A.,Straumann, D.(1999).Correlation: Pitfalls and Alternatives.RISK Magazine,12(5),69-71.
17. Engle, R.(2002).Dynamic Conditional Correlation: A Simple Class of Multivariate Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity Models.Journal of Business and Economic Statistics,20(3),339-350.
18. Forbes, K. J.,Rigobon, R.(2002).No Contagion, Only Interdependence: Measuring Stock Market Comovements.Journal of Finance,57(5),2223-2261.
19. Glascock, J. L.,Michayluk, D.,Neuhauser, K.(2004).The Riskiness of REITs Surrounding the October 1997 Stock Market Decline.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,28(4),339-354.
20. Glasserman, P.,Heidelberger, P.,Shahabuddin, P.(2002).Portfolio Valueat-Risk with Heavy-Tailed Risk Factors.Mathematical Finance,12(3),239-269.
21. Gorea, D.,Radev, D.(2014).The Euro Area Sovereign Debt Crisis: Can Contagion Spread from the Periphery to the Core?.International Review of Economics and Finance,30(3),78-100.
22. Gulko, L.(2002).Decoupling.The Journal of Portfolio Management,28(3),59-66.
23. Hartmann, P.,Straetmans, S.,de Vries, C. G.(2004).Asset Market Linkages in Crisis Periods.The Review of Economics and Statistics,86(1),313-326.
24. Hoesli, M.,Reka, K.(2015).Contagion Channels between Real Estate and Financial Markets.Real Estate Economics,43(1),101-138.
25. Hudson-Wilson, S.,Fabozzi, F. J.,Gordon, J. N.(2003).Why Real Estate?.Journal of Portfolio Management,29(5),12-25.
26. Huisman, R.,Koedijk, K. G.,Pownall, R. A. J.(1998).VaR-x: Fat Tails in Financial Risk Management.Journal of Risk,1(1),47-61.
27. Kanas, A.(2000).Volatility Spillovers between Stock Returns and Exchanges: International Evidence.Journal of Business Finance and Accounting,27(3),447-467.
28. Kearns, P.,Pagan, A.(1997).Estimating the Density Tail Index for Financial Time Series.Review of Economics and Statistics,79(2),171-175.
29. Li, Y.,Wang, K.(1995).The Predictability of REIT Returns and Market Segmentation.Journal of Real Estate Research,10(4),471-482.
30. Liow, K. H.(2012).Co-Movements and Correlations across Asian Securitized Real Estate and Stock Markets.Real Estate Economics,40(1),97-129.
31. Longin, F.,Solnik, B.(1995).Is the Correlation in International Equity Returns Constant: 1960-1990?.Journal of International Money and Finance,14(1),3-26.
32. McNeil, A. J.,Frey, R.(2000).Estimation of Tail-related Risk Measures for Heteroscedastic Financial Time Series: an Extreme Value Approach.Journal of Empirical Finance,7(3-4),271-300.
33. Milunovich, G.,Trueck, S.(2013).Regional and Global Contagion in Real Estate Investment Trusts: The Case of the Financial Crisis of 2007-2009.Journal of Property Investment and Finance,31(1),53-77.
34. Paladino, M.,Mayo, H.(1998).REIT Stocks Do Not Diversify Stock Portfolios: An Update.Real Estate Review,27(4),39-40.
35. Papavassiliou, V. G.(2014).Cross-Asset Contagion in Times of Stress.Journal of Economics and Business,76(6),133-139.
36. Straetmans, S. T. M.,Verschoor, W. F. C.,Wolff, C. C. P.(2008).Extreme US Stock Market Fluctuations in the Wake of 9/11.Journal of Applied Econometrics,23(1),17-42.
37. Susmel, R.,Engel, R. F.(1994).Hourly Volatility Spillovers between International Equity Markets.Journal of International Money and Finance,13(1),3-25.
38. Tai, C. S.(2007).Market Integration and Contagion: Evidence from Asian Emerging Stock and Foreign Exchange Markets.Emerging Markets Review,8(4),264-283.
39. Tamakoshi, G.,Hamori, S.(2014).Causality-in-Variance and Causality-in-Mean between the Greek Sovereign Bond Yields and Southern European Banking Sector Equity Returns.Journal of Economics and Finance,38(4),627-642.
40. Tse, Y. K.,Tsui, K. C.(2002).A Multivariate Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroscedasticity Model With Time-Varying Correlations.Journal of Business & Economic Statistics,20(3),351-362.