總體經濟對房地產景氣循環不對稱影響之研究－中國大陸之實證分析

A Study on the Asymmetric Impact of Macroeconomic Factors on the Real Estate Cycles of Mainland China

林祖嘉(Chu-Chia Lin)；游士儀(Shih-Yi You)

中國大陸房地產 ； 景氣循環 ； 馬可夫轉換模型 ； real estate market of China ； business cycle ； Markov switching model

住宅學報

27卷1期（2018 / 06 / 01）

23 - 46

繁體中文

房地產景氣波動是一動態的過程，如何在有效的樣本資料下，準確地認定中國大陸房地產景氣循環轉折點，並正確估計總體經濟變數對房地產景氣波動的影響，將有助於提供相關住宅政策建議。本研究使用中國大陸2004年1月至2015年7月的總體經濟資料，透過馬可夫轉換模型，重新對中國大陸房地產景氣循環進行估算，並且探討在不同房地產景氣的階段，總體經濟變數對房市是否存在非對稱的效果。實證結果顯示，中國大陸2004年至2015年以來，房地產擴張期的時間大於衰退期的時間，且總體經濟變數在房地產不同景氣下，確實對房地產市場有非對稱的影響效果。

The dynamic nature of the real estate market of China has posed specific challenges to researchers. It would be helpful to make policy suggestions by investigating the turning point in the real estate market cycle as well as the impacts of some fundamental economic factors. The main purpose of this study is to investigate the cycle of China's real estate market by adopting the Markov switching model. Our empirical results show that, during the period from 2004:01 to 2015:07, the average duration of the real estate market's expansion in China is longer than that of the contraction. In addition, our analysis confirms the significance of the asymmetric relationship between the real estate market and fundamental economic factors in China.

1. 李春長、梁志民、周幸蓉(2008)。台灣房地產景氣循環轉折點之認定與預測—馬可夫轉換模型之應用。臺灣土地研究，11(2)，155-177。
   連結：
2. 馬毓駿、林秋瑾(2009)。房地產景氣特性之再確認—多變量馬可夫轉換之應用。住宅學報，18(1)，23-37。
   連結：
3. Abelson, P.,Joyeux, R.,Milunovich, G.,Chung, D.(2005).Explaining House Prices in Australia: 1970-2003.Economic Record,81(8),96-103.
4. Ahuja, A.,Cheung, L.,Han, G.,Nathan, P.,Zhang, W.(2010).IMF Working PaperIMF Working Paper,International Monetary Fund.
5. Bracke, P.(2011).IMF Working PaperIMF Working Paper,International Monetary Fund.
6. Brown, G. T.(1984).Real Estate Cycles Alter the Valuation Perspective.Appraisal Journal,52(4),539-549.
7. Chen, S. W.(2008).Reliability of Coincident and Leading Indicators in Monitoring Real Estate Cycles.Empirical Economics Letters,7(3),270-280.
8. Claessens, A.,Kose, M. A.,Terrones, M. E.(2011).Financial Cycles: What? How? When?.NBER International Seminar on Macroeconomics,7(1),303-344.
9. Dahl, C. M.,Kulaksιzoğlu, T.(2006).Nonlinear Modeling of the Changing Lag Structure in US Housing Construction.Contributions to Economic Analysis,276,407-429.
10. Darrat, A. F.,Glascock, J. L.(1993).On the Real Estate Market Efficiency.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,7(1),55-72.
11. Deng, Y.,Zheng, D.,Ling, C.(2005).An Early Assessment of Residential Mortgage Performance in China.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,31(2),117-136.
12. Feng, Q.,Wu, G.(2015).Bubble or Riddle? An Asset-pricing Approach Evaluation on China's Housing Market.Economic Modelling,46,376-383.
13. Fortura, P.,Kushner, J.(1986).Canadian Inter-City Housing Price Differentials.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,14(4),525-536.
14. Glaeser, E.,Gyourko, J.(2003).The Impact of Zoning on Housing Affordability.Economic Policy Review,9(2),21-39.
15. Granger, C.,Newbold, P.(1974).Spurious Regressions in Econometrics.Journal of Econometrics,2(2),111-120.
16. Hamilton, J. D.(1989).A New Approach to the Economic Analysis of Nonstationary Time Series and the Business Cycle.Econometrica,57(2),357-384.
17. Heckman, J.,Matzkin, R.,Nesheim, L.(2010).Nonparametric Identification and Estimation of Nonadditive Hedonic Models.Econometrica,78(5),1569-1591.
18. Hu, J.,Su, L.,Jin, S.,Jiang, W.(2006).The Rise in House Prices in China: Bubbles or Fundamentals?.Economics Bulletin,3(7),1-8.
19. Hua, X.,Sun, L.,Borgia, D.(2012).The Influence of Fundamental Factors on Chinese Residential Real Estate Prices: A Unique Data Panel Study.SSRN Electronic Journal
20. Isabel, V.,Hiebert, P.(2011).Do House Price Developments Spillover across Euro Area Countries? Evidence from a Global VAR.Journal of Housing Economics,20(4),299-314.
21. Kau, J. B.,Keenan, D. C.(1981).On the Theory of Interest Rates, Consumer Durables, and the Demand for Housing.Journal of Urban Economics,10(3),320-331.
22. Kim, C. J.,Murray, C. J.(2002).Permanent and Transitory Components of Recessions.Empirical Economics,27(2),163-183.
23. Kim, S.,Bhattacharya, R.(2009).Regional Housing Prices in the USA: An Empirical Investigation of Nonlinearity.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,38(4),443-460.
24. Kuang, W. D.(2010).Expectation, Speculation and Urban Housing Price Volatility in China.Economic Research,9,67-78.
25. Li, Q.,Chand, S.(2013).House Prices and Market Fundamentals in Urban China.Habitat International,40,148-153.
26. Liang, Y. F.,Gao, T. M.(2007).Empirical Analysis on Real Estate Price Fluctuation in Different Provinces of China.Economic Research,8,133-142.
27. Lüükkonen, R.,Saikkonen, P.,Teräsvirta, T.(1988).Testing Linearity against Smooth Transition Autoregressive Models.Biometrika,75(3),491-499.
28. Meng, H.,Xie, W. J.,Zhou, W. X.(2015).Club Convergence of House Prices: Evidence from China's Ten Key Cities.International Journal of Modern Physics B,29(24),1-16.
29. Neukirchen, M. & H. Lange 2005 “Characteristics and Macroeconomic Drivers of House Price Changes in Australia,” U21 Global Working Paper 016, U21 Global.
30. Pelagatti, M. 2001 “Gibbs Sampling for a Duration Dependent Markov Switching Model with an Application to the U.S. Business Cycle,” Working Paper, Department of Statistics, Università degli Studi Milano-Bicocca
31. Peng, M. W.,Wang, D.,Jiang, Y.(2008).An Institution-Based View of International Business Strategy: A Focus on Emerging Economies.Journal of International Business Studies,39(5),920-936.
32. Pyhrr, S. A.,Roulac, S. E.,Born, W. L.(1999).Real Estate Cycles and Their Strategic Implications for Investors and Portfolio Managers in the Global Economy.Journal of Real Estate Research,81(1),7-68.
33. Ren, Y.,Xiong, C.,Yuan, Y.(2012).House Price Bubbles in China.China Economic Review,23(4),786-800.
34. Seslen, T. N.(2003).Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
35. Shen, Y.,Liu, H.(2004).Housing Prices and Economic Fundamentals: A Cross City Analysis of China for 1995-2002.Economic Research Journal,39(6),78-86.
36. Summers, L. H.(1981).Taxation and Corporate Investment: A Q-Theory Approach.Brookings Papers Economic Activity,12(1),67-127.
37. Sun, L.,Zhang, S.(2008).External Dependent Economy and Structural Real Estate Bubbles in China.China & World Economy,16(1),34-50.
38. Tsay, R.(1989).Testing and Modeling Threshold Autoregressive Processes.Journal of American Statistical Association,84(405),245-292.
39. Yu, H.(2010).China's House Price: Affected by Economic Fundamentals or Real Estate Policy?.Frontiers of Economics in China,5(1),25-51.
40. Zhang, Y.,Hua, X.,Zhao, L.(2012).Exploring Determinants of Housing Prices: A Case Study of Chinese Experience in 1999-2010.Economic Modelling,29(6),2349-2361.
41. Zhou, J. K.(2005).Currency Policy, Bank Loan, and Housing Prices-Empirical Study of the Four Cities.Financial Economy,5,22-27.
42. 何國釗、曹振良、李晟(1996)。中國房地產週期研究。經濟研究，12，51-77。
43. 周幸蓉、李春長(2007)。台灣房地產景氣循環轉折點之認定。2007 年全國不動產經營與管理實務學術研討會
44. 林秋瑾(2004)。房地產景氣指標衡量之再確認—馬可夫轉換狀態空間模型之應用。2004 年海峽兩岸土地學術研討會
45. 林秋瑾、王健安、張金鶚(1997)。房地產景氣與總體經濟景氣於時間上領先、同時、落後關係之探討。國科會人文及社會科學彙刊，7(1)，35-56。
46. 邱兆祥、王濤(2009)。我國房地產經濟週期劃分研究（1950 ~2008 年）。經濟研究參考，71，23-28。
47. 孫雅靜、張慶君(2008)。我國房地產週期波動與經濟週期的實證分析（1979-2008）。生產力研究，15，87-89。
48. 張大永、劉子寅(2015)。中國城市房價非線性收斂機制研究。南開研究，1，71-88。
49. 梁桂(1996)。中國不動產經濟波動與週期的實證研究。經濟研究，7，31-37。