綠建築評估項目對住宅不動產估價調整率之影響

The Influence of Green Building Indicators to the Percentage Adjustment of Valuation on Residential Building

孫振義(Chen-Yi Sun)；曹妤(Yu Tsao)

綠建築 ； 綠建築溢價 ； 不動產估價 ； green buildings ； green building price premium ； real estate valuation

住宅學報

28卷1期（2019 / 06 / 01）

27 - 50

繁體中文

為瞭解不動產估價師在綠建築價格查估之觀點，本研究透過「綠建築講習課程」與「層級分析法專家問卷」進行調查與分析，研究結果顯示不動產估價師對於取得綠建築標章之住宅，平均願提高9.77%之查估價格。此外，對於綠建築查估價格最具影響力的前三項綠建築指標分別為：「室內環境」、「節能設備」以及「空調系統」，且當綠建築等級越高時（總得分數越高），綠建築的溢價幅度亦會隨之提高，但當綠建築等級高至一定程度後，其溢價增加幅度便會趨於平緩。最終，本研究提出一份「住宅類綠建築估價應用表」，以作為估價實務時之參考。

In order to understand real estate appraisers' opinions on green building price assessment, this study conducts surveys and performs analysis based on ＂Green Building Class＂ and ＂Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) Questionnaires＂. The results of this study show that real estate appraisers are willing to raise the average appraisal price by 9.77% for those green buildings that have obtained the green building mark. Moreover, the first three green building indicators that have the greatest impact on the green building valuation are ＂indoor environment＂, ＂energy-saving equipment＂ and ＂air-conditioning system＂. The empirical analysis confirms that when the green building level is higher (the total score is higher), the green building premium will also increase. However, when the green building level (total score) reaches a certain level, the increase in the premium will tend to be flat. Finally, this study presents a ＂Residential Green Building Valuation Application Form＂ as a reference for real estate appraisers in valuation practice.

1. 江穎慧, Y. H.(2009)。不動產自動估價與估價師個別估價之比較—以比較法之案例選取、權重調整與估值三階段差異分析。住宅學報，18(1)，39-62。
   連結：
2. 洪鴻智, H. C.,張能政, N. C.(2006)。不動產估價人員之價值探索過程：估價程序與參考點的選擇。建築與規劃學報，7(1)，71-90。
   連結：
3. Barber, B. M.,Odean, T.(2001).Boys will be Boys: Gender, Overconfidence, and Common Stock Investment.Quarterly Journal of Economics,116(1),261-292.
4. Bhandari, G.,Deaves, R.(2006).The Demographics of Overconfidence.The Journal of Behavioral Finance,7(1),5-11.
5. Brounen, D.,Kok, N.(2011).On the Economics of Energy Labels in the Housing Market.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,62(2),166-179.
6. Diaz III, J.(1990).How Appraisers Do Their Work: A Test of the Appraisal Process and the Development of a Descriptive Model.Journal of Real Estate Research,5(1),1-15.
7. Diaz III, J.(1997).An Investigation into the Impact of Previous Expert Value Estimates on Appraisal Judgment.Journal of Real Estate Research,13(1),57-66.
8. Dwaikat, L. N.,Ali, K. N.(2016).Green Buildings Cost Premium: A Review of Empirical Evidence.Energy and Buildings,110,396-403.
9. Eichholtz, P.,Kok, N.,Quigley, J. M.(2010).Doing Well by Doing Good? Green Office Buildings.American Economic Review,100(5),2492-2509.
10. Fuerst, F.,McAllister, P.(2011).Green Noise or Green Value? Measuring the Effects of Environmental Certification on Office Values.Real Estate Economics,39(1),45-69.
11. Gilboa, I.,Schmeidler, D.(1995).Case-Based Decision Theory.Quarterly Journal of Economics,110(3),605-639.
12. Kahneman, D.,Tversky, A.(1979).Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk.Econometrica,47(2),263-291.
13. Miller, N. G.,Pogue, D.,Gough, Q. D.,Davis, S. M.(2009).Green Buildings and Productivity.Journal of Sustainable Real Estate,1(1),65-89.
14. Miller, N. G.,Pogue, D.,Saville, J.,Tu, C.(2010).The Operations and Management of Green Buildings in the United States.Journal of Sustainable Real Estate,2(1),51-66.
15. Miller, N.,Spivey, J.,Florance, A.(2008).Does Green Pay Off?.Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management,14(4),385-400.
16. Nelson, A. J.(2007).RREEF Research ReportRREEF Research Report,San Francisco:.
17. Nevin, R.,Watson, G.(1998).Evidence of Rational Market Valuations for Home Energy Efficiency.Appraisal Journal,66(4),401-409.
18. Wiley, J. A.,Benefield, J. D.,Johnson, K. H.(2010).Green Design and the Market for Commercial Office Space.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,41(2),228-243.
19. Zhang, L.,Liu, H.,Wu, J.(2016).The Price Premium for Green-Labelled Housing: Evidence from China.Urban Studies,54(15),3524-3541.
20. 內政部建築研究所=Architecture and Building Research Institute(2012).綠建築解說與評估手冊.
21. 方嘉琳, C. L.(2005)。國立高雄大學=National University of Kaohsiung。
22. 王士鳴, S. M.(2006)。國立政治大學=National Chengchi University。
23. 梁家甄, C. C.(2015)。國立台灣大學=National Taiwan University。
24. 彭逸瑋, Y. W.(2013)。國立政治大學=National Chengchi University。
25. 楊竣傑, C. C.(2014)。國立臺灣科技大學=National Taiwan University of Science and Technology。
26. 榮泰生, T. S.(2011).Expert Choice 在分析層級程序法（AHP） 之應用.臺北=Taipei:五南文化=Wunan Book.
27. 褚志鵬, C. P.(2009)。褚志鵬2009 《層級分析法 (AHP) 理論與實作》教學講義，國立東華大學。Chu, C. P. 2009 Analytic Hierarchy Process Theory, Course Materials, National Dong Hwa University.。