媒體新聞能否預測住房市場？

Can the News Media Predict the Housing Market?

江明珠(Ming-Chu Chiang)；許秉凱(Bing-Kai Shiu)

房價 ； 交易量 ； 預售屋 ； 中古屋 ； 向量自我迴歸模型 ； 新聞情緒 ； house prices ； amount ； new house ； existing house ； vector autoregression model ； media sentiment

住宅學報

28卷2期（2019 / 12 / 01）

37 - 61

繁體中文

本文擷取2005年至2017年間，聯合報、經濟日報中與房市相關的新聞，建構媒體新聞的情緒分數，解析新聞情緒與住房市場價格、交易量間的關係。在控制影響住房市場的總體經濟變數後，向量自我迴歸模型（vector autoregression model, VAR）的估計結果顯示，首先，較少證據支持房價的上漲與新聞的情緒間存在顯著關係；但交易量與新聞情緒間的關係則較為顯著。其次，當聯合報新聞情緒越高，房市交易量可能向下修正，且在去除廣告及雜訊新聞後，情緒對交易量的負向影響更為強烈。再者，當房市交易量越大，經濟日報新聞的樂觀情緒越高漲，從而有更多對房市榮景的報導。

The study uses a vector autoregression model to investigate the influence of media sentiment on prices and trading volume in Taiwan's housing market. It constructs sentiment indices from the housing market news of two newspapers, the United Daily News (UDN) and Economic Daily News (EDN). The empirical results based on samples from 2005 to 2017 indicate that an appreciation in lagged prices has no significant influence on media sentiment. By contrast, media sentiment and changes in trading volume are significantly interrelated. Moreover, when UDN sentiment increases, the trading volume may decrease, with this decrease becoming even greater when advertisements and noise news that are irrelevant to the housing market are excluded. Finally, the larger the trading volume, the greater the EDN sentiment, which may result in more optimistic news about the housing market.

1. 林左裕, T. Y.,程于芳, Y. F.(2014)。影響不動產市場之從眾行為與總體經濟因素之研究。應用經濟論叢，95，61-99。
   連結：
2. Bartik, T. J.(1991).Who Benefits from State and Local Economic Development Policies?.Michigan:W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.
3. Case, K. E.,Shiller, R. J.(2003).Is There a Bubble in the Housing Market?.Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,34(2),299-342.
4. Chen, M. C.,Patel, K.(1998).House Price Dynamics and Granger Causality: An Analysis of Taipei New Dwelling Market.Journal of the Asian Real Estate Society,1(1),101-126.
5. Chiang, C.,Han, C. C.,Chiang, Y. M.,Tsai, T. C.,Wu, F. S.,Seng, J. L.(2015).National Chengchi University.
6. Ehrlich, I.,Fisher, L.(1982).The Derived Demand for Advertising: A Theoretical and Empirical Investigation.The American Economic Review,72(3),366-388.
7. Garcia, D.(2013).Sentiment During Recessions.Journal of Finance,68(3),1267-1300.
8. Himmelberg, C.,Mayer, C.,Sinai, T.(2005).Assessing High House Prices: Bubbles, Fundamentals and Misperceptions.Journal of Economic Perspectives,19(4),67-92.
9. Jud, G. D.,Winkler, D. T.(2002).The Dynamics of Metropolitan Housing Prices.Journal of Real Estate Research,23(1-2),29-46.
10. Lemmon, M.,Portniaguina, E.(2006).Consumer Confidence and Asset Prices: Some Empirical Evidence.The Review of Financial Studies,19(4),1499-1529.
11. Mikhed, V.,Zemč k, P.(2009).Do House Prices Reflect Fundamentals? Aggregate and Panel Data Evidence.Journal of Housing Economics,18(2),140-149.
12. Shiller, R. J.(2014).Speculative Asset Prices.American Economic Review,104(6),1486-1517.
13. Shiller, R. J.(2002).Bubbles, Human Judgment, and Expert Opinion.Financial Analysts Journal,58(3),18-26.
14. Shiller, R. J.(2000).Irrational Exuberance.Philosophy & Public Policy Quarterly,20(1),18-23.
15. Sims, C. A.(1980).Macroeconomics and Reality.Econometrica,48(1),1-48.
16. Soo, C. K.(2015).Ross School of Business Working PaperRoss School of Business Working Paper,University of Michigan.
17. Sun, D.,Zhang, C.,Xu, W.,Zuo, M.,Zhou, J.,Du, Y.(2014).Does Web News Media have Opinions? Evidence from Real Estate Market Prediction.Pacific Asia Conference on Information Systems
18. Tetlock, P. C.(2007).Giving Content to Investor Sentiment: The Role of Media in the Stock Market.The Journal of Finance,62(3),1139-1168.
19. Tsai, I. C.,Peng, C. W.(2011).Bubbles in the Taiwan Housing Market: The Determinants and Effects.Habitat International,35(2),379-390.
20. Walker, C. B.(2014).Housing Booms and Media Coverage.Applied Economics,46(32),3954-3967.
21. 彭建文, C. W.,張金鶚, C. O.(2000)。總體經濟對房地產景氣影響之研究。國家科學委員會研究彙刊 : 人文及社會科學，10(3)，330-343。

1. 楊茜文,黃御維,陳明吉,朱芳妮(2020)。媒體傳播效應與房市變化關聯性之驗證。管理學報，37(3)，225-257。
2. (2022)。投資人情緒與建商情緒對臺灣住房市場之影響。臺灣銀行季刊，73(3)，105-133。