不動產逆向抵押貸款與清償選擇權評價

Reverse Mortgage and Prepayment Option Valuation

洪志興(Chih-Hsing Hung)；郭佳政(Chia-Cheng Kuo)；陳勤明(Chin-Ming Chen)

不動產逆向抵押貸款 ； 清償選擇權 ； 年金 ； reverse mortgage ； prepayment option ； annuity

住宅學報

29卷1期（2020 / 06 / 01）

47 - 61

繁體中文

不動產逆向抵押貸款（reverse mortgage, RM）制度已引起各個國家重視並陸續推廣，文獻上對此之研究較多聚焦於貸款年金之評價，惟其評價內容多建構在「貸款契約未發生提前清償」的假設下為之。然而，各國實務上的RM契約並未禁止借方提前清償，此隱含了RM契約附加一清償選擇權予借款人。值此，本研究綜合考量利率、房價與死力等變動因素，來評價此一清償選擇權（prepayment option）。經數值模擬結果發現該清償選擇權的價值佔整體RM金額的比率為3.79%，該選擇權的價值反映了RM借方彈性處理房產的權益價值，同時也是RM貸方應重視之契約被提前終止風險成本。

The real estate reverse mortgage (RM) system has been highly valued and widely accepted. However, while the valuation of the loanable annuity of RM has been previously discussed, the content of the valuations has mostly been established under the assumption of ＂no occurrence of prepayment of the loan contract＂. In reality, RM contracts in many countries do not prohibit the prepayment by the borrower, which thus implies that the lenders of the RM contract present a free prepayment option to borrowers. Therefore, in this study, variables such as the interest rate, housing price, and the force of mortality have comprehensively been taken into account to assess the prepayment option. The numerical simulation results show that the value of this prepayment option accounts for 3.79 percent of the total RM amount, which reflects the value of the rights and interests of the RM borrower's flexibility in dealing with the property, in addition to the risk cost of early termination of the contract, which may be of concern to RM lenders.

1. Ballotta, L.,Haberman, S.(2006).The Fair Valuation Problem of Guaranteed Annuity Options: the Stochastic Mortality Environment Case.Insurance: Mathematics and Economics,38(1),195-214.
2. Bardhan, A.,Karapandža, R.,Urošević, B.(2006).Valuing Mortgage Insurance Contracts in Emerging Market Economics.The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,32(1),9-20.
3. Boehm, T. P.,Ehrhardt, M. C.(1994).Reverse Mortgages an Interest Rate Risk.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,22(2),387-408.
4. Bühlmann, H.,Delbaen, F.,Embrechts, P.,Shiryaev, A. N.(1996).No-arbitrage, Change of Measure and Conditional Esscher Transforms.CWI Quarterly,9(4),291-317.
5. Cairns, A. J. G.,Blake, D.,Dowd, K.(2006).Pricing Death: Frameworks for the Valuation and Securitization of Mortality Risk.ASTIN Bulletin: The Journal of the IAA,36(1),79-120.
6. Case, K. E.,Shiller, R. J.(1989).The Efficiency of the Market for Single-Family Homes.The American Economic Review,79(1),125-137.
7. Chen, H.,Cox, S. H.,Wang, S. S.(2010).Is the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage in the United States Sustainable? Evidence from Pricing Mortgage Insurance Premiums and Non-Recourse Provisions Using the Conditional Esscher Transform.Insurance: Mathematics and Economics,46(2),371-384.
8. Chen, M. C.,Chang, C. C.,Lin, S. K.,Shyu, S. D.(2010).Estimation of Housing Price Jump Risks and Their Impact on the Valuation of Mortgage Insurance Contacts.The Journal of Risk and Insurance,77(2),399-422.
9. Chinloy, P.,Cho, M.,Megbolugbe, I. F.(1997).Appraisals, Transaction Incentives, and Smoothing.The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,14(1-2),89-112.
10. Chinloy, P.,Megbolugbe, I. F.(1994).Reverse Mortgages: Contracting and Crossover Risk.Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,22(2),367-386.
11. Cox, J. C.,Ingersoll, J. E.,Ross, S. A.(1985).A Theory of the Term Structure of Interest Rate.Econometrica,53(2),385-408.
12. Dahl, M.(2004).Stochastic Mortality in Life Insurance: Market Reserves and Mortality-Linked Insurance Contracts.Insurance: Mathematics and Economics,35(1),113-136.
13. Denuit, M.,Devolder, P.,Goderniaux, A. C.(2007).Securitization of Longevity Risk: Pricing Survivor Bonds with Wang Transform in the Lee-Carter Framework.The Journal of Risk and Insurance,74(1),87-113.
14. Gerber, H. U.,Shiu, E. S. W.(1994).Option Pricing by Esscher Transforms.Transactions of the Society of Actuaries,46,99-191.
15. Hilliard, J. E.,Reis, J.(1998).Valuation of Commodity Futures and Options under Stochastic Convenience Yields, Interest Rates, and Jump Diffusions in the Spot.The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,33(1),61-86.
16. Hosios, A. J.,Pesando, J. E.(1991).Measuring Prices in Resale Housing Markets in Canada: Evidence and Implications.Journal of Housing Economics,1(4),303-317.
17. Huang, H. C.,Wang, C. W.,Miao, Y. C.(2011).Securitization of Crossover Risk in Reverse Mortgages.The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice,36(4),622-647.
18. Institute of Actuaries2005 “Equity Release Report 2005, Equity Release Working Party, The Actuarial Profession’Volume 2: Technical Supplement Pricing Considerations,” (http://www.actuaries.org.uk/).
19. Ito, T.,Hirono, K. N.(1993).NBER Working PapersNBER Working Papers,National Bureau of Economic Research.
20. Kau, J. B.,Keenan, D. C.(1999).Catastrophic Default and Credit Risk for Lending Institutions.Journal of Finance Services Research,15(2),87-102.
21. Kau, J. B.,Keenan, D. C.(1995).An Overview of the Option-Theoretic Pricing of Mortgages.Journal of Housing Research,6(2),217-244.
22. Kau, J. B.,Keenan, D. C.(1995).The Valuation at Origination of Fixed-Rate Mortgages with Default and Prepayment.The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,11(1),5-36.
23. Kau, J. B.,Keenan, D. C.,Muller, W. J., III(1993).An Option-Based Pricing Model of Private Mortgage Insurance.The Journal of Risk and Insurance,60(2),288-299.
24. Kau, J. B.,Keenan, D. C.,Muller, W. J., III,Epperson, J.(1992).A Generalized Valuation Model for Fixed-Rate Residential Mortgages.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,24(3),279-299.
25. Lee, R. D.(2000).The Lee-Carter Method for Forecasting Mortality, with Various Extensions and Applications.North American Actuarial Journal,4(1),80-93.
26. Lee, R. D.,Carter, L. R.(1992).Modeling and Forecasting US Mortality.Journal of the American Statistical Association,87(419),659-675.
27. Lee, R. D.,Miller, T.(2001).Evaluating the Performance of the Lee-Carter Method for Forecasting Mortality.Demography,38(4),537-549.
28. Lee, Y. T.,Wang, C. W.,Huang, H. C.(2012).On the Valuation of Reverse Mortgages with Regular Tenure Payments.Insurance: Mathematics and Economics,51(2),430-441.
29. Li, J. S. H.,Hardy, M. R.,Tan, K. S.(2010).On Pricing and Hedging the No-Negative-Equity Guarantee in Equity Release Mechanisms.The Journal of Risk and Insurance,77(2),499-522.
30. Longstaff, F. A.,Schwartz, E. S.(2001).Valuing American Options by Simulation: A Simple Least-Squares Approach.The Review of Financial Studies,14(1),113-147.
31. Ma, S. R. & Y. H. Deng2006 Insurance Premium Structure of Reverse Mortgage Loans in Korea, Working Paper, Daegu University.
32. Ma, S.,Kim, G.,Lew, K.(2007).Estimating Reverse Mortgage Insurer’s Risk Using Stochastic Models.Asia Pacific Risk and Insurance Association 2007 Annual Meeting
33. Milevsky, M. A.,Promislow, S. D.(2001).Mortality Derivatives and the Option to Annuitise.Insurance: Mathematics and Economics,29(3),299-318.
34. Mizrach, B. 2008 Jump and Co-Jump Risk in Subprime Home Equity Derivatives, Working Paper, Department of Economics, Rutgers University.
35. Nothaft, F. E.,Gao, A. H.,Wang, G. H. K.(1995).The Stochastic Behavior of the Freddie Mac/Fannie Mae Conventional Mortgage Home Price Index.American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association Annual Meeting,San Francisco:
36. Schloemer, E.,Li, W.,Ernst, K.,Keest, K.(2006).Losing Ground: Foreclosures in the Subprime Market and Their Cost to Homeowners.Durham, NC:Center for Responsible Lending.
37. Szymanoski, E. J.(1994).Risk and the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage.Journal of American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,22(2),347-366.
38. Tse, Y. K.(1995).Modelling Reverse Mortgages.Asia Pacific Journal of Management,12(2),79-95.
39. Wang, L., E. A. Valdez & J. Piggott2007 “Securitization of Longevity Risk in Reverse Mortgages,” SSRN Working Paper, University of New South Wales.
40. Wang, S. S.(2000).A Class of Distortion Operators for Pricing Financial and Insurance Risks.The Journal of Risk and Insurance,67(1),15-36.
41. Yang, T. T.,Buist, H. I.,Megbolugbe, I. F.(1998).An Analysis of Ex-Ante Probabilities of Mortgage Prepayment and Default.Real Estate Economics,26(4),651-676.

1. 楊屯山,陳翰柏,林哲群(2023)。租金與住宅使用成本關係之再探討：實質選擇權觀點。住宅學報，32(2)，57-82。