教師介入幼兒自由音樂遊戲策略之研究

A Study of Teachers' Intervention Strategies for Young Children's Free Music Play

李萍娜(Pyng-Na Lee)

幼兒音樂教育 ； 目標性介入 ； 自由音樂遊戲 ； 初探性介入 ； 教師介入 ； exploring intervention ； free music play ； music education for young children ； purposive intervention ； teachers' intervention

藝術教育研究

18期（2009 / 12 / 01）

33 - 64

繁體中文

本研究以協同行動研究法，在自由音樂遊戲之情境中探究教師介入之策略。研究包含三個循環，第一循環以「初探性介入」打開師生互動，並分析出介入角色。此期，幼兒雖然展現豐富的音樂行爲，但缺乏音樂能力之進展。第二循環遂修正爲「目標性介入」，以音高和音長的運用爲介入目標，結果卻無法如期的達成目標。再經資料分析，發現各介入角色之間隱含教師主導與幼兒主導之關係，且在第二循環介入角色多屬教師主導之角色。此外，發現當教師的介入與幼兒遊戲的意圖不一致時，介入就不成功，而進一步釐清遊戲的不同脈絡，並且劃分不同脈絡之主導權。在第三循環以幼兒主導「遊戲脈絡」、教師主導「音樂學習目標」的方式介入，在保有幼兒的遊戲脈絡下，教師隨情境轉換介入角色以達成學習目標，結果2-3歲幼兒在教師的介入中展現高度的音樂能力。

This study investigated teachers' intervention strategies in 2-3 years old children's free music play. A method of collaborative action research consisting of three cycles was conducted. In the first cycle, an approach of exploring intervention opened teachers' and children's interaction to investigate the intervention roles. Children created various music behaviors in the first cycle, but they made little progress in the music ability of pitch and duration. Therefore, the second cycle was revised as purposive intervention to employ pitches and various durations for them to create patterns. Nevertheless, the intervention did not achieve the expected goal. Through data analysis, the relation of children control and teacher control was found in the intervention roles, and the majority of intervention roles in the second cycle were identified as teacher control. When teachers' intervention was not coincided with children's intention of play, conflict occurred. Further analysis clarified various contexts in play. In the third cycle, the intervention was employed under children controlling play context and teacher controlling learning goal. Teachers intervened under children's play context and shifted roles to achieve learning purposes. As a result, children demonstrated high music ability.

1. 李萍娜(2007)。幼兒在音樂區行爲之研究。藝術教育研究，14，25-55。
   連結：
2. Achilles, E.,B. L. Andress (Eds.),L. M. Walker (Eds.)(1992).Readings in early childhood music education.Reston, VA:The National Association for Music Education.
3. Berger, A. A.,Cooper, S.(2003).Musical play: A case study of preschool children and parents.Journal of Research in Music Education,51(2),151-165.
4. Bredekamp, S. (Eds.),Copple, C. (Eds.)(1997).Developmentally appropriate practices in early childhood programs.Washington, DC:National Association for the Education of Young Children.
5. Breig-Allen, C. L.(2001).Saint Louis,University of Missouri.
6. Coplan, R. J.,Prakash, K.(2003).Spending time with teacher: Characteristics of preschoolers who frequently elicit versus initiate interactions with teachers.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,18,143-158.
7. Drew, W. F.,Christie, J.,Johnson, J. E.,Meckley, A. M.,Nell, M. L.(2008).Constructive play: A value-added strategy for meeting early learning standards.Young Children,63(4),38-44.
8. Enz, B.,Christie, J.(1993).Teacher play interaction styles and their impact on children's oral language and literacy play.Paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Reading Conference,Charleston, SC.:
9. Enz, B.,Christie, J.(1997).Teacher play interaction styles: Effects on play behavior and relationships with teacher training and experience.International Journal of Early Childhood Education,2,55-69.
10. File, N.,Kontos, S.(1993).The relationship of program quality to children's play in integrated early intervention settings.Topics in Early Childhood Special Education,13(1),1-18.
11. Flohr, J. W.(1984).Young children's improvisations.Paper presented at the 49th Music Educators National Conference,Chicago, IL.:
12. Glaser, B.,Strauss, A.(1967).The discovery of ground theory.Chicago:Aldine.
13. Hildebrandt, C.(1998).Creativity in music and early childhood.Young Children,53(6),68-74.
14. Howes, C.,Matheson, C.,Hamilton, C.(1994).Maternal, teacher, and child care correlates of children's relationships with peers.Child Development,65,264-273.
15. Howes, C.,Smith, E.(1995).Relations among care quality, teacher behavior, children's play activities, emotional security, and cognitive activity in child care.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,10,381-404.
16. Hsee, Y.(2007).University Park,The Pennsylvania State University.
17. Johnson, J. E.,Christie, J. F.,Wardle, F.(2005).Play, development, and early education.Boston:Allyn & Bacon.
18. Johnson, J.,Christie, J.,Yawkey, T.(1987).Play and early childhood development.Glenview, IL:Scott, Foresman & Co..
19. Jones, E.,Reynolds, G.(1992).The play's the thing: Teachers' roles in children's play.New York:Teachers College.
20. Kontos, S.(1999).Preschool teachers' talk, role, and activity settings during free play.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,14(3),363-382.
21. Kontos, S.,Burchinal, M.,Howes, C.,Wisseh, S.,Galinsky, E.(2002).An eco-behavioral approach to examining the contextual effects of early childhood classrooms.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,17,239-258.
22. Kontos, S.,Hsu, H. C.,Dunn, L.(1993).Children's cognitive and social competence in child-care centers and family day-care homes.Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology,15,87-111.
23. Kontos, S.,Keyes, L.(1999).An ecobehavioral analysis of early childhood classroom.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,14(1),35-50.
24. Kontos, S.,Wilcox-Herzog, A.(1997).Influence on children's competence in early childhood classrooms.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,12,247-262.
25. Lincoln, Y.,Guba, E.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
26. Littleton, D.(1991).Austin,The University of Texas.
27. Mang, E.(2005).The referent of children's early songs.Music Education Research,7(1),3-20.
28. Manolson, A.(1992).It takes two to talk.Toronto:Hanen Centre.
29. McDonald, D.,Ramsey, J.,B. L. Andress (Eds.),L. M. Walker (Eds.)(1992).Readings in early childhood music education.Reston, VA:The National Association for Music Education.
30. Miller, H. A.(2001).Houston,University of Houston.
31. Moog, H.(1976).The musical experience of the preschool child.London:B. Schott.
32. Moorhead, G.,Pond, D.(1978).Music of young children.Santa Barbara, CA:Pillsbury Foundation for the Advancement of Music Education.
33. Neumann, E. A.(1971).The elements of play.New York:MSS Information.
34. Pellegrini, A.(1984).The social-cognitive ecology of preschool classrooms: Contextual relations revisited.International Journal of Behavioral Development,7,321-332.
35. Piaget, J.,J. K. Gardner (Ed.)(1982).Readings in developmental psychology.Boston:Little, Brown and Company.
36. Pond, D.,B. L. Andress (Eds.),L. M. Walker (Eds.)(1992).Readings in early childhood music education.Reston, VA:The National Association for Music Education.
37. Rainbow, E.(1981).A final report on a three-year investigation of rhythmic abilities of preschool aged children.Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education,66/67,69-73.
38. Rubin, K. N.,Fein, G. G.,Vandenberg, B.,E. M. Hetherington (Ed.),P. H. Mussen(1983).Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 4. Socialization, personality, and social development.New York:Wiley.
39. Shin, E.,Spodek, B.(1991).The relationship between children's play patterns and types of teacher intervention.Paper presented at the annual conference of the American Educational Research Association,Chicago, IL.:
40. Smilansky, S.(1968).The effects of sociodramatic play on disadvantaged preschool children.New York:Wily.
41. Smith, P. K.,Syddall, S.(1978).Play and non-play tutoring in preschool children: Is it play or tutoring which matter?.British Journal of Educational Psychology,48,315-325.
42. Smithrim, K.(1997).Free musical play in early childhood.Canadian Journal of Research in Music Education,38(4),17-24.
43. Spidell, R. A.(1985).Urbana-Champaign,University of Illinois.
44. Spodek, B.,D. Sponseller (Ed.)(1974).Play as a learning medium.Washington, DC:National Association for the Education of Young Children.
45. Sponseller, D. B. (Ed.)(1974).Play as a learning medium.Washington, DC:National Association for the Education of Young Children.
46. Trawick-Smith, J.(1994).Interactions in the classroom: Facilitating play in the early years.New York:Macmillan College.
47. Tzuo, P. W.(2007).The tension between teacher control and children's freedom in a child-centered classroom: Resolving the practical dilemma through a closer look at the related theories.Early Childhood Journal,35(1),33-39.
48. Tzuo, P. W.(2004).Bloomington,Indiana University.
49. Van Hoorn, J.,Monighan-Nourot, P.,Scales, B.,Alward, K. R.(2003).Play at the center of the curriculum.Columbus, OH:Merrill Prentice Hall.
50. Wilcox-Herzog, A.,Kontos, S.(1998).The nature of teacher talk in early childhood classrooms and its relationship to children's play with objects and peers.Journal of Genetic Psychology,159(1),30-44.
51. Zimmerman, M. P.,J. Boswell (Ed.)(1985).The young child and music: Contemporary principles in child development and music.Reston, VA:The National Association for Music Education.
52. 余安邦、凌俊嫻(1997)。眞的以幼兒爲中心嗎？開放教育的盲點與迷失。師友，366，30-37。
53. 呂佳陵(2004)。創造性音樂活動在中南部地區幼稚園的教學現況調查。臺中技術學院人文社會學報，3，181-197。
54. 李萍娜(2009)。私立托兒所外聘教師擔任音樂教學之個案研究。教育研究學報，43(2)，1-28。
55. 李萍娜、顏端儀(2008)。南部地區公立幼稚園音樂教學概況與影響音樂教學因素之探討。兒童與教育研究，4，51-86。
56. 林文生(1998)。以幼兒爲中心：在開放教育中的意義。師友，371，44-47。
57. 林玫君(1999)。讀寫遊戲之介入對學前幼兒遊戲型式與讀寫發展之影響。臺南師院學報，32，495-515。
58. 夏林清譯、Posch、Somekh Altrichter(2002)。行動研究方法導論。臺北:遠流。
59. 陳向明(2004)。社會科學質的研究。臺北:五南。
60. 黃瑞琴(1994)。論幼稚園遊戲課程的取向。臺北師院學報，7，881-916。
61. 楊艾琳(1992)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告，編號爲[NO.]NSC81-0301-H152-502行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告，編號爲[NO.]NSC81-0301-H152-502,未出版
62. 簡楚瑛(2005)。從教室言談與課程結構看教育改革的契機。教育與心理研究，28(1)，49-74。
63. 羅雅綺(1993)。臺北，國立臺灣師範大學音樂研究所。

1. 魏麗卿、廖美瑩(2013)。幼兒園音樂區之實施現況與困境。明新學報，39(2)，259-278。
2. 魏美惠、李曉瑩(2013)。一位公立幼兒園教師實施音樂教學特色及成效之探究。臺中教育大學學報：教育類，27(2)，27-49。