题名

Honesty as the Best Policy?An Examination of Online Chatters' Interpersonal Deception in Taiwan

并列篇名

誠實為上策？檢視臺灣線上聊天者的人際欺騙

DOI

10.29843/JCCIS.200401.0008

作者

盧鴻毅(Hung-Yi Lu)

关键词

欺騙 ； 人際欺騙 ； 線上人際欺騙 ； deception ； interpersonal deception ； online interpersonal deception

期刊名称

資訊社會研究

卷期/出版年月

6期（2004 / 01 / 01）

页次

173 - 198

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

網路問世後，線上欺騙對人際傳播的影響成為一個有趣的研究問題。本研究針對台灣地區二十位具有兩年以上線上聊天經驗的聊天族進行深度訪談，試圖瞭解線上欺騙對線上聊天者雙方人際關係的影響，結果發現（一）多數受訪者表示他們曾在線上聊天時騙過熟悉的人或陌生人；同樣地，他們也被熟悉的人或陌生人騙過；（二）受訪者在線上聊天時欺騙熟悉的人主要是「好玩」；但是他們欺騙陌生人的原因除了「好玩」之外，也是為了免於「受到心理上的傷害」；（三）受訪者認為他們大多可以輕而易舉地發現對方是否欺騙他們；相對地，受訪者也大多很有自信地認為線上聊天的另一方不太容易察覺正受騙；（四）如果雙方原本就熟識，線上欺騙行為對雙方的原有關係影響不大。一旦雙方原本不熟悉，可能會有兩種不同狀況發生，結果依雙方的上線聊天動機或態度而不同，只因好玩或為了殺時間而上線聊天的人，發現受騙時會選擇一笑置之， 但線上聊天者如果有被欺騙感情或感到不舒服的感覺時，線上欺騙會讓他們感到不悅，甚至採取報復行為。
英文摘要

With the advent of the Internet, the impact of online deception on interpersonal communication becomes intriguing. This study focuses on twenty online chatters in Taiwan with at least 2-year online chatting experience as research targets and employed qualitative interviews to solicit information about online interpersonal deception. It is found that (1) most interviewees reported that they had deceived strangers or intimate others online at least once, and vice versa; (2) their motive of deceiving intimate others was reported only for fun whereas the motives of deceiving strangers were for fun and/or preventing himself/herself from being hurt mentally; (3) interviewees indicated they could detect others’ online interpersonal deception easily whereas their deceptions were seldom detected by others; (4) online interpersonal deception would not affect the relationships between people with an intimate social tie. However, the outcomes of online interpersonal deception between two strangers were associated with their attitudes about being deceived. Those who took online interpersonal deception seriously wanted to stop chatting with those who deceived and to take revenge whereas people who chatted online only for fun would ignore the online interpersonal deception.
主题分类 基礎與應用科學 > 資訊科學
社會科學 > 社會學
社會科學 > 傳播學
参考文献
  1. Anderson, D. E.,M. E.Ansfield,B.M. Depaulo,P. Philippot,R. S. Feldman,E. J. Coats (Eds.)(1997).Love`s best habit: Deception in the context of relationships.The social context of nonverbal behavior,1-46.
  2. Borzekowski. D. L. G.,V. I. Rickert(2001).Adolescent cybersurfing for health information: A new resource that crosses barriers.Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine,155,813-817.
  3. Brooks, S.(2001).Romance and the Internet: How to stay safe.NY:The Rosen Publishing Groups, Inc.
  4. Brown, J. D.,S. N. Keller(2000).Can the mass media be healthy sex educator.Family Planning Perspectives,32,255-256.
  5. Buller D.B.,J.K.Burgoon,A.Buslig,J. Roiger(1990).Interpersonal deception: VIII. Nonverbal and verbal correlates of equivocation from the Bavelas (1990) research.Journal of Language and Social Psychology (special issue),13,396-417.
  6. Buller, D. B.,J. K. Burgoon(1996).Interpersonal deception theory.Communication Theory,6,203-242.
  7. Buller, D.B.,J.K. Burgoon,J. A. Daly,J. M. Wiemann(Eds.)(1994).Strategic interpersonal communication.Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum.
  8. Buller, D.B.,K.D. Strzyzewski,F. Hunsaker(1991).Interpersonal deception: II.The inderiority of conversational participants as deception detectors.Communication Monographs,58,25-40.
  9. Burgoon, J. K.,G. M.Stoner,J.A.Bonito,N.E.Dunbar(2003).Proceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on Systems Science.Kona, HI:
  10. Burgoon, J.K.,D.B.Buller(1994).Interpersonal deception: III. Effects of deceit on perceived communication and nonverbal behavior dynamics.Journal of Nonverbal Behavior,18,155-184.
  11. Burgoon, J.K.,D.B.Buller,A.Ebesu,P. Rockwell(1994).Interpersonal deception: V. Accuracy in deception detection.Communication Monographs,61,303-325.
  12. Cochran, S.D.,V. M. Mays(1990).Sex, lies, and HIV.New England Journal of Medicine,322,774-775.
  13. Cole, T.,L.Leets,J.J.Bradac(2002).Deceptive message processing: The role of attachment style and verbal intimacy markers in deceptive message judgments.Communication Studies,53,74-89.
  14. Comadena, M. E.M. Burgoon (Ed.)(1982).Accuracy in detecting deception: Intimate and friendship relationships.Communication Yearbook 6
  15. Cooper, A.,E.Griffin-Shelley(2002).A quick tour of online sexuality part 1.Annals of the American Psychotherapy Association,5,11-13.
  16. Dai, Y. G.(1999).An exploratory study of Internet user.Master`s thesis at the National Chang-Hua University of Education.
  17. DePaulo, B. M.,D.A.Kashy,S. E.Kirkendol,M.M. Wyer,J. A.Epstein(1996).Lying in everyday life.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,70,979-995.
  18. DePaulo, B.M.,D.A.Kashy(1998).Everyday lies in close and causal relationships.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,74,63-79.
  19. DeTurck, M.A.,J.J.Harszlak,D.J.Bodhorn,L.A.Texter(1990).The effects of training social perceivers to detect deception from behavior cues.Communication Quarterly,38,1-11.
  20. Ekman P.(1989).Why kids lie: How parents can encourage truthfulness.NY:Charles Scribner`s Sons.
  21. Feeley, T. H.,M. A. deTurck(1997).Paper presented to International Communication Association Convention.Montreal Quebec:
  22. Feeley, T. H.,M. J. Young(1998).Human as lie detectors: Some more second thoughts.Communication Quarterly,46,109.
  23. Ferguson, T.(1997).Health online and the empowered medical consumer.Joint Committee Journal on Quality Improvement,23,251-257.
  24. Mass media.
  25. Hample, D.(1980).Purposes and effects of lying.The southern Speech Communication Journal,46,33-47.
  26. Howard, P.,L.Rainie,S.Jones(2001).Days and nights on the Internet. The impact of a diffusing technology.American Behavioral Scientists,45,383-404.
  27. An examination of online friend-making deception-A study of National Chung-Hsing University in Taiwan
  28. Kanapp, M.L.,M.E.Comadena(1979).Telling it like it isn`t: A review of theory and research on deceptive communications.Human Communication Research,5,270-285.
  29. Katz, J.,R.E. Rice,P. Aspden(2001).The Internet, 1995-2000: Access, civic involvement, and social interaction.American Behavior Scientists,45,405-420.
  30. Lippard, P. V.(1988).Ask me no questions, I`ll tell you no lies`: Situational exigencies for interpersonal deception.Western Journal of Speech Communication,52,91-103.
  31. McCornack, S.A.,M.R. Parks,M. L. Mclaughlin (Ed.)(1986).Communication Yearbooks 9.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  32. Millar M. G.,K.U. Millar(1995).Detection of deception in familiar and unfamiliar persons: The effects of information restriction.Journal of Nonverbal Behavior,19,69-84.
  33. Napoli, P.M.,R. E. Rice,J. E. Katz. (Eds.)(2001).The Internet and health communication.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  34. Navarro, J.,J. R.Schafer(2001).Detecting deception.The FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin,70,9-14.
  35. Norris, P.,P. N. Howard,S. Jones. (Eds.)(2003).Society online: The Internet in context.Thousand Oaks, London:Sage.
  36. O`Hair H. D.,M.J.Cody,W. R. Cupach,B. H. Spitzberg (Eds.)(1994).The dark side of interpersonal communication.NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
  37. Teenage life online: The rise of the instant-message generation and the Internet`s impact on friendships and family relationship
  38. Rice, R. E.,R. E. Rice,J. E. Katz. (Eds.)(2001).The Internet and health communication.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  39. Rowatt, W. C.,M. R.Cunnungham,P. B.Druen(1998).Deception to get a date.Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin,24,228-242.
  40. Saarni, C.,M.Lewis,M. Lewis,C. Saarni (Eds.)(1993).Lying and deception in everyday life.NY:Guilford.
  41. Seiter, J.S.,J. Bruschke,C. Bai(2002).The acceptability of deception as a function of perceivers’ culture, deceiver's intention, and deceiver-deceived relationship.Western Journal of Communication,66,158-180.
  42. Shippee, G.(1977).Perceived deception in everyday social relationships: A preliminary statement.Psychology,14,57-62.
  43. Stiff, J.B.,H. J.Kim,C. N.Ramesh(1992).Truth biases and aroused suspicious in relational deception.Communication Research,13,326-345.
  44. Sun, S. H.,C.U.Wu, G. S.,Wan, G. L.Jen,Z.T.Shie(2001).A study of adolescents` online friend-making behaviors in Taipei City.Journal of Crime Commitment,7,37-98.
  45. Tamosaitis, N.(1995).Cross-dressing in cyberspace: You can change shape (or gender) online.Computer Life,2,145-147.
  46. Turner, R. E.,C.Edgley,G.Olmstead(1975).Information control in conversations: Honesty is not always the best policy.Kansas Journal of Speech,11,69-89.
  47. UCLA(2000).Surveying the digital future (SDF).Los Angeles:UCLA.
  48. Walter, J.(1996).Computer-mediate communication: Impersonal, interpersonal, and hyperpersonal interaction.Communication Research,23,3-43.
  49. Walter, J. B.,M.R.Parks,M.L. Knapp,J.A.Daly(Eds.)(2002).Handbook of interpersonal communication.Thousand Oaks, London:Sage.
  50. Wolak, J.,K.J. Mitchell,D. Finkelhor(2002).Close online relationship in a national sample of adolescents.Adolescent,37,441-455.
  51. Yo, S.C.(2001).A study of college students` Internet use, Internet addition and other related factors.Master`s thesis at the National Chang-Hua University of Education.
  52. Zuckerman, M.,B.M.Depaulo,R. Rosenthal,L.Berkowitz (Ed.)(1981).Advance in experimental social psychology.NY:Academic Press.
print cancel