大學生辯証性思考與成熟人際關係發展整體關聯之研究：必要非充要

Dialectical Thinking and the Development of Mature Interpersonal Relationships among College Students

10.29882/JTNUE.200410.0007

邱文彬(Wen-Bin Chiou)

自主性 ； 自我揭露 ； 同理心 ； 形式性思考 ； 容忍性 ； 辯証性思考 ； dialectical thinking ； formal thinking ； empathy ； self-disclosure ； tolerance ； autonomy ； interpersonal relationships

師大學報：教育類

49卷2期（2004 / 10 / 01）

133 - 160

繁體中文

本研究目的在探討大學生辯証性思考與成熟人際關係之容忍性、同理心、自我揭露、自主性發展的整體性關係，受試者為432位年級與性別分佈平均的技職校院大學生，以問卷蒐集資料並進行相關性研究，資料分析採用迴歸分析，典型相關分析，以及多元區別分析。結果發現辯証性思考與四個成熟人際關係變項（容忍性、同理心、自我揭露、自主性）呈正相關，對於這四個變項具有顯著的正向預測力，並且都高於形式性思考的預測力。區別分析指出成熟人際關係四個變項的線性組合可以區辨認知思考的發展水平，典型相關分析的結果支持認知思考與成熟人際關係發展存有整體關聯性。綜合二者發現，指出辯証性思考應是成熟人際關係的必要非充要條件。本研究討論上述發現的意義，並提出大學生辯証性思考對大學生處理人際關係的啟示與未來研究建議。

The purpose of this study was to explore the holistic relationship between dialectical thinking and the development of mature interpersonal relationships. The subjects were 432 college students from the technological and vocational school system, representing both genders and a variety of grade levels. A questionnaire was used to collect data collection for a correlational study. Results showed that students' dialectical thinking had a significantly higher correlation than formal thinking with four dimensions of mature interpersonal relationships: tolerance, empathy, self-disclosure, and autonomy. Multiple Discriminant Analysis showed that the linear combination of these four dimensions was an effective means of distinguishing between the operations of formal and dialectical thinking. The results of Canonical Correlation Analysis indicated that the relationship between cognitive thinking and mature interpersonal relationships was congruent with the holistic approach. Combining both findings, those of Multiple Discriminant Analysis and Canonical Correlation Analysis, indicated that dialectical thinking is a necessary rather than sufficient condition for the development of mature interpersonal relationships. Possible reasons for these findings are discussed in the paper, along with their implications for the development of interpersonal relationships among college students, and suggestions for future research.

1. 邱文彬、林美珍(2000)。後形式思考與人際關係之容忍性、同理心、自我揭露、自主性之關係。教育心理學報，32(1)
   連結：
2. 蘇家瑩(2003)。以Chickering、Josselson 的心理社會發展理論看大學女生社團領導經驗與心理會發展理論看大學女生社團領導經驗與心理。公民訓育學報，13
   連結：
3. Adler, A.(1958).What life should mean to you.
4. Anastasi, A.,Urbina, S.(1996).Psychological testing（7th ed..
5. Arlin, P. K.(1989).Problem solving and problem finding in young artists and young scientists.Adult development: Comparison and applications of developmental models,1
6. Basseches, M.(1984).Dialectical thinking and adult development..
7. Basseches, M.(1989).Dialectical thinking as an organized whole: Comments on Irwin and Kramer.Adult development: Comparisons and applications of developmental models,1
8. Beck, A. T.(1976).The evolution of psychotherapy.
9. Benack, S(1984).Beyond formal operations: Late adolescent and adult cognitive development.
10. Bennett, M. J.(1986).A development approach to training intercultural sensitivity..International Journal of Intercultural Relations,10
11. Blanchard-Fields, F.(1989).Postformal reasoning in a socioemotional context.Adult development: Comparisons and applications of developmental models,1
12. Blanchard-Fields, F.(1986).Reasoning on social dilemmas varying in emotional saliency: An adult developmental perspective.Psychology and Aging,1
13. Brainerd, C. J.(1978).Piaget's theory of intelligence..
14. Burleson, B. R.,Samter, W.(1990).Effects of cognitive complexity on the perceived importance of communication skills in friends..Communication Research,17(2)
15. Campbell, D. T.,Stanley, J. C.(1966).Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for research.
16. Chickering, A. W.(1969).Education and Identity.
17. Chickering, A. W.,Reisser, L.(1993).Education and Identity（2nd ed.）.
18. Coupland, J.,Coupland, H.,Giles, H.,Wieman, J.(1988).My life in your hands: Processes of self-disclosure in intergenerational talk.
19. Darden, W. R.,Perreault, W. D.(1975).A multivariate analysis of media exposure and vacation behavior with life style covariates..Journal of Consumer Research,2
20. Derlega, V. J.,Metts, S.,Petronio, S.,Margulis, S. T.(1993).Self-disclosure.
21. Ellis, A.(1979).Theoretical and empirical foundations of rational-emotive therapy.
22. Garthoeffner, J. L.,Henry, C. S.,Robinson, L. C.(1993).The modified interpersonal relationship scale: Reliability and validity..Psychological Reports,73
23. Hair, J. F.,Anderson, R. E.,Tatham, R. L.,Black, W. C.(1998).Multivariate data analysis (5th ed.).
24. Holtgraves, T(1990).Handbook of language and social psychology.
25. Kegan, R.(1982).The evolving self: Problem and process in human development.
26. Kegan, R.(1979).The evolving self: A process conception for ego psychology.Counseling Psychology,8
27. King, P. M.,Kitchener, K. S.,Davison, M. L.,Parker, C. A.,Wood, P. K.(1983).The justification of beliefs in young adults: A longitudinal study.Human Development,26
28. Kohlberg, L.(1976).Moral Development and Behavior.
29. Koplowitz, H.(1984).Beyond formal operations: Late adolescence and adult cognitive development.
30. Kramer, D. A(1983).Post-formal operations? A need for further conceptualization.Human Development,26
31. Kramer, D. A.,Kahlbaugh, P. E.,Goldston, R. B.(1992).A measure of paradigm beliefs about the social world.Journal of Gerontology: Psychological science,47
32. Kramer, D. A,Woodruff, D. S(1986).Relativistic and dialectical thought in three adult age-groups..Human Development,29
33. Kuder, G. F.,Richardson, M. W(1937).The theory of the estimation of test reliability..Psychometrika,2
34. Kuhn, D.,Pennington, N.,Leadbeater, B.(1982).Life-span development and behavior.
35. Labouvie-Vief, G.(1980).Beyond formal operations: Uses and limits of pure logic in life-span development.Human Development,,23
36. Labouvie-Vief, G.(1982).Dynamic development and mature autonomy.A theoretical prologue,25
37. Larson, D. G.,Chastain, R. L.(1990).Self-concealment: Conceptualization, measurement, and health implication..Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology,9
38. Loevinger, J.(1976).Ego development: Conceptions and theories.
39. Mayer, R. E.(1981).The promise of cognitive psychology.
40. Mebarbian, A.,Epstein, N.(1972).A measure of emotional empathy.Journal of Personality,40
41. Miller, P. H.(1989).Theories of developmental psychology （2nd ed.）.
42. Pascarella, E. T.,Terenzini, P. T.(1991).How college affects students: Findings and insights from twenty years of research.
43. Pascual-Leone, J(1983).Growing into human maturity: Toward a metasubjective theory of adult stages.Life-span development and behavior,5
44. Perry, W. G.(1970).Forms of intellectual and ethical development in the college years: A scheme..
45. Piaget, J.(1950).The psychology of intelligence..
46. Plank, R. E.,Minton, A. P.,Reid, D. A(1996).A short measure of perceived empathy..Psychological Reports,79
47. Plikington, C. J.,Richardson, D. R.(1988).Perceptions of risk in intimacy.Journal of Social and Personal Relationships,5
48. Powell, P. M.(1984).Beyond formal operations: Late adolescent and adult cognitive development.
49. Riegel, K. F.(1973).Dialectic operations: The final period of cognitive development.Human Development,16
50. Rybash, J. M.,Roodin, P. A.(1989).Making decisions about health-care problems: A comparison of formal and postformal modes of competence.Adult development: Comparisons and applications of developmental models,1
51. Schaie, K. W.(1984).Life-span developmental psychology: Historical and generational effects.
52. Schuster, C. S.,Ashburn, S. S.(1988).The process of human development.
53. Sebby, R. A.,Papini, D. R.(1991).Bridging paradigms: Positive development in adulthood and cognitive aging.
54. Sebby, R. A.,Papini, D. R.(1994).Postforma reasoning during adolescence and young adulthood: The influence of problem relevancy..Adolescence,29
55. Selman, R. L.,Byrne, D. F. A.(1974).A structural-developmental analysis of levels of role-taking in middle childhood.Child Development,45
56. Sheehan, O. T.,Perason, F.(1995).Asian international and American students' psychosocial development.Journal of College Student Development,36
57. Siegel, S.,Castellan, N. J.(1988).Nonparametric statistics for the behavioral sciences（2nd ed.）.
58. Sinnott, J. D.(1984).Beyond formal operations: Late adolescent and adult cognitive development.
59. White, R. W.(1981).The modern American college: Responding to the new realities of diverse students and a changing society.
60. Winston, R. B. Jr.,Miller, T. K.,Prince, J. S.(1987).Student Development Task and Lifestyle Inventory.
61. 邱文彬、林美珍(1999)。大學生邁向成熟人際關係中親密性的發展：自我揭露與自主性發展之性別與年級差異的探討。教育心理學報，31(1)
62. 邱文彬、林美珍(1999)。大學生邁向成熟的同儕人際關係：容忍性、同理心發展之性別與年級差異的探討。教育與心理研究，22(1)
63. 張郁文(1986)。碩士論文。
64. 黃玉(2000)。大學學生事務的理論基礎：臺灣大學生心理社會發展之研究。公民訓育學報，9
65. 葛樹人(1991)。心理測驗學。
66. 詹志禹(1986)。碩士論文。
67. 賴保禎(1980)。基氏人格測驗。

1. 蔡美香,孫頌賢,施香如(2019)。家庭關係中親密與自主的平衡。中華輔導與諮商學報，56，1-15。
2. 許育齡(2023)。大學生辨識生涯逆境發展涵納社會情懷的自主學習路徑。課程與教學，26(3)，73-90。