寫字困難學生寫字特徵之分析

Writing Characteristics of Taiwanese Students with Handwriting Difficulties

10.29882/JTNUE.200410.0003

李瑩玓(Ying-Ti Li)

國小學生 ； 寫字困難 ； 錯誤類型 ； elementary school students ； error types ； handwriting difficulties

師大學報：教育類

49卷2期（2004 / 10 / 01）

43 - 64

繁體中文

本研究旨在探討國小聽寫表現有顯著困難，認字能力無明顯困難之寫字困難學童各寫字能力表現、錯誤類型犯錯情形與普通學生之差異。研究對象為三年級寫字困難學生及普通配對學生，測驗工具包括近端抄寫熟悉字、近端抄寫罕見字、遠端抄寫熟悉字、遠端抄寫罕見字、抄短文、自發性書寫測驗。研究結果發現如下：（1）寫字速度方面，由快而慢依序為抄短文、抄寫熟悉字、抄寫罕見字、自發寫，唯一不同點為寫字困難組熟悉字的近端抄寫顯著較遠端快，普通組則無差異。（2）普通組學生各項寫字表現的相關較寫字困難組顯著。（3）寫字困難的特徵包括：所寫字體忽大忽小、在遠端抄寫及抄短文時間架結構問題較為明顯、抄寫時易犯部件錯誤結構正確的錯字、自發寫時易犯部件正確結構正確的錯字。

The purpose of this study was to compare the handwriting performance and error types of third-graders with and without handwriting difficulties (HWD). Twenty-three non-dyslexic third-graders with HWD and twenty-three grade-match (GM) normal students served as subjects. All the participants were measured for their handwriting performance in six tasks: near-copying familiar (Chinese) characters, far-copying familiar characters, near-copying unfamiliar characters, far-copying unfamiliar characters, copying a short essay, and free writing.The main findings of this research project are as follows:(1) Ranked in decreasing order of handwriting speed for both GM and HWD subjects were: copying a short essay, copying familiar characters, copying unfamiliar characters, and free writing. The main difference between the GM and HWD groups was that while the HWD group near-copied familiar characters faster than they far-copied familiar characters, there was no significant difference in the GM group.(2) Performances in the character copying, short essay copying and free writing tasks had a significant degree of correlation in the GM group, as did performances in the character copying and short essay copying in the HWD group.(3) The following characteristics were observed in the HWD group: more irregular character size; more correctly formed characters with inconsistent component size and spacing in far-copying and short essay copying; more incorrectly formed characters with nonexistent components but correct configurational structures in all copying tasks; more incorrectly formed characters with the existence components and correct configurational structures in the free writing task.

1. Berninger, V. W.,Mizokawa, D. T.,Bragg, R.(1991).Theory-based diagnosis and remediation of writing disabilities.Journal of School Psychology,29
2. Berninger, V. W.,Whitaker, D.(1993).Theory-based branching diagnosis of writing disabilities.School Psychology Review,22(4)
3. Cornhill, H.,Case-Smith, J.(1996).Factors that relate to good and poor handwriting.The American Journal of Occupational Therapy,50(9)
4. Graham, S.(1986).A review of handwriting scales and factors that contribute to variability in handwriting scores.Journal of School Psychology,24
5. Graham, S.(1982).Measurement of handwriting skills: A critical review..Diagnostique,8(1)
6. Hallahan, D. P.,Kauffman, J. M.,Lloyd, J. W.(1999).Instruction to learning disabilities.
7. Hamstra-Bletz, L.,Blote, A. W.(1999).A longitudinal study on dysgraphic handwriting in primary school.Journal of Learning Disabilities,26(10)
8. Hooper, S. R.,Montgomery, J.,Swartz, C.,Reed, M. S.,Sandler, A. D.,Levine, M. D.,Watson, T. E.,Wasileski, T.(1994).Frames of reference for assessment of learning disability: New views on measurement issues..
9. Towle, M.(1978).Assessment and remediation of handwriting deficits for children with learning disabilities.Journal of Learning Disabilities,11(6)
10. Tseng, M. H.,Murray, E. A.(1994).Differences in perceptual-motor measures in children with good and poor handwriting.The Occupational Therapy Journal of Research,14(1)
11. Weintraub, N.,Graham, S.(1998).Writing legibly and quickly: A study of children's ability to adjust their handwriting to meet common classroom demands.Learning Disabilities Research & Practice,13(3)
12. Yost, L. W.,Lesiak, J.(1980).The relationship between performance on the developmental test of visual perception and handwriting ability..Education,101
13. Ziviani, J.,Elkins, J.(1984).An evaluation of handwriting performance.Educational Review,36
14. 呂美娟(1999)。碩士論文。
15. 李白芬(1994)。碩士論文。
16. 孟令夫、林幸台(1998)。預防第二類型錯誤與推演效果值於量化研究中的重要性。中華民國特殊教育學會年刊
17. 孟瑛如、陳麗如(2000)。學習障礙學生在魏氏兒童智力量表上顯現之特質研究。特殊教育季刊，74
18. 林素貞(1998)。國科會專題研究計畫。
19. 林寶貴、錡寶香(2000)。國小學童書寫語言測驗指導手冊。
20. 洪儷瑜(1995)。學習障礙者教育。
21. 洪儷瑜、張郁雯、陳秀芬、陳慶順、李瑩玓(2003)。基本讀寫字綜合測驗。
22. 紀李美瑛(1990)。第二屆世界華語文教學研討會論文集─理論與分析（下冊）。
23. 崔永華(1997)。詞彙文字研究與對外漢語教學。
24. 教育部編(1983)。罕用字體表。
25. 許淑娟(1995)。台南市低年級學童錯別字之分析。國語文教育通訊，10
26. 郭為藩(1978)。我國學童閱讀缺陷問題的初步調查及其檢討。教育研究所集刊，20
27. 陳弘昌(1999)。國小語文科教學研究。
28. 陳秀芬(1998)。碩士論文。
29. 陳俊隆(1996)。碩士論文。
30. 陳慶順(2000)。碩士論文。
31. 黃沛榮(1996)。第七屆中國文字學全國學術研討會論文集。
32. 黃秀霜(2001)。中文年級認字量表：指導手冊。
33. 葉德明(1987)。漢字書寫錯誤之分析與教學。華文世界，43
34. 劉興漢(1987)。國小學生學習寫中文字錯誤之分析。教育與心理研究，10
35. 蔡金涼(1992)。國小易誤字之研究。國教月刊，39(3/4)
36. 戴汝潛(1999)。漢字教與學。
37. 蘇淑貞、宋維村、徐澄清(1984)。中文閱讀障礙之類型及智力測驗。中華心理學刊，26(1)

1. 簡睦容,陳振昇,林靖文,佘永吉(2021)。3D列印握筆器個別化設計發展對一位大專院校脊髓性肌肉萎縮症學生書寫功能表現之研究。特殊教育季刊，161，13-32。
2. 李怡靜(2013)。淺談資源班書寫障礙學生教學與個案實例分享。國小特殊教育，55，55-64。
3. 張麗蓮(2017)。臺灣寫字研究文獻探究。教育理論與實踐學刊，36，127-148。
4. (2008)。寫字教學法對國小二年級寫字困難學生學習成效之研究。東臺灣特殊教育學報，10，21-45。
5. (2014)。那些年我們一起努力學習讀書寫字：我與兩位學習障礙學生的讀寫學習歷程。東臺灣特殊教育學報，16，95-119。
6. (2015)。臺東縣國中原住民學習障礙學生讀寫表現調查研究。東臺灣特殊教育學報，17，57-84。
7. (2023)。強制回憶寫字教學法對國小三年級寫字困難學生之介入成效。特殊教育研究學刊，48(3)，67-97。