台北市國民小學九年一貫課程成績通知單之學習目標分析研究

A Study of the Learning Objectives for the Report Cards of the Taipei's Municipal Elementary Schools

10.29882/JTNUE.200604.0004

盧雪梅(Sheue-Mei Lu)

九年一貫課程 ； 成績通知單 ； 學習目標 ； Grade 1-9 Curriculum ； report card ； learning objective formulation (format)

師大學報：教育類

51卷1期（2006 / 04 / 01）

63 - 84

繁體中文

本研究旨在探究台北市國民小學因應九年一貫課程，在學生學期成績通知單內涵上所作的變革。本研究共收集台北市122所國民小學九十二學年度第一學期的成績通知單，分析其各學習領域或次領域之學習目標的項數和內涵。分析結果發現在學期成績通知單的學習目標建構上，部份學校缺乏系統化的規劃和一致性的規範，不論在目標項數或目標內涵敘寫上，均出現相當程度的歧異性。就單項目標敘寫內涵言，本研究共歸納出13種較常出現或特徵明顯的方式，其中多數是不符合學習目標敘寫體例；就學習領域目標的組成言，本研究歸納出3種常見和顯明的缺失。雖然台北市國小現行的學期成績通知單在形式上頗符合當前學生成績報告的發展趨勢，不過就實務現況來看，一些潛在的優點和功能並沒有發揮出來。最後，研究者根據研究發現提出建議，供作改進九年一貫課程學生成績評量紀錄或研擬相關配套措施參考。

The purpose of this study was to explore the design and function of Taipei City's elementary school repot cards, after the implementation of the Grade 1-9 Curriculum, in particular with regard to their designated learning objectives. The researcher collected report cards for the first semester of the 2003 school year from 122 schools, and analyzed the member of learning objectives and their formulation (content) for each Learning Domain or Sub-domain. The results indicated that some schools did not have a systematic and comprehensive plan for constructing report card learning objectives across grades, and did not have common rules for teachers to follow in writing the learning objectives. The number and formulation (content) of learning objectives showed a certain degree of variability across Learning Domains and across grades. With regard to the formulation of objectives, the researcher's analysis yielded 13 types of written format, and the researcher found that most of these were not correct or appropriate. In terms of the whole set of objectives for a specific Learning Domain, the researcher summarized three major problems. Although the form of the new report cards developed by Taipei's municipal elementary schools reflects the current trend in reporting on student learning, the actual reporting method of schools to full far short of fully actualizing the potential degree of efficacy. Finally, recommendations based on the findings of this project were offered, in order to improve the practice of reporting on student learning by suggesting new policies and strategies for grading and reporting on student learning under the Grade 1-9 Curriculum reform.

1. Laguna Salada Union School District[LSUSD](nd.)
2. Anderson, L. W.,Krathwohl D. R., Airasian, P. W.,Cruikshank, K. A.,Mayer, R. E.,Pintrich, P. R.(2001).A taxonomy for learning, teaching, and assessing: A revision of Bloom`s taxonomy of educational objectives
3. Bailey, J.,McTighe, J.,T.R. Guskey(1996).Reporting achievement at the secondary level: what and how.Communicating student learning 1996 Yearbood of the Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development
4. Carr, J.,Farr, B.,E. Trumbull,B. Farr(2000).Taking steps toward standards-based report cards.Grading and reporting student progress in an age of standards,185-208.
5. Farr, B.,E. Trumbull,B. Farr(2000).Grading practices: an overview of the issues.Grading and reporting student progress in an age of standards,1-21.
6. Gronlund, N. E.(1996).How to Write and use instructional objectives(4th ed.)
7. Guskey, T. R.,Bailey, J. M.(2001).Developing grading and reporting systems for student learning
8. Guskey, T. R.,T. R. Guskey(1996).Reporting on student learning: Lessons from the past-prescriptions for the future.Communicating student learning. 1996 Yearbook of the Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development
9. Marzano, R. J.(2000).Transforming classroom grading
10. Marzano, R. J.,Kendall, J. S.(1996).A comprehensive guide to designing standards-based districts, school, and classroom
11. Nikto, A. J.(2001).Educational assessment of students(3rd ed)
12. O`Connor, K.(2002).How to grade for learning: Linking grades to standards(2nd ed.)
13. Payne, D. A.(2003).Applied Educational Assessment(2nd ed.)
14. 教育部(1997)。國民中學學生成績考查法
15. 教育部(2004)。國民小學及國民中學學生成績評量准則
16. 教育部(2001)。國民中小學學生成績評量准則
17. 教育部(2000)。國民中小學九年一貫課程暫行綱要
18. 郭生玉(2004)。教育測驗與評量
19. 盧雪梅(2005)。九年一貫課程成績通知單模式探究：現況與展望。教育研究與發展期刊，1(3)，177-212。
20. 盧雪梅(2004)。從技術面談九年一貫課程能力指標建構：美國學習標准建構的啓示。教育研究資訊雙月刊，12(2)，3-34。
21. 盧雪梅(2005)。台北市國民小學九年一貫課程學生學期成績評定和報告實況調查研究。初等教育學刊，21，70-98。
22. 盧雪梅(2003)。學生成績評定和報告的新趨勢。國教新知，49(3)，28-39。