國中小品德校園文化營造實徵研究

An Empirical Study of Character-Based School Culture Building in Taiwan's Elementary and Junior High Schools

10.29882/JTNUE.200812.0007

李琪明(Angela Chi-Ming Lee)

品德教育 ； 校園文化 ； 道德社群 ； character education ； school culture ； moral community

師大學報：教育類

53卷3期（2008 / 12 / 01）

153 - 178

繁體中文

本研究試圖擬定一個兼顧本土與國際性的道德社群方案，以建構具科學且專業的品德校園推動參考模式。茲選取國中小各一所為合作夥伴，歷經兩年研究歷程，採用質量兼顧的多種研究方法加以規劃、執行與評鑑，包括專家諮詢座談，工作坊與會議的舉辦，以及準實驗研究的訪談、觀察與問卷調查等。經分析與討論歸納數點結論：一是品德校園彰顯了品德教育融入各類課程具可行性；二是品德校園實施後行政人員與教師的品德教育知能有所增長；三是家長與學生參與品德校園推動後之角色被強化與肯定；四是系統且密集的品德校園推動可證明其有效性。據此，本研究針對歷程與結果分享四點反思，並提供研究社群及教育行政機關數點建議，以促進品德校園的永續發展。

Based on Taiwan's educational reforms over the past fifteen years and the trends of international research and practice, this study focused on how to plan, implement and evaluate a character-based school culture (CBSC) project to meet the needs of Taiwan's moral education. The CBSC was a scientific and professional project, one inspired by several theoretical models of ”school culture” and ”moral atmosphere.” The CBSC adapted comprehensive American models of character education programs to fit Taiwan's educational system. The author conducted this research project from August 2005 to July 2007 in one elementary school and one junior high school. The methodology, both qualitative and quantitative, was drawn from symposia workshops, meetings, interviews, surveys, and observations, and made use of a quasi-experimental design. The findings were as follows: (1) The CBSC project showed that it is feasible to infuse character education into diversified curricula. (2) The staff members of the schools involved enhanced their own professional knowledge of character education as a result the CBSC project. (3) The CBSC project promoted students' autonomy and enhanced their parents' ability to collaborate in school character education. (4)The CBSC project, featuring systematic and intensive character education, manifested its effectiveness especially at the junior high school level. Furthermore, the author made several observations regarding the process and products of planning, implementing and evaluating the CBSC project. Finally, the author made recommendations with regard to the sustainable development of character-based school culture in Taiwan's academia and government.

1. 李琪明(2004)。我國國中小校園道德氣氛之調查研究。師大學報－教育類，49(1)，1-20。
   連結：
2. Berkowitz, W.,Bier, M.(2004).Research-based character education.The Annals of the American Academy,591,72-85.
3. Berkowitz, W.,Bier, M.(2004).What works in character education: A research-driven guide for educators.Washington, DC:Character Education Partnership.
4. Brown, R. D.,H. J. Canon,R. D. Brown (Eds.)(1985).Applied ethics in student services.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
5. Brugman, D.(1998).Paper presented at the meeting of University of Konstanz, Germany.Konstanz:Moral and Social action Interdisciplinary Colloquium (MOSAIC).
6. Durkheim, E.(1973).Moral education-A study in the theory and application of the sociology of education (E. K. Wilson Trans.).New York:Free Press.
7. Gilligan, C.(1993).In a different voice: Psychological theory and women`s development.Massachusetts:Harvard University Press.
8. Gilligan, C.(1982).In a different voice: Psychological theory and wome`s development.Massachusetts:Harvard University Press.
9. Higgins, A.,W. M. Kurtines,J. L. Gewirtz (Eds.)(1995).Moral development: An introduction.Massachusetts:Allen&Bacon.
10. Hinman, L. M.(1994).Ethics: A pluralistic approach to moral education.Florida:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
11. Host, K.,Brugman, D.,Tavecchio, L.W.C.,Beem, A. L.(1998).Students` perception of the moral atmosphere in secondary schools and the relationship between moral competence and moral atmosphere.Journal of Moral Education,27(1),47-71.
12. Kohlberg, L.(1981).The philosophy of moral development: Moral stages and the idea of justice.San Francisco:Harper.
13. Kohlberg, L.(1984).The psychology of moral development: The nature and validity of moral stages.San Francisco:Harper.
14. Kohlberg, L.,H. Giroux,D. Purpel (Eds.)(1983).The hidden curriculum and moral education.Cafornia:McCutchan.
15. Kohlberg, L.,S. Modgil,C. Modgil (Eds.)(1986).Lawrence Kohlberg: Consensus and controversy.Philadelphia:Falmer.
16. Lee, C. M.(2005).Teachers` moral development and their perceptions of school environment: preservice and in-service teachers in Taiwan`s elementary and junior high schools.Cambridge:Paper presented at The 31st Annual Meeting of the AME.
17. Lickona, T.(1991).Educating for character-How our schools can teach respect and responsibility.New York:A Bantam Book.
18. School as a caring community profile Ⅱ (SCCP Ⅱ)
19. Lukes, S.(1973).Emile Durkheim-his life and work: A historical and critical study.New York:Penguin.
20. Maul, J. P.(1980).A high school with intensive education: Moral atmosphere and moral reasoning.Journal of Moral Education,10,9-17.
21. Noddings, N.(1984).Caring, a feminine approach to ethics & moral education.Berkeley:University of California Press.
22. Noddings, N.(2002).Educating moral people-A caring alternative to character education.New York:Teachers College, Columbia University.
23. Power, C.(1988).The just community approach to moral education.Journal of Moral Education,17(3),195-208.
24. Power, C.(1981).Moral education through the development of the moral atmosphere of the school.Journal of Educational Thought,15(1),4-19.
25. Power, C.,Higgins, A.,Kohlberg, L.,C. Power, A. Higgins,L. Kohlberg (Eds.)(1989).Lawrence Kohlberg`s approach to moral education.New York:Columbia University.
26. Power, C.,Higgins-D`Alessandro, A.,L. Nuccy,D. Narvaez (Eds.)(2008).Handbook of moral and character education.New York:Routledge.
27. Power, C.,Makogon, T.(1995).The just community approach to care.Journal for a Just and Caring Education,2,9-24.
28. Reimer, J.,C. Power, A. Higgins,L. Kohlberg (Eds.)(1989).Lawrence Kohlberg`s approach to moral education.New York:Columbia University Press.
29. Saha, L. J.(2001).Durkheim`s sociology of education: A critical reassessment.Education and Society,19(2),21-23.
30. Thomas, B. R.,J. I. Goodlad (Eds.)(1990).The moral dimensions of teaching.California:Jossey-Bass.
31. Watson, M.,L. Nucci,D. Narvaez (Eds.)(2008).Handbook of moral and character education.New York:Routledge.
32. 中華民國課程與教學學會主編(2006)。專題－品格與道德教育。課程與教學季刊，9(2)，1-74。
33. 天下雜誌社主編(2007)。天下雜誌。2007親子天下專刊。
34. 天下雜誌社主編(2003)。品格決勝負－未來人才的秘密。天下雜誌，287，1-284。
35. 方志華(2000)。台北市，國立台灣師範大學教育研究所。
36. 台灣省教育會主編(2004)。專題－品德教育。台灣教育，625，1-84。
37. 但昭偉(2004)。最低限度的道德要求。教育資料與研究，61，2-6。
38. 李奉儒(2004)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告。嘉義:國立中正大學教育學研究所。
39. 李奉儒(2004)。九年一貫課程中實施道德教育的困境與突破。學生輔導季刊，92，38-55。
40. 李奉儒(2005)。尊重與關懷作為學校品格教育的核心。國教天地，1，20-29。
41. 李琪明(2003)。德行取向之品德教育理論與實踐。哲學與文化，30(8)，153-174。
42. 李琪明(2006)。新品德教育的興起與發展－美國經驗在台灣的反思與轉化。課程與教學季刊，9(2)，55-74。
43. 李琪明(2008)。論文發表於香港中文大學舉辦之「價值的追尋－變遷社會中價值教育的實踐」國際學術會議。香港:
44. 李琪明(2006)。將品德帶進教室，把民主融入校園。教師天地，142，22-30。
45. 李琪明、課程與教學學會主編(2005)。社會價值重建理念與實踐。高雄:復文。
46. 國家教育研究院籌備處主編(2007)。專題－品德教育。教育研究月刊，159，1-59。
47. 教育部訓委會主編(2004)。專題－品德教育。學生輔導，92，1-178。
48. 黃光雄、李奉儒(2001)。教育部委託專案報告。嘉義:國立中正大學教育學研究所。
49. 簡成熙(2004)。「缺德」的道德教育如何實施。教育研究月刊，121，94-109。
50. 蘇建文譯、L. Kuhmerker、U. Gielen、R. L. Hayes著、俞筱鈞譯(1993)。道德發展－柯爾堡的薪傳。台北:洪業。
51. 蘇建文譯、L. Kuhmerker、U. Gielen、R. L. Hayes著、俞筱鈞譯(1993)。道德發展－柯爾堡的薪傳。台北:洪業。

1. 陳延興(2017)。臺灣與英國中學教師實施品德與公民教育之研究。課程與教學，20(3)，27-58。
2. 高新建,侯一欣(2019)。縣市層級課程推廣之個案研究：以新北市品德教育聯絡簿為例。教育學誌，42，55-109。
3. 高新建,侯一欣,阮孝齊(2019)。品德教育教學轉化與實踐影響因素之研究：以新北市品德教育聯絡簿為例。學生事務與輔導，58(1)，11-29。
4. 李珮瑜(2014)。由 Nel Noddings關懷倫理學論教師圖像。學校行政，89，67-84。
5. 李琪明(2013)。校長道德發展及其品德校園營造之質性探究。教育科學研究期刊，58(1)，117-147。
6. 廖永堃、陳榮華、陳心怡、朱建軍(2011)。臺灣兒童於1997至2007年智能進步狀況分析：弗林效應之探討。教育科學研究期刊，56(1)，167-191。
7. 劉慈惠(2014)。幼兒品格的問題與需求－家長觀點及學校情境中的探究。教育資料與研究，113，27-74。
8. 楊淑雅、李崗(2015)。G. Ezzo 父母德育課程之研究：以「孩子的良知」為例。課程與教學，18(1)，93-122。
9. (2008)。學校本位倫理核心價值的建構與實踐。教育學報，36(1/2)，77-95。
10. (2010)。美國統整式倫理教育之探討。比較教育，68，53-88。
11. (2012)。動畫電影應用於國小二年級品格教育之行動研究。朝陽人文社會學刊，10(1)，141-174。