大學生自陳閱譜困難與發展性閱譜障礙之研究

Self-Reported Music-Reading Difficulties and Developmental Musical Dyslexia among University Students

10.29882/JTNUE.200812.0002

李宏鎰(Horng-Yih Lee)

音樂教育 ； 盛行率 ； 發展性閱譜障礙 ； 學習障礙 ； music education ； prevalence ； developmental music dyslexia ； learning disability

師大學報：教育類

53卷3期（2008 / 12 / 01）

29 - 46

繁體中文

本研究探討大一學生之閱譜困難情形，首先探討自陳閱譜困難的大學生之實際閱譜能力，再篩選出發展性閱譜障礙者，並進一步探討自陳閱譜困難與發展性閱譜障礙間的關係。504位學生填寫音樂學習經驗問卷及閱譜能力量表。結果39%的學生聲稱自已有閱譜困難，且他們的閱譜能力顯著低於自陳無閱譜困難者。再者，為控制課外音樂教育時間及性別比例等變項的影響，依這些變項，配對出101位自陳閱譜困難者及自陳無閱譜困難者進行比較，結果仍然發現自陳閱譜困難者的閱譜能力較差。最後，從學生中篩選出發展性閱譜障礙者，盛行率為9%，且只有18%的自陳閱譜困難者達閱譜障礙標準。可見，大部分的自陳閱譜困難者並不是閱譜障礙者，然閱譜障礙者絕大部分屬自陳閱譜困難者。

This study was concerned with self-reported music-reading difficulties and their possible relationship to developmental musical dyslexia. The study contained two parts. In part 1, participants completed a screening questionnaire including questions addressing demographic background, self-assessment of music-reading difficulties, years of music education, and musical interests. In part 2, participants completed the three tests of the Music-Reading Ability Assessment (MRAA) developed by Lee and his collaborators. Nearly 39% of 504 first-year university students reported their own music-reading difficulties. They were troubled by staff-reading and not interested in musical lessons. Results for each of the MRAA tests and composite scores for all tests showed clear a tendency for participants with self-reported music-reading difficulties to obtain lower scores than participants who reported that they did not have such difficulties. Neither the amount of music education nor gender affected the above results. Finally, only 9% of all participants actually met the criteria for music dyslexia. This prevalence was in agreement with that predicted by other studies. On the other hand, it means that the majority of those who reported ‘music-reading difficulties' did not meet the criteria for music dyslexics; that is, self-reported music-reading difficulties alone were not a strong indicator of music dyslexia. Thus an encouraging conclusion of this research project is that many individuals who consider themselves to have ”music-reading difficulties” may be not, in fact, be ”music dyslexics,” and these individuals should be supported in any of their efforts to proceed with a music education.

1. 李宏鎰(2005)。發展性閱譜障礙－個案報告。臨床心理學刊，2(2)，106-112。
   連結：
2. 李宏鎰、黃凱祺、顏瑞萱、李妍緹、莊婷(2006)。閱譜困難者之閱譜特徵。中華心理衛生學刊，19(1)，41-60。
   連結：
3. American Psychiatric Association(1994).Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders.Washington, DC:Author.
4. Ayotte, J.,Peretz, I.,Hyde, K.(2002).Congenital amusia: A group study of adults afflicted with a musicspecific disorder.Brain,125,238-251.
5. Banich, M. T.(1997).Neuropsychology: The neural basis of mental function.Boston, MA:Houghton Mifflin Company.
6. Brust, J.(1980).Music and language, musical alexia and agraphia.Brain,103,367-392.
7. Cappelletti, M.,Waley-Cohen, H.,Butterworth, B.,Kopelman, M.(2000).A selective loss of the ability to read and write music.Neurocase,6,321-332.
8. Di Pietro, M.,Laganaro, M.,Leemann, B.,Schnider, A.(2004).Receptive amusia: Temportal auditory processing deficit in a professional musician following a left temporo-parietal lesion.Neuropsychologia,42,868-877.
9. Gordon, N.(2000).Developmental dysmusia (developmental musical dyslexia).Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology,42,214-215.
10. Hébert, S.,Cuddy, L. L.(2006).Music-reading deficiencies and the brain.Advances in Cognitive Psychology,2,199-206.
11. Henson, R. A.,M. Critchley,. A. Henson (Eds.)(1997).Music and the brain.London:Heinemann.
12. Horikoshi, T.,Asari, Y.,Watanabe, A.,Nagaseki, Y.,Nukui, H.,Sasaki, H.,Komiya, K.(1997).Music alexia in a patient with mild pure alexia: Disturbed meaningful perception of nonverbal figures.Cortex,33,187-194.
13. Kalmus, H.,Fry, D. B.(1980).On tune deafness (dysmelodia): Frequency, development, genetics and musical background.Annals of Human Genetics,43,369-382.
14. Schön, D.,Semenza, C.,Denes, G.(2001).Naming of musical notes: A selective deficit in one musical clef.Cortex,37,407-421.
15. Sergent, J.,Zuck, E.,Terriah, S.,McDonald, B.(1992).Distributed neural network underlying musical sightreading and keyboard performance.Science,257,106-109.
16. Shaywitz, S. E.,Shaywitz, B. A.,Fletcher, J. M.,Escobar, M. D.(1990).Prevalence of reading disability in boys and girls: Results of the Connecticut longitudinal study.The Journal of the American Medical Association,264,998-1002.
17. Signoret, J. L.,Eeckhout, P.,Poncet, M.,Castaigne, P.(1987).Aphasia without amusia in a blind organist. Verbal alexia-agraphia without musical alexia-agraphia in braille.Revue Neurologique (Paris),143(3),172-181.
18. Stevenson, H. W.,Stigler, J. W.,Lucker, G. W.,Lee, S. Y.,Hsu, C. C.,Kitamura, S.,R. Glaser (Ed.)(1987).Advances in instructional psychology.Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum.
19. Stewart, L. M.,Walsh, V.(2001).Neuropsychology: Music of the hemispheres.Current Biology,11,125-127.
20. Tzortzis, C.,Goldblum, M. C.,Dang, M.,Forette, F.,Boller, F.(2000).Absence of amusia and preserved naming of musical instruments in an aphasic composer.Cortex,36,227-242.
21. Wright, B. A.,Lombardino, L. J.,King, W. M.,Puranik, C. S.,Leonard, C. M.,Merzenich, M. M.(1995).Deficits in auditory temporal and spectral resolution in language-impaired children.Nature,387,176-178.
22. 張錦鴻(1993)。新版基礎樂理。台北:大陸書店。