题名

環境、社會與治理（ESG）資訊揭露之規範－以重大性之判斷為核心

并列篇名

The Regulation of ESG Disclosure: Focus on Standard of Materiality

作者

黃朝琮(Chao-Tsung Huang)

关键词

ESG ； 永續發展 ； 公司社會責任 ； 重大性 ； 合理投資人 ； ESG ； Sustainable Development ； Corporate Social Responsibility ； Materiality ； Reasonable Investor

期刊名称

臺北大學法學論叢

卷期/出版年月

122期（2022 / 06 / 01）

页次

1 - 111

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

以ESG資訊之重大性標準為中心，本文藉由對於ESG概念與其他類似概念間之關係的探討，釐清我國方興未艾之ESG資訊揭露規範制定活動的性質，以及對該等性質未有正確認識下所生之混淆，而在此基礎上，探討目前規範關於重大性標準所生之疑義，並反思我國既有重大性標準。我國既有關規範已存有不同重大性標準，復於制定ESG資訊揭露規範時參考不同規範框架，而有不同重大性標準並存之現象。本文認為，如能先由既有之重大性標準著手，確立採用合理投資人標準，而在此主軸下制定相關ESG資訊揭露規範，不僅得以和我國規範現狀接軌，如能以此進一步反思並調整現有重大性標準，將可建立統一且彈性之標準，而在簡化既有規範之餘，有效因應ESG風潮而促使公司提出投資人所需之資訊。
英文摘要

Surrounding the materiality standard of ESG information, this article explores the nature of Taiwan's ESG information disclosure regulation and further rethinks currently available materiality standard. Under Taiwan's current securities regulation, there are already different materiality standards applied in different contexts, which, combined with the situation that our securities authority refers to different disclosure framework for ESG information, leads to a complicated and inconsistent scenario when it comes to determining the materiality of a piece of ESG information. This article argues that this conundrum can be solved by simply going back to the core ＂reasonable investor＂ and construct such investor's perception as to what would affect his/her investment decision, based on which the regulator could forge the scope of the information that needs to be disclosed in the ESG trend.
主题分类 社會科學 > 法律學
参考文献
  1. 林志潔(2016)。我國財務資訊不實刑事責任之法律適用疑義與重大性要件。證券市場發展季刊，111
    連結：
  2. 林志潔(2016)。我國財務資訊不實刑事責任之法律適用疑義與重大性要件。證券市場發展季刊，111
    連結：
  3. 洪秀芬(2019)。保險業 ESG 之公司治理。保險專刊，35(4)
    連結：
  4. 莊永丞(2018)。財務預測與證券詐欺之交錯與平行時空。國立臺灣大學法學論叢，47(4)
    連結：
  5. 莊永丞(2008)。論證券價格操縱行為之規範理論基礎－從行為人散布流言或不實資料之操縱行為開展。東吳法律學報，20(1)
    連結：
  6. 陳俊元(2021)。綠色債券監理之研究：以國際準則之最新發展為中心。證券市場發展季刊，33(2)
    連結：
  7. 黃朝琮(2020)。後 Corwin 案時代之德拉瓦州受託義務審查。國立中正大學法學集刊，68
    連結：
  8. 黃朝琮(2021)。證券詐欺責任中之因果關係與損害－實務見解之觀察。中正財經法學，23
    連結：
  9. 黃朝琮,張兆恬(2019)。意見表達之證券責任。輔仁法學，58
    連結：
  10. 賴英照(2007)。論全球盟約與公司社會責任。法令月刊，58(2)
    連結：
  11. Agudelo, Mauricio Andres Latapi,Jóhannsdóttir, Lara,Davidstóttir, Brynhildur(2019).A Literature Review of the History and Evolution of Corporate Social Responsibility.J. CORP. SOC. RESP.,4,1-23.
  12. Ahern, Deirdre(2016).Turning Up the Heat? EU Sustainability Goals and the Role of Reporting Under the Non-financial Reporting Directive.EUR. COMPANY & FIN. L. REV.,13,599-630.
  13. Bagby, John W.,Murray, Paula C.,Andrews, Eric T.(1995).How Green Was My Balance Sheet?: Corporate Liability and Environmental Disclosure.VA. ENVTL. L. J.,14,225-342.
  14. Bainbridge, Stephen M.,Gulati, G. Mitu(2002).How Do Judges Maximize? (The Same Way Everybody Else Does-Boundedly): Rules of Thumb in Securities Fraud Opinions.EMORY L. J.,51,83-152.
  15. Barzuza, Michal,Curtis, Quinn,Webber, David H.(2020).Shareholder Value(s): Index Fund ESG Activism and the New Millennial Corporate Governance.S. CAL. L. REV.,93,1243-1322.
  16. Bebchuk, Lucian A.,Hirst, Scott(2019).Index Funds and the Future of Corporate Governance: Theory, Evidence, and Policy.COLUM. L. REV.,119,2029-2146.
  17. Bebchuk, Lucian A.,Hirst, Scott(2019).The Specter of the Giant Three.B.U. L. REV.,99,721-742.
  18. Bebchuk, Lucian A.,Tallarita, Roberto(2020).The Illusory Promise of Stakeholder Governance.CORNELL L. REV.,106,91-178.
  19. Black, Barbara(2013).Behavioral Economics and Investor Protection: Reasonable Investors, Efficient Markets.LOY. U. CHI. L. J.,44,1493-1508.
  20. BOWEN, HOWARD(1953).SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE BUSINESSMAN.
  21. Bratton, William W.,Wachter, Michael L.(2010).The Case against Shareholder Empowerment.U. PENN. L. REV.,158,653-728.
  22. Bratton, William W.,Wachter, Michael L.(2008).Shareholder Primacy’s Corporatist Origins: Adolf Berle and the Modern Corporation.J. CORP. L.,34,99-152.
  23. Brudney, Victor(1989).A Note on Materiality and Soft Information Under the Federal Securities Laws.VA. L. REV.,75,723-760.
  24. Carroll, Archie B.(1999).Corporate Social Responsibility: Evolution of a Definitional Construct.BUS & SOC.,38,268-295.
  25. Carroll, Archie B.(2015).Corporate Social Responsibility: the Centerpiece of Competing and Complementary Frameworks.ORG. DYNAMICS,44,87-96.
  26. Carroll, Archie B.(2008).A History of Corporate Social Responsibility: Concepts and Practices.THE OXFORD HANDBOOK OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
  27. Cary, William L.(1962).The Direction of Management Responsibility.BUS. LAW.,18,29-89.
  28. Chaffee, Eric C.(2017).The Origins of Corporate Social Responsibility.U. CIN. L. REV.,85,353-380.
  29. Christie, Anna(2021).The Agency Costs of Sustainable Capitalism.U.C. DAVIS L. REV.,55,875-954.
  30. Coffee, John C., Jr.(1984).Market Failure and the Economic Case for a Mandatory Disclosure System.VA. L. REV.,70,717-754.
  31. Coffee, John C., Jr.(2021).The Future of Disclosure: ESG, Common Ownership, and Systematic Risk.COL. BUS. L. REV.,2021,602-650.
  32. Couture, Wendy Gerwick(2015).Materiality and a Theory of Legal Circularity.U. PA.J. BUS. L.,17,453-526.
  33. Cox, James D.(2015)."We’re Cool" Statements after Omnicare: Securities Fraud Suits for Failures to Comply with the Law.SMU L. REV.,68,715-726.
  34. Dahlsrud, Alexander(2008).How Corporate Social Responsibility Is Defined: An Analysis of 37 Definitions.CORP. SOC. RESP. ENVTL. MGMT.,15,1-13.
  35. Davis, Keith(1960).Can Business Afford to Ignore Social Responsibilities.CAL. MGMT. REV.,2,70-76.
  36. Douglas, William O., Protecting the Investor, 23 YALE REV. 521, 521-533 (1934).
  37. Dunbar, Frederick C.,Heller, Dana(2006).Fraud on the Market Meets Behavioral Finance.DEL. J. CORP. L.,31,455-532.
  38. Esty, Daniel C.,Karpilow, Quentin(2019).Harnessing Investor Interest in Sustainability: The Next Frontier in Environmental Information Regulation.YALE J. ON REG.,36,625-692.
  39. Fan, Jennifer S.(2016).Regulating Unicorns: Disclosure and the New Private Economy.B.C. L. REV.,57,583-642.
  40. Fichtner, Jan,Heemskerk, Eelke M.,Garcia-Bernardo, Javier(2017).Hidden Power of the Big Three? Passive Index Funds, Re-concentration of Corporate Ownership, and New Financial Risk.BUS. & POL.,19,298-326.
  41. Fisch, Jill E.(2019).Making Sustainability Disclosure Sustainable.GEO. L. J.,107,923-966.
  42. Fisch, Jill E.,Hamdani, Assaf,Solomon, Steven Davidoff(2019).The New Titans of Wall Street: A Theoretical Framework for Passive Investors.U. PA. L. REV.,168,17-72.
  43. Fisher, William O.(2017).To Thine Own CEO Be True: Tailoring CEO Compensation to Individual Personality and Circumstances.COLUM. BUS. L. REV.,2017,599-696.
  44. Fornasari, Federico(2020).Knowledge and Power in Measuring the Sustainable Corporation: Stock Exchanges As Regulators of ESG Factors Disclosure.WASH. U. GLOBAL STUD. L. REV.,19,167-234.
  45. Fox, Merritt B.(1997).Securities Disclosure in a Globalizing Market: Who Should Regulate Whom.MICH. L. REV.,95,2498-2632.
  46. Gadinis, Stavros,Miazad, Amelia(2020).Corporate Law and Social Risk.VAND. L. REV.,73,1401-1478.
  47. Gary, Susan N.(2016).Values and Value: University Endowments, Fiduciary Duties, and ESG Investing.J.C. & U.L.,42,247-310.
  48. Gary, Susan N.(2019).Best Interests in the Long Term: Fiduciary Duties and ESG Integration.U. COLO. L. REV.,90,731-802.
  49. Georgiev, George S.(2017).Too Big to Disclose: Firm Size and Materiality Blindspots in Securities Regulation.UCLA L. REV.,64,602-683.
  50. Georgiev, George S.(2021).The Human Capital Management Movement in U.S. Corporate Law.TUL. L. REV.,95,639-740.
  51. Gilson, Ronald J.,Kraakman, Reinier H.(2003).The Mechanisms of Market Efficiency Twenty Years Later: The Hindsight Bias.J. CORP. L.,28,715-742.
  52. Glavas, Ante,Mish, Jenny(2015).Resources and Capabilities of Triple Bottom Line Firms: Going Over Old or Breaking New Ground?.J. BUS. ETHICS,127,623-642.
  53. GLOBAL REPORTING INITIATIVE(2016).GRI 101: FOUNDATION.
  54. Gordon, Jeffrey N.(ed.),Ringe, Wolf-Georg(ed.)(2018).THE OXFORD HANDBOOK OF CORPORATE LAW AND GOVERNANCE.
  55. Griffin, Cable N.(2020).Environmental & Social Voting at Index Funds.DEL. J. CORP. L.,44,167-222.
  56. Guttentag, Michael D.(2013).Protection from What: Investor Protection and the JOBS Act.U.C. DAVIS BUS. L. J.,13,207-258.
  57. Hansen, Rick E.(2012).Climate Change Disclosure by SEC Registrants: REvisiting the SEC’s 2010 Interpretive Release.BROOK. J. CORP. FIN. & COM. L.,6,487-552.
  58. Hazen, Thomas Lee(2021).Social Issues in the Spotlight: The Increasing Need to Improve Publicly-Held Companies’ CSR and ESG Disclosures.U. PA.J. BUS. L.,23,740-796.
  59. Heminway, Joan MacLeod(2003).Materiality Guidance in the Context of Insider Trading: A Call for Action.AM. U. L. REV.,52,1131-1212.
  60. Heminway, Joan MacLeod(2009).Female Investors and Securities Fraud: Is the Reasonable Investor a Woman?.WM. & MARY J. WOMEN & L.,15,291-336.
  61. Hill, Claire A.(2017).Repugnant Business Models: Preliminary Thoughts on a Research and Policy Agenda.WASH. & LEE L. REV.,74,973-1000.
  62. Ho, Virginia Harper(2022).Modernizing ESG Disclosure.U. ILL. L. REV.,2022,277-356.
  63. Ho, Virginia Harper,Park, Stephen Kim(2019).ESG Disclosure in Comparative Perspective: Optimizing Private Ordering in Public Reporting.U. PA.J. INT’L L.,41,249-328.
  64. Hoffman, David A.(2006).The "Duty" to Be a Rational Shareholder.MINN. L. REV.,90,537-611.
  65. Hoffman, David A.(2006).The Best Puffery Article Ever.IOWA L. REV.,91,1395-1448.
  66. Huang, Peter H.(2005).Moody Investing and the Supreme Court: Rethinking the Materiality of Information and the Reasonableness of Investors.SUP. CT. ECON. REV.,13,99-132.
  67. HUMPHREYS, MATTHEW(2017).SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN THE EUROPEAN UNION: AGENERAL PRINCIPLE.
  68. Jebe, Ruth(2019).The Convergence of Financial and ESG Materiality: Taking Sustainability Mainstream.AM. BUS. L. J.,56,645-702.
  69. Jebe, Ruth(2017).Corporate Sustainability Reporting and “Material Information”: An Empirical Study of Materiality Under the GRI and Frameworks.CONN. J. INT’L L.,33,95-136.
  70. Jennings, Marianne M.(2019).The Social Responsibility of Business Is Not Social Responsibility: Assume That There Are No Angels and Allow the Free Market’s Touch of Heaven.BERKELEY BUS. L. J.,16,325-462.
  71. Karmel, Roberta S.(2016).Disclosure Reform: The SEC Is Riding Off in Two Directions at Once.BUS. LAW,71,781-834.
  72. Kenig-Witkowska, Maria M.(2017).The Concept of Sustainable Development in the European Union Policy and Law.J. COMP. URB. L. & POL’Y,1,64-80.
  73. Kitch, Edmund W.(1980).The Law and Economics of Rights in Valuable Information.J. LEGAL STUD.,9,683-724.
  74. Knauss, Robert L.(1964).A Reappraisal of the Role of Disclosure.MICH. L. REV.,62,607-648.
  75. Knoll, Michael S.(2002).Ethical Screening in Modern Financial Markets: The Conflicting Claims Underlying Socially Responsible Investment.BUS. LAW.,57,681-726.
  76. Korsmo, Charles R.(2017).The Audience for Corporate Disclosure.IOWA L. REV.,102,1581-1632.
  77. Kripke, Homer(1973).The Myth of the Informed Layman.BUS. LAW.,28,631-638.
  78. Langevoort, Donald C.(2002).Are Judges Motivated to Create "Good" Securities Fraud Doctrine?.EMORY L. J.,51,309-318.
  79. Langevoort, Donald C.(1994).Disclosures That "Bespeak Caution".BUS. LAW.,49,481-504.
  80. Langevoort, Donald C.(2019).Disasters and Disclosures: Securities Fraud Liability in the Shadow of a Corporate Catastrophe.GEO. L. J.,107,967-1016.
  81. Langevoort, Donald C.(2002).Taming the Animal Spirits of the Stock Markets: A Behavioral Approach to Securities Regulation.NW. U. L. REV.,97,135-188.
  82. Langevoort, Donald C.,Gulati, G. Mitu(2004).The Muddled Duty to Disclose Under Rule 10b-5.VAND. L. REV.,57,1639-1686.
  83. Lantos, Geoffrey P.(2001).The Boundaries of Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility.J. CONSUMER MARKETING,18,595-632.
  84. Lin, Tom C. W.(2015).Reasonable Investor(s).B.U.L. REV.,95,461-518.
  85. Lipshaw, Jeffrey M.(2021).The False Dichotomy of Corporate Governance Platitudes.J. CORP. L.,46,345-384.
  86. Lipton, Ann M.(2020).Not Everything Is About Investors: The Case for Mandatory Stakeholder Disclosure.YALE J. ON REG.,37,499-572.
  87. Lipton, Ann M.(2019).Fact or Fiction: Flawed Approaches to Evaluating Market Behavior in Securities Litigation.TENN. J. BUS. L.,20,741-776.
  88. Lipton, Ann M.(2017).Reviving Reliance.FORDHAM L. REV.,86,91-148.
  89. Loewenstein, Mark J.(2018).Thinking Fast and Slow About the Concept of Materiality.SMU L. REV.,71,853-868.
  90. Lowenstein, Louis(1996).Financial Transparency and Corporate Governance: You Manage What You Measure.COLUM. L. REV.,96,1335-1362.
  91. Lynn, David M.(2011).The Dodd-Frank Act’s Specialized Corporate Disclosure: Using the Securities Laws to Address Public Policy Issues.J. BUS. & TECH. L.,6,327-356.
  92. Nelson, James D.(2018).The Trouble with Corporate Conscience.VAND. L. REV.,71,1655-1702.
  93. O’Hare, Jennifer(1997).Good Faith and the Bespeaks Caution Doctrine: It’s Not Just a State of Mind.U. PITT. L. REV.,58,619-668.
  94. Oesterle, Dale A.(2011).The Overused and Under-defined Notion of "Material" in Securities Law.J. U. PA. BUS. L.,14,167-208.
  95. Osovsky, Adi(2016).Puffery on the Market: A Behavioral Economic Analysis of the Puffery Defense in the Securities Arena.HARV. BUS. L. REV.,6,333-392.
  96. Padfield, Stefan J.(2010).Immaterial Lies: Condoning Deceit in the Name of Securities Regulation.CASE W. RES. L. REV.,61,143-194.
  97. Paredes, Troy A.(2003).Blinded by the Light: Information Overload and Its Consequences for Securities Regulation.WASH. U. L. Q.,81,417-486.
  98. Pargendler, Mariana(2016).The Corporate Governance Obsession.J. CORP. L.,42,359-402.
  99. Porter, Michael E.,Kramer, Mark R.(2011).Creating Shared Value.HARV. BUS. REV.,89,62-77.
  100. Reiser, Brakman Dana,Tucker, Anne(2020).Buyer Beware: Variation and Opacity in ESG and ESG Index Funds.CARDOZO L. REV.,41,1921-2018.
  101. Ripken, Susanna Kim(2006).The Dangers and Drawbacks of the Disclosure Antidote: Toward a More Substantive Approach to Securities Regulation.BAYLOR L. REV.,58,139-204.
  102. Rock, Edward B.(2021).For Whom Is the Corporation Managed in 2020?: The Debate over Corporate Purpose.BUS. LAW,76,363-396.
  103. Rose, Amanda M.(2021).A Response to Calls for SEC-Mandated ESG Disclosure.WASH. U. L. REV.,98,1821-1856.
  104. Rose, Amanda M.(2017).The "Reasonable Investor" of Federal Securities Law: Insights from Tort Law’s "Reasonable Person" and Suggested Reforms.J. CORP. L.,43,77-118.
  105. S.E.C., Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, 54 FED. REG. 22427-22436 (1989).
  106. S.E.C., Executive Compensation and Related Person Disclosure, 71 FED. REG. 53158-53266 (Aug. 29, 2006).
  107. S.E.C., Modernization of Regulation S-K Items 101, 103, and 105, 85 FED. REG. 63726-63760 (Oct. 8, 2020).
  108. S.E.C., Commission Guidance Regarding Disclosure Related to Climate Change, 75 FED. REG. 6290-6297 (Feb. 8, 2010).
  109. Sachs, Margaret V.(2006).The Case for Replacing the Reasonable Investor with the Least Sophisticated Investor in Inefficient Markets.TUL. L. REV.,81,473-508.
  110. Sale, Hillary A.(2011).The New "Public" Corporation.L. & CONTEMP. PROBS.,74,137-148.
  111. Sauer, Richard C.(2007).The Erosion of the Materiality Standard in the Enforcement of the Federal Securities Laws.BUS. LAW.,62,317-358.
  112. Schanzenbach, Max M.,Sitkoff, Robert H.(2020).Reconciling Fiduciary Duty and Social Conscience: The Law and Economics of ESG Investing by a Trustee.STAN. L. REV.,72,381-454.
  113. Schwartz, Jeff(2012).The Twilight of Equity Liquidity.CARDOZO L. REV.,34,531-608.
  114. Sharfman, Bernard S.(2019).How the SEC Can Help Mitigate the "Proactive" Agency Costs of Agency Capitalism.AM. U. BUS. L. REV.,8,1-22.
  115. Sheehy, Benedict(2015).Defining CSR: Problems and Solutions.J. BUS. ETHICS,131,625-648.
  116. Shleifer, Andrei,Summers, Lawrence(1990).The Noise Trader Approach to Finance.J. ECON. PERSP.,4,19-33.
  117. Solomon, Steven Davidoff,Hill, Claire(2013).Limits of Disclosure.SEATTLE U. L. REV.,36,599-638.
  118. STEINBERG, MARC I.(2021).RETHINKING SECURITIES LAW.
  119. Steinberg, Marc I.,Goldman, Robin M.(1987).Issuer Affirmative Disclosure Obligations: An Analytical Framework for Merger Negotiations, Soft Information, and Bad News.MD. L. REV.,46,923-953.
  120. Stout, Lynn A.(2003).The Mechanisms of Market Inefficiency: An Introduction to the New Finance.J. CORP. L.,28,635-670.
  121. Szabó, Dániel Gergely,Sørensen, Karsten Engsig(2015).New EU Directive on the Disclosure of Non-Financial Information (CSR).EUR. COMPANY & FIN. L. REV.,12,307-340.
  122. Thomas, Randall S.(ed.),Hill, Jennifer G.(ed.)(2012).RESEARCH HANDBOOK ON EXECUTIVE PAY.
  123. Thompson, Robert B.,Sale, Hillary A.(2003).Securities Fraud as Corporate Governance: Reflections upon Federalism.VAND. L. REV.,56,859-910.
  124. Turk, Matthew C.,Woody, Karen E.(2018).The Leidos Mixup and the Misunderstood Duty to Disclose in Securities Law.WASH. & LEE L. REV.,75,957-1034.
  125. U.S. GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY OFFICE(2020).,未出版
  126. Van Hees, Sander R.W.(2014).Sustainable Development in the EU: Redefining and Operationalizing the Concept.UTRECHT L. REV.,10,60-76.
  127. Vizcarra, Hana V.(2019).Climate-Related Disclosure and Litigation Risk in the Oil & Gas Industry: Will State Attorneys General Investigations Impede the Drive for More Expansive Disclosures?.VT. L. REV.,43,733-776.
  128. Wagner, Constance Z.(2018).Evolving Norms of Corporate Social Responsibility: Lessons Learned from the European Union Directive on Non-Financial Reporting.TENN. J. BUS. L.,19,619-708.
  129. Wells, C. A. Harwell(2002).The Cycles of Corporate Social Responsibility: An Historical Retrospective for the Twenty-First Century.U. KAN. L. REV.,51,77-140.
  130. Williams, Cynthia A.,Nagy, Donna M.(2021).ESG and Climate Change Blind Spots: Turning the Corner on SEC Disclosure.TEX. L. REV.,99,1453-1486.
  131. Winter, Ralph K.(1988).On "Protecting the Ordinary Investor".WASH. L. REV.,63,881-902.
  132. Wouters, Jan,Chanet, Leen(2008).Corporate Human Rights Responsibility: A European Perspective.NW. U. J. INT’L HUM. RTS.,6,262-303.
  133. Yannaca-Small, Katia(2021).Corporate Social Responsibility and the International Investment Law Regime: Not Business as Usual.U. ST. THOMAS L. J.,17,402-421.
  134. 王文宇(2008)。認真地對待資訊－論內線交易之判斷標準與預防措施。月旦法學雜誌，155
  135. 吳玉鳳(2022)。保險公司氣候相關資訊揭露與 TCFD 揭露架構整合之探討。保險專刊，38(1)
  136. 吳盈德(2018)。財報不實與重大性之構成要件／最高法院 106 台上 278 判決。台灣法學雜誌，338
  137. 李宜樺(2018)。氣候變遷相關財務揭露。月旦會計實務研究，12
  138. 李宜樺,鄭可俐(2020)。加速永續金融的利器－永續會計準則（SASB）。會計研究月刊，411
  139. 李明機(2010)。推動上市上櫃公司履行企業社會責任。證券暨期貨月刊，28(5)
  140. 李建良(2000)。永續發展與國家責任。臺北大學法學論叢，46
  141. 李禮仲(2016)。內線交易中視而不見的構成要件－論證券交易法第 157 條之 1 第 5 項之「正當投資人」。法學叢刊，61(1)
  142. 林建中(2013)。從證券法觀點觀察強制公開揭露理論的界線與替代模型。科技法學評論，10(2)
  143. 林耿民,高晟晉(2016)。推動上市（櫃）公司企業社會責任。證券暨期貨月刊，34(6)
  144. 林國全(2005)。以散布流言或不實資料方法操縱價格－台灣高等法院九十二年度金上重訴字第九號判決評析。月旦民商法雜誌，7
  145. 邵慶平(2006)。證券訴訟上「交易因果關係」與「損害因果關係」之認定－評析高雄地院九一年重訴字第四四七號判決。台灣本土法學雜誌，79
  146. 張心悌(2004)。證券交易法中虛偽陳述之民事責任－兼論大陸銀廣廈案。月旦民商法雜誌，3
  147. 張書瑋(2021)。ESG 企業永續報告書準備好了嗎？。會計研究月刊，422
  148. 莊永丞(2015)。論證券交易法第 20 條之 1 之功過得失。月旦財經法雜誌，36
  149. 郭土木(2021)。財務報告虛偽隱匿犯罪構成要件重大性之再檢視－以最高法院 108 年度台上字第 1547 號刑事判決為中心。月旦法學教室，224
  150. 郭大維(2018)。財務報告不實重大性要件之判斷標準。台灣法學雜誌，350
  151. 陳友鋒,黃鵬達(2014)。刑事不法與行政不法臨界之檢討－以刑法第 185 條之 3 為論述中心。華岡法粹，57
  152. 陳麗娟(2021)。歐盟永續金融興起之概況。國會季刊，49(1)
  153. 黃帥升(2021)。歐盟永續金融揭露規範（SFDR）之內涵與衝擊因應。會計研究月刊，427
  154. 黃朝琮(2021)。價格維持理論於證券詐欺訴訟之適用。成大法學，42
  155. 黃朝琮(2020)。效率市場概念於美國公司法上之應用。政大法學評論，162
  156. 楊智傑(2015)。強制揭露資訊、商業言論與不表意自由。台灣法學雜誌，283
  157. 楊雅智(2014)。淺談企業社會責任之國際發展趨勢與國內推動現況。證券暨期貨月刊，33(1)
  158. 劉連煜(2009)。證交法第二十條第二項資訊不實規範功能之檢討－資訊內容具重大性是責任成立要件。台灣法學雜誌，131
  159. 劉連煜(1996)。內部人交易規範中內部消息「重大性」之認定基準。證券管理，14(6)
  160. 劉連煜(2006)。內線交易重大消息的範圍及其公開方式的認定。台灣法學雜誌，87
  161. 賴英照(2007)。從尤努斯到巴菲特－公司社會責任的基本問題。台灣本土法學雜誌，93
  162. 賴英照(2020).最新證券交易法解析.自版.
被引用次数
  1. 莊永丞(2023)。論我國ESG之揭露法制－從永續報告書揭開ESG面紗。東吳法律學報，35(2)，1-65。
  2. (2024)。人力資源專業職能永續發展指標之研究。品質學報，31(2)，71-98。
print cancel