論金融科技與金融監理

Financial Technology and Financial Supervision

莊永丞(Yung-Cheng Chuang)

金融科技 ； 破壞式創新 ； 監管科技 ； 金融監理沙盒 ； 規則基礎監理 ； 原則基礎監理 ； FinTech ； Disruptive Innovation ； RegTech ； Regulatory Sandbox ； Rule-based Regulation ； Principle-based Regulation

臺北大學法學論叢

127期（2023 / 09 / 01）

151 - 236

繁體中文;英文

金融科技之破壞式創新風潮下，如何調整既有金融監理規範使金融穩定、消費者保護及金融科技創新三者取得均衡乃各國金融主管機關所面臨之難題。是以本文首先探討當前金融科技之意涵及其運用層面及影響；其次探討各國面臨金融科技衝擊於法規範的調適方式；並探討我國銀行法第29條之1阻礙金融新創發展之可能性及金融新創商品於既有法規範之適用可能；最後細究監理沙盒制度存在意義及其可能問題。職此，於金融科技與現行法規調適之困境下，本文分析金融科技創新及金融科技監管模式，企圖提出我國法規調適之最佳實務模式。本文認為，雖透過實驗與主管機關溝通、調適監理沙盒制度之原則基礎監理或可為解決之道，然僅在無法認定、無法透過法規範解釋涵攝情形，始有監理沙盒制度運用之必要。本文建議引入日本法灰色地帶消除制度作為申請進入監理沙盒之前導程序，避免業者輕易進入實驗所產生行政怠惰與錯失創新良機之外部成本。進入沙盒完成實驗後，主管機關雖仍以原則基礎監理，惟在法規鬆綁與豁免階段，應有規則基礎監管之態度，賦予適度明確性，秉持「原則基礎監理為本，規則基礎監理為用」之立場。就以上內容希冀作為我國立法及金融主管機關，未來於法令或監理措施之思考立足點。

FinTech refers to the application of technology in the field of finance to provide the disruptive innovation of existing financial business models. FinTech can not only provide better convenience for financial consumers and reduce transaction costs, to achieve the goal of financial inclusion, but also help supervisors to improve supervision efficiency and reduce supervision cost with regulatory technology. However, FinTech is also problematic due to the impact of financial market stability and inadequate consumer protection, especially how the financial regulator should supervise and respond to the situation that the innovators of non-traditional financial institutions want to enter the financial market to provide better and cheaper services. In particular, the traditional laws and regulations are facing rapid changes in technology, but they are still unable to respond to the needs of the times. Therefore, the discussion and selection of rule-based regulation and principle based regulation in the regulation adjustment regression are the important issues under the existing regulation issues. This paper focuses on the impact of FinTech innovation and its regulatory dilemma and proposes the best practice of supervision adjustment in our country.

1. 郭土木(2018)。證券交易法有關經主管機關核定之有價證券其範圍與爭議－兼評最高法院 105 年台抗字第 925 號刑事確定裁定。軍法專刊，64(3)
   連結：
2. Abramowicz, Michael B.(2019).Blockchain-Based Insurance.REGULATING BLOCKCHAIN: TECHNO-SOCIAL AND LEGAL CHALLENGES
3. Adhami, Saman,Giudici, Giancarlo,Martinazzi, Stefano(2018).Why Do Businesses Go Crypto? An Empirical Analysis of Initial Coin Offerings.J. BUS. & ECON.,100,64-75.
4. Alcser, Marc G.(1996).The Howey Test: A Common Ground for the Common Enterprise Theory.U.C. DAVIS L. REV.,29,1217-1242.
5. Allen, Hilary J.(2019).Regulatory Sandboxes.GEO. WASH. L. REV.,87,579-645.
6. Allen, Hilary J.(2020).Sandbox Boundaries.VAND. J. ENT. & TECH. L.,22,299-322.
7. Arner, Douglas W.,Barberis, Janos Nathan,Buckley, Ross P.(2017).FinTech, RegTech and the Reconceptualization of Financial Regulation.NW. J. INT’L L. & BUS.,37,371-414.
8. Arner, Douglas W.,Barberis, Janos,Buckley, Ross P.(2016).The Evolution of FinTech: A New Post-Crisis Paradigm?.GEO. J. INT’L L.,47,1271-1319.
9. Arner, Douglas W.,Zetzsche, Dirk Andreas,Buckley, Ross P.,Barberis, Janos Nathan(2017).Fintech and Regtech: Enabling Innovation While Preserving Financial Stability.GEO. J. INT’L AFF.,18,47-58.
10. Baker, Tom,Dellaert, Benedict(2018).Regulating Robo Advice Across the Financial Services Industry.IOWA L. REV.,103,713-750.
11. Black, Julia,Hopper, Martyn,Band, Christa(2007).Making a Success of Principles-Based Regulation.LAW & FIN. MKT. REV.,1,191-206.
12. Borsani, Christopher L.(2008).A “Common” Problem: Examining the Need for Common Ground in the “Common Enterprise” Element of the Howey Test,.DUQ. BUS. L.J.,10,1-17.
13. Bradley, Caroline(1991).The Case of Financial Services.NW. J. INT’L L. & BUS.,12,124-162.
14. Brummer, Chris,Yadav, Yesha(2019).Fintech and the Innovation Trilemma.GEO. L.J,107,235-307.
15. Buckley, Ross P.,Arner, Douglas W.,Zetzsche, Dirk Andreas(2020).Sustainability, FinTech and Financial Inclusion.EUR. BUS. ORGAN. LAW REV.,21,7-35.
16. Buckley, Ross P.,Webster, Sarah(2016).Fintech in Developing Countries: Charting New Customer Journeys.JOURNAL OF FINANCIAL TRANSFORMATION,44,151-159.
17. Butenko, Anna,Larouche, Pierre(2015).Regulation for Innovativeness or Regulation of Innovation?.LAW INNOVAT ON & TECH,7,52-82.
18. Chaffee, Eric C.,Rapp, Geoffrey C.(2012).Regulating Online Peer-to-Peer Lending in the Aftermath of Dodd-Frank: In Search of an Evolving Regulatory Regime for an Evolving Industry.WASH. & LEE L. REV.,69,485-533.
19. Chiu, Iris H-Y(2016).Fintech and Disruptive Business Models in Financial Products, Intermediation and Markets - Policy Implications for Financial Regulators.J. TECH. L. & POL’Y,21,55-112.
20. COFFEE, JR.,JOHN, C.,SELIGMAN, JOEL(2003).SECURITIES REGULATION: CASE AND MATERIALS.
21. Coffee, Jr,John, C(2012).The Political Economy of Dodd-Frank: Why Financial Reform Tends to Be Frustrated and Systemic Risk Perpetuated.CORNELL L. REV.,97,1019-1082.
22. Cortez, Nathan(2014).Regulating Disruptive Innovation.BERKELEY TECH. L.J.,29,175-228.
23. Didenko, Anton(2018).Regulating Fintech: Lessons From Africa.SAN DIEGO INT L.J.,19,311-369.
24. Fenwick, Mark,Kaal, Wulf A.,Vermeulen, Erik P. M.(2017).Regulation Tomorrow: What Happens When Technology Is Faster than the Law?.AM. U. BUS. L. REV.,6,561-594.
25. Haddad, Christian,Hornuf, Lars(2019).The Emergence of the Global Fintech Market: Economic and Technological Determinants.SMALL BUS. ECON.,81,81-105.
26. Huang, Robin Hui(2018).Online P2P Lending and Regulatory Responses in China: Opportunities and Challenges.EUR. BUS. ORGAN. LAW,19,63-92.
27. Kaal, Wulf A.,Vermeulen, Erik P. M.(2017).How to Regulate Disruptive Innovation - Form Facts to Data.JURIMETRICS J.,57,169-209.
28. Malloy, Michael P.(1990).The 12(i)’ed Monster: Administration of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 by the Federal Bank Regulatory Agencies.HOFSTRA L. REV.,19,269-309.
29. Middlebrook, Stephen T.,Hughes, Sarah Jane,Kierner, Tom(2018).Developments in the Law Affecting Electronic Payments and Financial Services.BUS. LAW.,74,267-278.
30. Odinet, Christopher K.(2018).Consumer Bitcredit and Fintech Lending.ALA. L. REV.,69,781-858.
31. Oedel, David G.(1998).Introduction to a Panel on the Modernization of Financial Regulation: What is the Governmental Role in Finance, Anyway?.MERCER L. REV.,49,771-775.
32. Omarova, Saule T.(2011).Wall Street As Community of Fate: Toward Financial Industry Self-Regulation.U. PA. L. REV.,159,411-492.
33. Romano, Roberta(2019).Pitfalls of Global Harmonization of Systemic Risk Regulation in a World of Financial Innovation.SYSTEMIC RISK IN THE FINANCIAL SECTOR: TEN YEARS AFTER THE GREAT CRASH
34. Schooner, Heidi Mandanis(1998).Regulating Risk Not Function.U. CIN. L. REV.,66,441-488.
35. Schooner, Heidi Mandanis,Taylor, Michael(2003).United Kingdom and United States Responses to the Regulatory Challenges of Modern Financial Markets.TEX. INT,38,317-345.
36. Van Loo, Rory(2018).Making Innovation More Competitive: The Case of Fintech.UCLAL. REV.,65,232-279.
37. Verstein, Andrew(2011).The Misregulation of Person-to-Person Lending.U.C. DAVIS L. REV.,45,445-530.
38. Walker, George(2017).Financial Technology Law - A New Beginning and a New Future.INT’L LAW.,50,137-215.
39. Wu, Tim(2011).Agency Threats.DUKE L.J.,60,1841-1857.
40. Zetzsche, Dirk A.,Buckley, Ross P.,Arner, Douglas W.,Barberis, Janos Nathan(2018).From FinTech to TechFin: The Regulatory Challenges of Data-Driven Finance.N.Y.U. J. L. & BUS.,14,393-446.
41. Zetzsche, Dirk A.,Buckley, Ross P.,Barberis, Janos Nathan,Arner, Douglas W.(2017).Regulating a Revolution: From Regulatory Sandboxes to Smart Regulation.FORDHAM J. CORP. & FIN. L.,23,31-103.
42. Zhou, Weihuan,Arner, Douglas W.,Buckley, Ross P.(2015).Regulation of Digital Financial Services in China: Last Mover Advantage?.TSINGHUA CHINA L. REV.,8,25-62.
43. 王文宇（編）(2019).金融法.元照出版有限公司.
44. 王可言,李漢超,林蔚君(2019).代幣經濟崛起：洞見趨勢,看準未來,精選全球 50 則大型區塊鏈募資案例.聯經出版事業股份有限公司.
45. 吉澤卓哉(2020)。インシュアテックと保険法－新技術で加速する保険業の革新と法の課題。保険毎日新聞社。
46. 江朝國(2003).保險法基礎理論.瑞興圖書股份有限公司.
47. 谷湘儀（編）,臧正運（編）(2018).金融科技發展與法律.五南圖書出版股份有限公司.
48. 邱茗囷(2019)。加密資產（crypto assets）籌資之趨勢觀察。證券暨期貨月刊，37(7)
49. 范姜肱,鄭鎮樑,姜麗智(2017).InsurTech 趨勢與保險經營創新.財團法人保險事業發展中心.
50. 張冠群(2017)。自金融監理原則與金融消費者保護觀點論金融科技監理沙盒制度－兼評行政院版「金融科技創新實驗條例草案。月旦法學雜誌，266
51. 楊岳平(2018)。首次代幣發行與證券監理法制－以臺灣證券交易法下「證券」的定義為中心。月旦財經法雜誌，43
52. 葉啟洲(2019).保險法.元照出版有限公司.
53. 臧正運(2020)。論金融科技發展的監理難題與法制策略－以我國的規範與實踐為核心。政大法學評論，163
54. 劉連煜(2020).現代證券交易法實例研習.元照出版有限公司.