题名

比較親密伴侶殺人案之性別差異

并列篇名

Gender Differences in Intimate Partner Homicide

DOI

10.6171/ntuswr2012.26.01

作者

馬宗潔(Tsung-Chieh Ma)；廖美蓮(Miriam Mei-Lin Liu)；洪惠芬(Hui-Fen Hung)

关键词

性別差異 ； 殺人 ； 親密伴侶 ； gender difference ； homicide ； intimate partner

期刊名称

臺大社會工作學刊

卷期/出版年月

26期（2012 / 12 / 01）

页次

1 - 40

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究旨在檢視親密伴侶殺害案件之性別差異，以內容分析為研究方法，整理司法院法學資料庫從1998～2009年之間的親密伴侶殺人案件，總樣本數224件，男性殺人案198件、女性殺人案26件，皆為異性戀。其研究問題為：親密伴侶殺人案件於雙方當事人關係、殺人動機、親密暴力史與殺人歷程之性別不同。研究結果發現，女性與男性殺人案的比率為1：8。男性親密暴力殺人者更傾向在分居以後出手、較高機率發生在公共場所、較多曾有使用暴力的紀錄、較頻繁的跟蹤行為、較常採用正面攻擊手法，以及較容易波及他人；反觀女性殺人案，多等對方睡覺後才下手，且殺人既遂率更高。男性殺人的主要動機為伴侶疑似或實質外遇、伴侶企圖離開關係而產生的嫉妒；而女性最主要的殺人動機為因害怕而自我保護下的攻擊。對於社會工作的涵義為，長期或連續遭受親密暴力是殺害親密伴侶者的前兆，對於兩性皆是被殺害的危險因子。
英文摘要

The purpose of this research is to compare the profiles and motives of women versus men charged with murder or attempted murder of their intimate partners. Content analysis was used as research method. The data was collected from the database of the Taiwanese Department of Justice; all court verdicts of intimate partner homicide and attempted homicide cases from 1998 to 2009 were reviewed by the researcher. The cases were coded with regard to relationship status, relationship state, location of the murder, history of violence, weapon used, motives, mental illness, and killed others beside partners. The total number of the cases was 224, including 198 male and 26 female offenders. Since the female offenders sample is relatively small (11% of the total), descriptive statistics and Chi-Square have been used in this analysis. The significant result of this study regard to gender differences of intimate partner homicide were as follow: (1) Women were significantly more likely to have actually killed their intimate partners, (2) Males were more likely to have murdered or attempted murder when the relationship were over and separated, however, women generally killed the intimate partners while still in a relationship with them. (3) Male attempted to kill their partners in public places, however, women only killed partners at home. (4) 40% of men (but just 10% of women) had abused their partners before killing. 42% of the women had been victims of battery prior to killing their intimate partners. (5) Among men, the risk of partner abandonment, sexual jealousy, and economic issues were the major motivations to kill; however, self-defense was the most common motivation among women. (6) Regarding to killing method, only men used beating and only women use poison. Because of the gun controlled policy, gun is not easily accessed, knife is the major weapon for both man and women. (7) And 20% man also killed someone who were not their partners, they were parents, children, sibling, boy friend and suspected boyfriends.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會學
参考文献
  1. 陳高凌(2001)。義與面子在華人家庭暴力裡的運作及其對於治療之啟示。本土心理學研究，15，66-111。
    連結：
  2. 司法院（2001）。臺北地方法院90年訴字第1067號刑事判決
  3. 司法院（1947）。最高法院36年特覆字第4021號刑事判例
  4. 司法院（1930）。最高法院19年非字第77號刑事判例
  5. 司法院（2007）。臺北地方法院96年訴字第1070號刑事判決
  6. Rennison, C. M., & Welchans, S. (2000, May 17). Intimate partner violence. Bureau of Justice Statistics. Retrieved from http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/pdf/ipv.pdf
  7. Rennison, C. M. (2001, October 28). Intimate partner violence and age of victim, 1993-99. Bureau of Justice Statistics. Retrieved from http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/pdf/ipva99.pdf
  8. MacDonald, A. (1910). Death penalty and homicide. American Journal of Sociology, 16(1), 88-116
  9. 司法院（2010）。司法院法學資料庫。取自http://www.judicial.gov.tw。http://www.judicial.gov.tw
  10. Langan, P. A., & Dawson, J. M. (1995, September). Spouse murder defendants in large urban countries Bureat of Justice Statistics. Retrieved from http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/pdf/SPOUSMUR.PDF
  11. 司法院（2005）。苗栗地方法院94年矚重訴字第1號刑事判決
  12. Wabsdale, N. (2000). Lethality assessment tools: A critical analysis. Retrieved from http://www.vawent.org
  13. Adams, D.(2007).Why do they kill?.Nashville, TN:Vanderbilt University Press.
  14. Aldride, M. L.,Browne, K. D.(2003).Perpetrators of spousal homicide: A review.Trauma, Violence and Abuse,4(3),265-276.
  15. Anderson, K. L.(2005).Theorizing gender in intimate partner violence research.Sex Roles,52(11/12),853-865.
  16. Archer, J.(2000).Sex differences in aggression between heterosexual partners: A meta-analytic review.Journal of Interpersonal Violence,14,1263-1289.
  17. Baker, K. K.(2005).Gender and emotion in criminal law.Harvard Journal of Law & Gender,28,447-466.
  18. Browne, A.,Williams, K. R.(1993).Gender intimacy, and lethal violence: Trends from 1976 through 1987.Gender and Society,7(1),78-98.
  19. Brush, L. D.(2005).Philosophical and political issues in research on women's violence and aggression.Sex Roles,52(11/12),867-873.
  20. Buss, D. M.(1988).From vigilance to violence: Tactics of mate retention among American undergraduates.Ethology and Sociology,9(5),291-317.
  21. Campbell, J. C.(2005).Commentary on Websdale: Lethality assessment approaches: Reflections on their use and ways forward.Violence Against Women,11(9),1206-1213.
  22. Campbell, J. C.,Webster, D.,Koziol-McLain, J.,Block, C.,Campbell, D.,Curry, M. A.,Laughon, K.(2003).Risks factors for femicide in abusive relationship: Results from a multiside case control study.American Journal of Public Health,93(7),1089-1097.
  23. Catalano, S.,Smith, E.,Snyder, H.,Rand, M.(2009).,未出版
  24. Currie, S.(1995).Justice for women who kill in self-defense?.Social Alternatives,14(1),31-35.
  25. Dalton, B.(2001).Batterer characteristics and treatment completion.Journal of Interpersonal Violence,16,1223-1238.
  26. Daly, M.,Wilson, M.(1988).Homicide.New York, NY:Aldine de Gruyter.
  27. Dawson, M.(2003).The cost of 'lost' intimacy: The effect of relationship state on criminal justice decision making.The British Journal of Criminology,43(4),689-707.
  28. Dobash, R. E.,Dobash, R. P.,Cavanagh, K.,Lewis, R.(2004).Not an ordinary killer: Just an ordinary guy.Violence Against Women,10(6),577-605.
  29. Dressler, J.(2005).Criminal law.St. Paul, MN:Thomson/West.
  30. Dutton, M. A.,Goodman, L. A.(2005).Coercion in intimate partner violence: Toward a new conceptualization.Sex Roles: A Journal of Research,52,743-756.
  31. Farr, K. A.(2002).Battered women who were "being killed and survives it": Straight talk from survivors.Violence and Victims,17(3),267-281.
  32. Follingstard, D. R.,Brondino, M. J.,Kleinfelter, K. J.(1996).Reputation and behavior of battered women who kill their partners: Do these variables negative self-defense?.Journal of Family Violence,11(3),251-267.
  33. Hamberger, L. K.(2005).Men's and women's use of intimate partner violence in clinical samples: Toward a gender-sensitive analysis.Violence and Victims,20(2),131-151.
  34. Hotton, T.(2001).Spousal violence after marital separation.Jiristat: Canadian for Justice Statistics,21(7),1-17.
  35. Jewkes, R.(2002).Intimate partner violence: Causes and prevention.The Lancet,359,1423-1429.
  36. Johnson, H.,Hotton, T.(2003).Losing control: Homicide risk in estranged and intact intimate relationships.Homicide Studies,7(1),58-84.
  37. Kimmel, M. S.(2002)."Gender symmetry" in domestic violence: A substantive and methodological research review.Violence Against Women,8(11),1332-1363.
  38. Lips, H. M.(1991).Women, men, and power.Mountain View, CA:Mayfield.
  39. McHugh, M. C.(2005).Understanding gender and intimate partner abuse.Sex Roles,52(11/12),717-724.
  40. McNeely, R. L.,Mann, C. R.(1990).Domestic violence is a human issue.Journal of Interpersonal Violence,5,129-132.
  41. Miller, J. B.(1991).The construction of anger in women and men.Women's growth in connection: Writing from the Stone Center,New York, NY:
  42. Mills, G. L.(2008).Violent partners: A breakthrough plan for ending the cycle of abuse.New York, NY:Basic Press.
  43. Mize, K. D.,Shackelford, T. K.,Shackelford, V. A.(2009).Hand-on killings of intimate partners as a function of sex and relationship status/state.Journal of Family Violence,24,463-470.
  44. Mouzos, J.,Shackelforld, T. K.(2004).A comparative, cross-national analysis of partner-killing by women in cohabiting and martial relationship in Australia and the United States.Aggressive Behavior,30,206-216.
  45. Polk, K.(1994).When men kill: Scenarios of masculine violence.New York, NY:Cambridge University Press.
  46. Radflord, R.(ed.)(1992).Power and control in homicide of female partner.New York:Twayne.
  47. Radford, J.(ed.),Russell, D. E. H.(ed.)(1992).Femicide: The politics of women killing.New York, NY:Twayne.
  48. Shackelford, T. K.(2001).Cohabitation, marriage, and murder: Women-killing by male romantic partners.Aggressive Behavior,27,284-291.
  49. Shackelford, T. K.,Buss, D. M.,Peters, J.(2000).Wife killing: Risk to women as a function of age.Violence and Victims,15(3),237-282.
  50. Shackelford, T. K.,Buss, D. M.,Weekes-Shackelford, V. A.(2003).Wife killing committed in the contest of a lovers triangle.Basic and Applied Social Psychology,25,137-143.
  51. Smith, D.(ed.),Zahn, M.(ed.)(1998).Homicide studies.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  52. Smith, P. H.,Moracco, K. E.,Butts, J. D.(1998).Partner homicide in context: A population based perspective.Homicide Studies,2(4),400-421.
  53. Websdale, N.(1999).Understanding domestic homicide.Boston, NH:Northeastern University Press.
  54. Wilson, M.,Daly, M.(1993).Spousal homicide risk and estrangement.Violence and Victims,8(1),3-16.
  55. Wilson, M.,Johnson, H.,Daly, M.(1995).Lethal and nonlethal violence against wives.Canadian Journal of Criminology,37,331-365.
  56. 吳柳嬌(2010)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立中山大學學術研究所。
  57. 林俊仁(2010)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立中山大學學術研究所。
  58. 侯崇文(1999)。殺人事件中犯罪者與被害人關係研究。刑事政策與犯罪研究論文集（二），台北:
  59. 馬宗潔(2009)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。東吳大學法律系在職專班。
  60. 馬宗潔、陳俐蓉(2011)。保護令的保護性。2011年台灣社會工作專業人員協會年會，促進社會凝聚：社會工作專業的新視野研討會，台北:
  61. 張凱捷(2009)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。中央警官大學犯罪防治研究所。
  62. 莊雲卿(2008)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立暨南國際大學社會政策與社會工作研究所。
  63. 程淑華(2010)。兩性在嫉妒情緒及引發情緒之差異性研究。復興崗學報，99，125-150。
  64. 葉碧翠(2003)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台北大學犯罪研究所。
  65. 蔡宗達(2006)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台北大學犯罪學研究所。
  66. 鄭雅文(2006)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中正大學犯罪防治所。
  67. 謝文彥(2002)。博士論文(博士論文)。中央警察大學犯罪防治研究所。
  68. 魏仲亨(2006)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中正大學犯罪防治研究所。
被引用次数
  1. 黃翠紋、林淑君(2016)。高危機親密關係暴力事件特性與處遇作為之分析。犯罪學期刊，19(1)，20-58。
  2. 馬宗潔、江建仁(2013)。與目睹家內凶殺案兒童工作經驗探討。臺灣社會工作學刊，11，115-144。
  3. 潘淑滿、歐紫彤、陳杏容、林雅容、林東龍(2016)。親密關係暴力：臺灣女性之受暴與求助經驗。臺灣社會工作學刊，17，1-42。
  4. (2016)。暴力親密伴侶間的性忌妒議題。社區發展季刊，156，182-192。
print cancel