题名

社區組織參與老人預防照顧體系之社區治理分析

并列篇名

Community Organizations Participating in Preventive Elderly Care System: An Analysis of the Community Governance Perspective

DOI

10.6171/ntuswr.201912_(40).0004

作者

蕭文高(Wen-Kao Hsiao)

关键词

社區組織 ； 社區治理 ； 照顧服務 ； community organizations ； community governance ； care services

期刊名称

臺大社會工作學刊

卷期/出版年月

40期（2019 / 12 / 01）

页次

131 - 166

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

為滿足民眾照顧需求，協助長者在地老化，政府逐步補助社區組織提供老人照顧服務，此不僅改變公私部門互動模式，亦影響社區之永續發展。因此，本研究目的在整理運用社區治理觀點，瞭解社區發展協會參與老人預防照顧面臨之挑戰，進而提出實務性建議。經彙整相關文獻後，本文分析社區組織在老人預防照顧體系之角色及組織特性，統整社區治理理論分析架構，歸納出長照2.0計畫建立照顧型社區目標面臨下列挑戰：（1）政府在政策量化績效與尊重社區自主性間產生社區主義價值抉擇兩難；（2）社區組織所獲支援不足，承擔過高照顧風險；（3）為確立服務品質與責信之管控機制，造成志工服務疏離感；（4）社區組織經歷政治力干擾、志工人力老化，以及服務排他性等失靈危機。基於前述發現，本研究建議公部門應提供社區組織足夠支持及影響評量訊息，改革績效管考機制，委託辦理專業督導計畫，並協調社區所需空間與服務支援，以增進計畫成效。
英文摘要

In order to satisfy citizens' care needs and help older people to age in place, the government gradually subsidized community organizations to delivery care services for older adults. Within this system, there have been significant changes in the public-private sector interaction and effects on community-based sustainable development. Therefore, this study aimed to examine community governance perspectives, analyze challenges of community development associations participating in preventive elderly care, and outline some practical implications and suggestions. Through a literature review, this article discusses the roles and characteristics of community organizations in the preventive elderly care system and explores four challenges of Long Term Care Plan 2.0 (LTCP2) with the objective of building a caring community: (1) Government is facing the communitarian dilemma between seeking quantitative policy performance and respecting community autonomy; (2) Community organizations are bearing the risk in caregiving because of insufficient support; (3) Mechanisms of quality control and accountability increase volunteers' service alienation; (4) Failures of community organizations occur during political disturbance, aging volunteers, and community exclusion. Based on the research findings and for the purpose of enhancing the effectiveness of LTCP2, this paper suggests that the government should provide sufficient support and impact assessment information for community organizations, improve management mechanisms, contract out professional supervision program, and arrange space and service support for communities.
主题分类 社會科學 > 社會學
参考文献
  1. 王仕圖, S.-T.(2013)。非營利組織在社區照顧服務的協調合作：以社區照顧關懷據點為例。臺大社會工作學刊，27，185-228。
    連結：
  2. 黃源協, Y.-S.,劉素珍, S.-J.,蕭文高, W.-K.(2011)。英國社區新政對台灣社區工作的啟示與借鏡：社區治理觀點的分析。臺大社會工作學刊，23，1-45。
    連結：
  3. Acharya, K. K.(2018).Transforming grassroots associations through community governance in Nepal.Participation,18(1),62-78.
  4. Acharya, K. K.(2016).Determinants of community governance for effective basic service delivery in Nepal.Dhaulagiri Journal of Sociology and Anthropology,10,166-201.
  5. Andrew, M.(2006).Learning to love (the state) again? Money, legitimacy and community sector politics.Australian Journal of Social Issues,41(3),313-326.
  6. Billis, D.,Glennerster, H.(1998).Human services and the voluntary sector: Towards a theory of comparative advantage.Journal of Social Policy,27(1),79-98.
  7. Blackshaw, T.(2010).Key concepts in community studies.London, England:Sage.
  8. Bowles, S.,Gintis, H.(2002).Social capital and community governance.The Economic Journal,112,419-436.
  9. Box, R.(1998).Citizen governance: Leading American communities into the 21st century.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  10. Castles, F. G.(Ed.),Leibfried, S.(Ed.),Lewis, J.(Ed.),Obinger, H.(Ed.),Pierson, C.(Ed.)(2010).The Oxford handbook of the welfare state.Oxford, England:Oxford University Press.
  11. Chanan, G.,Miller, C.(2013).Rethinking community practice: Developing transformative neighbourhoods.Bristol, England:The Policy Press.
  12. Cloutier, D.,Penning, M.,Nuernberger, K.,Hainstock, T.,Funk, L.,Taylor, D. D.,Kelly, R.(2016).Long-term care service delivery challenges for ageing in place in rural communities: A health region case study of home and residential care.Ageing resource communities: New frontiers of rural population change, community development and voluntarism,Abingdon, England:
  13. Dai, H.(2018).Community governance, welfare service provision and state power in changing Chinese village.Journal of Asia Public Policy
  14. DeFilippis, J.,Fisher, R.,Shragge, E.(2010).Contesting community: The limits and potential of local organizing.New Brunswick, NJ:Rutgers University Press.
  15. DeFilippis, J.,Fisher, R.,Shragge, E.(2006).Neither romance nor regulation: Re-evaluating community.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,30(3),673-689.
  16. Everingham, J.,Warburton, J.,Cuthill, M.,Bartlett, H.(2012).Collaborative governance of aging: Challenges for local government in partnering with the seniors’ sector.Local Government Studies,38(2),161-181.
  17. Gilchrist, A.(2009).The well-connected community: A networking approach to community development.Bristol, England:Policy Press.
  18. Gilchrist, A.,Taylor, M.(2016).The short guide to community development.Bristol, England:Policy Press.
  19. Green, G. P.,Haines, A.(2016).Asset building community development.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  20. Halsall, J. P.(2012).Community governance: Where did it go wrong.Journal of Administration and Governance,7(2),1-8.
  21. Hanlon, N.,Rosenberg, M.,Clasby, R.(2007).Offloading social care responsibilities: Recent experiences of local voluntary organisations in a remote urban centre in British Columbia, Canada.Health & Social Care in the Community,15(4),343-351.
  22. Hanlon, N.,Skinner, M.,Joseph, A.,Ryser, L.,Halseth, G.(2016).New frontiers of rural ageing: Resource hinterlands.Ageing resource communities: New frontiers of rural population change, community development and voluntarism,New York, NY:
  23. Hardill, I.,Baines, S.(2009).Active citizenship in later life: Older volunteers in a deprived community in England.The Professional Geographer,61(1),36-45.
  24. Hardill, I.,Dwyer, P.(2011).Delivering public services in the mixed economy of welfare: Perspectives from the voluntary and community sector in rural England.Journal of Social Policy,40(1),157-172.
  25. Hogg, E.,Baines, S.(2011).Changing responsibilities and roles of the voluntary and community Sector in the welfare mix: A review.Social Policy & Society,10(3),341-352.
  26. Howlett, M.,Ramesh, M.(2009).Studying public policy: Policy cycles and policy subsystems.Oxford, England:Oxford University Press.
  27. Kelly, K.,Caputo, T.(2011).Community: A contemporary analysis of policies, programs, and practices.North York, Canada:University of Toronto Press.
  28. Lager, D.,van Hoven, B.,Huigen, P. P.(2015).Understanding older adults’ social capital in place: Obstacles to and opportunities for social contacts in the neighbourhood.Geoforum,59,87-97.
  29. Lake, R. W.,Newman, K.(2002).Differential citizenship in the shadow state.GeoJournal,58(2-3),109-120.
  30. Ledwith, M.(2011).Community development: A critical approach.Bristol, England:The Policy Press.
  31. Leichsenring, K.(Ed.),Billing, J.(Ed.),Nies, H.(Ed.)(2013).Long-term care in Europe: Improving policy and practice.Basingstoke, England:Palgrave Macmillan.
  32. Lie, M.,Baines, S.,Wheelock, J.(2009).Citizenship, volunteering and active ageing.Social Policy & Administration,43(7),702-718.
  33. Lowndes, V.,Sullivan, H.(2008).How low can you go? Rationales and challenges for neighbourhood governance’.Public Administration,86(1),53-74.
  34. Macmillan, R.,Townsend, A.(2011).A ‘new institutional fix’? The ‘community turn’ and the changing role of the voluntary sector.Landscapes of voluntarism: New spaces of health, welfare and governance,Bristol, England:
  35. Martin, S.(2010).From new public management to networked community governance? Strategic local public services networks in England.The new public governance? Emerging perspectives on the theory and practice of public governance,Abingdon, England:
  36. McDonald, C.,Marston, G.(2002).Patterns of governance: The curious case of non-profit community services in Australia.Social Policy & Administration,36(4),376-391.
  37. McGovern, P.(2017).Small voluntary organisations in the ‘age of austerity’: Funding challenges and opportunities.London, England:Palgrave..
  38. McKinlay P.,Pillora, S.,Tan, S. F.,von Tunzelmann, A.(2011).Evolution in community governance: Building on what works.Sydney, Australian:Australian Centre of Excellence for Local Government, University of Technology Sydney.
  39. McKinlay, P.(2016).Community Governance.Policy Quarterly,12(4),36-41.
  40. Milligan, C.(Ed.),Conradson, D.(Ed.)(2011).Landscapes of voluntarism: New spaces of health, welfare and governance.Bristol, England:The Policy Press.
  41. Milligan, C.,Fyfe, N. R.(2005).Preserving space for volunteers: Exploring the links between voluntary welfare organisations, volunteering and citizenship.Urban Studies,42(3),417-433.
  42. Murdoch, J.,Abram, S.(1998).Defining the limits of community governance.Journal of Rural Studies,14(1),41-50.
  43. National Audit Office(2005).Working with voluntary sector: Home office.London, England:The Stationary Office.
  44. Newman, J.,Clarke, J.(2016).The politics of deploying community.Politics, power and community development,Bristol, England:
  45. O’Hare, P(2018).Resisting the ‘long-arm’ of the state? Spheres of capture and opportunities for autonomy in community governance.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,42(2),210-225.
  46. Orsini, M.(2006).From ‘community run’ to ‘community based’? Exploring the dynamics of civil society-state transformation in urban Montreal.Canadian Journal of Urban Research,15(1),22-40.
  47. Osborne, S. P.(2010).The (new) public governance: A suitable case for treatment?.The new public governance? Emerging perspectives on the theory and practice of public governance,Abingdon, England:
  48. Osborne, S. P.(Ed.)(2010).The new public governance? Emerging perspectives on the theory and practice of public governance.Abingdon, England:Routledge.
  49. Rubin, H. R.,Rubin, I. S.(2008).Community organizing and development.Boston, MA:Pearson/Allyn & Bacon.
  50. Salamon, L. M.(1987).Of market failure, voluntary failure, and third-party government: Toward a theory of government-nonprofit relations in the modern welfare state.Journal of Voluntary Action Research,16(1-2),29-49.
  51. Scott, M.(Ed.),Gallent, N.(Ed.),Gkartzios, M.(Ed.)(2019).The Routledge companion to urban planning.Abingdon, England:Routledge.
  52. Skidmore, P.,Bound, K.,Lownsbrough, H.(2006).Community participation: Who benefits?.York, England:Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
  53. Skinner, M. W.,Joseph, A. E.,Hanlon, N.,Halseth, G.,Ryser, L.(2014).Growing old in resource communities: Exploring the links among voluntarism, aging, and community development.The Canadian Geographer,58(4),418-428.
  54. Somerville, P.(2016).Understanding community: Politics, policy and practice.Bristol, England:Policy Press.
  55. Somerville, P.(2011).Multiscalarity and neighbourhood governance.Public Policy and Administration,26(1),81-105.
  56. Taylor, M.(2011).Public policy in the community.Basingstoke, England:Palgrave Macmillan.
  57. Trudeau, D.(2008).Junior partner or empowered community? The role of non-profit social services providers amidst state restructuring in the US.Urban Studies,45(13),2805-2827.
  58. Vasunilashorn, S.,Steinman, B. A.,Liebig, P. S.,Pynoos, J.(2012).Aging in place: Evolution of a research topic whose time has come.Journal of Aging Research,2012,Article ID 120952.
  59. Walsh, K.(Ed.),Carney, G. M.(Ed.),Leime, A. Ni(Ed.)(2015).Active ageing: Social participation and volunteering in later life Ageing through austerity: Critical perspectives from Ireland.Bristol, England:Policy Press.
  60. Weicht, B.(2015).The meaning of care: The social construction of care for elderly people.Basingstoke, England:Palgrave Macmillan.
  61. Weil, M.(Ed.),Reisch, M.(Ed.),Ohmer, M. L.(Ed.)(2013).The handbook of community practice.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  62. Weil, M.(Ed.),Reisch, M.(Ed.),Ohmer, M. L.(Ed.)(2013).The handbook of community practice.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  63. Wenger, G. C.(1990).The special role of friends and neighbors.Journal of Aging Studies,4(2),149-169.
  64. Westwood, S.(Ed.)(2019).Ageing, diversity and equality: Social justice perspectives.Abingdon, England:Routledge.
  65. WHO(2015).World report on ageing and health.Geneva, Switzerland:WHO.
  66. Wills, J.(2016).Locating localism: statecraft, citizenship and democracy.Bristol, England:Policy Press.
  67. Winterton, R.,Warburton, J.,Clune, S.,Martin, J.(2014).Building community and organisational capacity to enable social participation for ageing Australian rural populations: A resource-based perspective.Ageing International,39,163-179.
  68. Winterton, R.,Warburton, J.,Trobe, L(2014).Healthy ageing in Australia's rural place: The contribution of older volunteers.Voluntary Sector Review,5(2),181-201.
  69. 孫智辰, J.-C.(2017)。社區照顧關懷據點轉型設置巷弄長照站的可能與限制─以臺南市資源不足區為例。台灣社區工作與社區研究學刊，7(2)，97-148。
  70. 張英陣, Y.-C.(2016)。福利社區化的省思：社區治理的觀點。社區發展季刊，154，44-55。
  71. 張英陣, Y.-C.(2004)。社區照顧與非營利組織。社區發展季刊，106，60-67。
  72. 黃松林, S.-L.,趙善如, S.-R.(2007)。社區照顧關懷據點模式之研究─以高雄市為例。台灣健康照顧研究學刊，2，63-90。
  73. 監察院（2019）。〈「108 內調 0009 號」調查報告〉。取自 https://www.cy.gov.tw/sp.asp?xdURL=./di/RSS/detail.asp&ctNode=871&mp=1&no=6457 【The Control Yuan. (2019). Investigation Report No. 0009, 2019. Retrieved from https://www.cy.gov.tw/sp.asp?xdURL=./di/RSS/detail.asp&ctNode=871&mp=1&no=6457】
  74. 衛生福利部（2018）。《社區整體照顧服務體系計畫行政作業須知》。台北市：衛生福利部。【Ministry of Health and Welfare. (2018). Guidelines for community comprehensive care service system. Taipei, Taiwan: Ministry of Health and Welfare.】
  75. 衛生福利部=Ministry of Health and Welfare(2016)。衛生福利部（2016）。《長期照顧十年計畫 2.0（106～115 年）》。台北市：衛生福利部。【Ministry of Health and Welfare. (2016). Long Term Care Plan 2.0 (2017-2026). Taipei, Taiwan: Ministry of Health and Welfare.】。
  76. 蕭文高, W.-K.(2016)。十年有成：社區照顧關懷據點計畫之挑戰與前瞻。社區發展季刊，154，118-131。
  77. 賴兩陽, L.-Y.(2004)。社區發展協會推動福利社區化的策略分析。社區發展季刊，106，68-78。
  78. 賴兩陽, L.-Y.(2009).社區工作與福利社區化.台北市=Taipei, Taiwan:洪葉=Hungyeh Publication.
  79. 簡慧娟, H.-J.,莊金珠, C.-C.,楊雅嵐, Y.-L.(2013)。我國長期照顧十年計畫現況與檢討。社區發展季刊，141，6-18。
被引用次数
  1. 蕭文高(2021)。政策變遷下之社區社會工作專業職能與教育省思。東吳社會工作學報，40，63-88。
  2. 蕭文高(2023)。社區照顧關懷據點督導人員之專業角色壓力與職能需求。臺大社會工作學刊，48，115-155。
  3. (2022)。本土社區輔導實務工作模式之建構。社區發展季刊，179，62-79。
  4. (2022)。長照C據點辦理單位的組織類型分析。社區發展季刊，178，389-403。
  5. (2024)。社區治理下的公民參與、網絡與權力—對社區工作的意涵。社區發展季刊，186，110-125。
print cancel