题名

Organizational Learning through Evaluation: A Challenge for Libraries

并列篇名

圖書館的挑戰：經由評鑑促進組織學習

DOI

10.6146/univj.2008.12-2.03

作者

陳冠年(Kuan-Nien Chen)；林蓓君(Pei-Chun Lin)；孫浩章(Hao-Chang Sun)；蔡文惠(Wen-Hui Tsai)

关键词

組織學習 ； 學習型組織 ； 圖書館評鑑 ； 圖書館管理 ； organizational learning ； Library evaluation ； Learning organization ； Library management

期刊名称

大學圖書館

卷期/出版年月

12卷2期（2008 / 09 / 01）

页次

42 - 78

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

本文按視組織學習理論和圖書館評鑑相關文獻，並進行系統性整理－耙梳重點，釐清脈絡，摘取經典，啓發思辯，旨在促使相關研究者更加暸解組織學習與圖書館詳鑑兩者之關聯，循其軌跡，觀其影響，提出更為合理有效之理論模式。 從圖書館評鑑的方向思考，評鑑的過程和功能理應涵納組織學習的意義，試圖營造圖書館成為學習型組織。為達此目的，評鑑設計者、評鑑執行者、評鑑決策者和被評鑑之組織都應具備共識，從制度面、領導面、執行面和學習面自我檢驗，期改善詳鑑水準，奠定、組織良性體質，裨益於圖書館永續發展。
英文摘要

This paper examines some of the current discussion in the literature of organizational learning theory and library evaluation, from which to derive a better understanding of how library evaluation can assist in the improvement of Libraries as learning organizations. The theoretical work of Argyris and Schon (single-loop and double-loop learning) and Crossan, Lane and White (the cognitive processes of intuiting, interpreting, integrating and institutionalizing) was considered, together with that of later theorists. Emphasis in the literature is collectively placed on the role of individuals within organizations, and how the organizations themselves should be a product of the creativity of those individuals and the enabling organizational structures. Library evaluation plays or should play a critical role in both enabling libraries to become learning organizations in this sense, and sustaining such continuing organizational development. In general there has been insufficient attention to how library evaluation can be effectively integrated in the library as a continuing planning and responding process. A more sophisticated approach must be taken, especially in view of the increased challenges and responsibilities which academic libraries are now facing.
主题分类 人文學 > 圖書資訊學
参考文献
  1. Albritton, R. L.(1995).Transformational leadership in academic libraries: An empirical study of the model and its relationship to perceived organizational effectiveness.Advances in Library Administration and Organization,13,57-110.
  2. Alderfer, C.,Brown, L. D.(1975).Learning from changing.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  3. Alemna, A. A.(1999).Library evaluation: Some options for academic libraries.Aslib Proceedings: New Information Perspectives,51(7),243-246.
  4. Allan, B.(1999).Developing information and library staff through work based learning: 101 activities.London:Library Association.
  5. Argyris, C.(1993).Education for leading-learning.Organizational Dynamics,Winter,5-17.
  6. Argyris, C.,Schon, D. A.(1978).Organizational learning: A theory of action perspective.Reading, MA:Addison-Wesley.
  7. Barker, R. T.,Camarata, M. R.(1998).The role of communication in creating and maintaining a learning organization: preconditions, indicators, and disciplines.Journal of Business Communication,35(4),443-467.
  8. Bennett, J. A.(2001).The relationship between team and organizational learning.International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance,14(1),14-20.
  9. Bhat, D. N. S.(2001).Sound change.New Delhi:Motilal Banarsidass.
  10. Billett, S.(2001).Learning in the workplace: Strategies for effective practice.Crows Nest, Sydney:Allen & Unwin.
  11. Bond, M.(1997).A learning team in the making.Journal of Interprofessional Care,11(1),89-97.
  12. Brinkerhoff, R.(2005).The success case method: A strategic evaluation approach to increasing the value and effect of training.Advances in Developing Human Resources,7(1),86-101.
  13. Buckley, P. S.,Carter, M. J.(1999).Managing cross-border complementary knowledge: conceptual developments in the business process approach to knowledge management in multinational firms (global competitiveness and national attractiveness).International Studies of Management & Organization,29(1),80-104.
  14. Caffoll, J. S.(1998).Organizational learning activities in high-hazard industries: The logics underlying self-analysis.Journal of Management Studies,35(6),699-717.
  15. Calvert, P. J.(1997).Developing indicators for academic library performance: Ratios from the ARL Statistics 1992-93 and 1993-94.Library Acquisitions: Practice and Theory,21(3),412-413.
  16. Calvert, P. J.(1997).Measuring service quality: From theory into practice.Australian Academic and Research Libraries,28,198-204.
  17. Canen, A.,Oliveira, M. T.(2000).Institutional Evaluation in the Mercosur: Transformation or control?.International Journal of Educational Development,20,277-286.
  18. Carley, K. M.,Harrald, J. R.(1997).Organizational learning under fire.American Behavioral Scientist,40(3),310-332.
  19. Carnall, C. A.(1999).Managing change in organizations.Harlow England:Prentice Hall.
  20. Casserly, M. F.(1987).Accreditation-related self-study as a planned change process: Factors relating to its success in academic libraries.Journal of Library Administration,8(1),85-105.
  21. Cherin, D.,Meezan, W.(1998).Evaluation as a means of organizational learning.Administration in Social Work,22(2),1-21.
  22. Clayton, P.,F. Nicholson (Eds.),M. Rochester (Eds.)(1996).Best practice: Challenges in library management.Adelaide:Auslib Press.
  23. Cole, F.(2000).Assessing service quality: Satisfying the expectations of library customers.International Journal of Information Management,20(1),87-88.
  24. Cook, D. N.,Yanow, M.,M. D. Cohen (Eds.),L. S. Eproull (Eds.)(1996).Organizational learning.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  25. Coopey, J.,Burgoyne, J.(2000).Politics and organizational learning.Journal of Management Studies,37(6),869-886.
  26. Cousins, J. B.,Earl, L. M.(1995).Participatory evaluation: enhancing evaluation use and organizational learning capacity.The Evaluation Exchange,1(3/4),2-3.
  27. Crossan, M. M.,Berdrow, I.(2003).Organizational learning and strategic renewal.Strategic Management Journal,24(11),1087-1130.
  28. Crossan, M. M.,Lane, H. W.,White, R. E.(2003).An organizational learning framework: from intuition to institution.Academy of Management Review,24(11),1087-1130.
  29. Cullen, R.(2001).Perspectives on user satisfaction surveys.Library Trends,49(4),662.
  30. Daft, R. L(2004).Organization theory and design.Sydney:South-Western.
  31. Day, M. T.(1998).Transformational discourse: Ideologies of organizational change in the academic libraries and information science literature.Library Trend,46(4),635-667.
  32. DiBella, A. J.,Nevis, B. C.(1998).How organizations learn: An integrated strategy for building learning capability.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
  33. Dodgson, M.(1993).Organizational learning: a review of some literatures.Organization Studies,14(3),375-394.
  34. Dugan, R. E.,Hernon, P.(2002).Outcomes assessment: Not synonymous with inputs and outputs.The Journal of Academic Librarianship,28(6),376-380.
  35. Duncan, R.,Weiss, A.(1979).Organizational learning: Implications for organizational design.Research in Organizational Behavior,1,75-123.
  36. Dunford, R. W.(1992).Organizational behavior: An organizational analysis perspective.Melbourne:Addison Wesley Longman Australia.
  37. Dutta, D. K.,Crossan, M. M.(2005).The nature of entrepreneurial activities: Understanding the process using the 41 organizational learning framework.Entrepreneurship: Theory and Practice,29(4),425-450.
  38. Espejo, R.,Schuhmann, W.,Schwaninger, M.,Bilello, U.(1996).Organizational transformation and learning.Chichester, UK:John Wiley.
  39. Fenwick, T.,S Scott (Eds.),B. Spencer (Eds.),A. Thomas (Eds.)(1998).Learning for life: Canadian readings in adult education.Toronto:Thompson.
  40. Forss, K.,Cracknell, B.,Samset, K.(1994).Can evaluation help an organization to learn?.Evaluation Review,18(5),574-591.
  41. Fowler, R. K.(1998).The university library as learning organization for innovation: An exploratory study.College and Research Libraries,59(3),220-231.
  42. Friedman, V. J.(2002).The individual as agent of organizational learning.California Management Review,44(2),70-89.
  43. Giesecke, J.,McNeil B.(2004).Transitioning to the learning organization.Library Trends,53(1),54-67.
  44. Golding, N.,I. Beardwell (Eds.),L. Holden (Eds.),T. Claydon. (Eds.)(2004).Human resource management: A contemporary approach.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
  45. Gumbley, H.(1998).Knowledge management.Work Study,47(5),175-177.
  46. Hankinson, P.(1999).An empirical study which compares the organizational structures of companies managing the World's Top 100 brands with those managing outsider brands.The Journal of Product and Brand Management,18(5),402-414.
  47. Hansson, F.(2006).Organizational use of evaluations: Governance and control in research evaluation.Evaluation,12(2),159-178.
  48. Haynes, A.(2004).Bridging the gulf: Mixed methods and library service evaluation.Australian Library Journal,53(3),285-307.
  49. Hedberg, B.,Nystrom, P. C. (Eds.),Starbuck, W. H. (Eds.)(1981).Handbook of organization design.Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
  50. Hendry, C.(1996).Understanding and creating whole organizational change through learning theory.Human Relations,49(5),621-641.
  51. Hernon, P.(2003).The next library leadership: Attributes of academic and public library directors.Westport, CT:Libraries Unlimited.
  52. Jenhink, P. M.(1994).Using evaluation to understand the learning architecture of an organizational.Evaluation and Program Planning,17(3),315-325.
  53. Jenlink, P. M.,Torres, Rosalie T.,P.M. Jenlink (Ed.)(1994).Systemic change anthology.Palatine, IL:Skylight.
  54. Jensen, J. A.,Rasmussen, O. E.(2004).An inquiry into the foundations of organizational learning and the learning organization.The Learning Organization: An International Journal,11(6),478-490.
  55. Kim, D. H.(1993).The link between individual and organizational learning.Sloan Management Review,35(1),37-50.
  56. Kofman, F.,Senge, R M.(1993).Communities of commitment: The heart of learning organizations.Organizational Dynamics,22(2),5-23.
  57. Electronic Journal of Academic and Special Librarianship
  58. Kyrillidou, M.(2002).From input and output measures to quality and outcome measures, or, from the user in the life of the library to the library in the life of the user.Journal of Academic Librarianship,28(1),42-46.
  59. Lahti, R. K.,Beyerlein, M. M.(2000).Knowledge transfer and management consulting: a look at 'the firm'.Business Horizons,January-February,65-74.
  60. Lee-Thomas, G.,Robson, J.(2004).The questions of academic library assessment.Indiana Libraries,23(1),6-10.
  61. Leeuw, F. L. (eds.),Sonnichsen, R. C. (eds.),R. C. Rist (eds.)(1994).Can governments learn? Comparative perspectives on evaluation and organizational learning.Brunswick, NJ:Transaction.
  62. Legge, K.(1984).Evaluating planned organizational change.London:Academic Press.
  63. Leroy, F.,Ramanantsoa, B.(1997).The cognitive and behavioural dimensions of organizational learning in a merger: An empirical study.Journal of Management Studies,34(6),871-895.
  64. Levitt, B.,March, J. G.(1988).Organizational learning.Annual Review Sociology,14,319-340.
  65. Lewis, M.,Moultrie, J.(2005).The organizational innovation laboratory.Creativity and Innovation Management,14(1),73-83.
  66. Lipshitz, R.,Popper, M.,Friedman, V. J.(2002).A multifacet model of organizational learning.Journal of Applied Behavioural Sciences,38(1),78-98.
  67. Lloyd, B.(1996).Knowledge management: The key to long-term organizational success.Long Range Planning,29(4),576-580.
  68. Lopez, P. S.,Peon, M. J. M.,Ordas, V. C. J.(2005).Organizational learning as a determining factor in business performance.The Learning Organization: An International Journal,12(3),227-245.
  69. Marcum, J, W.(1996).Can the college library become a learning organization?.Advances in Library Administration and Organization,14,39-62.
  70. Marquardt, S.(1996).Managing technological change by changing performance appraisal to performance evaluation.Journal of Library Administration,22(2/3),101-110.
  71. Marsick, V,Bitterman, J.,Van der Veen, R.(2000).From the learning organization to learning communities toward a learning society.(ERIC ED440294) Information Series No. 382.
  72. Miller, D.(1996).A preliminary typology of organizational learning: Synthesizing the literature.Journal of Management,22(3),485-505.
  73. Miller, R. I.(1979).The assessment of college performance.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
  74. Mink, O. G.,Esterhuysen, P. W.,Mink, B. P.,Owen, K. Q.(1993).Change at work: A comprehensive management process for transforming organizations.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  75. Mohrman, S. A.,Mohrman, A. M.,Galbraith, J. R (Eds.),Lawler III E. E. (Eds.)(1993).Organizing for the Future: The new logic for managing complex organizations.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  76. Morris, T.,Empson, L.(1998).Organization and expertise: An exploration of knowledge bases and the management of accounting and consulting firms.Accounting, Organizations and Society,23(5),609-624.
  77. Nevis, E. C.,DiBella, A. J.,Gould, J. M.(1995).Understanding organizations as learning systems.Sloan Management Review,36(2),73-85.
  78. O''Connor, W. E.,Morrison, T. G.(2001).A comparison of situational and dispositional predictors of perceptions of organizational politics.The Journal of Psychology,135(3),301-326.
  79. Offsey, S.(1997).Knowledge management: Linking people to knowledge for bottom line results.Journal of Knowledge Management,1(2),113-122.
  80. Olausson, C.(1992).Evaluation in university libraries: A tool for development?.Libri,42(1),63-74.
  81. Oldroyd, M.(2004).Developing academic library staff for future success.London:Facet.
  82. Ortenblad, A.(2005).Of course organizations can learn The Learning Organization.An International Journal,12(2),213-218.
  83. Pedler, M.,Burgoyne, J.,Boydell, T.(1997).The Learning company: A strategy for sustainable development.London:McGraw-Hill.
  84. Phipps, S. E.,G.isela M. (Eds),Von Dran (Eds),J. Cargill (Eds)(1993).Catalysts for change: Managing libraries in the 1990s.NY:Haworth Press.
  85. Powell, R. R.(2006).Evaluation research: An overview.Library Trends,55(1),102-120.
  86. Preskill, H.(1994).Evaluation's role in enhancing organizational learning.Evaluation and Program Planning,17(3),291-297.
  87. Preskill, H.,Torres, R. T.(1999).Evaluative inquiry for learning in organizations.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  88. Pritchard, S. M.(1996).Determining quality in academic libraries.Library Trends,44(3),572-594.
  89. Quinn, B.(1997).Adapting service quality concepts to academic libraries.The Journal of Academic Librarianship,23(5),359-369.
  90. Rhodes, J.,Lok, P.,Hung, R.,Fang, S.(2008).An integrative model of organizational learning and social capital on effective knowledge transfer and perceived organizational performance.Journal of Workplace Learning,20(4),245-258.
  91. Rist, R. C.(1997).Evaluation and organizational learning.1997 Australasian Evaluation Society International Conference,Adelaide, Australia:
  92. Roberts, S.,Rowley, J.(2004).Managing information services.London:Facet.
  93. Robinson, T.,Cousins, J. B.(2004).Internal participatory evaluation as an organizational learning system: A longitudinal case study.Studies in Educational Evaluation,30,1-22.
  94. Roffe, I.(1999).Innovation and creativity in organizations: A review of the implications for training and development.Journal of European Industrial Training,23(4/5),224-241.
  95. Rosenberg, M. J.(2001).E-leaning: strategies for delivering knowledge in the digital age.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  96. 5th Biennial Conference of the EES in Seville
  97. Rowley, J.(1997).The library as a Learning organization.Library Management,18(2),88-91.
  98. Rowley, J.(1999).What is knowledge management?.Library Management,20(6),416-419.
  99. Schulz, M.,Jobe, L. A.(2001).Codification and tacitness as knowledge management strategies: An empirical exploration.Journal of High Technology Management Research,12(1),139-165.
  100. Senge, P.(1990).The fifth discipline: the art and practice of the learning organization.New York:Doubleday.
  101. Shipton, H.,Fay, D.,West, M.,Patterson, M.,Birdi, K.(2005).Managing people to promote innovation.Creativity and Innovation Management,14(2),118-128.
  102. Stewart, T. A.(1991).Brainpower: Intellectual capital is becoming corporate America's most valuable asset and can be its sharpest competitive weapon; the challenge is to find what you have-and use it.Fortune,123(11),3-6.
  103. Stone, R. S.(2002).Human resource management.Brisbane, Australia:John Wiley and Sons.
  104. Stueart, R. D.,Moran, B. B.(1987).Library management.Littleton, CO:Libraries Unlimited.
  105. Tones, R. T.,Preskill, H.(2001).Evaluation and learning: Past, present, and future.American Journal of Evaluation,22(3),387-395.
  106. Torres, R. T.,Preskill, H.,Piontek, M. E.(1996).Evaluation strategies for communicating and reporting; Enhancing learning in organizations.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
  107. Ulrich, D.,Jick, T.,Glinow, M. A.(1993).High-impact leaning: Building and diffusing learning capability.Organizational Dynamics,22(2),52-66.
  108. Vakola, M.(2000).Exploring the relationship between the use of evaluation in business process re-engineering and organizational learning and innovation.Journal of Management Development,19(10),812-835.
  109. Wallace, D. P. (Eds.),Fleet, C. V. (Eds.)(2001).Library evaluation: A casebook and can-do guide.Englewood, Colo.:Libraries Unlimited.
  110. Watkins, K. E.,Marsick, V. J.(1992).Building the learning organization.Studies in Continuing Education,14(2),115-129.
  111. Watson, T. (Eds.),J. Leopold (Eds.),L. Harris (Eds.)(2005).The strategic managing of human resource.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
  112. Weiss, C. H.(1998).Evaluation.Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall.
  113. Wenzler, I.,Chartier, D.(1999).Why do we bother with games and simulations: an organizational learning perspective.Simulation & Gaming,30(3),375-384.
  114. Williams, D. B.(1983).Evaluation and the process of change in academic libraries.Advances in Library Administration and Organization,2,151-174.
被引用次数
  1. 劉幸真、王鳳雄(2011)。校長評鑑之趨勢與省思。學校行政，76，234-254。
  2. 鄭淑惠(2009)。教育評鑑的效用性：促進組織學習的觀點。新竹教育大學學報，26(2)，57-88。
print cancel