The Assessment of a Hospital-Based Care Management Model for Long-Term Care Services

長期照護之醫院型照顧管理模式評估

紀櫻珍(Ying-Chen Chi)；莊坤洋(Kun-Yang Chuang)；吳淑瓊(Shwu-Chong Wu)；黃國哲(Kuo-Cherh Huang)；吳振龍(Chen-Long Wu)

照顧管理模式 ； 成效評估 ； 長期照護 ； care management model ； effectiveness evaluation ； long-term care

The Journal of Nursing Research

12卷4期（2004 / 12 / 01）

317 - 326

英文

本研究旨在評估醫院型照護管理模式對功能障礙老人之成效。用縱貫式類實驗研究設計，研究對象爲居住在台北市大案行政區之功能障礙老人共331位，失道寡助照顧管理模式服務者爲實驗組，計166人，未接受服務者爲對照組，計165人，並於照顧管理模式服務介入前與介入後收集相關資料。使用邏輯式回歸分析探討照顧管理模式的介入對醫療費用、自評健康及對長期護之滿意度的相關性。研究主要發現照顧管理模式介入一年後，相較於對照組，實驗組比較可減少醫療費用支出，並維持或增加其對長期照護報務的滿意度，其差異均達到統計上顯著相關，但在自評健康方面則無相關性存在。綜而言之，醫院型照顧管理模式服務減少功能障礙老人在醫療服務的使用，及提昇個案與照顧者的滿意度，並爲連結長期照護服務之重要轉介單位，起泡沫爲應落實建立一套健全之照顧管理模式，並評估其成效。

The purpose of this research was to assess the effectiveness of a hospital-based care management model on disabled elderly people. A before-and-after quasi-experimental design was adopted. A total of 331 disabled elderly people, residing in the Da-An District of Taipei City, participated in the study. Among them, 166 received care management, while the other 165 did not. The latter served as controls Baseline and follow-up data collection were carried out before and after care management intervention. Logistic regression analysis was used to test the effects of care management on medical care expenditure, self-rated health, and satisfaction with long-term care arrangement. The results showed that those under care management, compared to the controls, were more likely to experience a decrease in medical care expenditure, and less likely to have a decrease in satisfaction with long-term care. The effects were statistically significant. However, there was no effect on self-rated health. The findings show that hospital-based care management is a viable option and has the potential to become an important segment in the delivery of long-term care services. More effort should be expended in its development and in the evaluation of its effectiveness.

1. Allen, N. E.,Meduna, E.(1999).Case management of interdisciplinary team in congenital heart failure's pa-tients.New England Journal of Medicine,311,162-182.
2. Anderson-Loftin, W.(1995).A case study of nursing case management in a rural hospital.Nursing Administra-tion Quarterly,19(3),33-40.
3. Anthony, M. K.,Hudson-Barr, D. C.(1998).Successful discharge: A comprehensive model of facilitators and barriers.Journal of Nursing Administration,28(3),48-55.
4. Bull, M. J.,Hansen, H. E.,Gross, C. R.(2000).A professional-patient partnership model of discharge planning with elders hospitalized with heart failure.Applied Nursing Research,13(1),19-28.
5. Fillenbaum, G. G.(1988).Multidimensional functional as-sessment of older adults: The duke older Americans resources and services procedures.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
6. Lim, W. K.,Lambert, S. F.,Gray, L. C.(2003).Effec-tiveness of case management and post-acute services in older people after hospital discharge.Medical Jour-nal of Australia,178(6),262-266.
7. Lin, Y. M.,Lee, L. C.,Wu, S. L.,Chen, C. Y.(2000).Case management and its effectiveness on total hip replacement.Medical Digest,30(2),178-184.
8. Major indicators analysis of elder population
9. Mui, A. C.,Burnette, J. D.(1994).A comparative pro-file of frail elderly persons liv-ing alone and those living with others.Journal of Gerontological Social Work,21(3/4),5-26.
10. Oslin, D. W.,Thompson, R.,Kallan, M. J.,TenHave, T.,Blow, F. C.,Bastani, R.(2004).Treatment ef-fects from UPBEAT: A randomized trial of care man-agement for behavioral health problems in hospital-ized elderly patients.Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry & Neurology,17(2),99-106.
11. Pei, X.,Pillai, V. K.(1999).Old age support in China: The role of the state and the family.International Journal of Aging & Human Development,49(3),197-212.
12. Proctor, E. K.,Morrow-Howell, N.,Kaplan, S. J.(1996).Implementation of discharge plans for chronically ill elders discharge home.Health & Social Work,21(1),30-40.
13. Sohl, P. E.(1986).Case management & patients care.Nursing Management,14(2),138-156.
14. Williams, M. E.,Williams, T. F.,Zimmer, J. G.(1987).How does the team approach to outpatient geriatric evaluation compare with traditional care: A report of a randomized controlled trial.Journal of the Ameri-can Geriatric Society,35(12),1071-1078.
15. Wu, S. C.,Chuang, K. Y.(2001).Aging in place: The direction of Taiwan long-term care policy in the 21st century.Taiwan Journal of Public Health,20(3),192-201.
16. Zimmer, J. G.,Juncker, A. G.,McCusker, J.(1985).randomized controlled study of a home health team.American Journal of Public Health,75,134-141.

1. 鍾玉珠,徐敏芳(2022)。運用系統性文獻回顧探討長期照顧管理制度之成效。領導護理，23(1)，1-10。