Applying Watson's Nursing Theory to Assess Patient Perceptions of Being Cared for in a Multicultural Environment

Wafika A. Suliman；Elizabeth Welmann；Tagwa Omer；Laisamma Thomas

caring behaviors ； Jean Watson's theory ； nursing care ； patient perception

The Journal of Nursing Research

17卷4期（2009 / 12 / 01）

293 - 300

英文

Background: J. Watson's (2002) caring theory addresses caring relationships among humans and the deep experiences of life itself. M. Leininger (1988) noted that caring is a universal phenomenon, which is likely to be perceived differently by patients and nurses if they come from different cultural backgrounds. Little is known about the patients' perception of ”being cared for” in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, where most nurses in the workforce come from cultural backgrounds different from their patients. Purpose: This study was designed to explore Saudi patient perceptions of important caring behaviors and those most frequently attended to by staff nurses in a multicultural environment. Methods: A questionnaire survey was used to explore discrepancies between the perceived importance of caring behaviors and how frequently those caring behaviors were attended to by staff nurses. A probability sample of 393 patients was drawn from three hospitals in three different regions of Saudi Arabia. The Caring Behaviors Assessment instrument of S. N. Cronin and B. Harrison (1988) was used in data collection. Results: Patients rated overall caring behaviors as important (97.2%) and frequently experienced (73.7%). The discrepancy between the importance of and frequency of attendance to caring behaviors by nurses was statistically significant (t=-4.689, p=.001). Conclusions and Implications for Practice: The caring behaviors based upon Jean Watson's theory were valued by Saudi patients irrespective of their cultural differences with the caregiver. However, the frequency of caring attended to by nurses in teaching/learning and helping/trust behavior subcategories were rated lower. Such is most likely the result of culture differences and language barriers existing between patients and nurses in Saudi Arabia. Results showed that the carative factors in Jean Watson's theory were also applicable to patients in Saudi Arabia and that nursing professionals should base their care on such theory to meet patient needs.

1. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing
2. Brilowski, G. A.,Wendler, M. C.(2005).An evolutionary concept analysis of caring.Journal of Advanced Nursing,50(6),641-650.
3. Brunton, B.,Beaman, M.(2000).Nurse practitioners' perceptions of their caring behaviors.Journal of the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners,12(11),451-456.
4. Cortis, J. D.(2000).Caring as experienced by minority ethnic patients.International Nursing Review,47(1),53-62.
5. Cronin, S.N.,Harrison, B.,J. Watson (Ed.)(1988).Assessing and measuring caring in nursing and health science.New York:Springer.
6. Drach-Zahavy, A.(2009).Patient-centered care and nurses' health: The role of nurses' caring orientation.Journal of Advanced Nursing,65(7),1463-1474.
7. Frank, C.,Asp, M.,Dahlberg, K.(2008).Patient participation in emergency care-a phenomenographic analysis of caregivers' conceptions.Journal of Clinical Nursing,18,2555-2562.
8. Frank, C.,Asp, M.,Dahlberg, K.(2009).Patient participation in emergency care-a phenomenographic study on patients' lived experience.International Emergency Nursing,17(1),15-22.
9. Green-Hernandez, C.,Quinn, A. A.(2004).Making nursing care culturally competent.Holistic Nursing Practice,18(4),215-218.
10. Halligan, P.(2005).Caring for patients of Islamic denomination: Critical care nurses' experiences in Saudi Arabia.Journal of Clinical Nursing,15(12),1565-1573.
11. Hayes, J.,Tyler-Ball, S.(2007).Perceptions of nurses' caring behaviors by trauma patients.Journal of Trauma Nursing,14(4),187-190.
12. Henderson, A.,Vaneps, M. A.,Pearson, K.,James, C.,Henderson, P.,Osborne, Y.(2007).'Caring for' behaviors that indicate to patients that nurses 'care about' them.Journal of Advanced Nursing,60(2),146-153.
13. Knott, P.(2002).How does the culture influence health care.Physician Assistant,26(4),21-37.
14. Leininger, M.(2002).Culture care theory: A major contribution to advance transcultural nursing knowledge and practices.Journal of Transcultural Nursing,13(3),189-192.
15. Leininger, M.,M. M. Leininger (Ed.)(1988).Caring: An essential human need.Detroit, MI:Wayne State University Press.
16. Liu, J. E.,Mok, E.,Wong, T.(2006).Caring in nursing: Investigating the meaning of caring from the perspective of cancer patients in Beijing, China.Journal of Clinical Nursing,15(2),188-196.
17. Lynn, M. L.(2007).Understanding and measuring patients' assessment of the quality of nursing care.Nursing,56(3),159-166.
18. Manogin, W. T.,Bechtel, G. A.,Rami, J. S.(2000).Caring behavior by nurses-women's perception during child birth.Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic and Neonatal Nursing,29(2),153-157.
19. Radwin, L. E.,Farquhar, S. L.,Knowles, M. N.,Virchick, B. G.(2005).Cancer patients' descriptions of their nursing care.Journal of Advanced Nursing,50(2),162-169.
20. Riccio, P.(2000).Quality evaluation of home nursing care: Perceptions of patients, physicians, and nurses.Nursing Administration,24(3),43-52.
21. Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences
22. Watson, J.(2002).Intentionality and caring-healing consciousness. A practice of transpersonal nursing.Holistic Nursing Practice,16(4),12-19.
23. Wilkin, K.,Slevin, E.(2004).The meaning of caring to nurses: An investigation into the nature of caring work in an intensive care unit.Journal of Clinical Nursing,13(1),50-59.
24. Wiman, E.,Wikblad, K.(2004).Caring and uncaring encounters in nursing in an emergency department.Journal of Clinical Nursing,13(4),422-429.