Care, Autonomy, and Gender in Nursing Practice: A Historical Study of Nurses' Experiences

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000184

Paola Galbany-Estragués；Dolors Comas-d'Argemir

professional autonomy ； nursing care ； nursing practice ； gender ； Spain

The Journal of Nursing Research

25卷5期（2017 / 10 / 01）

361 - 367

英文

Background: Care is the essence of the nursing role and is closely related to the concept of professional autonomy. Autonomy is implicated in power relations between doctors and nurses and between men and women. These relationships are closely linked to care practices and the inequality of nursing and medicine. Purpose: The aim of this study was to analyze nursing discourse regarding the concept of care and its relationship to the concept of autonomy and gender. Methods: This is a historical study based on oral interviews that took place between November 2008 and February 2011. We interviewed 19 nursing professionals who currently worked at the Hospital of the Holy Spirit (near Barcelona) or had worked there between 1961 and 2010. Semistructured interviews were recorded, transcribed, and analyzed. Results: We highlight four main themes: ＂a real nurse'; ＂more technology, less care＂; ＂the fragility of autonomy＂; and ＂the invisibility of nursing work.＂ These themes show the contradictions in the nursing profession that are based on the concept of care. However, in daily practice, the concept of care varies. Time pressure distances the nursing practice from its theoretical context. Changes in the concept of care are related to transformations in the health system and nursing work. Conclusions/Implications for Practice: Changes related to the autonomy of nursing are related to changes in the concept of care. In practice, care has a biomedical orientation. Care has become technologized and bureaucratized, which reduces the time that is spent with the patient. In a context in which medical authority predominates, nursing's struggle for autonomy is based on the recognition of the value of care. When care becomes invisible, the autonomy of nursing as a profession is threatened. This conclusion allows reflections about shifts in the concept of care and how they affect clinical practice and the autonomy of the nursing profession.

1. Liu, Y.(2010).Nurses' work role in the context of gender and Chinese culture: An online forum study.The Journal of Nursing Research,18(2),117-125.
   連結：
2. Arroyo Rodríguez, A.,Lancharro Tavero, I.,Romero Serrano, R.,Morillo Martín, M. S.(2011).Nursing as gender identity.Índex de Enfermería,20(4),248-251.
3. Baykara, Z. G.,Şahinoǧu, S.(2014).An evaluation of nurses' professional autonomyin Turkey.Nursing Ethics,21(4),447-460.
4. Cano-Caballero Gálvez, M. D.(2004).Nursing and gender, time for thinking in order to change.Índex de Enfermería,46,34-39.
5. Carrasco Acosta, M. C.,Márquez Garrido, M.,Arenas Fernández, J.(2005).Anthropology-nursing. Perspectives in gender.Cultura de los Cuidados, Revista de Enfermería y Humanidades,18,52-59.
6. Carrasco, C.(Ed.),Borderías, C.(Ed.),Torns, T.(Ed.)(2011).Care work. History, theory and policy.Madrid, Spain:Catarata.
7. Cole, C.,Wellard, S.,Mummery, J.(2014).Problematising autonomy and advocacy in nursing.Nursing Ethics,21(5),576-582.
8. Collière, F.(1996).Care...ensure the maintenance and continuity of life.Index de Enfermería,18,9-14.
9. Daly, M.,Lewis, J.(2000).The concept of social care and the analysis of contemporary welfare states.The British Journal of Sociology,51(2),281-298.
10. del Pino Casado, R.,Martínez Riera, J. R.(2007).Strategies to improve visibility and accessibility of nursing cares in primary health care.Revista de Administración Sanitaria Siglo XXI,5(2),311-337.
11. Evans, J.(1997).Men in nursing: Issues of gender segregation and hidden advantage.Journal of Advanced Nursing,26(2),226-231.
12. Fajardo Trasobares, M. E.,Germán Bes, C.(2004).Influence of genre in the reconnaissance of the visible and invisible nursing cares.Índex de Enfermería,13(46)
13. Galbany-Estragués, P.(2012).Spain,Universidad de Barcelona.
14. German, C.,Hueso, F.(2010).Humanized care, nurses invisible.Rev. Paraninfo Digital,9
15. Harmer, B.,Henderson, V.(1955).Textbook of the principles and practice of nursing.New York, NY:Macmillan.
16. Henderson, V.(1966).The nature of nursing: A definition and its implications for practice, research, and education.New York, NY:Macmillan.
17. Himmelweit, S.(2007).The prospects for caring: Economic theory and policy analysis.Cambridge Journal of Economics,31(4),581-599.
18. Hué rcanos Esparza, I.(2010).The invisible care, a dimension of nursing profession.Biblioteca Lascasas,6(1)
19. Iliopoulou, K. K.,While, A. E.(2010).Professional autonomy and job satisfaction: Survey of critical care nurses in mainland Greece.Journal of Advanced Nursing,66(11),2520-2531.
20. Karra, V.,Papathanassoglou, E. D.,Lemonidou, C.,Sourtzi, P.,Giannakopoulou, M.(2014).Exploration and classification of intensive care nurses' clinical decisions: A Greek perspective.Nursing in Critical Care,19(2),87-97.
21. Kirk, J.,Miller, M. L.(1986).Reliability and validity in qualitative research.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
22. Kouta, C.,Kaite, C. P.(2011).Gender discrimination and nursing: A literature review.Journal of Professional Nursing,27(1),59-63.
23. Leininger, M. M.(Ed.),McFarland, M. R.(Ed.)(2006).Culture care, diversity and universality. A worldwide nursing theory.London, England:Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
24. Lincoln, Y. S.,Guba, E. S.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
25. MacDonald, C.(2002).Nurse autonomy as relational.Nursing Ethics,9(2),194-201.
26. Rowe, J.(2010).The meaning of autonomy in nursing practice.Journal of Clinical Nursing,19,2662-2663.
27. Skår, R.(2010).The meaning of autonomy in nursing practice.Journal of Clinical Nursing,19(15-16),2226-2234.
28. ter Maten-Speksnijder, A.,Grypdonck, M.,Pool, A.,Meurs, P.,van Staa, A. L.(2014).A literature review of the Dutch debate on the nurse practitioner role: Efficiency vs. professional development.International Nursing Review,61(1),44-54.
29. Vázquez, M.(Ed.),Ferreira, M. R.(Ed.),Mogollón, A. S.(Ed.),de Sanmamed, M. J. Fernández(Ed.),Delgado, M. E.(Ed.),Vargas, I.(Ed.)(2006).Introduction to qualitative research techniques for health.Bellaterra, Spain:Servei de Publicacions UAB.