The Medical Futility Experience of Nurses in Caring for Critically Ill Patients

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000221

Ming-Yi Hsu；Shu-Fen Su；Lien-Ying Chiang；Sou-Jen Shih；Yu-Chen Chen

critically ill patients ； critical care nursing ； medical futility

The Journal of Nursing Research

26卷2期（2018 / 04 / 01）

80 - 87

英文

Background: Medical futility is a key bioethical concern. In Taiwan, policymakers tend to provide care standards and evaluation guidelines for critically ill and terminal patients whose treatment is medically futile. However, the current status of medical futility for critically ill patients is inadequate, and no consensus currently exists on the definition of medical futility. Purpose: The aim of this study was to understand the medical futility experiences of intensive care nurses. Methods: This qualitative research adopted a phenomenological perspective and was conducted in a medical center and a regional hospital in Central Taiwan. Eight nurses with at least 1 year of nursing tenure who were serving in the intensive care unit were recruited. Purposive and snowball sampling methods were used to conduct one-on-one in-depth interviews. Each of the tape-recorded interviews was transcribed before data analysis. Results: The research results found four themes, including (a) definitions of medical futility and types of patients, (b) considerations of medical futility, (c) the occurrence of medical futility, and (d) nurses' responses to medical futility. The participants indicated that medical futility refers to the point at which the continued provision of treatment does not evidently ease the disease condition of a patient or improve his or her quality of life or when life-sustaining treatment is provided to patients to facilitate the process of death. Conclusions: This study revealed that the major challenge in clinical cases of medical futility is for physicians, nurses, and patients to communicate effectively together during times of rapid and unanticipated change in patient condition. Thus, events of medical futility may be preventable. Past cases of medical futility involving critically ill patients may serve as references for guiding clinical care, education, and related policy formulation.

1. Bahramnezhad, F.,Cheraghi, M. A.,Salsali, M.,Asgari, P.,Khoshnava Fomani, F.,Sanjari, M.,Farokhnezhad Afshar, P.(2014).Futile care; concept analysis based on a hybrid model.Global Journal of Health Science,6(5),301-307.
2. Breslow, M. J.,Badawi, O.(2012).Severity scoring in the critically ill: Part 1-Interpretation and accuracy of outcome prediction scoring systems.Chest,141(1),245-252.
3. Brody, B. A.,Halevy, A.(1995).Is futility a futile concept?.The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy,20(2),123-144.
4. Chao, C. S.(2007)。The life and death in doctor。Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC:Aquarius。
5. Chen, C. Y.(2010)。Taichung City, Taiwan, ROC.，China Medical University。
6. Colaizzi, P. F.(1978).Psychological research as a phenomenologist views it.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
7. Converse, M.(2012).Philosophy of phenomenology: How understanding aids research.Nurse Researcher,20(1),28-32.
8. Day, L.(2009).Medical futility, personal goods, and social responsibility.American Journal of Critical Care,18(3),279-282.
9. Downar, J.,You, J. J.,Bagshaw, S. M.,Golan, E.,Lamontagne, F.,Burns, K.,Canadian Critical Care Trials Group(2015).Nonbeneficial treatment Canada: Definitions, causes, and potential solutions from the perspective of healthcare practitioners.Critical Care Medicine,43(2),270-281.
10. Gabbay, E.,Calvo-Broce, J.,Meyer, K. B.,Trikalinos, T. A.,Cohen, J.,Kent, D. M.(2010).The empirical basis for determinations of medical futility.Journal of General Internal Medicine,25(10),1083-1089.
11. Huang, H. S.(2013)。Health checkup report on the National Health Insurance。Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC:The Control Yuan, Taiwan, ROC.。
12. Huang, L. H.(2009)。Chiayi County, Taiwan, ROC.，Nanhua University。
13. Huang, Y. P.、Kellett, U. M.、St. John, W.、Lee, S.(2006)。Analysis phenomenology and application to nursing research。The Journal of Nursing，53(2)，49-58。
14. Jonsen, A. R.,Siegler, M.,Winslade, W. J.(2010).Clinical ethics: A practical approach to ethical decisions in clinical medicine.New York, NY:McGraw-Hill.
15. Jox, R. J.,Schaider, A.,Marckmann, G.,Borasio, G. D.(2012).Medical futility at the end of life: The perspectives of intensive care and palliative care clinicians.Journal of Medical Ethics,38(9),540-545.
16. Kadooka, Y.,Asai, A.,Fukuyama, M.,Bito, S.(2014).A comparative survey on potentially futile treatments between Japanese nurses and laypeople.Nursing Ethics,21(1),64-75.
17. Lin, F. R.、Huang, S. J.、Wu, C. K.、Huang, M. L.、Lin, Y. L.、Su, L. H.、Lin, H.M.(2010)。Medical futility in critical end-of life care。Journal of Emergency and Critical Care Medicine，21(4, Suppl.)，1-8。
18. Lincoln, Y. S.,Guba, E. G.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.London, England:Sage.
19. Lo, B.(2009).Resolving ethical dilemmas: A guide for clinicians.Philadelphia, PA:Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
20. Lo, S. F.、Hu, W. Y.(2008)。The critical review of health related quality of life (HRQL) concept and measure instrument for cancer patients。Taiwan Journal of Hospice Palliative Care，13(1)，4。
21. Moratti, S.(2010).Non-treatment decisions on grounds of "medical futility" and "quality of life": Interviews with fourteen Dutch neonatologists.Issues in Law & Medicine,26(1),3-11.
22. Moratti, S.(2009).The development of "medical futility": Towards a procedural approach based on the role of the medical profession.Journal of Medical Ethics,35(6),369-372.
23. Persaud, R.(2006)."Futile" care in the intensive care unit.Mayo Clinic Proceedings,81(11),1506-1507.
24. Schneiderman, L. J.,Jecker, N. S.,Jonsen, A. R.(1990).Medical futility: Its meaning and ethical implications.Annals of Internal Medicine,112(12),949-954.
25. Sibbald, R.,Downar, J.,Hawryluck, L.(2007).Perceptions of futile "care" among caregivers in intensive care units.Canadian Medical Association Journal,177(10),1201-1208.
26. Singer, P. A.、Tsai, F. C.Trans.(2009)。Bedside bioethics: A clinician's guide。Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC:Taiwan Joint Commission on Hospital Accreditation。
27. Thompson, R. J.(2011).Medical futility: A commonly used and potentially abused idea in medical ethics.British Journal of Hospital Medicine,72(2),96-99.
28. Vincent, J. L.,Moreno, R.(2010).Clinical review: Scoring systems in the critically ill.Critical Care,14(2),207.
29. Weng, Y. C.(2012)。End-of-life care in intensive care unit。VGH Nursing，29(3)，220-224。
30. Williams, T. A.,Ho, K. M.,Dobb, G. J.,Finn, J. C.,Knuiman, M.,Webb, S. A.,Royal Perth Hospital ICU Data Linkage Group(2010).Effect of length of stay in intensive care unit on hospital and long-term mortality of critically ill adult patients.The British Journal of Anaesthesia,104(4),459-464.
31. Yekefallah, L.,Ashktorab, T.,Manoochehri, H.,Hamid, A. M.(2015).Nurses' experiences of futile care at intensive care units: A phenomenological study.Global Journal of Health Science,7(4),235-242.
32. Zier, L. S.,Burack, J. H.,Micco, G.,Chipman, A. K.,Frank, J. A.,White, D. B.(2009).Surrogate decision makers' responses to physicians' predictions of medical futility.Chest,136(1),110-117.

1. (2023)。提升非安寧病房之癌症末期病人不施行心肺復甦術簽署率。長庚護理，34(4)，76-88。