The Relationship Between Critical Thinking Skills and Learning Styles and Academic Achievement of Nursing Students

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000307

Fatemeh SHIRAZI；Shiva HEIDARI

academic achievement ； critical thinking skills ； learning styles ； nursing student

The Journal of Nursing Research

27卷4期（2019 / 08 / 01）

1 - 7-010

英文

Background: Academic achievement is one of the most important indicators in evaluating education. Various factors are known to affect the academic achievement of students. Purpose: This study was performed to assess the relationship between critical thinking skills and learning styles and the academic achievement of nursing students. Methods: In this cross-sectional study, 139 sophomores to senior-year nursing students were selected using a simple random sampling method. The data were gathered using a three-part questionnaire that included a demographic questionnaire, the Kolb's Learning Style Standard Questionnaire, and the California Critical Thinking Skills Questionnaire. The previous semester's grade point average of the students was considered as a measure of academic achievement. The data were analyzed using descriptive and analytical statistics in SPSS 20. Results: The mean score for critical thinking skills was 6.75 ± 2.16, and the highest and lowest scores among the critical thinking subscales related to the evaluation and analysis subscales, respectively. No relationship between critical thinking and academic achievement was identified. ＂Diverging＂ was the most common learning style. The highest mean level of academic achievement was earned by those students who adopted the ＂accommodating＂ style of learning. A significant relationship was found between learning style and academic achievement (p ＜ .001). Conclusions: According to the findings, the critical thinking skills score of students was unacceptably low. Therefore, it is essential to pay more attention to improving critical thinking in academic lesson planning. As a significant relationship was found between learning style and academic achievement, it is suggested that instructors consider the dominant style of each class in lesson planning and use proper teaching methods that take into consideration the dominant style.

1. Abdollahi Adli Ansar, V.,FathiAzar, A.,Abdollahi, N.(2015).The relationship of critical thinking with creativity, self-efficacy beliefs and academic performance of teacher–students.Journal of Research in School and Virtual Learning,2(7),41-52.
2. Aghaei, N.,Souri, R.,Ghanbari, S.(2012).Comparison of the relationship between critical thinking and academic achievement among physical education students and students in other fields of study in Bu Ali Sina University, Hamedan.Management of Sport and Movement Sciences,2(4),35-45.
3. Ahadi, F.,Abedsaidi, J.,Arshadi, F.,Ghorbani, R.(2010).Learning styles of nursing and allied health students in Semnan University of Medical Sciences.Koomesh,11(2),141-146.
4. Ahanchian,M.,Mohamadzadeghasr, A.,Garavand, H.,Hosseini, A.(2012).Prevalent learning styles among nursing and midwifery students and its association with functionality of thinking styles and academic achievement a study in Mashhad School of Nursing and Midwifery.Iranian Journal of Medical Education,12(8),577-588.
5. Aripin, R.,Mahmood, Z.,Rohaizad, R.,Yeop, U.,Anuar, M.(2008).Student learning styles and academic performance.Proceedings of the 22nd Annual SAS Malaysia Forum,Malaysia:
6. Ashoori, J.(2014).Relationship between self-efficacy, critical thinking, thinking styles and emotional intelligence with academic achievement in nursing students.Scientific Journal of Hamadan Nursing & Midwifery Faculty,22(3),15-23.
7. Azodi, P.,Jahanpoor, F.,Sharif, F.(2010).Critical thinking skills of students in Bushehr University of Medical Sciences.Interdisciplinary Journal of Virtual Learning in Medical Sciences,1(2),10-16.
8. Babamohammadi, H.,Esmaeilpour, M.,Negarande, R.,Dehghan Nayeri, N.(2011).Comparison of critical thinking skills in nursing students of Semnan and Tehran Universities of Medical Sciences.Journal of Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences,10(1, Suppl.),67-78.
9. Can, Ş.(2009).The effects of science student teachers' academic achievements, their grade levels, gender and type of education they are exposed to on their 4mat learning styles (Case of Muğla University, Turkey).Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,1(1),1853-1857.
10. Edraki, M.,Rambod, M.,Abdoli, R.(2011).The relationship between nursing students' educational satisfaction and their academic success.Iranian Journal of Medical Education,11(1),32-39.
11. Emamipour, S.,Shams Esfandabad, H.(2007).Learning and cognitive styles: Theories and tests.Tehran, Iran:Samt Publisher.
12. Eslami, A. R.,Maarefi, F.(2010).A comparison of the critical thinking ability in the first and last term baccalaureate students of nursing and clinical nurses of Jahrom University of Medical Sciences in 2007.Journal of Jahrom University of Medical Sciences,8(1),37-45.
13. Facione, P. A.,Facione, N.(1994).The California Critical Thinking Skills Test: Test manual.Millbrae, CA:California Academic Press.
14. Farmanbar, R.,Hosseinzadeh, T.,Asadpoor, M.,Yeganeh, M.(2013).Association between nursing and midwifery students' learning styles and their academic achievements, based on Kolb's model.Journal of Guilan University of Medical Sciences,22(86),60-68.
15. Farooq, M. S.,Chaudhry, A. H.,Shafiq, M.,Berhanu, G.(2011).Factors affecting students' quality of academic performance: A case of secondary school level.Journal of Quality and Technology Management,7(2),1-14.
16. Fero, L. J.,O'Donnell, J. M.,Zullo, T. G.,Dabbs, A. D.,Kitutu, J.,Samosky, J. T.,Hoffman, L. A.(2010).Critical thinking skills in nursing students: Comparison of simulation-based performance with metrics.Journal of Advanced Nursing,66(10),2182-2193.
17. Ghazivakili, Z.,Norouzi Nia, R.,Panahi, F.,Karimi, M.,Gholsorkh, H.,Ahmadi, Z.(2014).The role of critical thinking skills and learning styles of university students in their academic performance.Journal of Advances in Medical Education & Professionalism,2(3),95-102.
18. Gordon, C. D.,Williams, S. K. P.,Hudson, G. A.,Stewart, J.(2010).Factors associated with academic performance of physical therapy students.West Indian Medical Journal,59(2),203-208.
19. Gurpinar, E.,Alimoglu, M. K.,Mamakli, S.,Aktekin, M.(2010).Can learning style predict student satisfaction with different instruction methods and academic achievement in medical education?.Advances in Physiology Education,34(4),192-196.
20. Hariri, N.,Bagherinejad, Z.(2012).Evaluation of critical thinking skills in students of health faculty, Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences.Journal of Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences,21(1),166-173.
21. Hosseini, Z.(2009).Cooperative learning and critical thinking.Developmental Psychology (Journal of Iranian Psychologists),5(19),199-208.
22. Jayanthi, S. V.,Balakrishnan, S.,Ching, A. L. S.,Latiff, N. A. A.,Nasirudeen, A. M. A.(2014).Factors contributing to academic performance of students in a tertiary institution in Singapore.American Journal of Educational Research,2(9),752-758.
23. Kolb, A. Y., & Kolb, D. A. (2005). The Kolb learning style inventory-Version 3.1 2005 technical specifications. Boston, MA: Hay Resources Direct.
24. Lau, W. W. F.,Yuen, A. H. K.(2010).Gender differences in learning styles: Nurturing a gender and style sensitive computer science classroom.Australasian Journal of Educational Technology,26(7),1090-1103.
25. Mlambo, V.(2011).An analysis of some factors affecting student academic performance in an introductory biochemistry course at the University of the WestIndies.Caribbean Teaching Scholar,1(2),79-92.
26. Mohammadi, I.,Sayehmiri, C.,Tavan, H.,Mohammadi, E.(2013).Learning styles of Iranian nursing students based on Kolb's theory: A systematic review and meta-analysis study.Iranian Journal of Medical Education,13(9),741-752.
27. Noohi, E.,Salahi, S.,Sabzevari, S.(2014).Association of critical thinking with learning styles in nursing students of school of nursing and midwifery, Iran.Journal of Strides in Development of Medical Education,11(2),179-186.
28. Orhun, N.(2012).The relationship between learning styles and achievement in calculus course for engineering students.Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,47,638-642.
29. Panahi, R.,Kazemi, S.,Rezaie, A.(2012).The relationship between learning styles and academic achievement: The role of gender and academic discipline.Developmental Psychology (Journal of Iranian Psychologists),8(30),189-196.
30. Pazargadi, M.,Tahmasebi, S.(2010).Learning styles and their application in nursing.Iranian Journal of Educational Strategies,3(2),73-76.
31. Shinnick, M. A.,Woo, M. A.(2013).The effect of human patient simulation on critical thinking and its predictors in prelicensure nursing students.Nurse Education Today,33(9),1062-1067.
32. Shirazi, F.,Sharif, F.,Molazem, Z.,Alborzi, M.(2016).Dynamics of self-directed learning in M.Sc. nursing students: A qualitative research.Journal of Advances in Medical Education & Professionalism,5(1),33-41.
33. Taghavi Larijani, T.,Mardani Hmouleh, M.,Rezaei, N.,Ghadiriyan, F.,Rashidi, A.(2014).Relationship between assertiveness and critical thinking in nursing students.Journal of Nursing Education,3(1),32-40.
34. Tulbure, C.(2012).Learning styles, teaching strategies and academic achievement in higher education: A cross-sectional investigation.Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,33,398-402.
35. Wangensteen, S.,Johansson, I. S.,Björkström,M. E.,Nordström, G.(2010).Critical thinking dispositions among newly graduated nurses.Journal of Advanced Nursing,66(10),2170-2181.
36. Zainol Abidin, M. J.,Rezaee, A. A.,Abdullah, H. N.,Singh, K. K. B.(2011).Learning styles and overall academic achievement in a specific educational system.International Journal of Humanities and Social Science,1(10),143-152.

1. Hsiang-Chin Hsu;Shuen-Lin Jeng;Hsin-I Shih;Tzu-Ching Sung;Su-Pin Hung;Yu-Chiao Huang;Wei-Ren Yao;Shyh-Jou Shieh(2023)。Learning Styles of Newly Enrolled Medical Students With Different Routes of Admission。Journal of Medical Education。27(2)。125-137。