Effects of Patient Activation Intervention on Chronic Diseases: A Meta-Analysis

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000387

Mei-Yu LIN；Wei-Shih WENG；Renny Wulan APRILIYASARI；Pham VAN TRUONG；Pei-Shan TSAI

chronic disease ； meta-analysis ； depression ； anxiety ； self-efficacy

The Journal of Nursing Research

28卷5期（2020 / 10 / 01）

1 - 16

英文

Background: Patient activation has been described as a potential strategy to improve chronic disease self-management. However, the effects of patient activation interventions on psychological and behavioral outcomes have not been systematically evaluated. Purpose: This study was designed to evaluate the effects of patient activation interventions on physiological, psychological, behavioral, and health-related quality of life outcomes in patients with chronic diseases. Methods: We systematically searched four databases (PubMed, Cochrane, CINAHL, and Embase) from inception to September 1, 2017. We identified English- and Chinese-language published reports of randomized controlled trials that evaluated the effects of patient activation interventions for adults with chronic diseases. Study selection, data extraction, and quality assessment were performed by two reviewers independently. We summarized the intervention effects with Hedges's g values and 95% confidence intervals using a random-effects model. We used the Cochrane Handbook to assess the methodological quality of the randomized controlled trials. Results: Twenty-six randomized controlled trials were included in the qualitative synthesis and meta-analysis. In terms of overall study quality, most of the included studies were affected by performance and detection bias. Patient activation interventions produced significant effects on outcomes related to physiological, psychological, behavioral, and health-related quality of life in the context of chronic diseases. The following effect sizes were obtained: (a) physiological, namely, glycated hemoglobin = -0.31 (p ＜ .01), systolic blood pressure = -0.20 (p ＜ .01), diastolic blood pressure = -0.80 (p = .02), body weight = -0.12 (p = .03), and low-density lipoprotein = -0.21 (p = .01); (b) psychological, namely, depression = -0.16 (p ＜ .01) and anxiety = -0.25 (p = .01); (c) behavioral, namely, patient activation = 0.33 (p ＜ .01) and self-efficacy = 0.57 (p ＜ .01); and (d) health-related quality of life = 0.25 (p = .01). Conclusions: Patient activation interventions significantly improve patients' physiological, psychosocial, and behavioral health statuses. Healthcare providers should implement patient activation interventions that tailor support to the individual patients' level of patient activation and strengthen the patients' role in managing their healthcare to improve chronic-disease-related health outcomes.

1. Anderson, R. M.,Funnell, M. M.,Aikens, J. E.,Krein, S. L.,Fitzgerald, J. T.,Nwankwo, R.,Tannas, C. L.,Tang, T. S.(2009).Evaluating the efficacy of an empowerment-based self-management consultant intervention: Results of a two-year randomized controlled trial.Therapeutic Patient Education,1(1),3-11.
2. Anderson, R. M.,Funnell, M. M.,Nwankwo, R.,Gillard, M. L.,Oh, M.,Fitzgerald, J. T.(2005).Evaluating a problem-based empowerment program for African Americans with diabetes: Results of a randomized controlled trial.Ethnicity & Disease,15(4),671-678.
3. Bennett, H. D.,Coleman, E. A.,Parry, C.,Bodenheimer, T.,Chen, E. H.(2010).Health coaching for patients with chronic illness.Family Practice Management,17(5),24-29.
4. Blackberry, I. D.,Furler, J. S.,Best, J. D.,Chondros, P.,Vale, M.,Walker, C.,Dunning, T.,Segal, L.,Dunbar, J.,Audehm, R.,Liew, D.,Young, D.(2013).Effectiveness of general practice based, practice nurse led telephone coaching on glycaemic control of type 2 diabetes: The patient engagement and coaching for health (PEACH) pragmatic cluster randomized controlled trial.BMJ (Clinical Research Ed.),347,f5272.
5. Bolen, S. D.,Chandar, A.,Falck-Ytter, C.,Tyler, C.,Perzynski, A. T.,Gertz, A. M.,Sage, P.,Lewis, S.,Cobabe, M.,Ye, Y.,Menegay, M.,Windish, D. M.(2014).Effectiveness and safety of patient activation interventions for adults with type 2 diabetes: Systematic review, meta-analysis, and meta-regression.Journal of General Internal Medicine,29(8),1166-1176.
6. Chen, M. F.,Wang, R. H.,Lin, K. C.,Hsu, H. Y.,Chen, S. W.(2015).Efficacy of an empowerment program for Taiwanese patients with type 2 diabetes: A randomized controlled trial.Applied Nursing Research,28(4),366-373.
7. Clarke, D. M.,Currie, K. C.(2009).Depression, anxiety and their relationship with chronic diseases: A review of the epidemiology, risk and treatment evidence.The Medical Journal of Australia,190(7, Suppl.),S54-S60.
8. Cortez, D. N.,Macedo, M. M.,Souza, D. A.,Dos Santos, J. C.,Afonso, G. S.,Reis, I. A.,Torres, H. C.(2017).Evaluating the effectiveness of an empowerment program for self-care in type 2 diabetes: A cluster randomized trial.BMC Public Health,17(1),41.
9. Deeks, A.,Lombard, C.,Michelmore, J.,Teede, H.(2009).The effects of gender and age on health related behaviors.BMC Public Health,9,213.
10. Donald, M.,Beanlands, H.,Straus, S.,Ronksley, P.,Tam-Tham,H.,Finlay, J.,MacKay, J.,Elliott, M.,Herrington, G.,Harwood,L.,Large, C. A.,Large, C. L.,Waldvogel, B.,Sparkes, D.,Delgado, M.,Tong, A.,Grill, A.,Novak, M.,James, M. T.,Hemmelgarn, B. R.(2019).Identifying needs for self-managementinterventions for adults with CKD and their caregivers: A qualitativestudy.American Journal of Kidney Diseases,74(4),474-482.
11. Ebrahimi, H.,Sadeghi, M.,Amanpour, F.,Vahedi, H.(2016).Evaluation of empowerment model on indicators of metaboliccontrol in patients with type 2 diabetes, a randomized clinicaltrial study.Primary Care Diabetes,10(2),129-135.
12. Fredericks, S.,Lapum, J.,Lo, J.(2012).Anxiety, depression, andself-management: A systematic review.Clinical Nursing Research,21(4),411-430.
13. Funnell, M. M.,Anderson, R. M.,Arnold, M. S.,Barr, P. A.,Donnelly, M.,Johnson, P. D.,Taylor-Moon, D.,White, N. H.(1991).Empowerment: An idea whose time has come in diabetes education.The Diabetes Educator,17(1),37-41.
14. García, A. A.,Brown, S. A.,Horner, S. D.,Zuñiga, J.,Arheart, K.L.(2015).Home-based diabetes symptom self-managementeducation for Mexican Americans with type 2 diabetes.Health Education Research,30(3),484-496.
15. Greene, J.,Hibbard, J. H.(2012).Why does patient activationmatter? An examination of the relationships between patientactivation and health-related outcomes.Journal of General Internal Medicine,27(5),520-526.
16. Grenard, J. L.,Munjas, B. A.,Adams, J. L.,Suttorp, M.,Maglione,M.,McGlynn, E. A.,Gellad, W. F.(2011).Depression andmedication adherence in the treatment of chronic diseases inthe United States: A meta-analysis.Journal of General Internal Medicine,26(10),1175-1182.
17. Grimm, M. O.,Grünwald, V.(2017).Health-related quality of lifeas a prognostic measure of clinical outcomes in renal cell carcinoma: A review of the checkmate 025 trial.Oncology and Therapy,5(1),75-78.
18. Hibbard, J. H.,Greene, J.(2013).What the evidence showsabout patient activation: Better health outcomes and care experiences; fewer data on costs.Health Affairs (Project Hope),32(2),207-214.
19. Hibbard, J. H.,Mahoney, E. R.,Stock, R.,Tusler, M.(2007).Doincreases in patient activation result in improved selfmanagement behaviors?.Health Services Research,42(4),1443-1463.
20. Hibbard, J. H.,Stockard, J.,Mahoney, E. R.,Tusler, M.(2004).Development of the patient activation measure (PAM): Conceptualizing and measuring activation in patients and consumers.Health Services Research,39(4, Pt. 1),1005-1026.
21. Higgins, J. P.,Altman, D. G.,Gøtzsche, P. C.,Jüni, P.,Moher, D.,Oxman, A. D.,Savović, J.,Schulz, K. F.,Weeks, L.,Sterne, J.A. C.,Cochrane Bias Methods Group,Cochrane StatisticalMethods Group(2011).The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials.BMJ (Clinical Research Ed.),343,d5928.
22. Holman, H.,Lorig, K.(2004).Patient self-management: A key toeffectiveness and efficiency in care of chronic disease.Public Health Reports,119(3),239-243.
23. Jacobson, A. F.,Sumodi, V.,Albert, N. M.,Butler, R. S.,DeJohn,L.,Walker, D.,Dion, K.,Tai, H. L.,Ross, D. M.(2018).Patientactivation, knowledge, and health literacy association withself-management behaviors in persons with heart failure.Heart & Lung,47(5),447-451.
24. Jonsdottir, H.,Amundadottir, O. R.,Gudmundsson, G.,Halldorsdottir, B. S.,Hrafnkelsson, B.,Ingadottir, T. S.,Jonsdottir, R.,Jonsson, J. S.,Sigurjonsdottir, E. D.,Stefansdottir, I. K.(2015).Effectiveness of a partnershipbased self-management programme for patients with mildand moderate chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: A pragmatic randomized controlled trial.Journal of Advanced Nursing,71(11),2634-2649.
25. Jowsey, T.,Jeon, Y. H.,Dugdale, P.,Glasgow, N. J.,Kljakovic, M.,Usherwood, T.(2009).Challenges for co-morbid chronic illness care and policy in Australia: A qualitative study.Australiaand New Zealand Health Policy,6,22.
26. Keeratiyutawong, P.,Hanucharurnkul, S.,Melkus, G. D. E.,Panpakdee, O.,Vorapongsathorn, T.(2006).Effectivenessof a self-management program for Thais with type 2 diabetes:An integrative review.Thai Journal of Nursing Research,10(2),85-97.
27. Kim, K. B.,Han, H. R.,Huh, B.,Nguyen, T.,Lee, H.,Kim, M. T.(2014).The effect of a community-based self-help multimodalbehavioral intervention in Korean American seniors with highblood pressure.American Journal of Hypertension,27(9),1199-1208.
28. Li, X.,Zhou, Q.,Zou, F.,Wu, L.,Chen, H.,Liu, Z.(2012).Effectiveness of systematic self-management education on bloodsugar level of patients in the community with type 2 diabetes.Journal of Central South University: Medical Sciences,37(4),355-358.
29. Lorig, K.,Ritter, P. L.,Villa, F. J.,Armas, J.(2009).Communitybased peer-led diabetes self-management: A randomized trial.Diabetes Educator,35(4),641-651.
30. Lynch, E. B.,Liebman, R.,Ventrelle, J.,Avery, E. F.,Richardson, D.(2014).A self-management intervention for African Americanswith comorbid diabetes and hypertension: A pilot randomizedcontrolled trial.Preventing Chronic Disease,11,E90.
31. McGowan, P.(2011).The efficacy of diabetes patient educationand self-management education in type 2 diabetes.CanadianJournal of Diabetes,35(1),46-53.
32. Meng, K.,Musekamp, G.,Schuler, M.,Seekatz, B.,Glatz, J.,Karger, G.,Kiwus, U.,Knoglinger, E.,Schubmann, R.,Westphal, R.,Faller, H.(2016).The impact of a self-management patient education program for patients with chronic heart failure undergoinginpatient cardiac rehabilitation.Patient Education and Counseling,99(7),1190-1197.
33. Moein, M.,Aghajani, M.,Ajorpaz, N. M.,Khorasanifar, L.(2017).Effect of an empowerment program on self-efficacyof patients with type 2 diabetes.Iranian Red Crescent Medical Journal,19(1),e29252.
34. Mosen, D. M.,Schmittdiel, J.,Hibbard, J.,Sobel, D.,Remmers, C.,Bellows, J.(2007).Is patient activation associated with outcomes of care for adults with chronic conditions?.The Journalof Ambulatory Care Management,30(1),21-29.
35. Odnoletkova, I.,Goderis, G.,Nobels, F.,Fieuws, S.,Aertgeerts,B.,Annemans, L.,Ramaekers, D.(2016).Optimizing diabetescontrol in people with type 2 diabetes through nurse-ledtelecoaching.Diabetic Medicine,33(6),777-785.
36. Olsen, J. M.(2014).Health coaching: A concept analysis.NursingForum,49(1),18-29.
37. Pauley, T.,Gargaro, J.,Chenard, G.,Cavanagh, H.,McKay, S.M.(2016).Home-based diabetes self-management coachingdelivered by paraprofessionals: A randomized controlled trial.Home Health Care Services Quarterly,35(3-4),137-154.
38. Safford, M. M.,Andreae, S.,Cherrington, A. L.,Martin, M. Y.,Halanych, J.,Lewis, M.,Patel, A.,Johnson, E.,Clark, D.,Gamboa, C.,Richman, J. S.(2015).Peer coaches to improvediabetes outcomes in rural Alabama: A cluster randomizedtrial.The Annals of Family Medicine,13(1, Suppl.),S18-S26.
39. Shao, J. H.,Chang, A. M.,Edwards, H.,Shyu, Y. I.,Chen, S. H.(2013).A randomized controlled trial of self-management programme improves health-related outcomes of older people withheart failure.Journal of Advanced Nursing,69(11),2458-2469.
40. Thom, D. H.,Ghorob, A.,Hessler, D.,De Vore, D.,Chen, E.,Bodenheimer, T. A.(2013).Impact of peer health coaching on glycemic control in low-income patients with diabetes: A randomizedcontrolled trial.Annals of Family Medicine,11(2),137-144.
41. Tol, A.,Alhani, F.,Shojaeazadeh, D.,Sharifirad, G.,Moazam, N.(2015).An empowering approach to promote the quality of lifeand self-management among type 2 diabetic patients.Journal of Education and Health Promotion,4,13.
42. Tousman, S. A.,Zeitz, H.,Bond, D.,Stewart, D.,Rackow, R.,Greer, R.,Hatfield, S.,Layman, K.,Ganjwala, P.(2011).A randomized controlled behavioral trial of a new adult asthma selfmanagement program.Journal of Asthma and Allergy Educators,2(2),91-96.
43. Van der Wulp, I.,de Leeuw, J. R.,Gorter, K. J.,Rutten, G. E.(2012).Effectiveness of peer-led self-management coachingfor patients recently diagnosed with type 2 diabetes mellitus in primary care: A randomized controlled trial.Diabetic Medicine,29(10),e390-e397.
44. Wolever, R. Q.,Dreusicke, M.,Fikkan, J.,Hawkins, T. V.,Yeung,S.,Wakefield, J.,Duda, L.,Flowers, P.,Cook, C.,Skinner, E.(2010).Integrative health coaching for patients with type 2 diabetes:A randomized clinical trial.Diabetes Educator,36(4),629-639.
45. World Health Organization. (2018). Noncommunicable diseases. https://www.who.int/en/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/noncommunicablediseases
46. Xue, F.,Yao,W.,Lewin, R. J.(2008).A randomised trial of a 5 week, manual based, self-management programme for hypertensiondelivered in a cardiac patient club in Shanghai.BMC Cardiovascular Disorders,8,10.
47. Yohannes, A. M.,Willgoss, T. G.,Baldwin, R. C.,Connolly, M. J.(2010).Depression and anxiety in chronic heart failure andchronic obstructive pulmonary disease: Prevalence, relevance, clinical implications and management principles.International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry,25(12),1209-1221.
48. Young, L.,Hertzog, M.,Barnason, S.(2016).Effects of a homebased activation intervention on self-management adherenceand readmission in rural heart failure patients: The PATCHrandomized controlled trial.BMC Cardiovascular Disorders,16(1),176.
49. Yun, Y. H.,Kim, Y. A.,Lee, M. K.,Sim, J. A.,Nam, B. H.,Kim, S.,Lee, E. S.,Noh, D. Y.,Lim, J. Y.,Kim, S.,Kim, S. Y.,Cho, C. H.,Jung, K. H.,Chun, M.,Lee, S. N.,Park, K. H.,Park, S.(2017).Arandomized controlled trial of physical activity, dietary habit,and distress management with the leadership and coachingfor health (LEACH) program for disease-free cancer survivors.BMC Cancer,17(1),298.