Screening Tools for Child Abuse Used by Healthcare Providers: A Systematic Review

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000475

Chia-Jung CHEN；Yi-Wen CHEN；Hsin-Yi CHANG；Jui-Ying FENG

child abuse ； screening tool ； healthcare provider

The Journal of Nursing Research

30卷1期（2022 / 02 / 01）

1 - 12

英文

Background: The early detection of child abuse is essential for children at risk. Healthcare professionals working at hospitals and in the community are often the first to encounter suspected cases of child abuse. Therefore, an accurate identification of child abuse is critical for intervention. However, there is no consensus on the best method to screen for child abuse. Purpose: This systematic review was designed to evaluate the relevant psychometric properties and critically appraise the methodological quality of child abuse screening tools used by healthcare providers with children less than 18 years old. Methods: We searched the Cochrane Library, MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Education Resources Information Center, PubMed, Airiti Library, and OpenGray databases for studies on screening tools used to identify abuse in children published through October 2019 in English or Chinese. Information regarding populations, assessment methods, and accuracy parameters were extracted. Study quality was assessed using the COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement INstruments checklist and Grading of Recommendation, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation criteria. Results: Nine hundred thirty-nine abstracts and 23 full-text articles were reviewed for eligibility, and 15 screening tools for child abuse used by healthcare providers were identified. Screening tools often assess the presence of more than one form of abuse, but no single tool covered all forms. Of these, 10 tools screened for a single, discrete type of abuse, including nine physical abuse screening tools (three abusive head trauma tools) and one sexual abuse tool. Eighty percent (n = 12) of the screening tools had a moderate-to-high quality of evidence based on the Grading of Recommendation, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation criteria. However, none of these screening tools achieved an adequate level of evidence based on the COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement INstruments checklist. Conclusions/Implications for Practice: In this systematic literature review, 15 assessment tools of child abuse used by healthcare providers were identified, of which nine screened for physical abuse. Screening tools must be valid, succinct, user-friendly, and amenable for use with children at every point of care in the healthcare system. Because of the paucity of informative and practical studies in the literature, findings related to the quality of child abuse screening tools were inconclusive. Therefore, future research should focus on the use of screening tools in the healthcare system to identify effective screening interventions that may help healthcare providers identify child abuse cases as early as possible.

1. Administration for Children and Families. (2020). Child abuse, neglect data released. https://www.acf.hhs.gov/media/press/2020/child-abuse-neglect-data-released
2. Berger, R. P.,Fromkin, J.,Herman, B.,Pierce, M. C.,Saladino, R. A.,Flom, L.,Tyler-Kabara, E. C.,McGinn, T.,Richichi, R.,Kochanek, P. M.(2016).Validation of the Pittsburgh infant brain injury score for abusive head trauma.Pediatrics,138(1),Article e20153756.
3. Carson, S. M.(2018).Implementation of a comprehensive program to improve child physical abuse screening and detection in the emergency department.Journal of Emergency Nursing,44(6),576-581.
4. Chang, D. C.,Knight, V. M.,Ziegfeld, S.,Haider, A.,Paidas, C.(2005).The multi-institutional validation of the new screening index for physical child abuse.Journal of Pediatric Surgery,40(1),114-119.
5. Chang, D. C.,Knight, V.,Ziegfeld, S.,Haider, A.,Warfield, D.,Paidas, C.(2004).The tip of the iceberg for child abuse: The critical roles of the pediatric trauma service and its registry.The Journal of Trauma and Acute Surgery,57(6),1189-1198.
6. Chang, Y. C.,Huang, J. L.,Hsia, S. H.,Lin, K. L.,Lee, E. P.,Chou, I. J.,Hsin, Y. C.,Lo, F. S.,Wu, C. T.,Chiu, C. H.,Wu, H. P.,Prevention, Protection Against Child Abuse, Neglect (PCHAN) Study Group(2016).Child protection medical service demonstration centers in approaching child abuse and neglect in Taiwan.Medicine,95(44),Article e5218.
7. Clarkson Freeman, P. A.(2014).Prevalence and relationship between adverse childhood experiences and child behavior among young children.Infant Mental Health Journal,35(6),544-554.
8. Cowley, L. E.,Morris, C. B.,Maguire, S. A.,Farewell, D. M.,Kemp, A. M.(2015).Validation of a prediction tool for abusive head trauma.Pediatrics,136(2),290-298.
9. Dinpanah, H.,Akbarzadeh Pasha, A.(2017).Potential child abuse screening in emergency department; a diagnostic accuracy study.Emergency,5(1),Article e8.
10. Ezpeleta, L.,Pérez-Robles, R.,Fanti, K. A.,Karveli, V.,Katsimicha, E.,Nikolaidis, G.,Hadjicharalambous, M. Z.,Hatzinikolaou, K.(2017).Development of a screening tool enabling identification of infants and toddlers at risk of family abuse and neglect: A feasibility study from three South European countries.Child: Care, Health and Development,43(1),75-80.
11. Flom, L.,Fromkin, J.,Panigrahy, A.,Tyler-Kabara, E.,Berger, R. P.(2016).Development of a screening MRI for infants at risk for abusive head trauma.Pediatric Radiology,46(4),519-526.
12. Hoft, M.,Haddad, L.(2017).Screening children for abuse and neglect: A review of the literature.Journal of Forensic Nursing,13(1),26-34.
13. Horwath, J.(2007).The missing assessment domain: Personal, professional and organizational factors influencing professional judgements when identifying and referring child neglect.The British Journal of Social Work,37(8),1285-1303.
14. Hoytema van Konijnenburg, E. M.,Teeuw, A. H.,SieswerdaHoogendoorn, T.,Leenders, A. G.,van der Lee, J. H.(2013).Insufficient evidence for the use of a physical examination to detect maltreatment in children without prior suspicion: A systematic review.Systematic Reviews,2,Article No. 109.
15. Hymel, K. P.,Armijo-Garcia, V.,Foster, R.,Frazier, T. N.,Stoiko, M.,Christie, L. M.,Harper, N. S.,Weeks, K.,Carroll, C. L.,Hyden, P.,Sirotnak, A.,Truemper, E.,Ornstein, A. E.,Wang, M.,Pediatric Brain Injury Research Network (PediBIRN) Investigators(2014).Validation of a clinical prediction rule for pediatric abusive head trauma.Pediatrics,134(6),e1537-e1544.
16. Kemp, A. M.,Hollén, L.,Emond, A. M.,Nuttall, D.,Rea, D.,Maguire, S.(2018).Raising suspicion of maltreatment from burns: Derivation and validation of the BuRN-Tool.Burns,44(2),335-343.
17. Louwers, E. C.,Korfage, I. J.,Affourtit, M. J.,Ruige, M.,van den Elzen, A. P.,de Koning, H. J.,Moll, H. A.(2014).Accuracy of a screening instrument to identify potential child abuse in emergency departments.Child Abuse & Neglect,38(7),1275-1281.
18. Louwers, E. C.,Korfage, I. J.,Affourtit, M. J.,Scheewe, D. J.,van de Merwe, M. H.,Vooijs-Moulaert, A. F.,van den Elzen, A. P.,Jongejan, M. H.,Ruige, M.,Manai, B. H.,Looman, C. W.,Bosschaart, A. N.,Teeuw, A. H.,Moll, H. A.,de Koning, H. J.(2012).Effects of systematic screening and detection of child abuse in emergency departments.Pediatrics,130(3),457-464.
19. McKelvey, L. M.,Whiteside-Mansell, L.,Conners-Burrow, N. A.,Swindle, T.,Fitzgerald, S.(2016).Assessing adverse experiences from infancy through early childhood in home visiting programs.Child Abuse & Neglect,51,295-302.
20. Mimasaka, S.,Ohtani, M.,Kuroda, N.,Tsunenari, S.(2010).Spectrophotometric evaluation of the age of bruises in children: Measuring changes in bruise color as an indicator of child physical abuse.The Tohoku Journal of Experimental Medicine,220(2),171-175.
21. Moher, D.,Liberati, A.,Tetzlaff, J.,Altman, D. G.,PRISMA Group(2009).Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement.PLoS Medicine,6(7),Article e1000097.
22. Moll, H. A.(2014).Screening on child abuse in Europe.Archives of Disease in Childhood,99,A18-A19.
23. Mullen, S.,Quinn-Scoggins, H. D.,Nuttall, D.,Kemp, A. M.(2018).Qualitative analysis of clinician experience in utilising the BuRN Tool (Burns Risk assessment for Neglect or abuse Tool) in clinical practice.Burns,44(7),1759-1766.
24. O'Donohue, W.,Cummings, C.,Willis, B.(2018).The frequency of false allegations of child sexual abuse: A critical review.Journal of Child Sexual Abuse,27(5),459-475.
25. Oral, R.,Yagmur, F.,Nashelsky, M.,Turkmen, M.,Kirby, P.(2008).Fatal abusive head trauma cases: Consequence of medical staff missing milder forms of physical abuse.Pediatric Emergency Care,24(12),816-821.
26. Paek, S. H.,Jung, J. H.,Kwak, Y. H.,Kim, D. K.,Ryu, J. M.,Noh, H.,Kyong, Y. Y.,Kang, Y. J.(2018).Development of screening tool for child abuse in the Korean emergency department: Using modified Delphi study.Medicine,97(51),Article e13724.
27. Pierce, M. C.,Kaczor, K.,Aldridge, S.,O'Flynn, J.,Lorenz, D. J.(2010).Bruising characteristics discriminating physical child abuse from accidental trauma.Pediatrics,125(1),67-74.
28. Prinsen, C. A. C.,Mokkink, L. B.,Bouter, L. M.,Alonso, J.,Patrick, D. L.,de Vet, H. C. W.,Terwee, C. B.(2018).COSMIN guideline for systematic reviews of patient-reported outcome measures.Quality of Life Research,27(5),1147-1157.
29. Rumball-Smith, J.,Fromkin, J.,Rosenthal, B.,Shane, D.,Skrbin, J.,Bimber, T.,Berger, R. P.(2018).Implementation of routine electronic health record-based child abuse screening in general emergency departments.Child Abuse & Neglect,85,58-67.
30. Saini, S. M.,Hoffmann, C. R.,Pantelis, C.,Everall, I. P.,Bousman, C. A.(2019).Systematic review and critical appraisal of child abuse measurement instruments.Psychiatry Research,272,106-113.
31. Salinas-Miranda, A. A.,Salemi, J. L.,King, L. M.,Baldwin, J. A.,Berry, E. L.,Austin, D. A.,Scarborough, K.,Spooner, K. K.,Zoorob, R. J.,Salihu, H. M.(2015).Adverse childhood experiences and health-related quality of life in adulthood: Revelations from a community needs assessment.Health & Quality of Life Outcomes,13,Article No. 123.
32. Sathiadas, M. G.,Viswalingam, A.,Vijayaratnam, K.(2018).Child abuse and neglect in the Jaffna district of Sri Lanka-A study on knowledge attitude practices and behavior of health care professionals.BMC Pediatrics,18(1),Article No. 152.
33. Schoemaker, C.,Smit, F.,Bijl, R. V.,Vollebergh, W. A.(2002).Bulimia nervosa following psychological and multiple child abuse: Support for the self-medication hypothesis in a population-based cohort study.International Journal of Eating Disorders,32(4),381-388.
34. Schols, M. W. A.,Serie, C. M. B.,Broers, N. J.,de Ruiter, C.(2019).Factor analysis and predictive validity of the Early Risks of Physical Abuse and Neglect Scale (ERPANS): A prospective study in Dutch public youth healthcare.Child Abuse & Neglect,88,71-83.
35. Schünemann, H. J.,Wiercioch, W.,Brozek, J.,EtxeandiaIkobaltzeta, I.,Mustafa, R. A.,Manja, V.,Brignardello-Petersen, R.,Neumann, I.,Falavigna, M.,Alhazzani, W.,Santesso, N.,Zhang, Y.,Meerpohl, J. J.,Morgan, R. L.,Rochwerg, B.,Darzi, A.,Rojas, M. X.,Carrasco-Labra, A.,Adi, Y.,Akl, E. A.(2017).GRADE Evidence to Decision (EtD) frameworks for adoption, adaptation, and de novo development of trustworthy recommendations: GRADE-ADOLOPMENT.Journal of Clinical Epidemiology,81,101-110.
36. Shakil, A.,Day, P. G.,Chu, J.,Woods, S. B.,Bridges, K.(2018).PedHITSS: A screening tool to detect childhood abuse in clinical settings.Family Medicine,50(10),763-769.
37. Sittig, J. S.,Uiterwaal, C. S.,Moons, K. G.,Nieuwenhuis, E. E.,van de Putte, E. M.(2011).Child abuse inventory at emergency rooms: CHAIN-ER rationale and design.BMC Pediatrics,11,Article No. 91.
38. Solis-Garcia, G.,Maranon, R.,Medina Munoz, M.,de Lucas Volle, S.,Garcia-Morin, M.,Rivas Garcia, A.(2019).Child abuse in the Emergency department: Epidemiology, management, and follow-up.Annals of Pediatrics,91(1),37-41.
39. van der Put, C. E.,Bouwmeester-Landweer, M. B. R.,LandsmeerBeker, E. A.,Wit, J. M.,Dekker, F. W.,Kousemaker, N. P. J.,Baartman, H. E. M.(2017).Screening for potential child maltreatment in parents of a newborn baby: The predictive validity of an Instrument for early identification of Parents At Risk for child Abuse and Neglect (IPARAN).Child Abuse & Neglect,70,160-168.
40. Wang, F.,Wang, M.,Xing, X.(2018).Attitudesmediate the intergenerational transmission of corporal punishment in China.Child Abuse & Neglect,76,34-43.
41. Wells, R.,McCann, J.,Adams, J.,Voris, J.,Dahl, B.(1997).A validational study of the structured interview of Symptoms Associated with Sexual Abuse (SASA) using three samples of sexually abused, allegedly abused, and nonabused boys.Child Abuse & Neglect,21(12),1159-1167.
42. World Health Organization. (2020). Child maltreatment. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/child-maltreatment