Examining the Needs-Based Time Use of Chinese Nursing Assistants: A Time-Motion Study

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000525

Xinxia WANG；Jun SHEN；Qiu CHEN

activity ； nursing home ； nursing assistants ； observation ； time and motion

The Journal of Nursing Research

30卷6期（2022 / 12 / 01）

1 - 10

英文

Background: In light of the worldwide shortage of nurses and to maximize the effectiveness of the nursing care available, it is important to investigate the components of the care regularly provided by nursing assistants (NAs) to older adults. Well-organized allocation of NA care activities is directly linked to the quality of care provided to nursing home (NH) residents and their quality of life. However, relevant knowledge about the actual time allocation of NAs in this context is lacking, as previous related studies have focused only on the duration necessary for NAs to complete nursing activities. Purpose: This study was designed to investigate the time allocation of NAs in completing job tasks necessary to meet the needs of residents in nursing care units at an NH in China. Methods: A time-motion method and nonparticipatory observations were used to collect data. Two postgraduate students observed 15 NAs' time expenditure and nursing content simultaneously during day shifts for 3 weeks as the NAs provided care to residents in four different nursing care levels. Data on nursing time and activity frequency were collected using a worklist based on the Zuluaga-Raysmith model. Results: The 119.6 hours of observation included 8,907 discrete observed activities. In terms of the care provided to meet the needs of residents, the most time-consuming activities were physical health care (26.8%) and communication care (18.3%), followed by mental, emotional, social, and spiritual health care (14.1%) and protection and security care (12.6%). The higher the level of care, the higher the proportion of somatic nursing time and nursing activity frequency. However, the time and frequency of psychological and spiritual care showed an opposite trend. Conclusions: Because of their lack of formal nursing training and skills, NAs pay more attention to meeting the physiological needs of residents while ignoring their mental needs. Moreover, their effectiveness in providing spiritual care tends to be quite low. Furthermore, the NA nursing activity classification system based on the Zuluaga-Raysmith model developed in this study is applicable for designing nursing work tasks, organizing NH units, and improving the quality of life of residents, as this model accurately reflects the essence of NA work.

1. Chang, H. K.,Gil, C. R.,Kim, H. J.,Bea, H. J.(2020).Factors affecting quality of life among the elderly in long-term care hospitals.The Journal of Nursing Research,29(1),Article e134.
   連結：
2. Audit Commission(2001).Acute hospital portfolio review: Ward staffing.Author.
3. Cai, E.,Liu, Y.,Jing, Y.,Zhang, L.,Li, J.,Yin, C.(2017).Assessing spatial accessibility of public and private residential aged care facilities: A case study in Wuhan, Central China.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,6(10),Article 304.
4. Campagna, S.,Conti, A.,Clari, M.,Basso, I.,Sciannameo, V.,Di Giulio, P.,Dimonte, V.(2021).Factors associated with missed nursing care in nursing homes: A multicentre crosssectional study.International Journal of Health Policy and Management
5. Chao, S. F.,Lu, P. C.(2020)。Differences in determinants of intention to stay and retention between younger and older nursing assistants in long-term care facilities: A longitudinal perspective。Journal of Nursing Management，28(3)，522-531。
6. Chen, E. Y. H.,Bell, J. S.,Ilomäki, J.,Corlis, M.,Hogan, M. E.,Caporale, T.,Van Emden, J.,Westbrook, J. I.,Hilmer, S. N.,Sluggett, J. K.(2021).Medication administration in Australian residential aged care: A time-and-motion study.Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice,27(1),103-110.
7. Chen, R.,Xu, P.,Song, P.,Wang, M.,He, J.(2019).China has faster pace than Japan in population aging in next 25 years.Bioscience Trends,13(4),287-291.
8. Cicchetti, D. V.(1994).Guidelines, criteria, and rules of thumb for evaluating normed and standardized assessment instruments in psychology.Psychological Assessment,6,284-290.
9. Donoghue, J.,Pelletier, D.,Duffield, C.(2005).Documentation and the transfer of clinical information in two aged care settings.The Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing,22(4),40-45.
10. Drennan, V. M.,Ross, F.(2019).Global nurse shortages—The facts, the impact and action for change.British Medical Bulletin,130(1),25-37.
11. Fahy, M. A.,Livingston, G. A.(2001).The needs and mental health of older people in 24-hour care residential placements.Aging & Mental Health,5(3),253-257.
12. Ge, H.,Yang, Z.,Li, X.,Liu, D.,Li, Y.,Pan, Y.,Luo, D.,Wu, X.(2020).The prevalence and associated factors of metabolic syndrome in Chinese aging population.Scientific Reports,10(1),Article 20034.
13. Goodwin, M. A.,Stange, K. C.,Zyzanski, S. J.,Crabtree, B. F.,Borawski, E. A.,Flocke, S. A.(2017).The Hawthorne effect in direct observation research with physicians and patients.Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice,23(6),1322-1328.
14. Griffiths, P.,Saville, C.,Ball, J.,Jones, J.,Pattison, N.,Monks, T.,Safer Nursing Care Study Group(2020).Nursing workload, nurse staffing methodologies and tools: A systematic scoping review and discussion.International Journal of Nursing Studies,103,Article 103487.
15. Han, Q.,Shi, X.(2016)。Investigation on job content of aged nurses in Shenzhen City。Chinese Nursing Research，30(12)，1478-1480。
16. Harrington, C.,Dellefield, M. E.,Halifax, E.,Fleming, M. L.,Bakerjian, D.(2020).Appropriate nurse staffing levels for U.S. nursing homes.Health Services Insights,13,Article 1178632920934785.
17. Hurst, K.(2003).Selecting and applying methods for estimating the size and mix of nursing teams: A systematic review of the literature commissioned by the Department of Health.Nuffield Institute for Health.
18. Karacsony, S.,Good, A.,Chang, E.,Johnson, A.,Edenborough, M.(2019).An instrument to assess the education needs of nursing assistants within a palliative approach in residential aged care facilities.BMC Palliative Care,18(1),Article 61.
19. Liu, L. F.,Yao, H. P.(2014).Examining the need assessment process by identifying the need profiles of elderly care recipients in the Ten-year Long-Term Care Project (TLTCP) of Taiwan.Journal of the American Medical Directors Association,15(12),946-954.
20. Ludlow, K.,Churruca, K.,Ellis, L. A.,Mumford, V.,Braithwaite, J.(2021).Decisions and dilemmas: The context of prioritization dilemmas and influences on staff members' prioritization decisions in residential aged care.Qualitative Health Research,31(7),1306-1318.
21. Ludlow, K.,Churruca, K.,Mumford, V.,Ellis, L. A.,Braithwaite, J.(2020).Staff members' prioritisation of care in residential aged care facilities: A Q methodology study.BMC Health Services Research,20(1),Article No. 423.
22. Matsumoto, R.,Yamada, T.,Takanokura, M.(2020).Staff scheduling and work allocation considering physical workload in senior daytime care facilities.Journal of Japanese Industrial Management Association,71(2E),99-110.
23. Munyisia, E. N.,Yu, P.,Hailey, D.(2011).How nursing staff spend their time on activities in a nursing home: An observational study.Journal of Advanced Nursing,67(9),1908-1917.
24. Paquay, L.,De Lepeleire, J.,Milisen, K.,Ylieff, M.,Fontaine, O.,Buntinx, F.(2007).Tasks performance by registered nurses and care assistants in nursing homes: A quantitative comparison of survey data.International Journal of Nursing Studies,44(8),1459-1467.
25. Qian, S. Y.,Yu, P.,Zhang, Z. Y.,Hailey, D. M.,Davy, P. J.,Nelson, M. I.(2012).The work pattern of personal care workers in two Australian nursing homes: A time–motion study.BMC Health Services Research,12(1),Article No. 305.
26. Qinggang Senior Care Center, the First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University. (2020). Top 100 list of combination of medical care and nursing in 2019 released: Qinggang elderly care center ranked first for four consecutive years. http://www.yanglaotiandi.com/press/7683
27. Rodriguez-Pereira, J.,de Armas, J.,Garbujo, L.,Ramalhinho, H.(2020).Health care needs and services for elder and disabled population: Findings from a Barcelona study.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,17(21),Article 8071.
28. Shin, S.,Park, J.-H.,Bae, S.-H.(2018).Nurse staffing and nurse outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis.Nursing Outlook,66(3),273-282.
29. Simmons, S. F.,Schnelle, J. F.(2006).Feeding assistance needs of long-stay nursing home residents and staff time to provide care.Journal of the American Geriatrics Society,54(6),919-924.
30. Sittig, D. F.(2005).Work-sampling: A statistical approach to evaluation of the effect of computers on work patterns in health care.Evaluating the organizational impact of healthcare information systems
31. Song, Y.,Anderson, R. A.,Corazzini, K. N.,Wu, B.(2014).Staff characteristics and care in Chinese nursing homes: A systematic literature review.International Journal of Nursing Sciences,1(4),423-436.
32. Telford, W.(1979).Determining nursing establishments.Health Services Manpower Review,5(4),11-17.
33. Trybusińska, D.,Saracen, A.(2019).Loneliness in the context of quality of life of nursing home residents.Open Medicine,14(1),354-361.
34. Tuinman, A.,de Greef, M. H.,Krijnen, W. P.,Nieweg, R. M.,Roodbol, P. F.(2016).Examining time use of dutch nursing staff in long-term institutional care: A time–motion study.The Journal of Post-Acute and Long-Term Care Medicine,17(2),148-154.
35. Wang, L.,Sun, Z.,Yin, L.,Xie, H.(2016)。Research on the allocation standards of nursing human resources in skilled nursing unit in long-term care facilities。Chinese Journal of Nursing，51(1)，15-20。
36. Wang, Z.,Yang, X.,Chen, M.(2020).Inequality and associated factors in utilization of long-term care among Chinese older people: Evidence from the Chinese longitudinal healthy longevity survey.Social Indicators Research,160,467-486.
37. Wise, S.(2020).Staffing policy in aged care must look beyond the numbers.Australian Health Review,44(6),829-830.
38. Xing, L.(2015)。A study on theoretical nurse staffing in general wards based on measurement of nursing working hours。Chinese Nursing Management，15(1)，61-64。
39. Xinhua Net. (2020, January 9). Rating pension institutions according to national standards this year. http://www.xinhuanet.com/health/2020-01/09/c_1125438015.htm (Original work published in Chinese)
40. Yen, P. Y.,Kellye, M.,Lopetegui, M.,Saha, A.,Loversidge, J.,Chipps, E. M.,Gallagher-Ford, L.,Buck, J.(2018).Nurses' time allocation and multitasking of nursing activities: A time motion study.AMIA Annual Symposium Proceedings,2018,1137-1146.
41. Zhang, H.,Shen, J.(2019)。Long term care needs and satisfaction of disabled elderly in medical and nursing institutions。Chongqing Medicine，48，3777-3780。
42. Zhao, X. (2018, July 9). The demand for elderly care workers is 13 million, but the number of employees is less than 300,000. China Daily. https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1605501637761496052&wfr=spider&for=pc
43. Zuluaga, B. H.(2000).Implementation of the Zuluaga–Raysmith (Z-R) model for assessment of perceived basic human needs in home health clients and caregivers.Public Health Nursing,17(5),317-324.