The Satisfaction With Care of Patients With Schizophrenia in Taiwan: A Cross-Sectional Survey of Patient-Centered Care Domains

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000549

Tsung-Tai CHEN；Ke-Hsin CHUEH；Kao-Chen CHEN；Chi-Ling CHOU；Jing-Jung YANG

patient-centered care ； schizophrenia ； patient satisfaction

The Journal of Nursing Research

31卷2期（2023 / 04 / 01）

1 - 8

英文

Background: Pharmacological interventions combined with nonpharmacological treatments such as patient-centered care (PCC)-related activities are widely used to enhance outcomes in patients with schizophrenia. However, few studies have examined and identified the PCC factors essential to achieving better outcomes in patients with schizophrenia. Purpose: This study was designed to identify the Picker-Institute-identified PCC domains associated with satisfaction and to determine which of these domains are most important in the context of schizophrenia care. Methods: Data were collected using patient surveys in outpatient settings and record reviews at two hospitals in northern Taiwan between November and December 2016. PCC data were collected in five domains: (a) support of patient autonomy; (b) goal setting; (c) collaboration and integration of healthcare services; (d) information, education, and communication; and (e) emotional support. The outcome measure was patient satisfaction. The study controlled for demographic factors, including age, gender, education, occupation, marriage, and urbanization level in the respondent's area of residence. Clinical characteristics included the Clinical Global Impressions severity and improvement index scores, previous admission, previous emergency department visit, and readmission within 1 year. Methods were adopted to prevent common method variance bias. Multivariable linear regression with stepwise selection and the generalized estimating equation were used to analyze the data. Results: After controlling for confounding factors, the generalized estimating equation model found only three PCC factors significantly associated with patient satisfaction, which differed slightly from the results of the multivariable linear regression. These three factors are as follows, in order of importance: information, education, and communication (parameter = 0.65 [0.37, 0.92], p < .001); emotional support (parameter = 0.52 [0.22, 0.81], p < .001); and goal setting (parameter = 0.31 [0.10, 0.51], p = .004). Conclusions: The three critical PCC-related factors were evaluated in terms of enhancing patient satisfaction in patients with schizophrenia. Practicable strategies related to these three factors should also be developed for implementation in clinical settings.

1. Allerby, K.,Goulding, A.,Ali, L.,Waern, M.(2020).Striving for a more person-centered psychosis care: Results of a hospital-based multi-professional educational intervention.BMC Psychiatry,20(1),523.
2. Aung, E.,Donald, M.,Williams, G. M.,Coll, J. R.,Doi, S. A.(2015).Joint influence of patient-assessed chronic illness care and patient activation on glycaemic control in type 2 diabetes.International Journal for Quality in Health Care,27(2),117-124.
3. Cella, D.,Hahn, E. A.,Jensen, S. E.,Butt, Z.,Nowinski, C. J.,Rothrock, N.,Lohr, K. N.(2015).Patient-reported outcomes in performance measurement.RTI Press.
4. Chan, S. W.(2021).Chronic disease management, self-efficacy and quality of life.The Journal of Nursing Research,29(1),e129.
5. Chang, T. J.,Bridges, J. F. P.,Bynum, M.,Jackson, J. W.,Joseph, J. J.,Fischer, M. A.,Lu, B.,Donneyong, M. M.(2021).Association between patient-clinician relationships and adherence to antihypertensivemedications among black adults: An observational study design.Journal of the American Heart Association,10(14),e019943.
6. Chang, W. P.,Wu, S. J.,Chang, W. C.,Kuo, H. C.(2013).Population-based study of the association between urbanization and Kawasaki disease in Taiwan.Scientific World Journal,2013,169365.
7. Chen, T. T.,Oldenburg, B.,Hsueh, Y. S.(2021).Chronic care model in the diabetes pay-for-performance program in Taiwan: Benefits, challenges and future directions.World Journal of Diabetes,12(5),578-589.
8. Correll, C. U.(2020).Using patient-centered assessment in schizophrenia care: Defining recovery and discussing concerns and preferences.The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry,81(3),MS19053BR2C.
9. Engle, R. L.,Mohr, D. C.,Holmes, S. K.,Seibert, M. N.,Afable, M.,Leyson, J.,Meterko, M.(2021).Evidence-based practice and patient-centered care: Doing both well.Health Care Management Review,46(3),174-184.
10. Gardner, T.,Refshauge, K.,McAuley, J.,Hübscher, M.,Goodall, S.,Smith, L.(2019).Combined education and patient-led goal setting intervention reduced chronic low back pain disability and intensity at 12 months: A randomised controlled trial.British Journal of Sports Medicine,53(22),1424-1431.
11. Gerteis, M.,Edgman-Levitan, S.,Daley, J.,Delbanco, T. L.(1993).Through the patient's eyes: Understanding and promoting patient-centered care.Jossey-Bass.
12. Jaensch, D.,Baker, N.,Gordon, S.(2019).Contemporaneous patient and health professional views of patient-centred care: A systematic review.International Journal for Quality in Health Care,31(10),G165-G173.
13. Johnsen, A. T.,Holge-Hazelton, B.,Skovbakke, S. J.,Rottmann, N.,Thomsen, T. G.,Eskildsen, N. B.,Pedersen, S. S.(2022).Perceptions of person-centred care in two large university hospitals: A cross-sectional survey among healthcare professionals.Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences,36(3),791-802.
14. Kim, C.,Berta, W. B.,Gagliardi, A. R.(2021).Exploring approaches to identify, incorporate and report patient preferences in clinical guidelines: Qualitative interviews with guideline developers.Patient Education and Counseling,104(4),703-708.
15. Langberg, E. M.,Dyhr, L.,Davidsen, A. S.(2019).Development of the concept of patient-centredness-A systematic review.Patient Education and Counseling,102(7),1228-1236.
16. Lee, A. A.,Piette, J. D.,Heisler, M.,Janevic, M. R.,Rosland, A. M.(2019).Diabetes self-management and glycemic control: The role of autonomy support from informal health supporters.Health Psychology,38(2),122-132.
17. Lee, Y. Y.,Lin, J. L.(2010).Do patient autonomy preferences matter? Linking patient-centered care to patient-physician relationships and health outcomes.Social Science & Medicine,71(10),1811-1818.
18. Leucht, S.,Burkard, T.,Henderson, J.,Maj, M.,Sartorius, N.(2007).Physical illness and schizophrenia: A review of the literature.Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica,116(5),317-333.
19. Luther, L.,Fukui, S.,Garabrant, J. M.,Rollins, A. L.,Morse, G.,Henry, N.,Shimp, D.,Gearhart, T.,Salyers, M. P.(2019).Measuring quality of care in community mental health: Validation of concordant clinician and client quality-of-care scales.Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research,46(1),64-79.
20. Marder, S. R.,Cannon, T. D.(2019).Schizophrenia.The New England Journal of Medicine,381(18),1753-1761.
21. McDermott, M. S.,Sharma, R.(2017).Evaluating the impact of method bias in health behaviour research: A meta-analytic examination of studies utilising the theories of reasoned action and planned behaviour.Health Psychology Review,11(4),358-373.
22. Med-IQ. (2014). Goal-setting worksheet for patients with schizophrenia. https://www.med-iq.com/files/noncme/material/pdfs/GoalSetting1.pdf
23. Meterko, M.,Wright, S.,Lin, H.,Lowy, E.,Cleary, P. D.(2010).Mortality among patients with acute myocardial infarction: The influences of patient-centered care and evidence-based medicine.Health Services Research,45(5, Pt. 1),1188-1204.
24. Mosen, D. M.,Schmittdiel, J.,Hibbard, J.,Sobel, D.,Remmers, C.,Bellows, J.(2007).Is patient activation associated with outcomes of care for adults with chronic conditions?.Journal of Ambulatory Care Management,30(1),21-29.
25. Navarro, S.,Ochoa, C. Y.,Chan, E.,Du, S.,Farias, A. J.(2021).Will improvements in patient experience with care impact clinical and quality of care outcomes?: A systematic review.Medical Care,59(9),843-856.
26. Oles, S. K.,Fukui, S.,Rand, K. L.,Salyers, M. P.(2015).The relationship between hope and patient activation in consumers with schizophrenia: Results from longitudinal analyses.Psychiatry Research,228(3),272-276.
27. Ong, L. M.,Visser, M. R.,Lammes, F. B.,de Haes, J. C.(2000).Doctor-patient communication and cancer patients' quality of life and satisfaction.Patient Education and Counseling,41(2),145-156.
28. Pestana-Santos, A.,Loureiro, L.,Santos, V.,Carvalho, I.(2018).Patients with schizophrenia assessing psychiatrists' communication skills.Psychiatry Research,269,13-20.
29. Podsakoff, P. M.,MacKenzie, S. B.,Lee, J. Y.,Podsakoff, N. P.(2003).Common method biases in behavioral research: A critical review of the literature and recommended remedies.Journal of Applied Psychology,88(5),879-903.
30. Ratanawongsa, N.,Karter, A. J.,Parker, M. M.,Lyles, C. R.,Heisler, M.,Moffet, H. H.,Adler, N.,Warton, E. M.,Schillinger, D.(2013).Communication and medication refill adherence: The diabetes study of Northern California.JAMA Internal Medicine,173(3),210-218.
31. Rathert, C.,Williams, E. S.,McCaughey, D.,Ishqaidef, G.(2015).Patient perceptions of patient-centred care: Empirical test of a theoretical model.Health Expectations,18(2),199-209.
32. Rathert, C.,Wyrwich, M. D.,Boren, S. A.(2013).Patient-centered care and outcomes: A systematic review of the literature.Medical Care Research and Review,70(4),351-379.
33. Robinson, J. D.,Hoover, D. R.,Venetis, M. K.,Kearney, T. J.,Street, R. L., Jr.(2013).Consultations between patients with breast cancer and surgeons: A pathway from patient-centered communication to reduced hopelessness.Journal of Clinical Oncology,31(3),351-358.
34. Schmittdiel, J.,Mosen, D. M.,Glasgow, R. E.,Hibbard, J.,Remmers, C.,Bellows, J.(2008).Patient Assessment of Chronic Illness Care (PACIC) and improved patient-centered outcomes for chronic conditions.Journal of General Internal Medicine,23(1),77-80.
35. Silva, N. C.,Bassani, D. G.,Palazzo, L. S.(2009).A case-control study of factors associated with multiple psychiatric readmissions.Psychiatric Services,60(6),786-791.
36. Stiggelbout, A. M.,Pieterse, A. H.,De Haes, J. C.(2015).Shared decision making: Concepts, evidence, and practice.Patient Education and Counseling,98(10),1172-1179.
37. Tsvitman, I.,Castel, O. C.,Dagan, E.(2021).The association between perceived patient-centered care and symptoms experienced by patients undergoing anti-cancer treatment.Supportive Care in Cancer,29,6279-6287.
38. Wagner, E. H.,Austin, B. T.,Davis, C.,Hindmarsh, M.,Schaefer, J.,Bonomi, A.(2001).Improving chronic illness care: Translating evidence into action.Health Affairs,20(6),64-78.
39. Waltz, C. F.,Strickland, O. L.,Lenz, E. R.(2017).Measurement in nursing and health research.Springer.
40. Williams, G. C.,McGregor, H. A.,King, D.,Nelson, C. C.,Glasgow, R. E.(2005).Variation in perceived competence, glycemic control, and patient satisfaction: Relationship to autonomy support from physicians.Patient Education and Counseling,57(1),39-45.
41. Zhang, I. Y.,Liao, J. M.(2021).Incorporating emotions into clinical decision-making solutions.Healthcare,9(3),100569.