Lived Experience of Violence Perpetrated by Treated Patients and Their Visitors in Intensive Care Units: A Qualitative Study of Nurses

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000562

I-Lu FANG；Mei-Chi HSU；Wen-Chen OUYANG

patient and visitor violence ； intensive care unit ； nurses ； flashpoints ； emotionally suppressed

The Journal of Nursing Research

31卷4期（2023 / 08 / 01）

1 - 10

英文

Background: Patient and visitor violence (PVV) is a widespread problem for health professionals. Nurses working in intensive care units (ICUs) face a relatively high risk of experiencing PVV, which significantly impacts both the health of nurses and the institution as a whole. The subjective perceptions of ICU nurses regarding PVV are inadequately explored in the literature. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to explore the perspectives, experiences, and perceptions of PVV in ICU nurses and to better understand the precipitating factors of violence. Methods: A phenomenological qualitative design and purposive sampling were used. A semistructured interview guide was used to conduct in-depth interviews with 12 ICU nurses with PVV experiences. Giorgi's method of analysis was used to discover and identify the essential categories of experience. Results: Five main experience categories were identified: family and patient factors as flashpoints, managing suppressed emotions by weathering the emotional storm, spiritual awakening after violence, and strategies for surviving further violence. The participants' experiences with PVV included a range of caring and mental health difficulties. In ICU settings, patient progress is often unpredictable, resulting in discrepancies between patient/family expectations and reality. Because feelings of frustration and powerlessness can eventually cause exhaustion in ICU nurses, implementing effective emotional management, stress adjustment, psychological counseling, team support, and violence intervention programs are crucial. Conclusions/Implications for Practice: This study provides new information on the process by which nurses can progress from inner trauma to self-recovery, moving from a negative affectivity disposition to a better understanding of threat appraisals and coping response options. Nurses should increase their awareness of the complexity of the phenomenon and of the interplay among the factors underlying PVV. The results of this study suggest that routine confusion and delirium assessments to rule out patients with ICU delirium in ICUs are important to preventing PVV. This study considers some of the implications of the research findings for nursing managers. Interventions, training programs, and/or management action should be used to ensure psychological and mental support is extended to all witnesses of PVV events and not only to those targeted by violence.

1. Gu, M.,Kim, Y. S.,Sok, S.(2022).Factors influencing turnover intention among operating room nurses in South Korea.The Journal of Nursing Research,30(1),e192.
   連結：
2. Niu, S. F.,Lee, T. Y.,Tsai, J. C.,Hsing, S. C.,Wu, S. C.,Kao, C. C.(2018)。Workplace violence against nurses in northern Taiwan: A cross-sectional study。The Journal of Nursing，65(6)，44-54。
   連結：
3. Rayan, A.,Sisan, M.,Baker, O.(2019).Stress, workplace violence, and burnout in nurses working in King Abdullah Medical City during Al-Hajj season.The Journal of Nursing Research,27(3),e26.
   連結：
4. Al-Sahlawi, K. S.,Atawneh, F. A.,Zahid, M. A.,Shahid, A. A.,Al-Farrah, M. H.(2003).Violence against nurses in hospitals: Prevalence and effects.British Journal of Nursing,12(2),102-107.
5. Bingöl, S.,İnce, S.(2021).Factors influencing violence at emergency departments: Patients’ relatives' perspectives.International Emergency Nursing,54,100942.
6. Cassell, C.(2015).Conducting research interviews for business and management students.SAGE Publications.
7. Chen, T. J.,Chung, Y. W.,Chang, H. R.,Chen, P. Y.,Wu, C. R.,Hsieh, S. H.,Chiu, H. Y.(2020).Diagnostic accuracy of The CAM-ICU and ICDSC in detecting intensive care unit delirium: A bivariate meta-analysis.International Journal of Nursing Studies,113,103782.
8. Chiou, S. T.,Chiang, J. H.,Huang, N.,Wu, C. H.,Chien, L. Y.(2013).Health issues among nurses in Taiwanese hospitals: National survey.International Journal of Nursing Studies,50(10),1377-1384.
9. de Looff, P.,Nijman, H.,Didden, R.,Embregts, P.(2018).Burnout symptoms in forensic psychiatric nurses and their associations with personality, emotional intelligence and client aggression: A cross-sectional study.Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing,25(8),506-516.
10. Döndü, Ş.,Yasemin, B.(2021).Determination of the society's perceptions, experiences, and intentions to use violence against health professionals.Safety and Health at Work,12(2),141-146.
11. Guba, E. G.,Lincoln, Y.(1989).Fourth generation evaluation.Sage.
12. Hahn, S.,Müller, M.,Hantikainen, V.,Kok, G.,Dassen, T.,Halfens, R. J.(2013).Risk factors associated with patient and visitor violence in general hospitals: Results of a multiple regression analysis.International Journal of Nursing Studies,50(3),374-385.
13. Huang, W.,Cai, S.,Zhou, Y.,Huang, J.,Sun, X.,Su, Y.,Dai, M.,Lan, Y.(2021).Personality profiles and personal factors associated with psychological distress in Chinese nurses.Psychology Research and Behavior Management,14,1567-1579.
14. International Labour Organization,International Council of Nurses,World Health Organization,Public Services International(2002).Framework guidelines for addressing workplace violence in the health sector.International Labour Organization.
15. Johnsen, G. E.,Morken, T.,Baste, V.,Rypdal, K.,Palmstierna, T.,Johansen, I. H.(2020).Characteristics of aggressive incidents in emergency primary health care described by the Staff Observation Aggression Scale-Revised Emergency (SOAS-RE).BMC Health Services Research,20(1),33.
16. Karatuna, I.,Jönsson, S.,Muhonen, T.(2020).Workplace bullying in the nursing profession: A cross-cultural scoping review.International Journal of Nursing Studies,111,103628.
17. Kibunja, B. K.,Musembi, H. M.,Kimani, R. W.,Gatimu, S. M.(2021).Prevalence and effect of workplace violence against emergency nurses at a tertiary hospital in Kenya: A cross-sectional study.Safety and Health at Work,12(2),249-254.
18. Kumar, N. S.,Munta, K.,Kumar, J. R.,Rao, S. M.,Dnyaneshwar, M.,Harde, Y. R.(2019).A survey on workplace violence experienced by critical care physicians.Indian Journal of Critical Care Medicine,23(7),295-301.
19. Lee, J.,Daffern, M.,Ogloff, J. R. P.,Martin, T.(2015).Towards A model for understanding the development of post-traumatic stress and general distress in mental health nurses.International Journal of Nursing Studies,24(1),49-58.
20. Liu, H.,Zhao, S.,Jiao, M.,Wang, J.,Peters, D. H.,Qiao, H.,Zhao, Y.,Li, Y.,Song, L.,Xing, K.,Lu, Y.,Wu, Q.(2015).Extent, nature, and risk factors of workplace violence in public tertiary hospitals in China: A cross-sectional survey.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,12(6),6801-6817.
21. Llor-Esteban, B.,Sánchez-Muñoz, M. D.,Ruiz-Hernández, J. A.,Jiménez-Barbero, J. A.(2017).User violence towards nursing professionals in mental health services and emergency units.European Journal of Psychology Applied to Legal Context,9,33-40.
22. Newman, C.,Roche, M.,Elliott, D.(2021).Exposure to workplace trauma for forensic mental health nurses: A scoping review.International Journal of Nursing Studies,117,103897.
23. Occupational Safety and Health Administration. (2015). Workplace violence in healthcare: Understanding the challenge. https://www.osha.gov/sites/default/files/OSHA3826.pdf
24. Papadopoulos, C.,Ross, J.,Stewart, D.,Dack, C.,James, K.,Bowers, L.(2012).The antecedents of violence and aggression within psychiatric in-patient settings.Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica,125(6),425-439.
25. Park, M.,Cho, S. H.,Hong, H. J.(2015).Prevalence and perpetrators of workplace violence by nursing unit and the relationship between violence and the perceived work environment.Journal of Nursing Scholarship,47(1),87-95.
26. Phillips, J. P.(2016).Workplace violence against health care workers in the United States.New England Journal of Medicine,374(17),1661-1669.
27. Pol, A.,Carter, M.,Bouchoucha, S.(2019).Violence and aggression in the intensive care unit: What is the impact of Australian National Emergency Access Target?.Australian Critical Care,32(6),502-508.
28. Salyers, M. P.,Bonfils, K. A.,Luther, L.,Firmin, R. L.,White, D. A.,Adams, E. L.,Rollins, A. L.(2017).The relationship between professional burnout and quality and safety in healthcare: A meta-analysis.Journal of General Internal Medicine,32(4),475-482.
29. Shi, L.,Li, G.,Hao, J.,Wang, W.,Chen, W.,Liu, S.,Yu, Z.,Shi, Y.,Ma, Y.,Fan, L.,Zhang, L.,Han, X.(2020).Psychological depletion in physicians and nurses exposed to workplace violence: A cross-sectional study using propensity score analysis.International Journal of Nursing Studies,103,103493.
30. Somani, R.,Muntaner, C.,Hillan, E.,Velonis, A. J.,Smith, P.(2021).A systematic review: Effectiveness of interventions to de-escalate workplace violence against nurses in healthcare settings.Safety and Health at Work,12(3),289-295.
31. Thomas, D. R.(2006).A general inductive approach for analyzing qualitative evaluation data.American Journal of Evaluation,27,237-246.
32. Wei, C. Y.,Chiou, S. T.,Chien, L. Y.,Huang, N.(2016).Workplace violence against nurses-Prevalence and association with hospital organizational characteristics and health-promotion efforts: Cross-sectional study.International Journal of Nursing Studies,56,63-70.
33. Zhan, Y.,Kim, S. K.,Zhou, L.,Xie, B.,Li, Y.,Wen, B.,Nie, L.(2019).Patient violence and health professionals' occupational outcomes in China: A time-lagged survey study.International Journal of Nursing Studies,94,120-130.