Feasibility of Different Exercise Modalities for Community-Dwelling Residents With Physical Inactivity: A Randomized Controlled Trial

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000578

Yu-Hsuan CHANG；Shiow-Ching SHUN；Min-Hsin CHEN；Yin-Fan CHANG

body composition ； endurance training ； high-intensity interval training ； lipids ； resistance training

The Journal of Nursing Research

31卷6期（2023 / 12 / 01）

1 - 11

英文

Background: Exercise interventions can promote health, but they can be difficult to implement. Moreover, no consensus has been reached regarding which exercise modality promotes the most significant improvement in metabolic health. Purpose: This feasibility study was conducted to (a) determine the implementation efficacy of supervised and home-based exercise interventions by investigating their respective rates of intervention adherence, adherence to targeted intensity, attrition, and adverse events and (b) explore the preliminary efficacy of 12-week exercise programs among aerobic exercise, aerobic exercise combined with resistance exercise, and high-intensity interval training on body composition, anthropometric parameters, and lipid profiles for community-dwelling residents with physical inactivity. Methods: This randomized controlled trial was conducted from April to October 2020. Seventy-two sedentary participants aged 40-70 years were enrolled and randomized into one of four groups: 12-week aerobic exercise, aerobic exercise combined with resistance exercise, high-intensity interval training, and control. The three exercise groups performed at least moderate-intensity supervised exercise twice a week and home-based exercise once a week, whereas the control group maintained their usual daily activities. The target variables, including body composition, anthropometric parameters, and lipid profiles, were measured before and after the 12-week intervention. Results: The intervention adherence rates were 74.01%- 87.54% for the supervised exercise group, 64.98%-83.90% for the home-based exercise group, and 82.65%-92.65% for the target exercise intensity group. The attrition rate ranged from 12.50%to 17.65%, and no adverse events were reported in any of the exercise groups. Preliminary efficacy data show the reductions in body weight (95% CI [0.01, 1.20], p = .048) and low-density lipoprotein (95%CI [2.76, 30.32], p = .02) were greater in the exercise groups than the control group, although the intergroup differences were not significant. Conclusions/Implications for Practice: Body weight and low-density lipoprotein may be efficiently reduced in a 12-week period using any of the three exercise modalities with at least 82.65%adherence to moderate-intensity exercise and 70.84% adherence to exercising 3 times a week.

1. Kim, H. J.,Kim, H. S.,Kim, H. R.,Yoo, Y. S.,Song, B. J.(2020).Characterization of metabolic syndrome risk factors and health-related behaviors in Korean patients with breast cancer by abdominal obesity status.The Journal of Nursing Research,28(2),e74.
   連結：
2. Su, Y.-L.,Chen, H.-L.,Han, S.-L.,Lin, Y.-K.,Lin, S.-Y.,Liu, C.-H.(2022).Effectiveness of elastic band exercises on the functional fitness of older adults in long-term care facilities.The Journal of Nursing Research,30(5),e235.
   連結：
3. Tsai, C.-C.,Li, A.-H.,Tu, C.-M.,Hwang, K.-L.,Jeng, C.(2019).Effectiveness of a tailored lifestyle management program for middle-aged women with coronary artery disease: A preliminary study.The Journal of Nursing Research,27(1),1-10.
   連結：
4. Abbas, Y.,Martinetti, A.,Frunt, L.,Klinkers, J.,Rajabalinejad, M.,van Dongen, L. A. M.(2022).Investigating interdependencies between key features of lessons learned: An integral approach for knowledge sharing.Journal of Information & Knowledge Management,21(2),2250019.
5. Abdelbasset, W. K.,Tantawy, S. A.,Kamel, D. M.,Alqahtani, B. A.,Elnegamy, T. E.,Soliman, G. S.,Ibrahim, A. A.(2020).Effects of high-intensity interval and moderate-intensity continuous aerobic exercise on diabetic obese patients with nonalcoholic fatty liver disease: A comparative randomized controlled trial.Medicine (Baltimore),99(10),e19471.
6. Alberga, A. S.,Prud'homme, D.,Kenny, G. P.,Goldfield, G. S.,Hadjiyannakis, S.,Gougeon, R.,Phillips, P.,Malcolm, J.,Wells, G.,Doucette, S.,Ma, J.,Sigal, R. J.(2015).Effects of aerobic and resistance training on abdominal fat, apolipoproteins and high-sensitivity C-reactive protein in adolescents with obesity: The HEARTY randomized clinical trial.International Journal of Obesity,39(10),1494-1500.
7. Andreato, L. V.,Esteves, J. V.,Coimbra, D. R.,Moraes, A. J. P.,de Carvalho, T.(2019).The influence of high-intensity interval training on anthropometric variables of adults with overweight or obesity: A systematic review and network meta-analysis.Obesity Reviews,20(1),142-155.
8. Arem, H.,Sorkin, M.,Cartmel, B.,Fiellin, M.,Capozza, S.,Harrigan, M.,Ercolano, E.,Zhou, Y.,Sanft, T.,Gross, C.,Schmitz, K.,Neogi, T.,Hershman, D.,Ligibel, J.,Irwin, M. L.(2016).Exercise adherence in a randomized trial of exercise on aromatase inhibitor arthralgias in breast cancer survivors: The Hormones and Physical Exercise (HOPE) study.Journal of Cancer Survivorship,10(4),654-662.
9. Argent, R.,Daly, A.,Caulfield, B.(2018).Patient involvement with home-based exercise programs: Can connected health interventions influence adherence?.JMIR mHealth and uHealth,6(3),e47.
10. Armstrong, A.,Jungbluth Rodriguez, K.,Sabag, A.,Mavros, Y.,Parker, H. M.,Keating, S. E.,Johnson, N. A.(2022).Effect of aerobic exercise on waist circumference in adults with overweight or obesity: A systematic review and meta-analysis.Obesity Reviews,23(8),e13446.
11. Baetge, C.,Earnest, C. P.,Lockard, B.,Coletta, A. M.,Galvan, E.,Rasmussen, C.,Levers, K.,Simbo, S. Y.,Jung, Y. P.,Koozehchian, M.,Oliver, J.,Dalton, R.,Sanchez, B.,Byrd, M. J.,Khanna, D.,Jagim, A.,Kresta, J.,Greenwood, M.,Kreider, R. B.(2017).Efficacy of a randomized trial examining commercial weight loss programs and exercise on metabolic syndrome in overweight and obese women.Applied Physiology, Nutrition, and Metabolism,42(2),216-227.
12. Ballin, M.,Hult, A.,Björk, S.,Lundberg, E.,Nordström, P.,Nordström, A.(2020).Web-based exercise versus supervised exercise for decreasing visceral adipose tissue in older adults with central obesity: A randomized controlled trial.BMC Geriatrics,20(1),173.
13. Bellicha, A.,van Baak, M. A.,Battista, F.,Beaulieu, K.,Blundell, J. E.,Busetto, L.,Carraça, E. V.,Dicker, D.,Encantado, J.,Ermolao, A.,Farpour-Lambert, N.,Pramono, A.,Woodward, E.,Oppert, J.-M.(2021).Effect of exercise training on weight loss, body composition changes, and weight maintenance in adults with overweight or obesity: An overview of 12 systematic reviews and 149 studies.Obesity Reviews,22(S4),e13256.
14. Berge, J.,Hjelmesaeth, J.,Hertel, J. K.,Gjevestad, E.,Småstuen, M. C.,Johnson, L. K.,Martins, C.,Andersen, E.,Helgerud, J.,Støren, Ø.(2021).Effect of aerobic exercise intensity on energy expenditure and weight loss in severe obesity—A randomized controlled trial.Obesity,29(2),359-369.
15. Brellenthin, A. G.,Lanningham-Foster, L. M.,Kohut, M. L.,Li, Y.,Church, T. S.,Blair, S. N.,Lee, D. C.(2019).Comparison of the cardiovascular benefits of resistance, aerobic, and combined exercise (CardioRACE): Rationale, design, and methods.American Heart Journal,217,101-111.
16. Brown, J. D.,Buscemi, J.,Milsom, V.,Malcolm, R.,O'Neil, P. M.(2016).Effects on cardiovascular risk factors of weight losses limited to 5-10.Translational Behavioral Medicine,6(3),339-346.
17. Chang, Y.-H.,Yang, H.-Y.,Shun, S.-C.(2021).Effect of exercise intervention dosage on reducing visceral adipose tissue: A systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.International Journal of Obesity,45(5),982-997.
18. Chien, W. T.,Mui, J. H.,Cheung, E. F.,Gray, R.(2015).Effects of motivational interviewing-based adherence therapy for schizophrenia spectrum disorders: A randomized controlled trial.Trials,16,270.
19. Chin, E. C.,Yu, A. P.,Lai, C. W.,Fong, D. Y.,Chan, D. K.,Wong, S. H.,Sun, F.,Ngai, H. H.,Yung, P. S. H.,Siu, P. M.(2020).Low-frequency HIIT improves body composition and aerobic capacity in overweightmen.Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,52(1),56-66.
20. Christensen, R. H.,Wedell-Neergaard, A. S.,Lehrskov, L. L.,Legaard, G. E.,Dorph, E.,Larsen, M. K.,Launbo, N.,Fagerlind, S. R.,Seide, S. K.,Nymand, S.,Ball, M.,Vinum, N. B.,Dahl, C. N.,Henneberg, M.,Ried-Larsen, M.,Boesen, M. P.,Christensen, R.,Karstoft, K.,Krogh-Madsen, R.,Ellingsgaard, H.(2019).Effect of aerobic and resistance exercise on cardiac adipose tissues: Secondary analyses from a randomized clinical trial.JAMA Cardiology,4(8),778-787.
21. Cronin, O.,Barton, W.,Moran, C.,Sheehan, D.,Whiston, R.,Nugent, H.,McCarthy, Y.,Molloy, C. B.,O'Sullivan, O.,Cotter, P. D.,Molloy, M. G.,Shanahan, F.(2019).Moderate-intensity aerobic and resistance exercise is safe and favorably influences body composition in patients with quiescent inflammatory bowel disease: A randomized controlled cross-over trial.BMC Gastroenterolgy,19(1),29.
22. Cuff, D. J.,Meneilly, G. S.,Martin, A.,Ignaszewski, A.,Tildesley, H. D.,Frohlich, J. J.(2003).Effective exercise modality to reduce insulin resistance in women with type 2 diabetes.Diabetes Care,26(11),2977-2982.
23. Curtis, R. G.,Ryan, J. C.,Edney, S. M.,Maher, C. A.(2020).Can Instagram be used to deliver an evidence-based exercise program for young women? A process evaluation.BMC Public Health,20(1),1506.
24. Dalah, E.,Hasan, H.,Madkour, M.,Obaideen, A.,Faris, M. A.(2021).Assessing visceral and subcutaneous adiposity using segmented T2-MRI and multi-frequency segmental bioelectrical impedance: A sex-based comparative study.Acta Bio-Medica,92(3),e2021078.
25. Garner, S.,Fenton, T.,Martin, L.,Creaser, C.,Johns, C.,Barnabe, C.(2018).Personalized diet and exercise recommendations in early rheumatoid arthritis: A feasibility trial.Musculoskeletal Care,16(1),167-172.
26. Hwang, C. L.,Lim, J.,Yoo, J. K.,Kim, H. K.,Hwang, M. H.,Handberg, E. M.,Petersen, J. W.,Holmer, B. J.,Leey Casella, J. A.,Cusi, K.,Christou, D. D.(2019).Effect of all-extremity high-intensity interval training vs. moderate-intensity continuous training on aerobic fitness in middle-aged and older adults with type 2 diabetes: A randomized controlled trial.Experimental Gerontology,116,46-53.
27. Keating, S. E.,Hackett, D. A.,Parker, H. M.,Way, K. L.,O'Connor, H. T.,Sainsbury, A.,Baker, M. K.,Chuter, V. H.,Caterson, I. D.,George, J.,Johnson, N. A.(2017).Effect of resistance training on liver fat and visceral adiposity in adults with obesity: A randomized controlled trial.Hepatology Research,47(7),622-631.
28. Kim, S. J.,Yoon, E. S.,Jung, S. Y.,Kim, D. Y.(2020).Effect of uphill walking on browning factor and high molecular weight-adiponectin in postmenopausal women.Journal of Exercise Rehabilitation,16(3),265-271.
29. Lee, A. S.,Johnson, N. A.,McGill, M. J.,Overland, J.,Luo, C.,Baker, C. J.,Martinez-Huenchullan, S.,Wong, J.,Flack, J. R.,Twigg, S. M.(2020).Effect of high-intensity interval training on glycemic control in adults with type 1 diabetes and overweight or obesity: A randomized controlled trial with partial crossover.Diabetes Care,43(9),2281-2288.
30. Lee, I. M.,Shiroma, E. J.,Lobelo, F.,Puska, P.,Blair, S. N.,Katzmarzyk, P. T.,Lancet Physical Activity Series Working Group(2012).Effect of physical inactivity on major non-communicable diseases worldwide: An analysis of burden of disease and life expectancy.The Lancet,380(9838),219-229.
31. Lee, S.,Libman, I.,Hughan, K.,Kuk, J. L.,Jeong, J. H.,Zhang, D.,Arslanian, S.(2019).Effects of exercise modality on insulin resistance and ectopic fat in adolescents with overweight and obesity: A randomized clinical trial.The Journal of Pediatrics,206,91-98.e1.
32. Lund, L. W.,Ammitzbøll, G.,Hansen, D. G.,Andersen, E. A. W.,Dalton, S. O.(2019).Adherence to a long-term progressive resistance training program, combining supervised and home-based exercise for breast cancer patients during adjuvant treatment.Acta Oncologica,58(5),650-657.
33. Luo, X.,Wang, Z.,Li, B.,Zhang, X.,Li, X.(2023).Effect of resistance vs. aerobic exercise in pre-diabetes: An RCT.Trials,24(1),110.
34. Ma, Y.,Cheng, H. Y.,Sit, J. W. H.,Chien, W. T.(2022).The effects of a smartphone-enhanced nurse-facilitated self-care intervention for Chinese hypertensive patients: A randomised controlled trial.International Journal of Nursing Studies,134,104313.
35. Maillard, F.,Pereira, B.,Boisseau, N.(2018).Effect of high-intensity interval training on total, abdominal and visceral fat mass: A meta-analysis.Sports Medicine,48(2),269-288.
36. Mann, S.,Beedie, C.,Jimenez, A.(2014).Differential effects of aerobic exercise, resistance training and combined exercise modalities on cholesterol and the lipid profile: Review synthesis and recommendations.Sports Medicine,44(2),211-221.
37. McLaughlin, T.,Abbasi, F.,Lamendola, C.,Yee, G.,Carter, S.,Cushman, S. W.(2019).Dietary weight loss in insulin-resistant non-obese humans: Metabolic benefits and relationship to adipose cell size.Nutrition, Metabolism, and Cardiovascular Diseases,29(1),62-68.
38. Patel, H.,Alkhawam, H.,Madanieh, R.,Shah, N.,Kosmas, C. E.,Vittorio, T. J.(2017).Aerobic vs anaerobic exercise training effects on the cardiovascular system.World Journal of Cardiology,9(2),134-138.
39. Pescatello, L. S.(2014).ACSM's guidelines for exercise testing and prescription.:Wolters Kluwer.
40. Picorelli, A. M.,Pereira, L. S.,Pereira, D. S.,Felício, D.,Sherrington, C.(2014).Adherence to exercise programs for older people is influenced by program characteristics and personal factors: A systematic review.Journal of Physiotherapy,60(3),151-156.
41. Power, S.,Rowley, N.,Flynn, D.,Duncan, M.,Broom, D.(2022).Home-based exercise for adults with overweight or obesity: A rapid review.Obesity Research & Clinical Practice,16(2),97-105.
42. Reljic, D.,Wittmann, F.,Fischer, J. E.(2018).Effects of low-volume high-intensity interval training in a community setting: A pilot study.European Journal of Applied Physiology,118(6),1153-1167.
43. Roberts, S. B.,Rosenberg, I.(2006).Nutrition and aging: Changes in the regulation of energy metabolism with aging.Physiological Reviews,86(2),651-667.
44. Ryan, B. J.,Schleh, M. W.,Ahn, C.,Ludzki, A. C.,Gillen, J. B.,Varshney, P.,Van Pelt, D. W.,Pitchford, L. M.,Chenevert, T. L.,Gioscia-Ryan, R. A.,Howton, S. M.,Rode, T.,Hummel, S. L.,Burant, C. F.,Little, J. P.,Horowitz, J. F.(2020).Moderate-intensity exercise and high-intensity interval training affect in-sulin sensitivity similarly in obese adults.The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism,105(8),e2941-e2959.
45. Sabag, A.,Way, K. L.,Keating, S. E.,Sultana, R. N.,O’Connor, H. T,Baker, M. K.,Chuter, V. H.,George, J.,Johnson, N. A.(2017).Exercise and ectopic fat in type 2 diabetes: A systematic review and meta-analysis.Diabetes & Metabolism,43(3),195-210.
46. Siri-Tarino, P. W.,Williams, P. T.,Fernstrom, H. S.,Rawlings, R. S.,Krauss, R. M.(2009).Reversal of small, dense LDL subclass phenotype by normalization of adiposity.Obesity,17(9),1768-1775.
47. Thompson, D.,Karpe, F.,Lafontan, M.,Frayn, K.(2012).Physical activity and exercise in the regulation of human adipose tis sue physiology.Physiological Reviews,92(1),157-191.
48. Vella, C. A.,Taylor, K.,Drummer, D.(2017).High-intensity interval and moderate-intensity continuous training elicit similar enjoyment and adherence levels in overweight and obese adults.European Journal of Sport Science,17(9),1203-1211.
49. Vincze, L.,Rollo, M. E.,Hutchesson, M. J.,Callister, R.,Collins, C. E.(2018).VITAL change for mums: A feasibility study investigating tailored nutrition and exercise care delivered by video-consultations for women 3-12 months postpartum.Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics,31(3),337-348.
50. Wang, J.,Gong, D.,Luo, H.,Zhang, W.,Zhang, L.,Zhang, H.,Zhou, J.,Wang, S.(2020).Measurement of step angle for quantifying the gait impairment of Parkinson's disease by wearable sensors: Controlled study.JMIR mHealth uHealth,8(3),e16650.
51. Wang, Y.,Xu, D.(2017).Effects of aerobic exercise on lipids and lipoproteins.Lipids in Health and Disease,16(1),132.
52. Woodward, A.,Broom, D.,Dalton, C.,Metwally, M.,Klonizakis, M.(2020).Supervised exercise training and increased physical activity to reduce cardiovascular disease risk in women with polycystic ovary syndrome: Study protocol for a randomized controlled feasibility trial.Trials,21(1),101.
53. Yan, J.,Dai, X.,Feng, J.,Yuan, X.,Li, J.,Yang, L.,Zuo, P.,Fang, Z.,Liu, C.,Hsue, C.,Zhu, J.,Miller, J. D.,Lou, Q.(2019).Effect of 12-month resistance training on changes in abdominal adipose tissue and metabolic variables in patients with prediabetes: A randomized controlled trial.Journal of Diabetes Research,2019,8469739.
54. Yang, S.-W.,Kim, T.-H.,Choi, H.-M.(2018).The reproducibility and validity verification for body composition measuring devices using bioelectrical impedance analysis in Korean adults.Journal of Exercise Rehabilitation,14(4),621-627.
55. Yarizadeh, H.,Eftekhar, R.,Anjom-Shoae, J.,Speakman, J. R.,Djafarian, K.(2021).The effect of aerobic and resistance training and combined exercise modalities on subcutaneous abdominal fat: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials.Advances in Nutrition,12(1),179-196.
56. Zhang, H.,Tong, T. K.,Qiu, W.,Zhang, X.,Zhou, S.,Liu, Y.,He, Y.(2017).Comparable effects of high-intensity interval training and prolonged continuous exercise training on abdominal visceral fat reduction in obese young women.Journal of Diabetes Research,2017,5071740.