Country-Level Factors Associated With Nurse Salaries: Empirical Evidence From Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Countries and Taiwan

10.1097/jnr.0000000000000585

Yu-Hung CHANG；Chia Hui HSU；Yu-Chun TSENG；Chao A. HSIUNG

nurse salary ； nursing shortage ； nursing workforce ； health policy

The Journal of Nursing Research

31卷6期（2023 / 12 / 01）

1 - 12

英文

Background: Salary impacts nurse retention rates and thus is a factor affecting the nursing shortage both in Taiwan and around the world. Nurses in Taiwan earn a low salary compared with other health professionals and may be undervalued compared with their international counterparts. Purpose: This study was designed to analyze the factors associated with nurse salary (NS) in Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries and to compare NS in Taiwan with those in OECD member states. Methods: Data were extracted from the OECD statistics database and official statistics for Taiwan. For the 28 OECD member countries considered in this study and Taiwan, 21 indicators characterizing healthcare systems, including demographics, socioeconomic status, health behaviors and risks, healthcare resources, health financing, healthcare utilization, health outcomes, and economic inequality, were examined for the period of 2009-2018. A random-effects model (REM) and a fixed-effects model (FEM) were used to investigate the associations between these indicators and annual NS levels. The expected annual NS for Taiwan was estimated and compared with the actual NS for Taiwan using the REM. Results: In the REM, higher NS in OECD countries was shown to be positively associated with gross domestic product per capita (0.49, 95% confidence interval [CI] [0.41, 0.56]), proportion of population aged 65 years and over (2.72, 95%CI [2.17, 3.26]), crude birth rate (1.02, 95%CI [0.56, 1.49]), number of computerized tomography scanners per million population (0.26, 95% CI [0.17, 0.35]), alcohol consumption per person (0.94, 95% CI [0.26, 1.61]), and prevalence of obesity (0.64, 95% CI [0.40, 0.89]) and to be in inversely associated with infant mortality rate (-3.13, 95% CI [-3.94, -2.32]), bed density (-0.99, 95% CI [-1.72, -0.25]), number of hospital discharges (-0.08, 95%CI [-0.11, -0.05]), household out of- pocket expenditure as a percentage of health expenditure (-0.34, 95% CI [-0.56, -0.11]), and the Gini coefficient (-0.25, 95% CI [-0.50, -0.01]). The FEM results were similar to those of the REM. The predicted annual NS for Taiwan based on the REM rose from29,390 U.S. dollars (corrected for purchasing power parity; 95% CI [22,532, 36,247]) in 2009 to 49,891 U.S. dollars (95% CI [42,344, 57,438]) in 2018. The actual annual NS in Taiwan in 2018 was approximately 12% lower than the model-predicted value. Conclusions/Implications for Practice: Taiwan has a lower NS compared with its OECD counterparts. These findings may help policymakers, healthcare managers, and nurse organizations develop effective strategies to improve the remuneration system for nurses in Taiwan.

1. Fan, K.-T.,Chen, M.-S.(2009)。A preliminary analysis of the increasing workforce of hospital nurses in Taiwan。Taiwan Journal of Public Health，28(1)，26-34。
   連結：
2. Aiken, L. H.,Cerón, C.,Simonetti, M.,Lake, E. T.,Galiano, A.,Garbarini, A.,Soto, P.,Bravo, D.,Smith, H. L.(2018).Hospital nurse staffing and patient outcomes.Revista Médica Clínica Las Condes,29(3),322-327.
3. Amiri, A.,Solankallio-Vahteri, T.(2019).Nurse staffing and life expectancy at birth and at 65 years old: Evidence from 35 OECD countries.International Journal of Nursing Sciences,6(4),362-370.
4. Amiri, A.,Vehviläinen-Julkunen, K.,Solankallio-Vahteri, T.,Tuomi, S.(2020).Impact of nurse staffing on reducing infant, neonatal and perinatal mortality rates: Evidence from panel data analysis in 35 OECD countries.International Journal of Nursing Sciences,7(2),161-169.
5. Awases, M.,Gbary, A.,Nyoni, J.,Chatora, R.(2004).,未出版
6. Bimpong, K. A. A.,Khan, A.,Slight, R.,Tolley, C. L.,Slight, S. P.(2020).Relationship between labour force satisfaction, wages and retention within the UK National Health Service: A systematic review of the literature.BMJ Open,10(7),e034919.
7. Blume, K. S.,Dietermann, K.,Kirchner-Heklau, U.,Winter, V.,Fleischer, S.,Kreidl, L. M.,Meyer, G.,Schreyögg, J.(2021).Staffing levels and nursing-sensitive patient outcomes: Umbrella review and qualitative study.Health Services Research,56(5),885-907.
8. Butler, R. J.,Lai, G. N.,Wilson, B. L.(2021).Nurses' wages and hours of work in the COVID-19 era.Nursing Economics,39(3),132-138.
9. Cacace, M.,Ettelt, S.,Mays, N.,Nolte, E.(2013).Assessing quality in cross-country comparisons of health systems and policies: Towards a set of generic quality criteria.Health Policy,112(1-2),156-162.
10. Dall'Ora, C.,Ball, J.,Reinius, M.,Griffiths, P.(2020).Burnout in nursing: A theoretical review.Human Resources for Health,18,41.
11. Dovlo, D.(2007).Migration of nurses from sub-Saharan Africa: A review of issues and challenges.Health Services Research,42(3, Pt2),1373-1388.
12. Falatah, R.(2021).The impact of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic on nurses' turnover intention: An integrative review.Nursing Reports,11(4),787-810.
13. Flinkman, M.,Laine, M.,Leino-Kilpi, H.,Hasselhorn, H.-M.,Salanterä, S.(2008).Explaining young registered Finnish nurses' intention to leave the profession: A questionnaire survey.International Journal of Nursing Studies,45(5),727-739.
14. Frogner, B. K.,Frech, H. E.,Parente, S. T.(2015).Comparing efficiency of health systems across industrialized countries: A panel analysis.BMC Health Services Research,15(1),415.
15. Greipp, M. E.(2003).Salary compression: Its effect on nurse recruitment and retention.Journal of Nursing Administration,33(6),321-323.
16. Griffiths, P.,Maruotti, A.,Recio Saucedo, A.,Redfern, O. C.,Ball, J. E.,Briggs, J.,Dall'Ora, C,Schmidt, P. E.,Smith, G. B.,Missed Care Study Group(2019).Nurse staffing, nursing assistants and hospital mortality: Retrospective longitudinal cohort study.BMJ Quality & Safety,28(8),609-617.
17. Griffiths, P.,Recio-Saucedo, A.,Dall'Ora, C.,Briggs, J.,Maruotti, A.,Meredith, P.,Smith, G. B.,Ball, J.,Missed Care Study Group(2018).The association between nurse staffing and omissions in nursing care: A systematic review.Journal of Advanced Nursing,74(7),1474-1487.
18. Hagan, J.,Curtis, D. L., Sr.(2018).Predictors of nurse practitioner retention.Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners,30(5),280-284.
19. Halcomb, E.,Smyth, E.,McInnes, S.(2018).Job satisfaction and career intentions of registered nurses in primary health care: An integrative review.BMC Family Practice,19,136.
20. Heyes, A.(2005).The economics of vocation or ‘why is a badly paid nurse a good nurse’?.Journal of Health Economics,24(3),561-569.
21. Huang, T.-T. (2021, June 8). Taiwan grappling with nurse exodus amid COVID surge. Taiwan News. https://www.taiwannews.com.tw/en/news/4218386
22. International Labour Organization & OECD(2015).,未出版
23. Kline, D. S.(2003).Push and pull factors in international nurse migration.Journal of Nursing Scholarship,35(2),107-111.
24. McHugh, M. D.,Ma, C.(2014).Wage, work environment, and staffing: Effects on nurse outcomes.Policy, Politics & Nursing Practice,15(3-4),72-80.
25. Ministry of Health and Welfare, Taiwan, ROC.(2016).,未出版
26. Moyo, M. (2019). Radiology nursing: A growing specialty. https://www.myamericannurse.com/radiology-nursing-a-growing-specialty/
27. Muthmainnah, H. A.,Hariyati, R. T. S.(2018).Improving nurses' performance through remuneration: A literature review.Enfermería Clínica,27,130-133.
28. National Health Insurance Committee. (2014). The 1st National Health Insurance Committee, 6th Committee meeting minutes 2014. https://www.mohw.gov.tw/dl-2787-1ed88a30-eaa7-4b07-bb11-87deaa76e45e.html (Original work published in Chinese)
29. Nelson, J. A.,Folbre, N.(2006).Why a well-paid nurse is a better nurse.Nursing Economics,24(3),127-130.
30. Ono, T.,Lafortune, G.,Schoenstein, M.(2013).OECD Health Working PaperOECD Health Working Paper,未出版
31. Person, S. D.,Allison, J. J.,Kiefe, C. I.,Weaver, M. T.,Williams, O. D.,Centor, R. M.,Weissman, N. W.(2004).Nurse staffing and mortality for Medicare patients with acute myocardial infarction.Medical Care,42(1),4-12.
32. Ragin, C. C.(1999).The distinctiveness of case-oriented research.Health Services Research,34(5, Pt. 2),1137-1151.
33. Reibling, N.,Ariaans, M.,Wendt, C.(2019).Worlds of healthcare: A healthcare system typology of OECD countries.Health Policy,123(7),611-620.
34. Reinhardt, U.(1972).A production function for physician services.The Review of Economics and Statistics,54(1),55-66.
35. Scheffler, R. M.,Arnold, D. R.(2019).Projecting shortages and surpluses of doctors and nurses in the OECD: What looms ahead.Health Economics, Policy, and Law,14(2),274-290.
36. Shin, S.,Park, J.-H.,Bae, S.-H.(2018).Nurse staffing and nurse outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis.Nursing Outlook,66(3),273-282.
37. Sochalski, J.,Konetzka, R. T.,Zhu, J.,Volpp, K.(2008).Will mandated minimum nurse staffing ratios lead to better patient outcomes?.Medical Care,46(6),606-613.
38. Squires, A.,Uyei, S. J.,Beltrán-Sánchez, H.,Jones, S. A.(2016).Examining the influence of country-level and health system factors on nursing and physician personnel production.Human Resources for Health,14(1),48.
39. Tomblin Murphy, G.,MacKenzie, A.,Waysome, B.,Guy-Walker, J.,Palmer, R.,Elliott Rose, A.,Rigby, J.,Labonté, R.,Bourgeault, I. L.(2016).A mixed-methods study of health worker migration from Jamaica.Human Resources for Health,14(1),36.
40. Van Buuren, S.(2018).Flexible imputation of missing data.CRC Press.
41. World Health Organization. (2020). State of the world's nursing 2020: Investing in education, jobs and leadership. https://apps.who.int/iris/rest/bitstreams/1274201/retrieve
42. Xu, K.,Evans, D. B.,Carrin, G.,Aguilar-Rivera, A. M.,Musgrove, P.,Evans, T.(2007).Protecting households from catastrophic health spending.Health Affairs,26(4),972-983.
43. Yum, M.(2022).Model selection for panel data models with fixed effects: A simulation study.Applied Economics Letters,29(19),1776-1783.
44. Zhang, Q.,Yu, Y.(2021).Effects of graded emergency nursing on resuscitation outcomes, prognosis, and nursing satisfaction in patients with acute myocardial infarction.American Journal of Translational Research,13(9),10586-10592.